t-test for imams+Jamaica shock+5 US Muslims+Lynne+Newburgh shame+Qadianis+Hadith on menses+anti-zionist movement USA

[kaukab siddique]

New Trend Magazine
New Phone: 410-891-8451 . Subscription for printed edition: $10 for 3 months. Mail check to: New Trend, P.O. Box 356, Kingsville, MD 21087.
Disclaimer: Views expressed are not necessarily shared by the editors. New Trend does not endorse violence of any kind. Information on news or views related to violence is for analysis and understanding, not for endorsement. New Trend is against racism, classism, gender superiority, Zionism and Imperialism.
The Qur'an and the authentic Hadith are our foundation.
All views are welcome but only a selection can be published owing to high volume of mail. Anyone criticized in New Trend has the right of reply up to 300 words.
Email address: buts...@msn.com
------------------------------------                                    
Rajab 12, 1432/ June 25, 2010 # 26             
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Verse of the Week
 

Call to the way of your Lord with wisdom and goodly exhortation, and have disputations with them in the best manner; surely your Lord best knows those who go astray from His path, and He knows best those who follow the right way.    And if you take your turn, then retaliate with the like of that with which you were afflicted; but if you are patient, it will certainly be best for those who are patient.    And be patient and your patience is not but by (the assistance of) Allah, and grieve not for them, and do not distress yourself at what they plan.    Surely Allah is with those who guard (against evil) and those who do good (to others)  -Holy Qur'an 16:125-128   submitted by Sis. Abigail ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Jamaat al-Muslimeen Shoora Theme: Unite Against Zionism   Series of Mini-Shoora Meetings to be Held: US Muslims to Organize for non-Violent Resistance to Zionism        On July 24 [Saturday] the first of a series of mini shoora meetings will be held by Jamaat al-Muslimeen. The leadership of JAM has come up with this new plan of action owing to the great need for the build up of non-violent resistance to Zionism. The Zionists are on the retreat. It is time for US Muslims to push Jewish-Zionist power structure further into the defensive.   Creative tactics are needed to mobilize the Muslim abhorrence of Zionism. The nine million Muslims of America can become a catalyst for the transformation of America.     America should not be enslaved by International Jewry. Let us help America to break the Zionist stranglehold in the best possible ways. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From Imam Badi Ali [Jamaat al-Muslimeen Shoora leader] North Carolina   Spotlight # 1: The West seems to be involved in re-thinking Israel. It sees the corrupt regimes in the Muslim world as a greater deterrent against the rising power of Islam than Israel. How much more damage can the US bear for supporting Israel when Cairo and Amman are more effective?   Spotlight #2: Capitalism is on the decline. The sudden reversals Toyota and BP have suffered indicate that the system is sick and may not revive.   Spotlight #3: The US can see that it cannot win in Afghanistan. How to get out? Blame McCrystal? Get a new general? Dump Karzai? It is a dilemma. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Our America: Unite Against Zionism. Jamaat al-Muslimeen Shoora theme.   Rally in Support of Lynn Stewart who Defended the Blind Shaikh. First Rally July 7. Re-Sentencing on July 15          On April 9, 2002 Lynne stewart was arrested on charges that 2 years earlier she had issued a press release on the views of her client Shaikh Omar Abdel Rahman.       In its attack on America's legal system, the oppressors sentenced Lynn Stewart to 28 months on October 16, 2006. The government claimed that was a lenient sentence. She was re-arrested and is in prison.     She will face re-sentencing on July 15 and is facing 30 years. Her health is deteriorating as she is 70 years old. [She is taken to hospital shackled hand and foot and chained at the waist. ]     A rally in support of Lynn Stewart will be held on July 7 at Judson Church, Washington Square, N., New York city, 6 to 10 PM. For more information, contact Ralph Poynter : 917-853-9759     Send letters to Sis. Lynn: at this address:  Lynne Stewart #53504-054, MCC-NY, 150 Park Row, NY, NY 10007   Rallies will also be held, inshallah, before and after the court hearing on July 15. -------------------------- Our America: Unite Against Zionism. Jamaat al-Muslimeen Shoora theme.          Five US Muslims Sentenced to 10 Years by Pakistani Kangaroo Court on "terrorism" Charges.        June 24, 2010: A Pakistani special court held a quick "trial" INSIDE a PRISON in Sargodha, Pakistan, and sentenced five US Muslims to 10 years in prison on bogus terrorism charges. The US refused to defend the rights of the 5 US citizens.   A spokesman for the United States Embassy in Islamabad, Richard Snelsire, said, “We respect the decision of the Pakistani courts.” But the families of the men said they would fight. “We are not going to lose heart,” Khalid Farooq, the father of one of the men, Umer Farooq, said outside the court after the verdict. “Such a decision is strange in a Muslim country by a Muslim judge for innocent Muslims accused of baseless charges of terrorism.” He added: “I am a lawyer by profession and I can confidently say that there was nothing in this case. All documents of the government were fabricated and evidence is fake.” [AP]   [US Muslims should note that the 5 innocents were shunted off by ICNA [of Zahid Bukhari fame], to CAIR [Hooper and Awad] who called the FBI on them, who handed them over to the puppet Pakistani police.