greske u filmu
Cor$aiR
ovaj sajt, pa tko zeli neka cita. Ne znam da li je ovo istina jer jos nisam
pogledao film .....pa mi nemojte govoriti ako nije tocno. =)
Hmmm...ovo bi mogla biti neka vrsta spojlera, pa ako zelite zivjeti u
totalnom neznanju dok ne odlucite pogledati film......jednostavno preskocite
post. =)
----------------
1.When Frodo is recovering in Rivendell he goes out onto a balcony, places
his hand on the railing and looks out over the city. However, the railing
for Frodo is waisthigh. Seeing as how he is a 3-foot Hobbit in a city of
human-sized elves, the railing should be over his head.
2.In the scene where Strider throws apples to Merry and Pippin, the second
apple has a label on it - as you would find at the grocers.
3.In the scene where Sam and Frodo are in the field with the scarecrow, you
can plainly see a car cruising past in the distance, from right to left.
4.When Borormir walks towards Merry and Pippin to rescue them in a brief
shot his elven-cloak is open. In the next shot the cloak is perfectly sealed
with the broach again.
5.As Boromir and Aragorn talk right before Boromir dies, you can see
Boromir's right hand gripping Aragorn's left shoulder in the shot from
behind Aragorn's right shoulder, but when the camera veiw changes to
Boromir's perspective, looking up at Aragorn, his hand is not there. The
scene goes back and forth between these two views several times.
6.When Frodo awakes in the bed in Rivendell, Frodo's shirt is open and the
sheet low down on the bed in the first shot, and then his shirt's closed and
the sheet pulled substantially higher in the next shot.
7.When Sean Astin (Sam) and Elijah Wood (Frodo) are in the boat, they switch
positions, first Sam is in front of Frodo, then it cuts away and when it
comes back Frodo is in front of Sam, and it switches off and on.
8.When Frodo stops rolling down the snow covered hill, just before the shot
of Boromir picking up the ring, the place where Frodo's fake hobbit foot and
real leg meet is visible (it's usually covered by his trousers).
9.Director Peter Jackson makes a cameo as the first menacing figure the
hobbits run into in Bree.
10.During the wide, perhaps computer-animated shot when the fellowship walks
up the snow-covered mountain, you can clearly see that they leave no
footsteps or other visible things in the snow after they walked through it.
11.When Sam tells Frodo that if he take another step, he will be farther
away from home than ever before, he stands next to a scarecrow. In the next
scene, we see both Sam and Frodo, and sam has passed the scarecrow with
several metres. Another zoom at Sam, and he stands by the Scarecrow again.
12.In Bag End, once Bilbo has left, and has left the ring on the doorstep
inside, Frodo walks in and looks at the ring. From above, one shot of the
ring has a different floor than in Bag End(it is grey with grooves, not
reddish with cracks). This shot was obviously taken from when the ring lays
atop the table in the middle of the council of Elrond.
13.As the last Black Rider jumps in flames from the top of Weathertop, you
can clearly see the stuntman's breathing snorkle that lets him draw air from
outside of the flames that engulf him.
14.When Frodo and Gandalf are talking in the kitchen of Frodo's house, watch
Frodo. He pours some tea into a cup, and then the very next scene, he is
drinking from a cup, all in a split second as the conversation continues.
15.The elf that fires arrows near the end of the film in the battle sequence
in the forest has a cut above his right eye but when they meet back up at
the river when they go to save Pippin the cut is gone.
16.When Frodo and Arwen are riding with the Nazgul, Frodo had green ooze on
his mouth and eyes. After the Nazgul are swept away with the big wave, Arwen
puts Frodo on the floor and his face is clean.
17.When they are in front of the 2 big statues, the statues raise their left
arms. When they pass them and you can see them from behind, one statue has
raises its left arm and the other its right arm.
18.When the hobbits rush to get off the road at Frodo's demand, the space to
both sides of the tree in the upper-right-hand side of the screen is clear.
Seconds later, the Rider appears on the left side of the tree, having never
appeared on the right side of the tree. There doesn't seem to be any bend in
the road that could explain this sudden appearance...
19.When Frodo is lying on the floor after Arwen defeats the Nazgul you can
see a pimple under the right side of his mouth. The same pimple can be seen
when the fellowship aproaches the Pillar of the Kings on the Emyn Muil; in
the rest of the movie there is no pimple.
20.When the orcs charge down the mountain, Legolas shoots his arrows at
them. At one point, he has three left and doesn't fire any more, but in the
shot by the lake, he has about 20, which then change colour to a vibrant
green!
21.In the overhead shot of the Ringwraiths chasing Arwen and Frodo before
the fords of Bruinen, there are only 8 instead of 9.
22.In the scene where Sam has sunk to the bottom of the river, we see a shot
of the empty boat on the water (as if Frodo dove in to save Sam). When Sam
is pulled into the boat, though, Frodo is completely dry.
