Holly Poly 2025 - Pinch Hit #2
53 views
Skip to first unread message
Holly Poly
Dec 2, 2025, 2:34:48 PMDec 2
to Holly Poly Pinchhits
All current pinch hits are due by 11:00 AM UTC on 25 January 2026.
To claim this pinch hit, simply reply to the e-mail that you received or send an e-mail to holly.pol...@gmail.com with the number of the pinch hit you would like to claim. Please make certain to include your AO3 name in the e-mail that you send.
Fandom summary for hauntedhive:
Riverdale (TV 2017)
Glee (TV 2009)
Person of Interest (TV)
---
Request 1 by hauntedhive
Fandom: Riverdale (TV 2017)
Relationships:
I'm happy with any and all interpretation of what a poly story means for these combinations of characters. I'm good with a fic that's just about a one time threesome between them, threesomes that happen regularly, a threesome that evolves into a relationship, established throuples, a couple welcoming a third into their relationship, a third wanting to watch, cucking situations, three people coming together at the same time, open relationships, one of them dating both of the others who aren't interested in each other, two of them being in love with the third and learning like each other, whatever. I'm good with stories where all three are happy with the arrangement or stories where one or two of them are just doing it to compromise.
Prompts/Ideas
Sam/Brittany/Santana: Love triangles being solved my polyamory! They all dated each other at some point! Brittany could get Sam and Santana to agree to anything, including sharing her or even being in a throuple. Always happy for a plotless smut focused fic that's just Brittana welcoming Sam for a threesome (for pregnancy purposes or for fun) or Britt/Sam welcoming Santana or Santana getting cucked
Sam/Brittany/Rory: In an alternate timeline, Rory was in season 4 and Brittany got two boyfriends after Santana dumped her. I can see both boys being more than happy to share her or be in a throuple together. Brittany having a boyfriend that lives with her whose room she can sneak into every night. Rory being allowed to invite Sam for sleepovers because he's a boy and Brittany's parents don't know what's really going on with them. Brittany and Sam feeling bad for Rory when he's homesick or gets dumped and inviting him for a threesome. Have fun.
Finn/Santana/Puck and Sam/Santana/Finn: I just want to see these trios fucking tbh. If you can come up with a larger plot, go ahead, I'm sure there's something there, Santana has some history and issues with all three guys. I've always liked the idea of Santana struggling with her feelings for Finn post death and using Sam or Puck (or both, I know Sam/Santana/Puck isn't nominated but shh) to work it out. Does spiritual poly count here?
Quinn/Santana/Puck, Rachel/Santana/Brody and Rachel/Santana/Finn: Santana tried to/did get between all couples at different times and had sexual tension/history with all four of them, so I just think there's potential for interesting or hot stuff here. Santana would totally sleep with both people in a couple to break them up. Maybe they invited Santana for a threesome (and catch feelings?). Maybe something to do with denial of sexuality. Or just hot threesomes.
Likes and Kinks
Likes: porn with or without plot, angst, fluff, complicated relationship, incestuous relationships (subtextual or overt), dark fic, dubcon/noncon, cheating, 5+1 fics, canon compliant and divergent, unhealthy coping mechanisms, jealousy, toxic relationships, blackmail
Favorite Kinks: creampies/cumplay, breeding/sex resulting in pregnancy, barebacking, gentle/romantic/comfort sex, public sex/exhibitionism, humiliation, cockwarming, free use/sex slavery/punishment, anal sex, rimming, squirting/multiple orgasms/overstimulation, rough sex, playful sex, threesomes, double penetration, sextapes, body worship, cockslut/cumslut, slut shaming/dirty talk, caught having sex, revenge sex, dubcon/noncon, submission, tied up. for f/f ships: oral sex, rimming and face sitting.
There's a lot more info on my likes and kinks in my linked letter.
DNW: condoms/pulling out, scat, snuff, vomit, vore, aliens, tentacles, demons/vampire/mermaid/genre bending aus, boy pussy/girl penis or any kind of gender swap or trans headcanons, specific clothing fetishes (like shoes), period sex, infantilization, age play, diapers, explicit sex with characters under 16 (can reference it happened), sex while the character is heavily pregnant, 1st or 2nd person.
Dear Creator Letter https://hauntedhives.tumblr.com/genletter
---
Request 3 by hauntedhive
Fandom: Person of Interest (TV)
Relationships:
To claim this pinch hit, simply reply to the e-mail that you received or send an e-mail to holly.pol...@gmail.com with the number of the pinch hit you would like to claim. Please make certain to include your AO3 name in the e-mail that you send.