---Editor]   [Khalid Khawaja, the man who stopped the 5 from being sent back to the US to rot in prison here was murdered under mysterious circumstances. The Pakistani regime is silent on the murder. -Editor]  ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Taliba’s t-Test (Uncle Tom Test). Try it on your Imam or Shaykh Share   Our communities are not encouraging Muslims to think for themselves. In particular, they do not encourage discussion, questioning, or organizing against the ongoing genocide of Muslims worldwide. A huge reason for this is a sold out Muslim leadership. Why are they sold out? Part of the reason may be here (in particular, see pages 6 - 9): http://usnews.com/usnews/news/articles/050425/25roots.htm Is your imam or shaykh a Tom/bootlicker/bootpakh? Here are 10 ways you can determine this: 1. He encourages you not to watch the news. What can you do about it anyway, he says. 2. He discourages you from boycotting Coca-Cola, Starbucks, McDonalds, Sara Lee, Home Depot and other companies supportive of/invested in Israel. He employs sophistry to prove that their support for Israel is insignificant, or it’s not on an official level, or some such. 3. In the face of major police actions, in which huge numbers of Muslims are killed, he encourages you to make du’ah. Then make more du’ah. Then make more du’ah. Just make sure you don’t do anything in terms of speaking out, organizing, protesting, picketing, educating, and especially not conducting civil disobedience. 4. He says the best way to help a starving, bombed out, population, eg, Gaza, Fallujah ('04), Jenin ('02), etc. is to work on your nafs, improve your diin, increase your nafili (or, if it is Ramadan) taraweeh prayers. Just as long as you do nothing of practical value for the afflicted population. 5. He invites major killers of Muslims, eg, Madeleine Albright to the mosque. 6. At the end of a week in which U.S. drone attacks have killed scores of Muslim civilians, or a U.S. funded dictator has launched an attack on a mosque or a madressa, he gives a juma’ah khutba on the proper way to wash one’s feet, the adaab of parking in the mosque parking lot when it is crowded, or a similar topic. 7. He hosts meetings with law enforcement officials inside the mosque, disregarding U.S. laws governing separation of church and state (and Qur’anic injunctions against cooperating with oppressors, for those of us who still believe in this antiquated idea). 8. He allows the positioning of government surveillance cameras inside the mosque, claiming it is for the protection of the congregation, never mind the First Amendment violations involved. 9. He encourages and supports political canvassing at the mosque for candidates of a party currently and officially engaged in the killing of Muslims. But, when you ask him to support a vigil for murdered Iraqi children or a fundraiser for the families of Muslim political prisoners, he claims that would be too political. 10. He allows distribution of handbills about carnivals, bake sales, and the next trip to the amusement park in the mosque parking lot, but when you attempt to distribute this (or the New Trend, or other literature which might actually make one think), he (or his guard dog) accosts you and wants to know who authorized it. - - - - - - - Scoring Count the number from the items above which apply to your favorite imam or shaykh. Then match them to the numbers below. 1 - 3 Uncle Tom-in-Training 4 - 6 The Next Muslim Condee/Colin/Barack Lookalike 7 - 10 Candidate for next Muslim Advisor to the White House/Booklicker Extreme -N. Siddique  ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ War News from New Trend's Media Monitors. Latest War News:# 1 Afghan Woman Takes Revenge After Two Years A bad 22 Days for NATO: 80 Elite Troops killed by Poorly Armed Taliban         From June 1 to 22, NATO has admitted 80 of its troops killed in Afghanistan. The highest losses are US followed by British, Canadian, Australian and French. Even the Romanians have had two of their troops killed.     By contrast Taliban losses are negligible. Observers say that the Taliban seem to have perfected the art of guerrilla  warfare. They keep moving, they hit NATO units when the Europeans  want to sleep, they attack the weakest units. The people are losing their fear of NATO and sometimes openly help the Taliban. Many of the NATO dead were killed by small arms fire.     Also, our observers say that if somehow the Americans can draw the Taliban  into a conventional battle, that'll be fatal for the Taliban because of there is no equation between the firepower of the two sides. The Taliban have no jet fighters, helicopters, tanks or artillery.         [Yahoo news reports that on June 22  a Taliban woman mujahid carried out a martyrdom attack on US troops killing 2 of them and injuring 17 of their Afghan supporters. US journalists  went to the woman's village in Kunar and found that "coalition" troops had raided her home two years back and killed two of her relatives. Thereafter she joined the Taliban. The martyr's name is Alima Bibi.]         If for every NATO elite trooper killed, the average number wounded is 4, NATO losses are becoming serious. Owing to the use of heavy armor, NATO troops suffer few killed but more wounded. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Latest war news #2 Pakistan Admits Horrific Losses at the hands of Islamic Forces: Asks US for $2.5 billion in new Weaponry. Pakistani Taliban were willing to fight to the last against Asia's best troops       Pakistani troops in the "thousands" have been killed  in battle against Pakistani Taliban all the way from Swat and Dir to Darra Adam Khel and South Waziristan. The losses are so heavy that they are not being revealed to the Pakistani people. Some idea of the losses can be guaged from the figure of 600 ISI officers and 9 Generals admitted by Pakistani ambassador Haqqani in an interview with the Washingto Times [June 15].        Pakistan is determined to continue fighting on behalf of the US. The new plan is to send 100,000 troops in a new surge into the Islamic strongholds, the Times reports. The demand for new weaponry is specifically meant to kill the Islamic populations.   "The $2.5 billion in arms that Pakistan has requested includes new helicopter gunships, including AH-1W and the Apache-64-D; armed helicopters, such as the AH-6 and MD-530 Little Bird; and utility and cargo helicopters, such as the UH-60 Black Hawk, the CH-47 D Chinook and the UH-1Y Huey." [Washington Times]       Our observers say that at least 10,000 Islamic civilians have been killed in Pakistani military attacks plus more than 2,000 Pakistani Taliban.  --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Military Action in Tourist Paradise Near America's Shores.
Zionist-corporate Media Ignored this Important Report.
 
