COMPLAINT against FAA (First Appellate Authority) of the CIC

1 view
Skip to first unread message

C K Jam

May 7, 2015, 9:23:54 AM5/7/15
to, India Rti, Rti4ngo, Humjanenge,, Ncpri
The Secretary
Central Information Commission
New Delhi


1. Hon'ble MoS, DoPT
2. Secretary, DoPT

C J Karira
Secunderabad                                                    Date 07 May 2015

RE: COMPLAINT against the First Appellate Authority of the Central Information Commission

Dear Madam,

I am constrained to send this email to you to COMPLAIN to you regarding the Non Disposal of my First Appeal by the FAA of your Commission.

As you can very well see from the trailing emails (copies of all emails and letters have been marked to you !), there has been an inordinate delay in disposing off my first appeal. Since this matter pertains to Corruption in the CIC, there is no doubt in my mind that the disposal of this first appeal is being delayed on the prodding of the corrupt persons working in the Central Information Commission.

If you recall, I had also called you about a month ago, before Mr Dash demitted office, and you had assured me to look into the matter and get this matter disposed at the earliest. 

However no such thing happened !

Following is the sequence of events:

RTI Application filed with CPIO, CIC, re missing files
14 Jul 2014
Reply of the CPIO, CIC
22 Aug 2014
First Appeal filed with FAA of CIC
08 Sep 2014
Date of First Appeal Hearing & FAA’s 1st order
27 Oct 2014
FAA gives further directions to trace the “missing files”
27 Oct 2014
Another First Appeal for non-compliance of FAAs orders
09 Nov 2014
Incomplete information provided by CPIO
28 Nov 2014
Reminder to FAA
03 Dec 2014
Another First Appeal to FAA for incomplete information
10 Dec 2014
FAA passes order and gives more time to CPIO / Registrar to trace missing files and conduct Inquiry
19 Dec 2014
First reminder to FAA
11 Jan 2015
Second reminder to FAA
05 Feb 2015
Several calls to FAA between 23 Feb & 05 April 2015
Third reminder to FAA
18 April 2015
Fourth reminder to FAA
01 May 2015
Fifth reminder to FAA
07 May 2015

As you can clearly see from the above table, I have tried my best to follow all rules
and procedures as well as send timely reminders to the FAA to get his orders implemented.

However, I am now convinced that both Mr A K Dash, the former Adnl Secretary 
cum FAA and  the present FAA Mr Beck, are both part of the same 
CORRUPT MAFIA , existing in the Commission.

Madam, you are part of the Central Information Commission, the apex body for deciding
second appeals / complaints under the RTI Act. If your own senior officers:

- do not follow the time lines specified in the RTI Act 2005
- are not able to enforce their orders on their own subordinates
- do not even reply to 5 reminders over a period of 5 months

then with what face and authority can the Commission direct officers of other public 
authorities and expect the compliance of their orders ?

Since Mr Beck took over as the FAA of the Commission, I have called him more than 15 
times and he has never ever come on the phone. 

His email, as given on the website of the Commission, keeps bouncing.

Madam our Prime Minister keeps talking about "courteous behaviour" of Government
officers towards citizens, but surely, not responding to 15 phone calls cannot be termed as 
"courteous behaviour".

I therefore URGE and REQUEST you to immediately remove such an officer from
the post of FAA and reassign the duties to some other officer who can at least
return calls from applicants/appellants who have been waiting for an order
since more than 6 months.

I also did call you once and left a message with your PA, but the call was
not returned.

Thanking You,
C J Karira

Atal Ahirwar

May 8, 2015, 3:07:20 PM5/8/15
to, Ncpri,, Humjanenge, Rti4ngo, India Rti

Dear sir,

Now CIC converted into the protection center for corruption. Same problem I am also facing. I also approached same ministry but no use. These all are sitting here to protect corrupted people. All such things happening with the support of central government. This is the reason why till date no CIC appointed by government.
Now you will receive email from Mr. Sanjay Kothari to show you they are doing importance to your email. But these things are just to fool you.

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "HumJanenge Forum People's Right to Information, RTI Act 2005" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to
For more options, visit
Reply all
Reply to author
0 new messages