<<<U.T.M>>> Fw: Fwd: THE POLICE STORY STANDS SHATTERED!
Ghulam Muhammed
Sent: Thursday, December 18, 2008 11:55:20 AM
Subject: Fwd: THE POLICE STORY STANDS SHATTERED!
From: Amaresh Misra <misra.amaresh@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, Dec 18, 2008 at 11:16 AM
Subject: THE POLICE STORY STANDS SHATTERED!
To: misra.amaresh@gmail.com
Mumbai Carnage: The Police Story stands shattered
"Unfortunately his end came. It may be a separate inquiry how his (Karkare's) end came," he told reporters outside Parliament.
Antulay said "Karkare found that there are non-Muslims involved in the acts of terrorism during his investigations in some cases. Any person going to the roots of terror has always been the target, he said.
"Superficially speaking they (terrorists) had no reason to kill Karkare. Whether he (Karkare) was victim of terrorism or terrorism plus something. I do not know," he added.
When he came under attack in Lok Sabha on the issue, Antulay sought to wriggle out saying he had not talked about who killed Karkare but about "who sent him in the direction" of Cama hospital, outside which he was killed.
"Who had sent them to Cama hospital (a lane opposite which he and two other officers were killed by Pakistani terrorists on Nov 26). What were they told that made them leave for the same spot in the same vehicle.
"I repeat what I had said. I had not said who had killed them but only questioned who had sent them there (Cama Hospital) in that direction," he said in Lok Sabha where BJP and Shiv Sena members attacked him for his remarks.
Anant Geete of Shiv Sena accused him of "misleading" the house and sought Chidambaram's clarification.
Earlier in the day, describing Hemant Karkare as a very bold officer having great acumen and vision, Antulay asked "How come instead of going to Hotel Taj or Oberai or even the Nariman House, he went to such a place where there was nothing compared to what happened in the three places?"
"Why all the three (Hemant Karakre, Vijay Salaskar and Ashok Kamte) went together. It is beyond my comprehension," the minister said.
The minister's remarks came under immediate attack from BJP which asked the prime minister to clarify whether his remarks are an "individual misdemeanour or the collective wisdom of the Cabinet".
"The remarks are obnoxious and deserves a clarification from the prime minister," BJP spokesman Rajiv Pratap Rudy told reporters.
Reacting to Antulay's remarks, Congress spokesman Abhishek Manu Singhvi they should be treated his "personal views" and Congress party does not agree with them and does not support such a formulation.
To a question, he said there was no question of embarrassment to the party.
Samajwadi Party MP Amar Singh, who himself was in the centre of a controversy when he had raised doubts over the killing of a Delhi police official in an encounter recently, said a senior leader like Antulay should before issuing any statement uphold the cherished tradition of collective wisdom of the cabinet.
Not completely disapproving the remarks, Union minister Ram Vilas Paswan said Antulay must be having "more information" since he hails from Maharashtra.
The issue came up when the house was discussing two bills brought in by the government to tackle terror against the backdrop of Mumbai terror attacks.
Geete said the prime minister and several senior union ministers have gone on record to say that Karkare was killed by terrorists.
Not satisfied with Antulay's reply, Geete charged the union minister with "misleading" the house, which he "did not "expect".
FOR POSTING MESSAGES: unitedtam...@yahoogroups.com
HOMEPAGE: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/unitedtamilmuslims
TO MODIFY YOUR LIST SUBSCRIPTION, PLEASE SEND A BLANK E-MAIL TO
SUBSCRIPTION: unitedtamilmus...@yahoogroups.com
THE OTHER OPTIONS ARE:-
INDIVIDUAL MAILS: unitedtamilm...@yahoogroups.com
DAILY DIGEST: unitedtamilm...@yahoogroups.com
VACATION HOLD: unitedtamilm...@yahoogroups.com
UNSUBSCRIBE: unitedtamilmusl...@yahoogroups.com
THERE IS AN ALTERNATIVE FOR RECEIVING LOT OF EMAILS EVERYDAY
It is by setting in the U.T.M. yahoo group’s website as
DAILY DIGEST instead of INDIVIDUAL EMAILS.
Please follow the below steps.
Step 1. Sign in yahoo first and then click the below link
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/unitedtamilmuslims/join
Step 2. Click edits membership
Step 3. See below for Message Delivery then click Daily Digest Instead of Individual mails and make save changes.
In Daily Digest option or Web option (no mail option) all images and attachments are deleted. Individual email option is advisable. Through Special notices option receives only important email notices from the group moderator.
OR
If you can use the Filters avoid this problem. Through use the filters Mails will be automatically send to the separate folder (U.T.M).
In YAHOO after sign in go to Mail Options -> Filters
You can see the "Add or Edit filters" link. Just click Add link then new window will be opened from that you can arrange the separate folder for filter (U.T.M)
Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch format to Traditional
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
__,_._,___
Amit Bindal
Perhaps, much more still needs to be known. And no doubt these questions (which are raised in the post) beg answers from the government. It's too early to say much but reading the post sends shivers down the spine!
----- Forwarded Message ----To: 20...@abc.com; 48h...@cbsnews.com; aalami...@rediffmail.com; afza...@hotmail.com; agni...@yahoo.com; aija...@khaleejtimes.com; akhbare...@yahoo.co.in; aleem....@gmail.com; alma...@arabnews.com; amah...@detaone.in; am...@arf-asia.org; ambas...@embassyofpakistanusa.org; amki...@gmail.com; andal...@yahoo.com; arsh...@gmail.com; ashraf....@hindustantimes.com; ash...@idafa.com; asi...@yahoo.com; ass...@gmail.com; a...@npr.org; au_...@yahoo.co.in; ayesh...@expressindia.com; azim....@wipro.com; bags...@yahoo.com; Bakhtiarspa...@yahoo.no; Bar...@ndtv.com; bbcw...@bbc.co.uk; burneyaz...@hotmail.com; chair...@nic.in; c...@medleylab.com; cov...@mjakbar.org; c...@vsnl.com; crmo...@gmail.com; ctc-tri...@tribune.com; date...@nbc.com; dawa...@indiatimes.com; de...@asianews.it; doctor...@yahoo.com; drbhan...@sify.com; earl...@cbs.com; edi...@islamicamagazine.com; edi...@metimes.com; edi...@newageislam.com; edi...@usatoday.com; edit...@expressindia.com; eng...@palestine-info.co.uk; epw.m...@gmail.com; eve...@cbsnews.com; fa...@fair.org; Foxr...@foxnews.com; f...@cbsnews.com; Han...@foxnews.com; hard...@msnbc.com; hasans...@googlegroups.com; in...@ap.org; in...@isim.nl; in...@muslimobserver.com; ism...@gmail.com; jadeed...@gmail.com; jameel...@gmail.com; kaling...@gmail.com; let...@newsweek.com; let...@usnews.com; m_sal...@yahoo.com; maga...@dawn.com; mah...@yahoo.com; mahmood...@vsnl.net; manoha...@yahoo.co.in; markaz...@gmail.com; markazu...@yahoogroups.com; mcbm...@mcb.org.uk; mdsha...@gmail.com; meh...@gmail.com; memehd...@yahoo.co.in; mhh...@yahoo.com; mohamme...@mid-day.com; Mohsin...@gmail.com; mohsi...@hotmail.co.uk; mor...@npr.org; msso...@hotmail.com; mubassh...@gmail.com; mukhtar...@yahoo.com; munsi...@eth.net; Muslims...@yahoogroups.com; nasi...@yahoo.com; nation...@rediffmail.com; net...@abc.com; ne...@alqamar.org; newsb...@etemaaddaily.com; news...@pbs.org; newswat...@gmail.com; nigh...