Jamaican struggle: the crisis of imperialism

UhuruNews

 

Jamaican soldiers patrol the streets of Kingston

Since Sunday May 23 citizens of Kingston, Jamaica neighborhood, Tivoli Gardens, have been waging a fierce struggle against U.S. attempts to extradite a man the governments of Jamaica and U.S. have labeled one of the “world’s most dangerous narcotics kingpins.”

Christopher “Dudus” Coke, 42, is native to this neighborhood which is well known for its level of poverty and violence. He is said to have had control of this area since 1990 amassing a “dictator” like control on the people, trafficking guns, ordering murders, and orchestrating a drug ring that reaches beyond the shores of Jamaica.

 

However, the people of this neighborhood have a different understanding. “Dudus” has taken on the role that government has forfeited. He has created jobs, paid for school fees, loaned money to the residents, provided financial assistance, sponsored community programs all in an effort to make the suffering of the people a little better.

 

Because of this understanding, the people, who the media have called “his gang,” have risen up bombing and torching several police stations and have been engaged in fierce gun battles with the Jamaican armed forces.

 

These disturbances have cast an unappealing eye onto the “One Love” island that has been a playground to benefactors of capitalism. 

 

While tourists and investors enjoy the post colonial slave service of the Africans of Jamaica, held up in the million dollar hotels, Africans have been suffering as a result of the neocolonial corrupt government’s disregard for their well-being.

 

The African masses have had to fend for themselves, doing what they must to survive and as a result are being attacked by police armed with military style gear and weaponry. This is the Jamaica they don’t show you and one most people aren’t ready to see.

 

Jamaica, like many other islands of the Caribbean, is the victim of imperialist engines, International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank.

 

Although Jamaica was granted independence from its colonial master Great Britain in 1962, most of its resources were still controlled by foreign entities. Unemployment doubled, illiteracy was high and 55 percent of land was controlled by private farmers. 

 

In 1972, when People’s National Party (PNP) candidate, Michael Manley was elected Prime Minister, he went about forging new relationships with Cuba and introducing progressive socialist policies intended to promote national ownership and increase self-sufficiency.

 

Under Manley, Jamaica established minimum wage for all workers, free education at secondary and university level, idle lands were distributed to the peasants, control of pricing on staple products was introduced, paid maternity leave was institutionalized and the voting age was reduced to 18 years old.

 

These policies afforded Jamaica some breathing room between itself and foreign dominators. However, as a result of an increase in oil prices, Jamaica would soon be within grasp of the empire’s clutches, once again.

 

In 1974, Jamaica underwent a severe economic crisis when the price of oil rose from $12 to $75 per barrel. The IMF took advantage of the situation presenting a plan geared toward short term development by providing money to take care of some immediate needs of the economy. 

 

The trade off was a “capitalistic model based on free trade…[which] was in fact designed to force Jamaica to turn from industries which it depended on for development.”
(http://www.mtholyoke.edu/~aehaynes/politicssite/INDEX.html; Haynes, Annabelle; “Michael Manley’s foresight on the role of the IMF in Jamaica”)

 

Under the agreement, free zones were created (areas on Jamaican land that exempted from Jamaican law, taxation, custom duties on import and export and import licensing requirements) where foreign companies like Tommy Hilfiger and Brooks Brothers take full advantage of the lack of barriers.

 

Although these companies provide jobs to the jobless without needing to adhere to the minimum wage regulations of Jamaica, the people work for slave wages and have been replaced by imported Chinese workers that were brought to the island.