23.When traveling after Rivendell the fellowship is shown from several
diffrent views, never showing a horse. Then just before entering Moria they
remove a saddle from a horse and state that a mine is no place for a horse.
24. How can one of the Uruk-Hai's be so much better than the others? He
almost kills Aragorn, who just killed like 20 of his kind. Remember that
they are of the same breed and that they have recieved no training at all
since they are born adult.
25.When Gandalf and Saruman are talking in Ortanc, we can see a black ring
on Gandalf's finger on the hand holding his staff, but in the next shot it's
disappeared.
26.When the hobbits are hiding under the roots of the tree just off the
road, you can see to the right of the tree an opening showing the road, but
when the black rider approaches from behind the tree, he does not pass by
the opening to the right of the tree.
27.When Arwen enters the water after being chased by the Ringwraiths, as she
turns the horse, you can clearly see the fake hobbit (representing an
injured Frodo), bounce up and down like a rubber band.
28.When they are all walking up the snowy mountain the camera starts off
with a larger view and then goes to a closer view of the people. In the
larger view there are no footprints but in the smaller view there are.
29.Before the passage of Carhadras, Boromir is fencing with Merry and
Pippin. When they tackle him you can see Merry's face and it's obviously a
dwarf stand-in for the actor.
30.When Boromir goes to the door of Balin's Tomb in the mines you can see
Aragorn in the background putting his torch on the ground, then when it
switches to Aragorn and the others he puts the torch down again.
31.Most of the time the hobbits are barefoot, but when Frodo and Sam are
first walking through the fields, Sam's leg come above long-grass level and
his shoe is clearly visible.
32.Near the end when Frodo has tears running down his face. In the first
shot the tear on his right side is short and the left side tear is down to
his chin. in the next shot they are reversed.
33.In the beginning, Gandalf's pipe keeps mysteriously vanishing from each
scene, when he is guiding the cart with Frodo.
34.When Frodo is recovering in Rivendell from the Ringwraith dagger he is
first seen lying in the bed with a chain necklace clearly visible (to which
the ring is attached) - in following scenes the necklace is sometimes
there - sometimes not.
35.When Borimir is about to die and Strider is running towards him, one of
the supposedly dead Orcs lifts his head to watch Strider run by and then
promptly lays his head down again.
36.At the end of the movie, when Frodo takes the boat to continue on his
own. Sam runs into the water to follow Frodo as he promised Gandalf. When
Sam is about half way to the boat, he goes under water because he can not
swim. He almost reaches the bottom of the flood, and does not swim up at any
time. Suddenly, Frodo takes his hand and pulls him into the boat, but Frodo
has not moved an inch and Sam did not swim to the surface.
37.On top of the mountain ridge (after Boromir gives the dropped ring back
to Frodo) there is a conversation between Gandalf and Strider. As the camera
flicks back and forth between Gandalf and Strider, Gandalf is in sunlight
but Strider is in shadow - despite the two only being about 5 metres apart.
IMHO neke greske jednostavno nije potrebno ni spominjati, u ovako dugom (i
odlicnom, naravno) filmu nije ni cudo sto ih ima. Ali takoder ima nekih koje
su mi pomalo khm ... smijesne (naravno ako uopce i postoje).
--
UIN:16510476
Surrender Is Not An Option
\\ cor...@hotmail.com //
kalimero
"Cor$aiR" wrote:
> Kao i svaki film tako i FOTR ima nekih greskica. Slucajno sam naletio na
> ovaj sajt, pa tko zeli neka cita. Ne znam da li je ovo istina jer jos nisam
> pogledao film .....pa mi nemojte govoriti ako nije tocno. =)
> Hmmm...ovo bi mogla biti neka vrsta spojlera, pa ako zelite zivjeti u
> totalnom neznanju dok ne odlucite pogledati film......jednostavno preskocite
> post. =)
>
E, ako uspijes primijetiti ijednu gresku u kinu, svaka ti cast! I ako ti je
bitno da li je nesto na lijevoj ili desnoj strani u tih par sekundi...
k.
Cor$aiR
"kalimero" <kalime...@lycos.com> wrote in message
news:3C2C9482...@lycos.com...
>
> E, ako uspijes primijetiti ijednu gresku u kinu, svaka ti cast! I ako ti
je
> bitno da li je nesto na lijevoj ili desnoj strani u tih par sekundi...
>
Nije mi to uopce bitno, i nisam jedan od onih koji zive samo da nadu nesto
sto nevalja u filmu. Meni je ipak draze uziviti se u ono sta se prikazuje na
platnu i ne misliti na nista drugo.
Ovo sam poslao samo zato jer sam slucajno naletio na jednom sajtu i pomislio
da bi mogao postat na grupu.
kalimero
"> >
> > E, ako uspijes primijetiti ijednu gresku u kinu, svaka ti cast! I ako ti
> je
> > bitno da li je nesto na lijevoj ili desnoj strani u tih par sekundi...