Fandom summary for hauntedhive:
Riverdale (TV 2017)
Glee (TV 2009)
Person of Interest (TV)
---
Request 1 by hauntedhive
Fandom: Riverdale (TV 2017)
Relationships:
Fangs Fogarty/Sweet Pea/Toni Topaz (Riverdale)
Cheryl Blossom/Fangs Fogarty/Toni Topaz (Riverdale)
Archie Andrews/Cheryl Blossom/Jason Blossom (Riverdale)
Archie Andrews/Cheryl Blossom/Veronica Lodge (Riverdale)
Medium: Fanfiction
Summary:
I'm happy with any and all interpretation of what a poly story means for these combinations of characters. I'm good with a fic that's just about a one time threesome between them, threesomes that happen regularly, a threesome that evolves into a relationship, established throuples, a couple welcoming a third into their relationship, a third wanting to watch, cucking situations, three people coming together at the same time, open relationships, one of them dating both of the others who aren't interested in each other, two of them being in love with the third and learning like each other, whatever. I'm good with stories where all three are happy with the arrangement or stories where one or two of them are just doing it to compromise.
Prompts/Ideas
Cheryl/Toni/Fangs: I'm always for love triangles having poly solutions. If you erase the jump to the 50s, there's a lot of potential for this threesome. Toni realizing she still has feelings for Cheryl but also still loves Fangs. Fangs had an open relationship with Kevin, so I can see him being cool with Toni seeing them both. Or maybe Toni breaks up with Fangs to get back with Cheryl, but finds herself missing Fangs, and it's Cheryl that offers to share. Or Choni get back together and slowly, through Fangs being around so much because of Anthony, they both welcome him in and become the original nontraditional family Anthony was originally going to be raised in. If you want to do something more on the porn without plot side: Choni want to have another baby and ask Fangs to be the father so it can be Anthony's full sibling and they want to conceive naturally; Toni and Fangs want to spice up their marriage and invite Cheryl for a threesome; Choni are together and Cheryl admits she wants to be cucked and watch Toni fuck Fangs or Cheryl's jealousy of Fangs gets out of control and Toni teaches her how to share.
Fangs/Toni/Sweet Pea: This trio was very underused on the show and I love the prospect of them being really free and comfortable with each other, casually hooking up in all variations or having impromptu threesomes. If in high school, I like the idea of it being really casual, like just hanging out, getting high or playing video games and suddenly they're fucking. Or them coming back together after Toni gets kicked out of the Serpents, or the boys cheering her up after breaking up with Cheryl. If older, I love the idea of Toni/Fangs inviting Sweet Pea for threesomes or to watch or into their relationship or maybe Toni seeing both of them.
Archie/Cheryl/Jason: So much potential for interesting nuance here with the canon incest subtext of Cheryl's relationships with both of them and Archie being seen as a stand in for Jason. Maybe the twins are a packaged deal, maybe Jason is overprotective and has to approve/supervise his sister's dates/relationships, maybe Cheryl can't choose between her boys and gets both. Maybe Archie works as a vessel for Jason to possess sometimes. Go wild.
Archie/Cheryl/Veronica: I don't have many prompts for them, they just seem like the people that cares about Cheryl most outside of Jason and Toni and I think they would treat her well/she could have loved them. I love the idea of them inviting her for a threesome during a time of need or maybe both of them hooking up with her (cheating or while they were on a break) without knowing and then it leading to a throuple.
Likes and Kinks
Likes: porn with or without plot, angst, fluff, complicated relationship, incestuous relationships (subtextual or overt), dark fic, dubcon/noncon, cheating, 5+1 fics, canon compliant and divergent, unhealthy coping mechanisms, jealousy, toxic relationships, blackmail
Favorite Kinks: creampies/cumplay, breeding/sex resulting in pregnancy, barebacking, gentle/romantic/comfort sex, public sex/exhibitionism, humiliation, cockwarming, free use/sex slavery/punishment, anal sex, rimming, squirting/multiple orgasms/overstimulation, rough sex, playful sex, threesomes, double penetration, sextapes, body worship, cockslut/cumslut, slut shaming/dirty talk, caught having sex, revenge sex, dubcon/noncon, submission, tied up. for f/f ships: oral sex, rimming and face sitting.
There's a lot more info on my likes and kinks in my linked letter.