 

In addition to that, the government had to let down its trade restrictions, opening up its market to foreign imports. Many of these imports undercut the prices of national goods like bananas, potatoes, and dairy, destroying the internal economy.

 

Most farmers could not compete with foreign goods and as such their livelihood was irreversibly impacted.

 

Results of this can be seen upon a visit to any store on the island as the shelves are stocked with foreign goods.

 

Agriculture accounts for only 6 percent of the GDP, which is much lower than most developing countries.

 

Sugar is still a widely farmed crop, a remnant of the capitalist slave economy that is being exported at a cost set by the terms of this agreement. 

 

To top it all off, the value of the Jamaican dollar was decreased and has never regained its market value; currently the exchange rate is US$1 to JMD$88. 

 

Tourism brings in the most money which accounts for nearly 66 percent of the country’s GDP. School children are groomed to be happy smiling servants re-establishing a slave/master relationship to capitalist imperialism.

 

The economy of Jamaica is a result of this IMF agreement coupled with a spineless neocolonial government whose only interest is to appease its foreign masters, demonizing the population while distributing wealth to a small minority. 

 

For years the impoverished neighborhoods of Jamaica have been war zones plagued with crime and corruption.

 

The people of these communities view the police as the enemy because they murder just as maliciously as the so called “criminals.” 

 

In an economy where unemployment has risen and the government has abandoned the people for its own interest, it is no wonder that the Africans of Jamaica have turned to the means available to them to feed their families. 

 

The problem does not originate from the people; instead the problem is the lack of good governance and capitalist greed, which created these objectionable conditions.  

 

Under these current conditions, it is estimated that nearly 20,000 Africans emigrate from Jamaica to neighboring islands and the U.S. every year.

 

Left with no other alternative than to smile and take it, some would hope that the poor and destitute of the island should suffer in silence. 

 

The people are revolting to protect their friend “Dudus” who has done more to improve their condition than the “officials” and in doing so are taking a stand against the U.S. and the Jamaican government. 

 

This situation surrounding Christopher “Dudus” Cokes is one that we must all pay attention to. Why? Because it is indicative of a struggle that we must all make and make people aware of.

 

From this point on when you look at news from Jamaica ask yourself what has caused these conditions. The people are fed up and are illustrating the power of the masses.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

America's "Justice" System on the Roll.

Uneducated, Greedy Muslims are Easy Targets

 

Courtesy: The Daily Gazette (Schenectady, NY) [Copyright]
With thanks to New Trend reader Kwame Madden

June 20, 2010

Trial delayed in new fake terror case 
by Carl Strock [by special permission to New Trend]

We are in the middle of another manufactured-terrorism case, this one in Newburgh, and it was going very smoothly until last week, when the presiding federal judge postponed the scheduled trial indefinitely, ordering the government to turn over more evidence that might be helpful to the defense. The defendants are four petty criminals, three black Americans and one Haitian, all of whom converted to Islam in prison and upon their release took to frequenting a mosque in Newburgh.

They were recruited into a fake terrorist plot by the same wretch who a few years ago duped two Albany Muslims into an exchange of checks for cash that could be sold to a jury as money-laundering in support of terrorism.

The FBI is still working him. I had thought such efforts to create terrorists in order to arrest them was an artifact of the Bush administration, which seemed unable to distinguish between real enemies and imaginary, but I was wrong. Here we are with a new, supposedly more enlightened, president and it's still going on.

The wretch is Shahed (or Shaheed) Hussain, a Pakistani who immigrated to this country in the early 1990s and soon began making his living in the Albany area by cheating on drivers license exams for immigrants who knew less English than he did. He was supposed to interpret for them but actually took their tests for them, for substantial fees.

He got caught and faced a string of felonies, to be followed by deportation, when the FBI got hold of him and put him to work in exchange for keeping him out of jail and allowing him to remain in this country. Undoubtedly a great boon to us all.

A miserable liar and cheat who couldn't distinguish truth from falsehood even when he was under oath in the Albany trial of Yassin Aref and Mohammed Hossain and was trying his best to make a good impression.

In the Newburgh affair, he presented himself in a black Mercedes, and, in a script apparently much favored by the FBI, let on to have a great deal of money, which he was very free with. Also to be a radical jihadist, or at least in league with radical jihadists.

He recruited these disaffected petty drug dealers and misfits with promises of money and cars, according to the FBI's own secret tape recordings, some of which have become public through court filings by the defense.

It took him a year to do it, but he did it. He got them to accompany him to the Air National Guard base at Stewart International Airport and take photographs, supposedly with a view to eventually shooting down airplanes with surface-to-air missiles.

He got them to plant what they thought were explosives at a synagogue and a Jewish community center in the Bronx.

There is no sign they would have done any of this on their own or even imagined doing it. Shahed Hussain, acting not as an informant as the government calls him but as an agent provocateur, coaxed them, urged them and bribed them.