@abcnews.com; nig...@nbc.com; n...@canadianislamiccongress.com; nyt...@nytimes.com; ombu...@npr.org; ombu...@washpost.com; Onthe...@foxnews.com; Ore...@foxnews.com; perve...@eth.net; pra...@ndtv.com; p...@trans.in; publ...@muslimfreepress.com; qaumiaw...@erdiffmail.com; qurb...@gmail.com; qur...@josloc.com; radianc...@gmail.com; rah...@hotmail.com; ram...@vsnl.com; r...@indiatribune.com; reade...@latimes.com; rhed...@gmail.com; rinaislami...@yahoo.co.in; rizvi...@yahoo.com; rsha...@gmail.com; ru...@eibnet.com; sadiyac...@gmail.com; saeed...@yahoo.com; sahafa...@yahoo.co.uk; sahil...@hotmail.com; sajad...@yahoo.com; sardesai...@gmail.com; sar...@hotmail.com; sayeed....@gmail.com; secret...@bol.net.in; shad...@yahoo.com; shaki...@yahoo.com; she...@vsnl.com; shekhar...@express2.indexp.co.in; shobha.s...@merinews.com; Spe...@foxnews.com; sudheen...@gmail.com; syed_was...@yahoo.com; syedsaj...@yahoo.com; tanveer...@gmail.com; tanveer...@gmail.com; tari...@btinternet.com; teesta...@gmail.com; thedai...@yahoo.com; Tinas...@yahoo.com; to...@nbc.com; to...@npr.org; tsa...@hotmail.com; u_g...@yahoo.com; unni...@gmail.com; UrduTa...@googlegroups.com; voiceof...@rediffmail.com; waha...@yahoo.com; wa...@spa.gov.sa; webm...@allama-mashriqi.8m.com; webm...@jasarat.com; webm...@nation.com.pk; webmasw...@asiantribune.com; writ...@gmail.com; yase...@gmail.com; ya...@yawarbaig.com; yogendr...@gmail.com; zafar...@yahoo.co.in; zeeshan...@hindustantimes.com; SHAHI IMAM AHAMED BUKHARI <si...@hotmail.com>; 786 <7...@muslimrevival.com>; aariz_mohammed <aariz_m...@yahoo.co.in>; Abdul Hafiz Lakhani <lakh...@yahoo.com>; Abdul Hasib <ha...@mtnl.net.in>; Abdul Wahid Azad <abdul.wa...@googlemail.com>; "abdulr...@hotmail.com" <abdulr...@hotmail.com>; Abdus Sattar Ghazali <asghaz...@yahoo.com>; "abl...@yahoo.com" <abl...@yahoo.com>; abu zafar <abuza...@gmail.com>; "abuas...@hotmail.com" <abuas...@hotmail.com>; "ad...@mcb.org.uk" <ad...@mcb.org.uk>; afternoonletters <afternoo...@gmail.com>; ahmed soroor <soroo...@yahoo.com>; "ahmeda...@yahoo.com" <ahmeda...@yahoo.com>; "ahram...@ahram.org.eg" <ahram...@ahram.org.eg>; Ajit Sahi <aj...@tehelka.com>; akbar hasan <malik_a...@yahoo.co.in>; Akhtar Ali Khan <naj...@yahoo.co.uk>; Alan Border <withh...@yahoo.com>; "ali_z...@hotmail.com" <ali_z...@hotmail.com>; "aliha...@aol.com" <aliha...@aol.com>; Amanullah Khan <ak1...@rediffmail.com>; Amaresh Misra <misra....@gmail.com>; "ami...@ilaam.net" <ami...@ilaam.net>; amr_cnbc <amr_...@yahoo.co.in>; anees <anees.m...@rediffmail.com>; "arifiq...@yahoo.co.in" <arifiq...@yahoo.co.in>; arshi khan <khanar...@rediffmail.com>; "ar...@aol.com" <ar...@aol.com>; "ashra...@hotmail.com" <ashra...@hotmail.com>; "asif...@hotmail.com" <asif...@hotmail.com>; aslam ghazi <mag...@indiatimes.com>; "atha...@yahoo.co.in" <atha...@yahoo.co.in>; "ayesha...@tufts.edu" <ayesha...@tufts.edu>; "a...@georgetown.edu" <a...@georgetown.edu>; "ayubp...@hotmail.com" <ayubp...@hotmail.com>; "b_q...@hotmail.com" <b_q...@hotmail.com>; Badri Raina <badri...@gmail.com>; bashiruddin babukhan <bashirudd...@yahoo.com>; BBC World Service <worldservi...@bbc.co.uk>; "ca...@cair-net.org" <ca...@cair-net.org>; CARD <ca...@ricmail.com>; "cdlr_m...@hotmail.com" <cdlr_m...@hotmail.com>; "comm...@foxnews.com" <comm...@foxnews.com>; "comm...@truthout.org" <comm...@truthout.org>; Cowasjee Dawn <ar...@cyber.net.pk>; Daily Millat <edi...@millat.com>; danish reyaz <danis...@gmail.com>; Dr A R Mookhi <drmo...@hotmail.com>; Dr Arshad G Moh'd <arsh...@yahoo.com>; DR.QASIM RASOOL ILYAS <sqri...@gmail.com>; "dr_ph...@hotmail.com" <dr_ph...@hotmail.com>; "drabdulk...@yahoo.com" <drabdulk...@yahoo.com>; "drrehm...@yahoo.co.in" <drrehm...@yahoo.co.in>; drsalimkhan <drsal...@hotmail.com>; "dtle...@telegraph.co.uk" <dtle...@telegraph.co.uk>; "edi...@timesgroup.com" <edi...@timesgroup.com>; "edi...@aljazeerah.info" <edi...@aljazeerah.info>; "edi...@amperspective.com" <edi...@amperspective.com>; "edi...@centralchronical.com" <edi...@centralchronical.com>; "edi...@deccanherald.co.in" <edi...@deccanherald.co.in>; "edi...@deccanmail.com" <edi...@deccanmail.com>; "edi...@greaterkashmir.com" <edi...@greaterkashmir.com>; "edi...@ibnlive.com" <edi...@ibnlive.com>; "edi...@iexpressusa.com" <edi...@iexpressusa.com>; "edi...@medialens.org" <edi...@medialens.org>; "Edi...@MediaMonitors.net" <Edi...@mediamonitors.net>; "edi...@muslimedia.com" <edi...@muslimedia.com>; "edi...@nawaiwaqt.com.pk" <edi...@nawaiwaqt.com.pk>; "edi...@newsindia-times.com" <edi...@newsindia-times.com>; "edi...@nytimes.com" <edi...@nytimes.com>; "edi...@the-week.com" <edi...@the-week.com>; "edi...@themuslimweekly.com" <edi...@themuslimweekly.com>; "edi...@urdutimes.org" <edi...@urdutimes.org>; "edi...@zaman.com.tr" <edi...@zaman.com.tr>; "edit...@indiaabroad.com" <edit...@indiaabroad.com>; "edi...@newsweek.com" <edi...@newsweek.com>; ehtasham khan <ehtas...@yahoo.co.in>; "email...@gmail.com" <email...@gmail.com>; "etv...@bom8.vsnl.net.in" <etv...@bom8.vsnl.net.in>; "express...@express.co.uk" <express...@express.co.uk>; "f.k...@unsw.edu.au" <f.k...@unsw.edu.au>; "faisal...@hotmail.com" <faisal...@hotmail.com>; "faisal...@gmail.com" <faisal...@gmail.com>; "farr...@hotmail.com" <farr...@hotmail.com>; "far...@pacbell.net" <far...@pacbell.net>; "fchaud...@gmail.com" <fchaud...@gmail.com>; "feed...@tehelka.com" <feed...@tehelka.com>; Feroze Mithiborwala <feroze...@gmail.com>; "fffk...@yahoo.com" <fffk...@yahoo.com>; "f...@vsnl.com" <f...@vsnl.com>; "FP...@fpri.org" <FP...@fpri.org>; Friday Times <t...@lhr.comsats.net.pk>; "fron...@thehindu.co.in" <fron...@thehindu.co.in>; G. R. Siddiqui <grs...@gmail.com>; "gall...@parliament.uk" <gall...@parliament.uk>; ghaziahmed shaikh <ghazi...@hotmail.com>; "gil...@nsstc.uah.edu" <gil...@nsstc.uah.edu>; GM.Shaikh <gm.sha...@gmail.com>; "gpsh...@rediff.com" <gpsh...@rediff.com>; hanif lakdawala <m...@rediffmail.com>; Hasan Shabbir <HasanS...@gmail.com>; haseeb <has...@aspratech.com>; "hasn...@yahoo.com" <hasn...@yahoo.com>; "hina...@gmail.com" <hina...@gmail.com>; "hindusta...@yahoo.com" <hindusta...@yahoo.com>; "hsi...@thestar.ca" <hsi...@thestar.ca>; "hsi...@yahoo.com" <hsi...@yahoo.com>; "hyd1_...@sancharnet.in" <hyd1_...@sancharnet.in>; "iah...@nicholaspiramal.co.in" <iah...@nicholaspiramal.co.in>; "id_n...@yahoo.co.in" <id_n...@yahoo.co.in>; "ideam...@yahoo.com" <ideam...@yahoo.com>; "iftikha...@gmail.com" <iftikha...@gmail.com>; "iht-l...@iht.com" <iht-l...@iht.com>; Impact International <edi...@impactnews.demon.co.uk>; "imtiyaz...@gmail.com" <imtiyaz...@gmail.com>; "inderma...@hotmail.com" <inderma...@hotmail.com>; Indian Muslim Council <me...@imc-usa.org>; Indian Muslims <mohib...@gmail.com>; Indian Muslims <shaa...@gmail.com>; Info <in...@futureislam.com>; "in...@beiruttimes.com" <in...@beiruttimes.com>; "in...@ibn.net" <in...@ibn.net>; "in...@ihrc.org" <in...@ihrc.org>; "in...@jamiat.org.za" <in...@jamiat.org.za>; "in...@mediareviewnet.com" <in...@mediareviewnet.com>; "in...@merinews.com" <in...@merinews.com>; "in...@mpacuk.org" <in...@mpacuk.org>; "in...@oic-oci.org" <in...@oic-oci.org>; "in...@palestinechronicle.com" <in...@palestinechronicle.com>; "in...@prc.org.uk" <in...@prc.org.uk>; "in...@shanghaidaily.com" <in...@shanghaidaily.com>; "in...@siasat.com" <in...@siasat.com>; "in...@yvonneridley.org" <in...@yvonneridley.org>; "intern...@upi.com" <intern...@upi.com>; iqbal a ansari <iqbala...