DNW: condoms/pulling out, scat, snuff, vomit, vore, aliens, tentacles, demons/vampire/mermaid/genre bending aus, boy pussy/girl penis or any kind of gender swap or trans headcanons, specific clothing fetishes (like shoes), period sex, infantilization, age play, diapers, explicit sex with characters under 16 (can reference it happened), sex while the character is heavily pregnant, 1st or 2nd person.
Dear Creator Letter https://hauntedhives.tumblr.com/genletter
---
Request 2 by hauntedhive
Fandom: Glee (TV 2009)
Relationships:
Medium: Fanfiction
Summary:
I'm happy with any and all interpretation of what a poly story means for these combinations of characters. I'm good with a fic that's just about a one time threesome between them, threesomes that happen regularly, a threesome that evolves into a relationship, established throuples, a couple welcoming a third into their relationship, a third wanting to watch, cucking situations, three people coming together at the same time, open relationships, one of them dating both of the others who aren't interested in each other, two of them being in love with the third and learning like each other, whatever. I'm good with stories where all three are happy with the arrangement or stories where one or two of them are just doing it to compromise.
Prompts/Ideas
Cheryl/Toni/Fangs: I'm always for love triangles having poly solutions. If you erase the jump to the 50s, there's a lot of potential for this threesome. Toni realizing she still has feelings for Cheryl but also still loves Fangs. Fangs had an open relationship with Kevin, so I can see him being cool with Toni seeing them both. Or maybe Toni breaks up with Fangs to get back with Cheryl, but finds herself missing Fangs, and it's Cheryl that offers to share. Or Choni get back together and slowly, through Fangs being around so much because of Anthony, they both welcome him in and become the original nontraditional family Anthony was originally going to be raised in. If you want to do something more on the porn without plot side: Choni want to have another baby and ask Fangs to be the father so it can be Anthony's full sibling and they want to conceive naturally; Toni and Fangs want to spice up their marriage and invite Cheryl for a threesome; Choni are together and Cheryl admits she wants to be cucked and watch Toni fuck Fangs or Cheryl's jealousy of Fangs gets out of control and Toni teaches her how to share.
Fangs/Toni/Sweet Pea: This trio was very underused on the show and I love the prospect of them being really free and comfortable with each other, casually hooking up in all variations or having impromptu threesomes. If in high school, I like the idea of it being really casual, like just hanging out, getting high or playing video games and suddenly they're fucking. Or them coming back together after Toni gets kicked out of the Serpents, or the boys cheering her up after breaking up with Cheryl. If older, I love the idea of Toni/Fangs inviting Sweet Pea for threesomes or to watch or into their relationship or maybe Toni seeing both of them.
Archie/Cheryl/Jason: So much potential for interesting nuance here with the canon incest subtext of Cheryl's relationships with both of them and Archie being seen as a stand in for Jason. Maybe the twins are a packaged deal, maybe Jason is overprotective and has to approve/supervise his sister's dates/relationships, maybe Cheryl can't choose between her boys and gets both. Maybe Archie works as a vessel for Jason to possess sometimes. Go wild.
Archie/Cheryl/Veronica: I don't have many prompts for them, they just seem like the people that cares about Cheryl most outside of Jason and Toni and I think they would treat her well/she could have loved them. I love the idea of them inviting her for a threesome during a time of need or maybe both of them hooking up with her (cheating or while they were on a break) without knowing and then it leading to a throuple.
Likes and Kinks
Likes: porn with or without plot, angst, fluff, complicated relationship, incestuous relationships (subtextual or overt), dark fic, dubcon/noncon, cheating, 5+1 fics, canon compliant and divergent, unhealthy coping mechanisms, jealousy, toxic relationships, blackmail
Favorite Kinks: creampies/cumplay, breeding/sex resulting in pregnancy, barebacking, gentle/romantic/comfort sex, public sex/exhibitionism, humiliation, cockwarming, free use/sex slavery/punishment, anal sex, rimming, squirting/multiple orgasms/overstimulation, rough sex, playful sex, threesomes, double penetration, sextapes, body worship, cockslut/cumslut, slut shaming/dirty talk, caught having sex, revenge sex, dubcon/noncon, submission, tied up. for f/f ships: oral sex, rimming and face sitting.
There's a lot more info on my likes and kinks in my linked letter.
DNW: condoms/pulling out, scat, snuff, vomit, vore, aliens, tentacles, demons/vampire/mermaid/genre bending aus, boy pussy/girl penis or any kind of gender swap or trans headcanons, specific clothing fetishes (like shoes), period sex, infantilization, age play, diapers, explicit sex with characters under 16 (can reference it happened), sex while the character is heavily pregnant, 1st or 2nd person.