"I told you I can make you $250,000, but you don't want it, brother," he said to his principal recruit, James Cromitie, a 45-year-old native of Brooklyn with 27 arrests on his record, when Cromitie showed reluctance.

At another point he told Cromitie he would pay lookouts $25,000 each, to which Cromitie responded, "If you can assure them that they gonna see that much money, they gonna go for it ; They will do it for the money; they're not even thinking about the cause."

Cromitie dreamed of a new car. "You're getting your car, brother -- the Beamer," Shahed Hussain told him.

A swell way for the government to protect us, no? Bribe some low-life ex-cons to participate in a fake plot and then arrest them on charges of terrorism and conspiracy to use weapons of mass destruction. Possible sentence: life in prison.

After which Shahed Hussain will presumably ride off to his next slimy assignment, and the government will bask in glory for having blocked a terrorist attack.

Slimy?

"You should believe me, because I am your brother, I am your true brother," he told Cromitie regarding the promise of a new car. "I love you to death, brother."

Which is pretty much the approach he took when he was pressing money on Mohammed Hossain, owner of a hole-in-the-wall pizza shop on Central Avenue in Albany.

The difference: Back then his nomme de guerre was Malik; in Newburgh it was Maqsood.

I shouldn't be so hard on him, maybe. He's trying to save his skin. It's the FBI that writes the script and puts him to work acting it, and it's U.S. attorneys who prosecute these cases.

How dangerous would this Cromitie character have been in Newburgh without Shahed "Maqsood" Hussain to egg him on?

Apparently not very. The FBI agent running the operation, Robert Fuller (who also ran the celebrated Fort Dix operation), wrote to officials at Stewart Airport alerting them that Cromitie would be out there scouting for a possible attack site but assured them he would pose no danger without Hussain.

It was the revelation of a memo referring to that letter that prompted Judge Colleen McMahon last week to call a halt to the proceedings until the FBI produces all materials that might tend to exculpate the defendants, as the law requires.

She also noted that "the Government has retreated from its original position that the defendants had any connections to any international terrorist organization."

At this point the legal-minded reader might be asking, isn't the inducing of criminal activity forbidden? Isn't it called entrapment, and isn't it grounds for acquittal?

To which your legal correspondent answers, yes, it's forbidden, yes, it's called entrapment, and yes, it's grounds for acquittal -- except in cases of alleged Muslim terrorism, and then all rules are suspended. Not as a matter of law, of course, but as a practical matter.

I know this from the unhappy case of Aref and Hossain in Albany, who were equally induced to do things they would not have done otherwise and which they showed no previous inclination to do -- like launder money, which they didn't even understand -- and yet are now serving 15-year prison terms.

The federal appeals court that reviewed their case dismissed the entrapment argument without rebuttal but just with a wave of the hand.

If a government agent cajoles an ordinary citizen into a robbing a bank who had never robbed a bank before nor shown any inclination to rob a bank, that citizen has a sturdy defense and can expect to be exonerated.

But if a government agent cajoles a Muslim man into participating in a terrorist plot, no matter how far-fetched, and no matter how little inclination the Muslim man had previously shown for such activity, that Muslim man is dead meat.

I wait to see if things turn out any differently in Newburgh. And I also wait to see what Shahed Hussain's next assignment will be.

I hope it's not me. My car is getting run down, and if he offered me a new Beamer, heaven knows what I would do.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Open Letter from a Patriot

Do not let Israel Push us into a War with Iran

Hamas is the Only Democratically elected Government in the Middle East

 

President Barack Obama
1600 Pennsylvania Ave.
Washington, D.C. 20500
 
Dear President Obama,
 
First of all, I would like to say that I helped sponsor your campaign with donations and voted for you in the last campaign.  I was thrilled when you were elected.  I thought you were your own man and could not be swayed by PAC money or blackmailed by the media.
 
Then May 31^st came about with Israeli terrorist pirating several humanitarian ships with aid to Gaza, an area that is undergoing a terrible genocide.  10 people were murdered including one American and over 30 wounded.  This was a horrible atrocity by the biggest terrorist nation in the Middle East now, perhaps the world.  However, when you backed down on insisting that Israel stop all its settlement in Palestinian territory, and when you failed to go further than to "...regret the loss of life" when Israel resorted to piracy to stop the ships trying to undo the blockage of Gaza, I must conclude that you are incapable of standing up to the huge Zionist lobby.  Your failure to insist on an end to Israel's blockade (by land, sea and air) of Gaza (an acknowledged open-air prison), makes one question whether you are truly on the side of human rights.  Your Cairo speech was wonderful but your actions belie your words.

 Why has the U.S. (and Israel) designated Hamas as a terrorist organization?  What right do you have to do that?  If one looks at destruction of life and property as a criterion of terrorism, Israel is by far more terroristic than Hamas.  Hamas is actually the only democratically-elected government in the Middle East, Israel is in fact an ethnocracy, a democracy for Jews only.