> >
>
> Nije mi to uopce bitno, i nisam jedan od onih koji zive samo da nadu nesto
> sto nevalja u filmu. Meni je ipak draze uziviti se u ono sta se prikazuje
na
> platnu i ne misliti na nista drugo.
> Ovo sam poslao samo zato jer sam slucajno naletio na jednom sajtu i
pomislio
> da bi mogao postat na grupu.
Onda ces sigurno uzivati u filmu :))) Radnja tece tako brzo da ne stignes
uloviti razlike izmedju filma i knjige :)))
k.
Domagoj Paljug
> 37.On top of the mountain ridge (after Boromir gives the dropped ring back
> to Frodo) there is a conversation between Gandalf and Strider. As the
camera
> flicks back and forth between Gandalf and Strider, Gandalf is in sunlight
> but Strider is in shadow - despite the two only being about 5 metres
apart.
ok.....dobar dio sam josh i progutao kao moguce ili nevazne...itd.....ali
ova mi fakat nije jasna??
kakve veze ima dal' je ovaj na suncu a ovaj u sjeni na 5 m......pa i 1m je
dovoljan......
Jon Blue
"Domagoj Paljug" wrote > > 37.On top of the mountain ridge (after Boromir
gives the dropped ring back
to Frodo) there is a conversation between Gandalf and Strider.
ova scena je bila prikazana u Cafe Cinema u petak i totalno me je zbunila,
mislim kad je to Frodu ispao prsten koliko ja znam Boromir nije ni vidio
prsten a kamoli ga dotaknu pa cak i drzao
>>As the camera flicks back and forth between Gandalf and Strider, Gandalf
is in sunlight
> > but Strider is in shadow - despite the two only being about 5 metres
> apart.
>
>
> ok.....dobar dio sam josh i progutao kao moguce ili nevazne...itd.....ali
> ova mi fakat nije jasna??
> kakve veze ima dal' je ovaj na suncu a ovaj u sjeni na 5 m......pa i 1m je
> dovoljan......
>
>
da mislim to je nevazno vjerovatno i neprimjetno
CroW
mikrofona
CroW
Domagoj Paljug <dom...@moscroatia.com> wrote in message
news:a0lkc7$5k0u$1...@as201.hinet.hr...
Domagoj Paljug
"CroW" <ask...@mail.com> wrote in message
news:a0n5sr$st7$1...@sunce.iskon.hr...
> Nisam gledao film, ali cini mi se da bi to mogla biti sjena od kamere ili
> mikrofona
>
tu pishe kao da ovaj stoji u sjeni, a ovaj stoji na suncu, shto je kao
nemoguce jer su na samo 5 metara.....i meni nije jasno kakva je tu greska??!
evo, ja sam na svjetlu, a pas lezi na podu u sjeni od stola, a samo je pola
metra udaljen od mene......
Jon Blue
"Domagoj Paljug" wrote
>> tu pishe kao da ovaj stoji u sjeni, a ovaj stoji na suncu, shto je kao
> nemoguce jer su na samo 5 metara.....i meni nije jasno kakva je tu
greska??!
> evo, ja sam na svjetlu, a pas lezi na podu u sjeni od stola, a samo je
pola
> metra udaljen od mene......
>
>
Ovisi mozda je Sunce bilo pod takvim kutom da je sjena od ovog drugog padala
na njega pogotovo sto je udaljenost samo 5m
Gandalf
> Ovisi mozda je Sunce bilo pod takvim kutom da je sjena od ovog drugog
padala
> na njega pogotovo sto je udaljenost samo 5m
Najveca je greska u filmu sto Gandalfa glumi neki ishlapjeli, matori glumac,
dok pravi Gandalf nakon odlaska preko mora biva nastanjen u Primorju (u
njegovom glavnom gradu), gdje prelistava newse i hvata se za glavu od muke!
--
Gandalf
www.gamer.hr
Burne Feathers
> his hand on the railing and looks out over the city. However, the railing
> for Frodo is waisthigh. Seeing as how he is a 3-foot Hobbit in a city of
> human-sized elves, the railing should be over his head.
Hehe - tip koji je ovo stavija NIJE CITA KNJIGU!!!
Rivendell je gradjen tako da se SVI osjecaju dobro (pa patuljci su tu imali
svoje mini rudnike) tako da je Frojd (da namjerno san tako napisa) bio kao u
Vrecastom Vijencu.
Phoenix (tm)
unawares, the longed for that cometh beyond hope!
A pravi Gandalf valjda ne glumi zato jer mu nisu ponudili dovoljno
para? :)) Pohlepni starce :))
---
Smatram svoj dan izgubljenim ako mi se barem jedna zena
toga dana ne osmjehne.
Nije mi zao napustiti ovaj svijet, ali mi je zao sto
ostavljam tolike ljepotice.
Giaccomo Casanova
Gandalf
> A pravi Gandalf valjda ne glumi zato jer mu nisu ponudili dovoljno
> para? :)) Pohlepni starce :))
nema dzabe ni kod stare babe!
---
Gandalf
www.gamer.hr