@gmail.com>; "iqbal...@gmail.com" <iqbal...@gmail.com>; "ircg...@yahoo.com" <ircg...@yahoo.com>; "irfa...@hotmail.com" <irfa...@hotmail.com>; "iscr...@ntu.edu.sg" <iscr...@ntu.edu.sg>; "is...@irf.net" <is...@irf.net>; "j.st...@guardian.co.uk" <j.st...@guardian.co.uk>; "jadid...@rediffmail.com" <jadid...@rediffmail.com>; "jam...@del6.vsnl.net.in" <jam...@del6.vsnl.net.in>; "jamia...@bol.net.in" <jamia...@bol.net.in>; "javed...@rediffmail.com" <javed...@rediffmail.com>; "jave...@yahoo.com" <jave...@yahoo.com>; "ja...@muslimsweekly.com" <ja...@muslimsweekly.com>; John Dayal <cathol...@gmail.com>; "jot...@jpf.com.jo" <jot...@jpf.com.jo>; "junaid...@yahoo.com" <junaid...@yahoo.com>; Juzar Bandukwala <drband...@yahoo.co.in>; Juzer Mohammed Husain <rez...@gmail.com>; "k_k_...@hotmail.com" <k_k_...@hotmail.com>; "kamalf...@hotmail.com" <kamalf...@hotmail.com>; "karama...@hotmail.com" <karama...@hotmail.com>; kaukab siddique <buts...@msn.com>; "kbat...@al-madina.com.sa" <kbat...@al-madina.com.sa>; "khaba...@bol.net.in" <khaba...@bol.net.in>; "khalida...@gmail.com" <khalida...@gmail.com>; Khan Arif <ank2...@yahoo.com>; "khan...@rediffmail.com" <khan...@rediffmail.com>; "khat...@msn.com" <khat...@msn.com>; "khwaj...@rediffmail.com" <khwaj...@rediffmail.com>; "kin...@gmail.com" <kin...@gmail.com>; "kor...@hotmail.com" <kor...@hotmail.com>; "kti...@emirates.net.ae" <kti...@emirates.net.ae>; "kuldip...@yahoo.com" <kuldip...@yahoo.com>; "letter...@gulfnews.com" <letter...@gulfnews.com>; "let...@globe.com" <let...@globe.com>; "letters...@intoday.com" <letters...@intoday.com>; "let...@arabnews.com" <let...@arabnews.com>; "let...@atimes.com" <let...@atimes.com>; "let...@dailytimes.com.pk" <let...@dailytimes.com.pk>; "let...@dawn.com" <let...@dawn.com>; "let...@hardnewsmedia.com" <let...@hardnewsmedia.com>; "let...@hindustantimes.com" <let...@hindustantimes.com>; "let...@independent.co.uk" <let...@independent.co.uk>; "let...@latimes.com" <let...@latimes.com>; "let...@msnbc.com" <let...@msnbc.com>; "let...@newint.org" <let...@newint.org>; "let...@newsday.com" <let...@newsday.com>; "let...@slate.com" <let...@slate.com>; "let...@taipeitimes.com" <let...@taipeitimes.com>; "let...@theage.com.au" <let...@theage.com.au>; "let...@thehindu.co.in" <let...@thehindu.co.in>; "let...@thetimes.co.uk" <let...@thetimes.co.uk>; "let...@time.com" <let...@time.com>; "let...@tribuneindia.com" <let...@tribuneindia.com>; "let...@washingtontimes.com" <let...@washingtontimes.com>; "let...@washpost.com" <let...@washpost.com>; "lette...@thestar.ca" <lette...@thestar.ca>; "lhe...@gulfnews.com" <lhe...@gulfnews.com>; "lo...@vsnl.com" <lo...@vsnl.com>; Lord Meghnad Desai <M.D...@lse.ac.uk>; "m...@ajmal.net" <m...@ajmal.net>; "mahmood...@yahoo.com" <mahmood...@yahoo.com>; Mahtab Alam <mdmaht...@gmail.com>; "ma...@jimas.org" <ma...@jimas.org>; "mai...@nstp.com.my" <mai...@nstp.com.my>; Majid <sid...@yahoo.com>; majlis muslim <muslim...@hotmail.com>; malikkazim2000 <malikka...@rediffmail.com>; Manoj Padhi <manoj...@gmail.com>; "mansur_...@hotmail.com" <mansur_...@hotmail.com>; "man...@ndf.vsnl.net.in" <man...@ndf.vsnl.net.in>; "manzu...@yahoo.com" <manzu...@yahoo.com>; MB. Qasmi <man...@markazulmaarif.org>; "mb...@gsa.state.al.us" <mb...@gsa.state.al.us>; "med...@giasdl01.vsnl.net.in" <med...@giasdl01.vsnl.net.in>; MEDIA CELL <mediac...@gmail.com>; "media...@yahoo.com" <media...@yahoo.com>; "med...@hotmail.com" <med...@hotmail.com>; "mehmo...@rediffmail.com" <mehmo...@rediffmail.com>; "mf...@wiu.edu" <mf...@wiu.edu>; MIRZA ANWARULHAQ <anwarul...@gmail.com>; mjamal patiwala <medi...@yahoo.co.in>; "mk...@radioislam.co.za" <mk...@radioislam.co.za>; "mkasi...@yahoo.com" <mkasi...@yahoo.com>; "mkem...@hotmail.com" <mkem...@hotmail.com>; "mnaz...@btopenworld.com" <mnaz...@btopenworld.com>; Mohd Sajid Shaikh <sajid...@yahoo.co.in>; Mohd. Shariq <shar...@yahoo.co.in>; muazzam naik <muazz...@hotmail.com>; Mujeeb Adil <mujee...@rediffmail.com>; Mujtaba Farooq <mujtaba...@gmail.com>; "mumt...@hotmail.com" <mumt...@hotmail.com>; "muqteda...@yahoo.com" <muqteda...@yahoo.com>; musaed alsubaie <alsu...@yahoo.com>; "mus...@del3.vsnl.net.in" <mus...@del3.vsnl.net.in>; "mus...@ndc.vsnl.net.in" <mus...@ndc.vsnl.net.in>; "muslimpa...@hotmail.com" <muslimpa...@hotmail.com>; muzzammil husaini <rinews...@rediffmail.com>; "mzki...@hotmail.com" <mzki...@hotmail.com>; "na...@sancharnet.in" <na...@sancharnet.in>; Nasimul Hasan <nasi...@hotmail.com>; "nasim...@hotmail.com" <nasim...@hotmail.com>; Nasir Rakhangi <nasirr...@gmail.com>; navaid hamid <navai...@yahoo.co.in>; "ne...@muslimsweekly.com" <ne...@muslimsweekly.com>; "ne...@timeatlantic.com" <ne...@timeatlantic.com>; "newse...@channelnewsasia.com" <newse...@channelnewsasia.com>; Newsfromindia786 <Newsfrom...@hotmail.com>; "news...@news.com.au" <news...@news.com.au>; nigar <ni...@yahoo.co.in>; "nmuha...@yahoo.com" <nmuha...@yahoo.com>; "oicca...@arab.net.sa" <oicca...@arab.net.sa>; "okha...@mit.edu" <okha...@mit.edu>; "Omar...@aol.com" <Omar...@aol.com>; "omeras...@aol.com" <omeras...@aol.com>; OpEd <op...@csps.com>; "op...@freepress.com" <op...@freepress.com>; "opi...@japantimes.co.jp" <opi...@japantimes.co.jp>; "opi...@manilatimes.net" <opi...@manilatimes.net>; "out...@outlookindia.com" <out...@outlookindia.com>; "pio...@del2.vsnl.net.in" <pio...@del2.vsnl.net.in>; "politic...@guardianunlimited.co.uk" <politic...@guardianunlimited.co.uk>; "po...@anitapratap.com" <po...@anitapratap.com>; qureish raghib <qhra...@yahoo.co.in>; "rabey...@yahoo.com" <rabey...@yahoo.com>; "radianc...@vsnl.com" <radianc...@vsnl.com>; "ra...@thelodhiacenter.org" <ra...@thelodhiacenter.org>; "razaa...@hotmail.com" <razaa...@hotmail.com>; "rehmanf...@yahoo.com" <rehmanf...@yahoo.com>; S A Hannan <saha...@sonarbangladesh.com>; "sa...@rediffmail.com" <sa...@rediffmail.com>; "sa_...@eth.net" <sa_...@eth.net>; "saad...@yahoo.co.uk" <saad...@yahoo.co.uk>; Sadr Shaikh <sadrs...@gmail.com>; saeed naqvi <saeed...@hotmail.com>; Saidul Islam <msa...@gmail.com>; Sajid Siddiqui <sid...@yahoo.com>; "sa...@comcast.net" <sa...@comcast.net>; "sajja...@newcivilisation.com" <sajja...@newcivilisation.com>; "sali...@msn.com" <sali...@msn.com>; "sarfar...@rediffmail.com" <sarfar...@rediffmail.com>; Seema Mustafa <seemam...@gmail.com>; shabana qureshi <shabanaqu...@yahoo.com>; Shabih Hasan <sha...@hotmail.com>; "sha...@indianmuslims.org" <Sha...@indianmuslims.org>; shafi wassan <shafi...@yahoo.co.in>; "shah_...@hotmail.com" <shah_...@hotmail.com>; Shaikh Sadik <shaik...@gmail.com>; shakeel dad <shakeel...@yahoo.com>; Sherwani Mustafa <sherw...@yahoo.com>; "shujas...@hotmail.com" <shujas...@hotmail.com>; Siraj Wahab <siraj...@arabnews.com>; "stl...@sph.com.sg" <stl...@sph.com.sg>; "st...@indiatimes.com" <st...@indiatimes.com>; Subhash Gatade <subhash...@gmail.com>; "sufi...@gmail.com" <sufi...@gmail.com>; "sultan...@yahoo.co.uk" <sultan...@yahoo.co.uk>; Syed Khalique Ahmed <ie.sk...@gmail.com>; Syed Mazhar <mazhar...@yahoo.co.in>; syed tausief <tau...@hotmail.com>; syediftikhar <syedif...@rediffmail.com>; "syedtahi...@hotmail.com" <syedtahi...@hotmail.com>; "tau...@sancharnet.in" <tau...@sancharnet.in>; "tavlee...@expressindia.com" <tavlee...@expressindia.com>; "tha...@net.sy" <tha...@net.sy>; The Milli Gazette <ed...@milligazette.com>; The Review <the-r...@dawn.com>; "theh...@vsnl.com" <theh...@vsnl.com>; "thesta...@vsnl.com" <thesta...@vsnl.com>; "thin...@pbs.org" <thin...@pbs.org>; "ti...@upi.com" <ti...@upi.com>; "toiedi...@timesgroup.com" <toiedi...@timesgroup.com>; "tte...@abpmail.com" <tte...@abpmail.com>; Tufail Shaikh <tuf...@gmail.com>; "twf-org-f...@lb.bcentral.com" <twf-org-f...@lb.bcentral.com>; "umarg...@yahoo.com" <umarg...@yahoo.com>; "v...@ndf.vsnl.net.in" <v...@ndf.vsnl.net.in>; "webm...@dawn.com" <webm...@dawn.com>; "webm...@jang.com.pk" <webm...@jang.com.pk>; "webm...@tehrantimes.com" <webm...@tehrantimes.com>; "webm...@thejakartapost.com" <webm...@thejakartapost.com>; "y.alibh...@independent.co.uk" <y.alibh...@independent.co.uk>; YAHYA BUKHARI (Delhi) <syedyahy...@yahoo.com>; Yamin Zakaria <yam...@yahoo.co.uk>; "yara...@msn.com" <yara...@msn.com>; YASIR KHAN <yasi...@gmail.com>; Zafar Iqbal <raabta...@yahoo.com>; "z...@vsnl.com" <z...@vsnl.com>; Zohra Javed <zoh...@rediffmail.com>; ZUBER GOPALANI <zgop...@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, December 18, 2008 11:55:20 AM