I urge you not to let Israel (and the neo-cons here in the U.S. ) push us into a war with Iran, as they did in Iraq.  I also urge you to side with Iran in its suggestion to make the Middle East a nuclear-free zone, which of course means that Israel gives up its nuclear weapons.  It is past time to recognize Israel as the brutal oppressor it is rather than the perpetual victim it likes to make one believe.  "What renders Israel's abuses unique throughout the world is the relentless effort to justify that which cannot be justified."  Norman Finkelstein.

A patriotic American

Carolyn Johnson

[Florida]

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hadith Studies by Kaukab Siddique

Perwezi sect's attack on Hadith:
Attempt to Claim that Hadith permits Sex during Menstruation
Libellous Attribution of Translation to Abdul Hameed Siddiqui

A heretical Pakistani group called Tolu-e-Islam, organized by a Pakistani writer named Ghulam Ahmed Pervez, has been making frantic efforts to discredit Hadith. Known for its subservience to western ideas against Islam, Tolu-i-Islam claims that it is serving the true Islam by calling people to concentrate on the Qur'an "only."

One of the books this group published was titled MAQAME HADITH which can be called its magnum opus because it was published in four editions, 1953, 1965, 1975 and 1986 WITHOUT change.

MAQAME HADITH (written in the Urdu language) is packed with baseless attacks on Hadith, quoted out of context and twisted in a variety of ways.

In one of its most vicious attacks, MAQAME HADITH tries to give the impression that the Hadith teaches sexual intercourse during menstruation and thus violates the Qur'an. MAQAME HADITH achieves this "meaning" by translating a key word in the Hadith about menstruation as MUBASHIRAT which in Urdu means sexual intercourse. (See page 202 of MAQAME HADITH under the heading: halate haiz main mubashirat)

The Perwezi sect could not succeed in Pakistan owing to the Islamic resurgence led by Maulana Maudoodi and later by the Jihad movements. Perwezis in Pakistan are residual now and exist largely in minute sections of the westernized ruling class which can easily be led astray owing to their relative ignorance of both the Qur'an and the Hadith.

However, the Perwezis retreated to Canada and started spreading their heresies among Pakistani immigrants and sometimes even among recent converts to Islam.

Earlier on Pakistan Forum and more recently on Wide Minds (two Pakistani discussion groups), a number of Perwezis made the same claim as in MAQAME HADITH, that the Hadith violates the Qur'an by teaching sexual intercourse during menstruation. I pointed out to the readers of these groups that no scholar of HADITH had EVER taught that the Hadith permits sex during menses. As a result I was subjected to incessant abuse by a number of Perwezis on these lists. The attackers tried to make the claim that I was defending Hadith because I am a "Mullah."

However, after the Perwezis were put on the defensive, they came up with the claim that they had finally found a translation of SAHIH MUSLIM which has the Hadith about menstruation which clearly says that the Prophet (pbuh) [nauzoobillah min zalik] did intercourse with his wife during menstruation. They said the TRANSLATION WAS BY ABDUL HAMID SIDDIQUI and was published from India!

They have been transmitting ABDUL HAMID SIDDIQUI's "translation" far and wide and claiming victory against Hadith on that basis.

UNFORTUNATELY FOR THE PERWEZIS, the library of Masjid Jamaat al-Muslimeen has Abdul Hamid Siddiqui's translation of SAHIH MUSLIM. Here is the translation from page 173 of Volume 1:

"(577) ‘Aisha (ra) reported: When anyone amongst us (amongst the wives of the Holy Prophet) menstruated, the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) asked her to tie a waist-wrapper over her (body) and then embraced her."

Not only does Abdul Hamid Siddiqui's translation NOT say anything about doing sexual intercourse, the translator seems to be aware of the attack by the enemies of Islam on this Hadith and he writes this commentary on this hadith: (same page)

"499. This tradition has been the target of worst criticism by the hostile critics of the Hadith. They assert that it contravenes the teaching of the Qur'an (ii.222), in which it has been commanded to keep aloof from women during menstrual period. But these critics little realise that it is the sexual intercourse with the menstruating women which is prohibited. The hadith gives no indication that the Holy Prophet acted against this injunction of the Qur'an. The very wording that he ordered to tie a waist-wrapper on the lower part of her body gives a clear indication that the Holy Prophet did not have sexual intercourse with his wives during this period of menstrual discharge; he simply embraced them. The verb yubashira does not necessarily mean sexual intercourse. It denotes to have contact, to touch (Lane's Arabic-English Lexicon).

Notice also that ABDUL HAMEED SIDDIQUI produced his translation of SAHIH MUSLIM in Pakistan, not India as the Perwezis claim. He wrote it and published it in Pakistan.

The question arises, why did the Perwezis decide to libel Abdul Hameed Siddiqui? Allah knows what is in their minds but we do need to notice that Abdul Hameed Siddiqui's translation of Sahih Muslim into English was a unique event. There are not many (IF ANY) other translations into English.

