A.I. and the Trillion-Dollar Question
Even the companies building the technology don’t seem exactly sure where it’s headed.
You’re reading The World newsletter. Your daily guide to understanding what’s happening — and why it matters. Hosted by Katrin Bennhold, for readers around the world.
An A.I. boom or bubble?
In 2014, I read “The Second Machine Age,” a book by two M.I.T. economists. The authors offered a sort of utopian vision of A.I.: The technology would lead to an age of hyper-productivity and plenty, where the only question was how to distribute its gains fairly.
We could still get there, but it seems fair to say the road to utopia, if that is our destination, won’t be smooth. Current anxieties around whether A.I. has become too dominant in the global economy — what happens if it’s not all it’s cracked up to be? — sit alongside competing ones: What happens if A.I. is all it’s cracked up to be, and can replace all those humans after all? Would that really be a good outcome?
I spoke to my colleague Cade Metz, who writes about artificial intelligence. He told me every technological revolution has created anxiety during the transition from the old to the new, when jobs are destroyed, money is lost and companies go bust. The question is what emerges on the other side.
Cade, is this A.I. boom in fact an A.I. bubble?
That’s the million-dollar question. Or rather: the trillion-dollar question. This one technology is propping up the economy in so many ways. But we’re at a point where we’re not sure where that technology is going. It’s hard for even the companies building the technology to articulate where they’re going.
Some of these companies are not even turning a profit. What justifies these valuations?
So some of these companies are enormously profitable. Google, Meta, Amazon and Microsoft make billions of dollars a quarter, on core products that are not fundamentally A.I.-related.
But their bottom line is also being driven by the interest in A.I. To build these A.I. technologies, you need enormous amounts of computing power. Google has that computing power. So do Amazon, Microsoft and Meta.
Everyone else who’s jumping on the A.I. bandwagon pays those firms for that computing power. So there’s all this other money that’s being pumped into these big companies, and so their stock price goes up, their valuation goes up, their revenues go up.
All that makes sense. But if those other, smaller companies don’t start making money soon enough, you might have a problem.
If this is a bubble, and it bursts, how bad would it be?
The dot-com bubble is one potential analogy. What happened there was, a lot of people lost a lot of money — people who were invested in the technology, people who were building the technology. Many companies just vanished, right? And you had some large companies go bankrupt. So you know, it wasn’t a small thing.
But the larger economy wasn’t affected in the same way that it was in the 2008 financial crisis, which is another possible analogy.
Some people are concerned about what they call potential systemic risk in the economy that would make it more like 2008. There is a lot of debt being taken on by highly leveraged investors and it’s hard to tell how much debt, who holds it, how widespread it is.
All these companies that are betting big on A.I. — what does a successful bet for them look like?
Take a company like OpenAI. They think that within a few years, they’ll make tens of billions of dollars a year. They’re already getting billions of dollars in revenue. But they’re losing even more because it’s so expensive to build this stuff. They think that by 2030 it will flip.
It might. But even if the technology comes through, not everybody can win here. It’s a crowded field. There will be winners and losers.
Yet another potentially good analogy is the railroad boom of the 19th century. The invention of the steam engine led to a boom in railroad building. You had railroad lines being built right beside each other. And that’s a lot of what’s happening here: You have all these companies building exactly the same thing — these massive data centers. Many people think there is surplus capacity being built right now. Which means you’ll have a lot of losers in the longer term.
MORE TOP NEWS
A search for survivors of the Hong Kong inferno
Firefighters pulled people and corpses from a high-rise apartment complex in Hong Kong, a day after it was engulfed in the city’s worst fire in nearly 70 years. The number of deaths rose to at least 94. That toll could go much higher, as dozens of people remain unaccounted for.
Lau Yu Hung said he and his wife barely escaped the flames in time. “Nobody warned us,” he said. “No alarm went off. We escaped by ourselves.”
The authorities said flammable netting and foam boards may have fueled the blaze. Three people with ties to a construction company that installed the materials were arrested on suspicion of manslaughter. Here are some images from the disaster.
OTHER NEWS
Pope Leo XIV kicked off the first foreign trip of his papacy in Turkey. On Sunday, he flies to Lebanon, home to the Arab world’s largest Catholic community. See photos.