Subject: Fwd: THE POLICE STORY STANDS SHATTERED!
---------- Forwarded message ----------
![]()
__,_._,___
anand patwardhan
one consequence of these theories is that it may prevent genuine introspection amongst muslims and hindus. it is a fact, no matter who created them first, that both islamic and hindutva terror are a reality. we are victimized by both and we need to fight ideologically against both.
anand patwardhan
would like to share here the views of pervez hoodbhoy from pakistan:
The Mumbai Massacres And Pakistan's Nightmare To Come
An Interview With Dr. Pervez
Hoodbhoy
Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy is chairman of the physics
department at Quaid-e-Azam University in
Islamabad, a frequent commentator on nuclear and
security matters, and a member of the Permanent
Monitoring Panel on Terrorism of the World
Federation of Scientists. This interview was
conducted by Cristina Otten for FOCUS and may
be found on-line (in German) at:
http://www.focus.de/politik/ausland/tid-12856/pakistan-die-menschen-sindblind-
vor-hass_aid_355157.html
Tensions between Pakistan and India have been growing after
the Mumbai attacks. Are we close to a military escalation?
In spite of vociferous demands by the Indian public, Manmohan
Singh's government has withstood the pressure to conduct crossborder
strikes into Pakistan. Correspondingly, in spite of the bitter
criticism by Islamic parties, Pakistan's government has taken some
action against the Lashkar-e-Tayyaba (LeT), the jihadist organization
that is quite probably behind the attacks. For now, the tension has
eased somewhat but another attack could push India over the fence.
What makes the LeT so different from other militant groups? Is
Pakistan really moving against it?
LeT, one of the largest militant groups in Pakistan, was established
over 15 years ago. It had the full support of the Pakistani military and
Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) for over a decade because it focussed
upon fighting Indian rule in Muslim Kashmir. Today it is one of the
very few extremist groups left that does not attack the Pakistani army
and state; in contrast almost all others have turned into mortal
enemies. We now hear that a few members of LeT, who were named
by India, have been arrested. Time will tell whether this was a serious
move, or if this was a ruse to ease the enormous pressure against
Pakistan. If serious, then the Army and ISI will have earned the bitter
enmity of yet another former ally. They are afraid of a repeat of their
experience with Jaish-e-Muhammad, a formerly supported Islamic
militant group that now is responsible for extreme brutalities, including
torture and decapitations, of Pakistani soldiers captured in FATA. It's a
nightmarish situation for the Pakistan Army.
2
How have Pakistanis reacted to the Mumbai massacre?
The initial reaction was of sympathy. I did not see any celebrations,
contrary to those I saw after 911. But then, as the Indian TV channels
started accusing Pakistan and demanding that it be bombed in
retaliation, the reaction turned to that of anger and then flat denial –
Pakistanis did not want to accept that this attack was done by
Pakistanis or had been launched from Pakistani soil. Subsequently one
saw amazing mental calisthenics. Popular TV anchors, and their
guests, invoked far-out conspiracy theories. Years ago, some of the
same anchors had confidently (but wrongly) claimed that Kathmandu-
Delhi Indian Airlines Flight 814 (IC814) had been hijacked by RAW to
malign Pakistan. They had also ridiculed the notion that Pakistan was
involved in the Kargil invasion. Now, pointing to the RSS hand in the
Samjhota Express bombing, they are alternately ascribing the Mumbai
attacks to radical Hindus, and to Jews and Americans. It is sad to see
intelligent persons losing their marbles.
Pakistan has always stressed that it will deliver the first
nuclear strike if it feels threatened by India? Do you see any
signs on the Pakistani sign to carry out its threat?
About a week before the Mumbai massacre, President Asif Ali Zardari
had given the assurance that Pakistan would not use nuclear weapons
first. India had announced a no first use policy almost ten years ago.
But Zardari is not taken seriously by the Pakistani generals who
actually control the Bomb, and the Indian NFU declaration is frankly of
no consequence. Cross-border raids by India could well ignite a
conventional war. If that happens, all bets are off and it could escalate
without warning into a nuclear conflict. For many years US defence
strategists, belonging to various think tanks and war colleges, have
been simulating conflicts between Pakistan and India. They say that a
conventional war will almost certainly lead to a nuclear conclusion.
Fear of nuclear weapons has made deterrence work. More accurately,
deterrence has worked only thus far. No guarantees can be given for
the future.
Why did the assassins choose India instead of committing
attacks against Western allies in Afghanistan?
LeT is based around Lahore, which is on the Pakistan-India border, in a
town called Muridke. This has a huge militant training and charity
complex. LeT's membership is mostly Punjabi, which makes it
linguistically and culturally quite unsuited for fighting in Afghanistan.
You could say that LeT is an India-specific, Kashmir-specific group.
Indeed, over the years it has had many military successes in Kashmir
3
against Indian forces. But LeT, like other militant groups in Pakistan,
sees a nexus between Indians, Americans, and Israelis. Hence they
are all seen as enemies and fair game.
What did the Mumbai terrorists want?
No demands were made and all hostages were killed. So the purpose
of the attack was never formally declared. On the other hand, the
stated goals of LeT and similar organizations based in Pakistan leave
little doubt. The attack clearly sought to hurt India's economy and its
newly acquired reputation as an economic powerhouse, and to create
a climate of war between India and Pakistan. If Pakistan moves its
troops towards the eastern border the pressure on the Taliban in
FATA, which is close to the western border, would be lessened. Still
another reason would be to encourage pogroms against Muslims in
India. This would swell the ranks of the extremists, and also have the
added benefit of destabilizing both the Pakistani and Indian states.