Dear Creator Letter https://hauntedhives.tumblr.com/genletter
---
Request 2 by hauntedhive
Fandom: Glee (TV 2009)
Relationships:
Sam Evans/Santana Lopez/Brittany S. Pierce (Glee TV)
Sam Evans/Rory Flanagan/Brittany S. Pierce (Glee TV)
Sam Evans/Finn Hudson/Santana Lopez (Glee TV)
Rachel Berry/Finn Hudson/Santana Lopez (Glee TV)
Quinn Fabray/Santana Lopez/Noah Puckerman (Glee TV)
Finn Hudson/Santana Lopez/Noah Puckerman (Glee TV)
Rachel Berry/Santana Lopez/Brody Weston (Glee TV)
Medium: Fanfiction
Summary:
Medium: Fanfiction
Summary:
I'm happy with any and all interpretation of what a poly story means for these combinations of characters. I'm good with a fic that's just about a one time threesome between them, threesomes that happen regularly, a threesome that evolves into a relationship, established throuples, a couple welcoming a third into their relationship, a third wanting to watch, cucking situations, three people coming together at the same time, open relationships, one of them dating both of the others who aren't interested in each other, two of them being in love with the third and learning like each other, whatever. I'm good with stories where all three are happy with the arrangement or stories where one or two of them are just doing it to compromise.
Prompts/Ideas
Sam/Brittany/Santana: Love triangles being solved my polyamory! They all dated each other at some point! Brittany could get Sam and Santana to agree to anything, including sharing her or even being in a throuple. Always happy for a plotless smut focused fic that's just Brittana welcoming Sam for a threesome (for pregnancy purposes or for fun) or Britt/Sam welcoming Santana or Santana getting cucked
Sam/Brittany/Rory: In an alternate timeline, Rory was in season 4 and Brittany got two boyfriends after Santana dumped her. I can see both boys being more than happy to share her or be in a throuple together. Brittany having a boyfriend that lives with her whose room she can sneak into every night. Rory being allowed to invite Sam for sleepovers because he's a boy and Brittany's parents don't know what's really going on with them. Brittany and Sam feeling bad for Rory when he's homesick or gets dumped and inviting him for a threesome. Have fun.
Finn/Santana/Puck and Sam/Santana/Finn: I just want to see these trios fucking tbh. If you can come up with a larger plot, go ahead, I'm sure there's something there, Santana has some history and issues with all three guys. I've always liked the idea of Santana struggling with her feelings for Finn post death and using Sam or Puck (or both, I know Sam/Santana/Puck isn't nominated but shh) to work it out. Does spiritual poly count here?
Quinn/Santana/Puck, Rachel/Santana/Brody and Rachel/Santana/Finn: Santana tried to/did get between all couples at different times and had sexual tension/history with all four of them, so I just think there's potential for interesting or hot stuff here. Santana would totally sleep with both people in a couple to break them up. Maybe they invited Santana for a threesome (and catch feelings?). Maybe something to do with denial of sexuality. Or just hot threesomes.
Likes and Kinks
Likes: porn with or without plot, angst, fluff, complicated relationship, incestuous relationships (subtextual or overt), dark fic, dubcon/noncon, cheating, 5+1 fics, canon compliant and divergent, unhealthy coping mechanisms, jealousy, toxic relationships, blackmail
Favorite Kinks: creampies/cumplay, breeding/sex resulting in pregnancy, barebacking, gentle/romantic/comfort sex, public sex/exhibitionism, humiliation, cockwarming, free use/sex slavery/punishment, anal sex, rimming, squirting/multiple orgasms/overstimulation, rough sex, playful sex, threesomes, double penetration, sextapes, body worship, cockslut/cumslut, slut shaming/dirty talk, caught having sex, revenge sex, dubcon/noncon, submission, tied up. for f/f ships: oral sex, rimming and face sitting.
There's a lot more info on my likes and kinks in my linked letter.
DNW: condoms/pulling out, scat, snuff, vomit, vore, aliens, tentacles, demons/vampire/mermaid/genre bending aus, boy pussy/girl penis or any kind of gender swap or trans headcanons, specific clothing fetishes (like shoes), period sex, infantilization, age play, diapers, explicit sex with characters under 16 (can reference it happened), sex while the character is heavily pregnant, 1st or 2nd person.