France announced a new form of military service, following in the footsteps of other European countries that have bolstered their armed forces since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
The Louvre will raise ticket prices for visitors from outside the European Economic Area in order to fund an ambitious new renovation plan.
One of the National Guard troops shot near the White House has died, President Trump said. The U.S. paused immigration from Afghanistan after an Afghan man, who had worked with a C.I.A.-backed military unit during the war there, was detained in connection with the attack.
A day after deposing Guinea-Bissau’s president, the military installed his close ally General Horta Inta-a as the new transitional leader. The opposition accused the president of staging the coup in order to lead by proxy, after an election that it says he lost.
The U.S. Army secretary, Daniel Driscoll, is playing an unusually active role in the Ukraine peace negotiations. Driscoll pushed for a quick deal by warning the Europeans that Russia is stockpiling long-range missiles.
SPORTS
Football: Liverpool’s latest defeat has plunged the reigning champions into crisis.
Tennis: What Rafael Nadal is doing a year after retiring.
PHRASE OF THE DAY
Potato shoe
— Do the best shoes look like … potatoes? Just as hemlines rise and fall to reflect the fashion moment, so too do shoes swing from pointy to paunchy. Think Birkenstock clogs or the Ugg slipper.
MORNING READ
Ladi Kwali, a Nigerian artist who died in 1984, is the only woman whose face appears on the country’s currency. Her pottery is seen less often, but it’s now getting attention in a new exhibition in New York City.
The show feels like a revelation, our West Africa bureau chief Ruth Maclean writes. It provides a more complete picture of one of Nigeria’s most famous but least-understood artists.
What they’re reading in … Finland
At 34, Sanna Marin became the world’s youngest sitting prime minister. She led Finland through the early days of the coronavirus pandemic and the country’s integration into NATO.
Then, videos leaked of her partying, vamping straight to camera. The so-called dancing scandal set off a feminist firestorm in Finland and abroad, and prompted a debate: Was this inappropriate or inspirational?
In the two years since she left politics, Marin, now 40, has rarely given interviews, and Finns, still fascinated, have had to parse her Instagram for clues about her life.
Now they have a book to parse, too. Marin is trying to turn the scandal into a battle cry, using a new memoir to reclaim her legacy. In it, she argues that she has fought to build “a world where you can, yes, dance freely when the day’s work is done.” — Amelia Nierenberg, reporting from Helsinki
RECIPE
If you are a fan of the classic French dessert tarte au citron (lemon tart), you will love this cranberry version. One reader had this tip for keeping the color bright: purée the cranberry mixture in a pot with an immersion blender.
Where is this lake?
BEFORE YOU GO …
You might know I live in Wales. It was an adjustment moving to Cardiff after Paris, London and Berlin. At first I missed the energy, the diversity, the sense of freedom that comes with the scale of those places.
But what I’ve learned here is the power of community.
The Welsh comedian Rob Brydon jokes that if you name someone from Wales to a Welsh person, he either knows someone related to them or who went to school with them. When I drop my son at the school gate, I don’t just bump into my sister-in-law, I see my hair dresser, the guy who runs our gym and half a dozen people who went to school with my husband.
Last weekend, the actor Matthew Rhys was in town, to do a one-man show on the actor Richard Burton (Welsh!) on a local stage. Matthew grew up in Cardiff and, yes, went to school with my husband. It was part of a fund-raising tour for a new National Theater of Wales that Michael Sheen, another Welsh actor, is driving. At the reception afterward I spoke to Michael’s assistant (who went to school with my husband).
With that sense of community comes an extraordinary sense of national pride, joyful and inclusive, which to me personally as a German has been a revelation.
One of the most rousing expressions of this was the 2022 pep talk that Michael gave to the Welsh football team before it headed to the World Cup. Watch it here. It’s incredible.
This week’s world-themed song is Welsh, of course: Super Furry Animals’ “It’s Not the End of the World?” The lead singer, Gruff Rhys, did not go to school with my husband (but his wife did!)
Have a great weekend. — Katrin
TIME TO PLAY
Here are today’s Spelling Bee, Mini Crossword, Wordle and Sudoku. Find all our games here.
We welcome your feedback. Send us your suggestions at thew...@nytimes.com.