Finally, the attack was a means of releasing hatred against non-
Muslims.
What differences and parallels do you see between the Mumbai
attacks and the attack in the in Marriott Hotel in Islamabad?
They were quite dissimilar in how they were executed. The Mumbai
attacks were extremely intricate, used GPS and voice-over-internet
protocols for communication purposes, involved extensive military
training, and probably required planning over a period of a year. The
goal was to kill foreigners, particularly Jews and Americans, although
Muslims were also collateral casualties. On the other hand, the Marriot
bombing in Islamabad was a relatively simple affair involving a single
dump-truck with a suicide bomber, and its victims were principally
Muslims. The basic purpose, however, was similar – to destabilize the
Pakistani state, take revenge on the US (2 of the 58 killed were US
marines), and raise the cost of war in Afghanistan and FATA.
In the West experts talk about a new dimension of terror in
India. Do you also see tight connections between Lashkar-e-
Taiba and al-Qaida?
One is naturally tempted to guess a nexus between LeT and Al-Qaida.
Of course, they do share similar goals. But in the world that extremists
inhabit, mere similarity is insufficient – it has to be much closer than
that and small ideological differences are amplified out of proportion.
As yet there is no proof of joint operations or cooperation. So
presently this is no more than a plausible hypothesis.
4
What role does Kashmir play in the current conflict?
Since 1987, Kashmir has been in a state of upheaval. Fraudulent
elections conducted by India led to widespread resentment, followed
by a horrifically bloody crackdown by Indian security forces. Pakistan's
army saw opportunity in this, and waged a covert war in Kashmir
using jihadists to "bleed India with a thousand cuts". The United Jihad
Council, which oversees the activities of an estimated 22 Pakistanbased
organizations, acts outside of the domain of the Pakistani state
but it has had active support from the country's army and intelligence
agencies. The Kargil conflict in 1999 brought matters to a head when
General Musharraf initiated a war with the assistance of jihadist forces.
This inflicted severe damage on Indian forces but Pakistan was
ultimately forced to withdraw. Jihadists subsequently celebrated
General Musharraf as a hero, and vilified Nawaz Sharif for a cowardly
surrender.
In January 2002, General Musharraf had declared that no
groups on Pakistani territory would be permitted to launch
cross-border attacks. Was this promise fulfilled?
Subsequently there indeed was a decline in cross-border infiltrations,
and some lessening of the covert support given by Pakistani agencies.
But this was far from zero and they maintained a strong presence. On
a personal note: soon after the terrible October 8, 2005 earthquake, I
had gone to various areas of Azad Kashmir for relief work. There I
found the Lashkar-i-Tayyaba, Jaish-e-Muhammad, Sipah-i-Sahaba,
and other banned jihadist organizations operating openly and freely
using military-style six-wheeled vehicles, as well as displaying their
weapons. Their relief efforts were far better organized than that of the
Pakistan army and, in fact, they were pulling injured soldiers out of the
rubble. When I mentioned this fact to General Musharraf a few months
later at a Kashmir peace conference, he was very angry at me for
discussing a tabooed subject.
On the one hand, we have radical extremists in Pakistan who
want to bring strict Islamic law into force and demonize the
West. On the other hand, however, the government presents
itself as a friend and ally of the United States. Could you please
describe this antagonism and explain where it originates from?
What does this tell us about the growth of extremism in
Pakistan?
Radical extremism is the illegitimate offspring of a union between the
United States under Ronald Reagan, and Pakistan under General Zia5
ul-Haq. Twenty five years ago, the two countries had joined up to
harness Islamic fighters for expelling the Soviets from Afghanistan.
The US was quite happy to see radical Islam spreading because it
served its goal at the time. Simultaneously, Pakistan saw a major
social transformation under General Zia. Prayers in government
departments were deemed compulsory, floggings were carried out
publicly, punishments were meted out to those who did not fast in
Ramadan, selection for university academic posts required that the
candidate demonstrate knowledge of Islamic teachings, and jihad was
declared essential for every Muslim. But today the government is in
open conflict with the radicals. It has to deal with a spontaneous
groundswell of Islamic zeal. The notion of an Islamic state – as yet in
some amorphous and diffuse form – is more popular today than ever
before as people look desperately for miracles to rescue a failing state.
Even though the government and military in Pakistan are allied
formally to the US, the people are strongly against the US.
What parts of the Pakistani society support al-Qaida and
Osama bin Laden?
Baluchistan and Sind are far less supportive than Punjab or the NWFP.
The amazing fact is that parts of Pakistan's upper class – which is very
Westernized but also very anti-Western – also support the Islamists. I
find it tragic that there is no uproar in the country when Taliban
suicide bombers target mosques, funerals, hospitals, girls schools, and
slaughter policemen and soldiers. People have become so anti-
American that it has blinded them to these atrocities. Even the
Pakistani left is thoroughly confused and mistakes the Taliban as antiimperialist
fighters.
And where do you stand on this matter? Do you see anything
that the Islamists have to offer?
The people of Pakistan need and deserve everything that people
everywhere else want. This means food, jobs, houses to live in, a
system of justice and governance, and protection of life and property.
Equally, people need freedom of worship and thought, education for
both males and females, and protection of their freedom as
summarized in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. These are
everybody's primary needs. After this – a distinct second – come
matters that deal with national sovereignty, foreign policy, various
global issues, etc. Frankly, I cannot see Pakistan's Islamists offering
anything positive. They are against population planning, educating
females, tolerating other sects or religions, etc. They neither know the
outside world, nor want to know it. All they know – and know well – is
how to make war. Fortunately, as their rout in the recent elections
6
showed, most Pakistanis do not want to live under their narrow
doctrines and belief system.
President Asif Ali Zardari promised to hunt terrorists and to
destroy terror camps in Pakistan? But his affirmations seem to
be halfhearted. Can't he do more or doesn't he want do more?
It is not up to him to do more. The real power lies with the Pakistan
Army, which is still undecided as to who the real enemy is. The Army
has lost nearly two thousand soldiers in battles with extremists. But it
still cannot convince itself that they constitute an existentialist threat
to Pakistan. One can understand this reluctance. Over the years,
officers and soldiers were recruited into the Army on the basis that
they were defenders of Islam and would always fight India. Instead
they now have to fight forces that claim to be even better defenders of
Islam. Worse, they are no longer being called upon to fight India,
which is what they were trained for. So there is confusion and
demoralization, and practically zero public understanding or support.
Therefore, Pakistani soldiers are not fighting well at all in FATA. Many
have surrendered without a fight. This is the first time in my life that I
feel the Army should be supported, but only to the extent that it fights
the extremists without killing innocents. Unfortunately, the Army's
current tactic is to flatten villages suspected of harbouring terrorists.
The collateral damage is huge and completely unacceptable.
Pakistan has armed and financed the Taliban after the US
invasion of Afghanistan. The CIA pays Pakistan to arrest al-
Qaeda operatives, but Pakistan uses the money to fund the
Taliban resurgence in northwest Pakistan. Any changes under
the new president?
It will take time – and perhaps still more suffering – to kick an old
habit. Even though the Army is being literally slaughtered by the
Taliban, it continues to make a distinction between the "good" and
"bad" Taliban. The good ones are, by definition, those who attack only
US/Nato or Indian interests in Afghanistan, but do not attack the
Pakistan Army. The good ones are seen as essential for having a
friendly Afghanistan when, as will surely happen some day, the
Americans withdraw. Among the good Taliban are jihadist leaders such
as Jalaludin Haqqani. On the other hand, Baitullah Mehsud or Maulana
Fazlullah, are considered bad Taliban because they attack the Army
and the state. Interestingly, Army inspired propaganda paints the bad
Taliban as Indian agents – which is quite ridiculous. This false
differentiation is the real reason for the Army's ambivalence and
inability to deal effectively with the Taliban menace.
7
Pakistan is a nuclear state. Should we fear that one day the
Taliban or al-Qaida could get access to the nuclear arsenal?
I am more worried about extremists having access to nuclear
materials, particularly highly enriched uranium, rather than a
completed weapon. Because of secrecy requirements, it is very difficult
for outsiders to monitor the output of uranium enrichment or
plutonium reprocessing plants. Interestingly, we are seeing a shift
away from nuclear weapons in the West. The unusability of nuclear
weapons by national states is being recognized even by mainstream
politicians in the US and Europe because they no longer guarantee the
monopoly of power. This makes possible the ultimate de-legitimization
of nuclear weapons, and hence winding down of fissile material
production globally. This may be our best long-term hope of
countering the nuclear terrorist threat, whether by Al-Qaida or other
terrorist groups. Meanwhile, in the short term, great care must be
given to watching over suspicious nuclear activities.
What should India do and what is your forecast for the region?
India should not attack Pakistan. This would be counter-productive in
every possible way. Even if it wins a war, it will be a pyrrhic victory.
On the other hand, a small attack can be no more than a pin-prick.