The Perwezis might have chosen to smear Abdul Hameed Siddiqui because he was an associate of Maulana Maudoodi (ra). G.A. Perwez, the doyen of the Perwezi sect, wrote at length and very viciously and abusively against Maulana Maudoodi. Obviously the disciples of Perwez want to continue their leader's tradition of  fabrication.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Letter
Re: Hadith Studies in June 3 issue of New Trend About Punishment for Rape
 
Bismillaah.  As salaamu 'alaikum.  Where will I find the quoted hadiith re: "For instance, the PUNISHMENT for RAPE is given in the Hadith ONLY, not in the Qur'an. Those who take the Qur'an ONLY have made the mistake of trying to apply the rule of 4 witnesses to rape. If that were accepted, most men would get away with rape [and that is happening in some cases, with the victim being punished instead]."
 
Abdul Ali' [Miami, Florida]
 
Answer from Br. Kaukab Siddique:
 
It's in my book LIBERATION of WOMEN THRU ISLAM.
 
The two Hadith about rape I have translated into English and quoted are from Tirmidhi's Sunan. Tirmidhi's Sunan is one of the six canonical books of Hadith.
 
See pages 91 and 92 of my book. I have also discussed how the two hadith connect with the Qur'an.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Letter: Re: Uncouth Behavior in Masjids + Weak Defense of Zahid Bukhari: Al-Qur'an is not Subjective

[From a Muslim Teacher.]

 

As-Salaam Elekum Brother!

This latest issue of New Trend  newsletter (of 6/18/2010) was extremely well-organized and focused on issues.

However, I feel it appropriate to respond with the following comments of a couple of items in it and they are:

(1)  Refer article of Asma bint Shameen, "Women and Hijab:  Where is your finger pointing?"
(A)  No reference (awareness of the writer about this?) of the ayah in the Qur'an regarding use of hijab for older women (If your search contradicts my statement, please do inform me about it).
(B)  Regarding the focus of the writer about  responses of the Arab women towards her during Umrah when she was 16/17 years old and later (when she had become better informed about the Qur'an/Islam):
Based on my personal experience and observation of decades (of watching these incidents and, more importantly, experiences of others (both of Muslims and non-Muslims towards such negative incidents) and THE EFFECTS of these "harsh" "rude" "inhumane" behavior and attitude of Muslims-- such as the ones that this writer has described at length-- on the "victims" of these (particularly)  ARAB men and women ( who seem to have a "belief" that they are gaining "sawaab/ spiritual rewards) when they do this for they are fulfilling a "religious duty" and are "educating" others about Islam). If not "bigotry" and "bias" they display uncouth behavior due to ignorance and lack of knowledge and education of many, many issues needed in this "modern" world such as basic communication skills. They turn their "victims" away from Islam.They never stop for a moment and think about the consequences of their behavior. What, for example, is the punishment" for turning human beings away from Islam since even many believing Muslims have "dropped out" of Islam because of their negative contacts with Muslims in masjids?  As an educator I can say with confidence that these acts/behavior/attitudes-- far from educating, informing, reforming others-- (they) achieve just the opposite result/consequence.  Besides, it is unnecessary and there are many more positive ways of responding to these situations with gentleness, kindness and  good humor.

(2) Regarding letter in support of  Zahid Bukhari activities. in   "RE:  ICNA leader Zaid Bukhari's Love Affair with the U.S. State Department." The writer's statement that the "Qur'an has always been 'subjective'" displays his ignorance of the very nature and use of Language and nature of  discourse and of the functioning of the human brain when dealing with language (both oral and written). He assumes that this "subjectivity" as he calls it of the Qur'anic ayat /text makes them "ambiguous."  Far from it. The Qur'an reaches the readers depending on the Spiritual level and  sincere intentions of the reader AND their worldly experiences and belief systems. No human hand or mind could have achieved this level of  comprehensiveness and complexity in Time and Space.  It is proof that the Qur'an is a Sublime Revelation.

His statement, "And besides the verses that are ambigous..."-- and his entire third paragraph:: If it confuses any reader, the problem lies within them and they need to look for answers within themselves. Muslims should  stop using the Qur'an when fighting their "earthly" arguments among themselves. It is extremely distressing when one notes that this writer is a professor of religion at a U.S. college in Athens, Georgia.

As-Salaam Elekum!
Sofia  [New York City]

--------------------------------------------------------------

Letter: [From ChaCha Kamal in England]

 Non-Halal Animal content in some Chocolate Products

 

  O mankind! Eat of that which is lawful and good on the earth, and
  follow not the footsteps of Shaitan. Verily, he is to you an open
  enemy. – The holy Qur’an, Surah 2, Verse 168.

  He has forbidden you only the Maitah (dead animals), and blood, and
  the flesh of swine, and that which is slaughtered as a sacrifice for
  others than Allah- The holy Qur’an, Surah 2, Verse 173.