This would do more harm than good because it will unite the army and
the jihadists who, at this juncture in history, are in serious
confrontation with each other. Worse, even a small attack could lead
to large response, and then escalate out of control. Nuclear armed
countries simply cannot afford skirmishes. I think India's demand for
action against jihadist groups is entirely legitimate, but this must be
done by Pakistan, which is susceptible to international pressure. To get
rid of militants and extremists – whether Muslim or Hindu – is in the
best interests of both Pakistan and India.
Will Pakistani extremists win or can the West still bring about a
rebound?
It's a grim situation but not irreversible. The invasion of Iraq, and US
imperial policies over the last decades, created a hatred for Americans
that ultimately translated into support for all who fight them. Most
Pakistanis do not approve of the Taliban's fundamental and primitivist
social agenda. But, by virtue of fighting the Americans, popular
sentiment is still with them. So, reducing anti-Americanism is the key.
One hopes that Barack Obama will be able to undo some of the harm
his country did to Pakistan. Let's see. But basically it is for Pakistanis –
not Indians or anybody else – to fight it out. We Pakistanis have to
realize that this is a war for our very existence as a civilized nation.
8
Western support for Pakistan must be very judicious and not too overt.
Similarly, isolating Pakistan, or inflicting harsh punitive measures,
could easily backfire. The Taliban and allied extremists have a real
chance of winning in Pakistan. The state is already crumbling in places
and it could disintegrate quite rapidly, leaving the fanatics in charge.
One cannot think of a bigger disaster for Pakistan.
-------------
To: 20...@abc.com; 48h...@cbsnews.com; aalami...@rediffmail.com; afza...@hotmail.com; agni...@yahoo.com; aija...@khaleejtimes.com; akhbare...@yahoo.co.in; aleem....@gmail.com; alma...@arabnews.com; amah...@detaone.in; am...@arf-asia.org; ambas...@embassyofpakistanusa.org; amki...@gmail.com; andal...@yahoo.com; arsh...@gmail.com; ashraf....@hindustantimes.com; ash...@idafa.com; asi...@yahoo.com; ass...@gmail.com; a...@npr.org; au_...@yahoo.co.in; ayesh...@expressindia.com; azim....@wipro.com; bags...@yahoo.com; Bakhtiarspa...@yahoo.no; Bar...@ndtv.com; bbcw...@bbc.co.uk; burneyaz...@hotmail.com; chair...@nic.in; c...@medleylab.com; cov...@mjakbar.org; c...@vsnl.com; crmo...@gmail.com; ctc-tri...@tribune.com; date...@nbc.com; dawa...@indiatimes.com; de...@asianews.it; doctor...@yahoo.com; drbhan...@sify.com; earl...@cbs.com; edi...@islamicamagazine.com; edi...@metimes.com; edi...@newageislam.com; edi...@usatoday.com; edit...@expressindia.com; eng...@palestine-info.co.uk; epw.m...@gmail.com; eve...@cbsnews.com; fa...@fair.org; Foxr...@foxnews.com; f...@cbsnews.com; Han...@foxnews.com; hard...@msnbc.com; hasans...@googlegroups.com; in...@ap.org; in...@isim.nl; in...@muslimobserver.com; ism...@gmail.com; jadeed...@gmail.com; jameel...@gmail.com; kaling...@gmail.com; let...@newsweek.com; let...@usnews.com; m_sal...@yahoo.com; maga...@dawn.com; mah...@yahoo.com; mahmood...@vsnl.net; manoha...@yahoo.co.in; markaz...@gmail.com; markazu...@yahoogroups.com; mcbm...@mcb.org.uk; mdsha...@gmail.com; meh...@gmail.com; memehd...@yahoo.co.in; mhh...@yahoo.com; mohamme...@mid-day.com; Mohsin...@gmail.com; mohsi...@hotmail.co.uk; mor...@npr.org; msso...@hotmail.com; mubassh...@gmail.com; mukhtar...@yahoo.com; munsi...@eth.net; Muslims...@yahoogroups.com; nasi...@yahoo.com; nation...@rediffmail.com; net...@abc.com; ne...@alqamar.org; newsb...@etemaaddaily.com; news...@pbs.org; newswat...@gmail.com; nigh...@abcnews.com; nig...@nbc.com; n...@canadianislamiccongress.com; nyt...@nytimes.com; ombu...@npr.org; ombu...@washpost.com; Onthe...@foxnews.com; Ore...@foxnews.com; perve...@eth.net; pra...@ndtv.com; p...@trans.in; publ...@muslimfreepress.com; qaumiaw...@erdiffmail.com; qurb...@gmail.com; qur...@josloc.com; radianc...@gmail.com; rah...@hotmail.com; ram...@vsnl.com; r...@indiatribune.com; reade...@latimes.com; rhed...@gmail.com; rinaislami...@yahoo.co.in; rizvi...@yahoo.com; rsha...@gmail.com; ru...@eibnet.com; sadiyac...@gmail.com; saeed...@yahoo.com; sahafa...@yahoo.co.uk; sahil...@hotmail.com; sajad...@yahoo.com; sardesai...@gmail.com; sar...@hotmail.com; sayeed....@gmail.com; secret...@bol.net.in; shad...@yahoo.com; shaki...@yahoo.com; she...@vsnl.com; shekhar...@express2.indexp.co.in; shobha.s...@merinews.com; Spe...@foxnews.com; sudheen...@gmail.com; syed_was...@yahoo.com; syedsaj...@yahoo.com; tanveer...@gmail.com; tanveer...@gmail.com; tari...@btinternet.com; teesta...@gmail.com; thedai...@yahoo.com; Tinas...@yahoo.com; to...@nbc.com; to...@npr.org; tsa...@hotmail.com; u_g...@yahoo.com; unni...@gmail.com; UrduTa...@googlegroups.com; voiceof...@rediffmail.com; waha...@yahoo.com; wa...@spa.gov.sa; webm...@allama-mashriqi.8m.com; webm...@jasarat.com; webm...@nation.com.pk; webmasw...@asiantribune.com; writ...@gmail.com; yase...@gmail.com; ya...@yawarbaig.com; yogendr...@gmail.com; zafar...@yahoo.co.in; zeeshan...@hindustantimes.com; SHAHI IMAM AHAMED BUKHARI <si...@hotmail.com>; 786 <7...@muslimrevival.com>; aariz_mohammed <aariz_m...@yahoo.co.in>; Abdul Hafiz Lakhani <lakh...@yahoo.com>; Abdul Hasib <ha...@mtnl.net.in>; Abdul Wahid Azad <abdul.wa...@googlemail.com>; "abdulr...@hotmail.com" <abdulr...@hotmail.com>; Abdus Sattar Ghazali <asghaz...@yahoo.com>; "abl...@yahoo.com" <abl...@yahoo.com>; abu zafar <abuza...@gmail.com>; "abuas...@hotmail.com" <abuas...@hotmail.com>; "ad...@mcb.org.uk" <ad...@mcb.org.uk>; afternoonletters <afternoo...@gmail.com>; ahmed soroor <soroo...@yahoo.com>; "ahmeda...@yahoo.com" <ahmeda...@yahoo.com>; "ahram...@ahram.org.eg" <ahram...@ahram.org.eg>; Ajit Sahi <aj...@tehelka.com>; akbar hasan <malik_a...@yahoo.co.in>; Akhtar Ali Khan <naj...@yahoo.co.uk>; Alan Border <withh...@yahoo.com>; "ali_z...@hotmail.com" <ali_z...@hotmail.com>; "aliha...@aol.com" <aliha...@aol.com>; Amanullah Khan <ak1...@rediffmail.com>; Amaresh Misra <misra....@gmail.com>; "ami...@ilaam.net" <ami...@ilaam.net>; amr_cnbc <amr_...@yahoo.co.in>; anees <anees.m...@rediffmail.com>; "arifiq...@yahoo.co.in" <arifiq...@yahoo.co.in>; arshi khan <khanar...@rediffmail.com>; "ar...@aol.com" <ar...@aol.com>; "ashra...@hotmail.com" <ashra...@hotmail.com>; "asif...@hotmail.com" <asif...@hotmail.com>; aslam ghazi <mag...@indiatimes.com>; "atha...@yahoo.co.in" <atha...@yahoo.co.in>; "ayesha...@tufts.edu" <ayesha...@tufts.edu>; "a...@georgetown.edu" <a...@georgetown.edu>; "ayubp...@hotmail.com" <ayubp...@hotmail.com>; "b_q...@hotmail.com" <b_q...@hotmail.com>; Badri Raina <badri...@gmail.com>; bashiruddin babukhan <bashirudd...@yahoo.com>; BBC World Service <worldservi...@bbc.co.uk>; "ca...@cair-net.org" <ca...@cair-net.org>; CARD <ca...@ricmail.com>; "cdlr_m...@hotmail.com" <cdlr_m...@hotmail.com>; "comm...@foxnews.com" <comm...@foxnews.com>; "comm...@truthout.org" <comm...@truthout.org>; Cowasjee Dawn <ar...@cyber.net.pk>; Daily Millat <edi...@millat.com>; danish reyaz <danis...@gmail.com>; Dr A R Mookhi <drmo...@hotmail.com>; Dr Arshad G Moh'd <arsh...@yahoo.com>; DR.QASIM RASOOL ILYAS <sqri...@gmail.com>; "dr_ph...@hotmail.com" <dr_ph...@hotmail.com>; "drabdulk...@yahoo.com" <drabdulk...@yahoo.com>; "drrehm...@yahoo.co.in" <drrehm...@yahoo.co.in>; drsalimkhan <drsal...@hotmail.com>; "dtle...@telegraph.co.uk" <dtle...@telegraph.co.uk>; "edi...@timesgroup.com" <edi...@timesgroup.com>; "edi...@aljazeerah.info" <edi...@aljazeerah.info>; "edi...@amperspective.com" <edi...@amperspective.com>; "edi...@centralchronical.com" <edi...@centralchronical.com>; "edi...@deccanherald.co.in" <edi...@deccanherald.co.in>; "edi...@deccanmail.com" <edi...@deccanmail.com>; "edi...@greaterkashmir.com" <edi...@greaterkashmir.com>; "edi...@ibnlive.com" <edi...@ibnlive.com>; "edi...@iexpressusa.com" <edi...@iexpressusa.com>; "edi...@medialens.org" <edi...@medialens.org>; "Edi...@MediaMonitors.net" <Edi...@mediamonitors.net>; "edi...@muslimedia.com" <edi...@muslimedia.com>; "edi...@nawaiwaqt.com.pk" <edi...@nawaiwaqt.com.pk>; "edi...@newsindia-times.com" <edi...@newsindia-times.com>; "edi...@nytimes.com" <edi...@nytimes.com>; "edi...@the-week.com" <edi...@the-week.com>; "edi...@themuslimweekly.com" <edi...@themuslimweekly.com>; "edi...@urdutimes.org" <edi...@urdutimes.org>; "edi...@zaman.com.tr" <edi...@zaman.com.tr>; "edit...@indiaabroad.com" <edit...@indiaabroad.com>; "edi...@newsweek.com" <edi...@newsweek.com>; ehtasham khan <ehtas...@yahoo.co.in>; "email...@gmail.com" <email...@gmail.com>; "etv...@bom8.vsnl.net.in" <etv...@bom8.vsnl.net.in>; "express...@express.co.uk" <express...@express.co.uk>; "f.k...@unsw.edu.au" <f.k...@unsw.edu.au>; "faisal...@hotmail.com" <faisal...@hotmail.com>; "faisal...@gmail.com" <faisal...@gmail.com>; "farr...@hotmail.com" <farr...@hotmail.com>; "far...@pacbell.net" <far...@pacbell.net>; "fchaud...@gmail.com" <fchaud...@gmail.com>; "feed...@tehelka.com" <feed...@tehelka.com>; Feroze Mithiborwala <feroze...@gmail.com>; "fffk...@yahoo.com" <fffk...@yahoo.com>; "f...@vsnl.com" <f...@vsnl.com>; "FP...@fpri.org" <FP...@fpri.org>; Friday Times <t...@lhr.comsats.net.pk>; "fron...@thehindu.co.in" <fron...@thehindu.co.in>; G. R. Siddiqui <grs...@gmail.com>; "gall...@parliament.uk" <gall...@parliament.uk>; ghaziahmed shaikh <ghazi...@hotmail.com>; "gil...@nsstc.uah.edu" <gil...@nsstc.uah.edu>; GM.Shaikh <gm.sha...@gmail.com>; "gpsh...@rediff.com" <gpsh...@rediff.com>; hanif lakdawala <m...@rediffmail.com>; Hasan Shabbir <HasanS...@gmail.com>; haseeb <has...@aspratech.com>; "hasn...@yahoo.com" <hasn...@yahoo.com>; "hina...@gmail.com" <hina...@gmail.com>; "hindusta...@yahoo.com" <hindusta...@yahoo.com>; "hsi...@thestar.ca" <hsi...@thestar.ca>; "hsi...@yahoo.com" <hsi...@yahoo.com>; "hyd1_...@sancharnet.in" <hyd1_...@sancharnet.in>; "iah...@nicholaspiramal.co.in" <iah...@nicholaspiramal.co.in>; "id_n...@yahoo.co.in" <id_n...@yahoo.co.in>; "ideam...@yahoo.com" <ideam...@yahoo.com>; "iftikha...@gmail.com" <iftikha...@gmail.com>; "iht-l...@iht.com" <iht-l...@iht.com>; Impact International <edi...@impactnews.demon.co.uk>; "imtiyaz...@gmail.com" <imtiyaz...@gmail.com>; "inderma...@hotmail.com" <inderma...@hotmail.com>; Indian Muslim Council <me...@imc-usa.org>; Indian Muslims <mohib...@gmail.com>; Indian Muslims <shaa...@gmail.com>; Info <in...@futureislam.com>; "in...@beiruttimes.com" <in...@beiruttimes.com>; "in...@ibn.net" <in...@ibn.net>; "in...@ihrc.org" <in...@ihrc.org>; "in...@jamiat.org.za" <in...@jamiat.org.za>; "in...@mediareviewnet.com" <in...@mediareviewnet.com>; "in...@merinews.com" <in...@merinews.com>; "in...@mpacuk.org" <in...@mpacuk.org>; "in...@oic-oci.org" <in...@oic-oci.org>; "in...@palestinechronicle.com" <in...@palestinechronicle.com>; "in...@prc.org.uk" <in...@prc.org.uk>; "in...@shanghaidaily.com" <in...@shanghaidaily.com>; "in...@siasat.com" <in...@siasat.com>; "in...@yvonneridley.org" <in...@yvonneridley.org>; "intern...@upi.com" <intern...@upi.com>; iqbal a ansari <iqbala...@gmail.com>; "iqbal...@gmail.com" <iqbal...@gmail.com>; "ircg...@yahoo.com" <ircg...@yahoo.com>; "irfa...@hotmail.com" <irfa...@hotmail.com>; "iscr...@ntu.edu.sg" <iscr...@ntu.edu.sg>; "is...@irf.net" <is...@irf.net>; "j.st...@guardian.co.uk" <j.st...@guardian.co.uk>; "jadid...@rediffmail.com" <jadid...@rediffmail.com>; "jam...@del6.vsnl.net.in" <jam...@del6.vsnl.net.in>; "jamia...@bol.net.in" <jamia...@bol.net.in>; "javed...@rediffmail.com" <javed...@rediffmail.com>; "jave...@yahoo.com" <jave...@yahoo.com>; "ja...@muslimsweekly.com" <ja...@muslimsweekly.com>; John Dayal <cathol...@gmail.com>; "jot...@jpf.com.jo" <jot...@jpf.com.jo>; "junaid...@yahoo.com" <junaid...@yahoo.com>; Juzar Bandukwala <drband...@yahoo.co.in>; Juzer Mohammed Husain <rez...@gmail.com>; "k_k_...@hotmail.com" <k_k_...@hotmail.com>; "kamalf...@hotmail.com" <kamalf...@hotmail.com>; "karama...@hotmail.com" <karama...@hotmail.com>; kaukab siddique <buts...@msn.com>; "kbat...@al-madina.com.sa" <kbat...@al-madina.com.sa>; "khaba...@bol.net.in" <khaba...@bol.net.in>; "khalida...@gmail.com" <khalida...@gmail.com>; Khan Arif <ank2...@yahoo.com>; "khan...@rediffmail.com" <khan...@rediffmail.com>; "khat...@msn.com" <khat...@msn.com>; "khwaj...@rediffmail.com" <khwaj...@rediffmail.com>; "kin...@gmail.com" <kin...@gmail.com>; "kor...@hotmail.com" <kor...@hotmail.com>; "kti...@emirates.net.ae" <kti...@emirates.net.ae>; "kuldip...@yahoo.com" <kuldip...@yahoo.com>; "letter...@gulfnews.com" <letter...@gulfnews.com>; "let...@globe.com" <let...@globe.com>; "letters...@intoday.com" <letters...@intoday.com>; "let...@arabnews.com" <let...@arabnews.com>; "let...@atimes.com" <let...@atimes.com>; "let...@dailytimes.com.pk" <let...@dailytimes.com.pk>; "let...@dawn.com" <let...@dawn.com>; "let...@hardnewsmedia.com" <let...@hardnewsmedia.com>; "let...@hindustantimes.com" <let...@hindustantimes.com>; "let...@independent.co.uk" <let...@independent.co.uk>; "let...@latimes.com" <let...