  Mars, Twix, and other Masterfood Company Chocolate Products have
  non-halal animal content (rennet) in them.
  Please read the following bbc article; & be careful of not consuming  
  haraam.
   http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/6653175.stm
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Kashmiris have been holding Rallies against Indian Occupation for the last 7 Days.

No Coverage in US Media.

June 24, 2010. Srinagar:  Another Palestine: Photo shows Kashmiri kid throwing stones at Indian security forces.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Letter: Re: "Why are the Established Christian Churches Silent About Gaza and the Israeli Attack?"

 

Dr. Siddique, I did not see you condemning the attack on Ahmadiya masjid in Lahore, Pakistan, where more than 80 people were brutally murdered. Why are you silent on that massacre? This is not the first time, though. I have not seen you condemning murders and burning alive of Christians in Gojra, Pakistan. You have never spoken against the brutal treatment of minorities in the name of blasphemy in Pakistan. Isn't this hypocritical of you to demand the above from Christian churches while you are silent about cruel treatment of minorities in your country of origin? Your organization has lost all its credibility by demanding selective justice.

 

Ghazala Kazi [West Virginia]

----------------------------------------------------------

Editor's Response: The comparison between Gaza and the attack on a Qadiani temple [not an "Ahmadi masjid" as the reader puts it] is too far fetched to be relevant but I'll still address it. First a technical matter: We do not issue condemnations of specific atrocities around the world. That would require a full job.

    As far as attacks on places of wortship are concerned, Muslims have suffered the most from Zionist and imperialist attacks. By last count, at least 130 Palestinian mosques have been demolished by the Israelis. The number of mosques destroyed by US occupation forces in Iraq and by NATO in Afghanistan run in the thousands. Similar is the situation in occupied Kashmir, parts of India and Chechnya. In Nigeria, the military destroyed the mosques of Islamic groups intent on breaking away from the US and Israel.

    So you see, we would have our hands full if we started condemning each attack on a place of worship. 

     Now for the attack on the Qadiani ["Ahmadi"] temple in Lahore, a full investigation is needed. The government of Pakistan has not carried out an investigation. You should write to the Pakistani government and push for an investigation.

   I can only speculate on why this attack occurred. This should be seen as an explanation, not as a justification. As you might know, the Pakistani military, at the orders of the US carried out  military cleansing of the populated areas of Swat, Dir, Buner, Adam Khel, South Waziristan and ancillary districts. Nearly 5 million Muslims were displaced, of whom one million are still in internal refugee camps. Tens of thousands were killed, including suspected Taliban as well as women and children. Just about ALL the masjids and medressas [Islamic schools] run by the Taliban, and these were thousands, were hit by the military's heavy artillery and aerial bombardment. The situation in the areas occupied by the Pakistani military is so bad that journalists are not permitted to enter them.

    This was genocide.

   There is a widespread impression in Pakistan, that the genocide carried out by the army and the air force had [and has] the full support of the Qadiani ["ahmadi"] elites. Among those killed in the attack on the Qadiani ["ahmadi"] temple was a retired general of the Pakistani army. The Qadiani support for General Kayani's operations comes on top of the Pakistani perception, widespread among the masses, that the Qadianis do not accept the Finalty of Muhammad's [pbuh] prophethood and are thus undermining the very basis of Islam. The Qadianis are seen as the enemies of Islam and Pakistan in a very fundamental sense. A secular leader like Z.A. Bhutto understood this sense of threat to Islam and Pakistan and declared the Qadianis non-Muslims to gain popular support.

     Your information about Christians in Pakistan is incorrect. Almost all Christians are living comfortably in Pakistan. Islam gives more protection to Christians than Israel does. On Christmas, Jamaate Islami and other Muslim groups take gifts to the Christian communities. The same is true of Easter. Churches and cathedrals flourish in major cities. There have been a few, very few, ugly incidents based on desecration of the Qur'an by demented individuals but these exceptions prove the rule that Muslims and Christians do not have serious issues. By contrast in India there has been widespread killing of Christian priests and rape of nuns.

      Compare the situation of the Muslims in America. Based on one major attack on 9.11 which hit high value targets, the ENTIRE Muslim population of America has been treated as if it is a bunch of terrorists.  Islamic leaders of US Muslims are in prison. Puppet organizations have been set up to infiltrate Muslim communities and to keep them scared. The so-called Muslim organizations jump to support US actions against Muslims. Mentally US Muslims are terrorized and are facing large  scale brainwashing. Under the aegis of US think tanks, a new 'islam' is being concocted. The Qur'an has been desecrated, the Prophet, pbuh, and his scholarly wife, Ayesha, r.a., have been abused. The dregs of Muslim society like Salman Rushdie, Ayana Hirsi Ali, Irshad Manji etc are being presented as experts on Islam.

    Without New Trend, silence would descend on the Muslims of America, punctuated only by the prostrations of Uncle Tom 'Muslims' in front of the White House.

---------------------------------------------------

To unsubscribe, write UNSUBSCRIBE in the subject line and click on SEND.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------