@latimes.com>; "let...@msnbc.com" <let...@msnbc.com>; "let...@newint.org" <let...@newint.org>; "let...@newsday.com" <let...@newsday.com>; "let...@slate.com" <let...@slate.com>; "let...@taipeitimes.com" <let...@taipeitimes.com>; "let...@theage.com.au" <let...@theage.com.au>; "let...@thehindu.co.in" <let...@thehindu.co.in>; "let...@thetimes.co.uk" <let...@thetimes.co.uk>; "let...@time.com" <let...@time.com>; "let...@tribuneindia.com" <let...@tribuneindia.com>; "let...@washingtontimes.com" <let...@washingtontimes.com>; "let...@washpost.com" <let...@washpost.com>; "lette...@thestar.ca" <lette...@thestar.ca>; "lhe...@gulfnews.com" <lhe...@gulfnews.com>; "lo...@vsnl.com" <lo...@vsnl.com>; Lord Meghnad Desai <M.D...@lse.ac.uk>; "m...@ajmal.net" <m...@ajmal.net>; "mahmood...@yahoo.com" <mahmood...@yahoo.com>; Mahtab Alam <mdmaht...@gmail.com>; "ma...@jimas.org" <ma...@jimas.org>; "mai...@nstp.com.my" <mai...@nstp.com.my>; Majid <sid...@yahoo.com>; majlis muslim <muslim...@hotmail.com>; malikkazim2000 <malikka...@rediffmail.com>; Manoj Padhi <manoj...@gmail.com>; "mansur_...@hotmail.com" <mansur_...@hotmail.com>; "man...@ndf.vsnl.net.in" <man...@ndf.vsnl.net.in>; "manzu...@yahoo.com" <manzu...@yahoo.com>; MB. Qasmi <man...@markazulmaarif.org>; "mb...@gsa.state.al.us" <mb...@gsa.state.al.us>; "med...@giasdl01.vsnl.net.in" <med...@giasdl01.vsnl.net.in>; MEDIA CELL <mediac...@gmail.com>; "media...@yahoo.com" <media...@yahoo.com>; "med...@hotmail.com" <med...@hotmail.com>; "mehmo...@rediffmail.com" <mehmo...@rediffmail.com>; "mf...@wiu.edu" <mf...@wiu.edu>; MIRZA ANWARULHAQ <anwarul...@gmail.com>; mjamal patiwala <medi...@yahoo.co.in>; "mk...@radioislam.co.za" <mk...@radioislam.co.za>; "mkasi...@yahoo.com" <mkasi...@yahoo.com>; "mkem...@hotmail.com" <mkem...@hotmail.com>; "mnaz...@btopenworld.com" <mnaz...@btopenworld.com>; Mohd Sajid Shaikh <sajid...@yahoo.co.in>; Mohd. Shariq <shar...@yahoo.co.in>; muazzam naik <muazz...@hotmail.com>; Mujeeb Adil <mujee...@rediffmail.com>; Mujtaba Farooq <mujtaba...@gmail.com>; "mumt...@hotmail.com" <mumt...@hotmail.com>; "muqteda...@yahoo.com" <muqteda...@yahoo.com>; musaed alsubaie <alsu...@yahoo.com>; "mus...@del3.vsnl.net.in" <mus...@del3.vsnl.net.in>; "mus...@ndc.vsnl.net.in" <mus...@ndc.vsnl.net.in>; "muslimpa...@hotmail.com" <muslimpa...@hotmail.com>; muzzammil husaini <rinews...@rediffmail.com>; "mzki...@hotmail.com" <mzki...@hotmail.com>; "na...@sancharnet.in" <na...@sancharnet.in>; Nasimul Hasan <nasi...@hotmail.com>; "nasim...@hotmail.com" <nasim...@hotmail.com>; Nasir Rakhangi <nasirr...@gmail.com>; navaid hamid <navai...@yahoo.co.in>; "ne...@muslimsweekly.com" <ne...@muslimsweekly.com>; "ne...@timeatlantic.com" <ne...@timeatlantic.com>; "newse...@channelnewsasia.com" <newse...@channelnewsasia.com>; Newsfromindia786 <Newsfrom...@hotmail.com>; "news...@news.com.au" <news...@news.com.au>; nigar <ni...@yahoo.co.in>; "nmuha...@yahoo.com" <nmuha...@yahoo.com>; "oicca...@arab.net.sa" <oicca...@arab.net.sa>; "okha...@mit.edu" <okha...@mit.edu>; "Omar...@aol.com" <Omar...@aol.com>; "omeras...@aol.com" <omeras...@aol.com>; OpEd <op...@csps.com>; "op...@freepress.com" <op...@freepress.com>; "opi...@japantimes.co.jp" <opi...@japantimes.co.jp>; "opi...@manilatimes.net" <opi...@manilatimes.net>; "out...@outlookindia.com" <out...@outlookindia.com>; "pio...@del2.vsnl.net.in" <pio...@del2.vsnl.net.in>; "politic...@guardianunlimited.co.uk" <politic...@guardianunlimited.co.uk>; "po...@anitapratap.com" <po...@anitapratap.com>; qureish raghib <qhra...@yahoo.co.in>; "rabey...@yahoo.com" <rabey...@yahoo.com>; "radianc...@vsnl.com" <radianc...@vsnl.com>; "ra...@thelodhiacenter.org" <ra...@thelodhiacenter.org>; "razaa...@hotmail.com" <razaa...@hotmail.com>; "rehmanf...@yahoo.com" <rehmanf...@yahoo.com>; S A Hannan <saha...@sonarbangladesh.com>; "sa...@rediffmail.com" <sa...@rediffmail.com>; "sa_...@eth.net" <sa_...@eth.net>; "saad...@yahoo.co.uk" <saad...@yahoo.co.uk>; Sadr Shaikh <sadrs...@gmail.com>; saeed naqvi <saeed...@hotmail.com>; Saidul Islam <msa...@gmail.com>; Sajid Siddiqui <sid...@yahoo.com>; "sa...@comcast.net" <sa...@comcast.net>; "sajja...@newcivilisation.com" <sajja...@newcivilisation.com>; "sali...@msn.com" <sali...@msn.com>; "sarfar...@rediffmail.com" <sarfar...@rediffmail.com>; Seema Mustafa <seemam...@gmail.com>; shabana qureshi <shabanaqu...@yahoo.com>; Shabih Hasan <sha...@hotmail.com>; "sha...@indianmuslims.org" <Sha...@indianmuslims.org>; shafi wassan <shafi...@yahoo.co.in>; "shah_...@hotmail.com" <shah_...@hotmail.com>; Shaikh Sadik <shaik...@gmail.com>; shakeel dad <shakeel...@yahoo.com>; Sherwani Mustafa <sherw...@yahoo.com>; "shujas...@hotmail.com" <shujas...@hotmail.com>; Siraj Wahab <siraj...@arabnews.com>; "stl...@sph.com.sg" <stl...@sph.com.sg>; "st...@indiatimes.com" <st...@indiatimes.com>; Subhash Gatade <subhash...@gmail.com>; "sufi...@gmail.com" <sufi...@gmail.com>; "sultan...@yahoo.co.uk" <sultan...@yahoo.co.uk>; Syed Khalique Ahmed <ie.sk...@gmail.com>; Syed Mazhar <mazhar...@yahoo.co.in>; syed tausief <tau...@hotmail.com>; syediftikhar <syedif...@rediffmail.com>; "syedtahi...@hotmail.com" <syedtahi...@hotmail.com>; "tau...@sancharnet.in" <tau...@sancharnet.in>; "tavlee...@expressindia.com" <tavlee...@expressindia.com>; "tha...@net.sy" <tha...@net.sy>; The Milli Gazette <ed...@milligazette.com>; The Review <the-r...@dawn.com>; "theh...@vsnl.com" <theh...@vsnl.com>; "thesta...@vsnl.com" <thesta...@vsnl.com>; "thin...@pbs.org" <thin...@pbs.org>; "ti...@upi.com" <ti...@upi.com>; "toiedi...@timesgroup.com" <toiedi...@timesgroup.com>; "tte...@abpmail.com" <tte...@abpmail.com>; Tufail Shaikh <tuf...@gmail.com>; "twf-org-f...@lb.bcentral.com" <twf-org-f...@lb.bcentral.com>; "umarg...@yahoo.com" <umarg...@yahoo.com>; "v...@ndf.vsnl.net.in" <v...@ndf.vsnl.net.in>; "webm...@dawn.com" <webm...@dawn.com>; "webm...@jang.com.pk" <webm...@jang.com.pk>; "webm...@tehrantimes.com" <webm...@tehrantimes.com>; "webm...@thejakartapost.com" <webm...@thejakartapost.com>; "y.alibh...@independent.co.uk" <y.alibh...@independent.co.uk>; YAHYA BUKHARI (Delhi) <syedyahy...@yahoo.com>; Yamin Zakaria <yam...@yahoo.co.uk>; "yara...@msn.com" <yara...@msn.com>; YASIR KHAN <yasi...@gmail.com>; Zafar Iqbal <raabta...@yahoo.com>; "z...@vsnl.com" <z...@vsnl.com>; Zohra Javed <zoh...@rediffmail.com>; ZUBER GOPALANI <zgop...@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, December 18, 2008 11:55:20 AM
Subject: Fwd: THE POLICE STORY STANDS SHATTERED!
---------- Forwarded message ----------
![]()
__,_._,___