Dear Creator Letter https://hauntedhives.tumblr.com/genletter
---
Request 3 by hauntedhive
Fandom: Person of Interest (TV)
Relationships:
Tomas Koroa/Root/Sameen Shaw (POI)
Medium: Fanfiction
Summary:
I'm happy with any and all interpretation of what a poly story means for this combinations of characters. I'm good with a fic that's just about a one time threesome between them, threesomes that happen regularly, a threesome that evolves into a relationship, established throuple, a couple welcoming a third into their relationship, a third wanting to watch, cucking situations, three people coming together at the same time, open relationships, one of them dating both of the others who aren't interested in each other, two of them being in love with the third and learning like each other, whatever. I'm good with stories where all three are happy with the arrangement or stories where one or two of them are just doing it to compromise.
Prompts/Ideas
Tomas was only around for one episode but he left quite the impression on me. We never really saw Shaw thirst after someone as much as we did with him, and while she wad in denial or pushing away her budding one of kind emotional connection with Root. Plus, that one scene of Root listening in on their date was really fun. So I'd love something where maybe Shaw is seeing both of them and comparing the sex she has with both, or her fucking Tomas knowing Root is watching, either in the room or through the Machine. Maybe they have an actual threesome, because Root is curious about what's so great about Tomas that Shaw is so infatuated with him or just because Shaw wants to see her fuck him and she's happy to oblige.
Likes and Kinks
Likes: porn with or without plot, angst, fluff, complicated relationship, incestuous relationships (subtextual or overt), dark fic, dubcon/noncon, cheating, 5+1 fics, canon compliant and divergent, unhealthy coping mechanisms, jealousy, toxic relationships, blackmail
Favorite Kinks: creampies/cumplay, breeding/sex resulting in pregnancy, barebacking, gentle/romantic/comfort sex, public sex/exhibitionism, humiliation, cockwarming, free use/sex slavery/punishment, anal sex, rimming, squirting/multiple orgasms/overstimulation, rough sex, playful sex, threesomes, double penetration, sextapes, body worship, cockslut/cumslut, slut shaming/dirty talk, caught having sex, revenge sex, dubcon/noncon, submission, tied up. for f/f ships: oral sex, rimming and face sitting.
There's a lot more info on my likes and kinks in my linked letter.
DNW: condoms/pulling out, scat, snuff, vomit, vore, aliens, tentacles, demons/vampire/mermaid/genre bending aus, boy pussy/girl penis or any kind of gender swap or trans headcanons, specific clothing fetishes (like shoes), period sex, infantilization, age play, diapers, explicit sex with characters under 16 (can reference it happened), sex while the character is heavily pregnant, 1st or 2nd person).
Dear Creator Letter https://hauntedhives.tumblr.com/genletter
---
Medium: Fanfiction
Summary:
I'm happy with any and all interpretation of what a poly story means for this combinations of characters. I'm good with a fic that's just about a one time threesome between them, threesomes that happen regularly, a threesome that evolves into a relationship, established throuple, a couple welcoming a third into their relationship, a third wanting to watch, cucking situations, three people coming together at the same time, open relationships, one of them dating both of the others who aren't interested in each other, two of them being in love with the third and learning like each other, whatever. I'm good with stories where all three are happy with the arrangement or stories where one or two of them are just doing it to compromise.
Prompts/Ideas
Tomas was only around for one episode but he left quite the impression on me. We never really saw Shaw thirst after someone as much as we did with him, and while she wad in denial or pushing away her budding one of kind emotional connection with Root. Plus, that one scene of Root listening in on their date was really fun. So I'd love something where maybe Shaw is seeing both of them and comparing the sex she has with both, or her fucking Tomas knowing Root is watching, either in the room or through the Machine. Maybe they have an actual threesome, because Root is curious about what's so great about Tomas that Shaw is so infatuated with him or just because Shaw wants to see her fuck him and she's happy to oblige.
Likes and Kinks
Likes: porn with or without plot, angst, fluff, complicated relationship, incestuous relationships (subtextual or overt), dark fic, dubcon/noncon, cheating, 5+1 fics, canon compliant and divergent, unhealthy coping mechanisms, jealousy, toxic relationships, blackmail
Favorite Kinks: creampies/cumplay, breeding/sex resulting in pregnancy, barebacking, gentle/romantic/comfort sex, public sex/exhibitionism, humiliation, cockwarming, free use/sex slavery/punishment, anal sex, rimming, squirting/multiple orgasms/overstimulation, rough sex, playful sex, threesomes, double penetration, sextapes, body worship, cockslut/cumslut, slut shaming/dirty talk, caught having sex, revenge sex, dubcon/noncon, submission, tied up. for f/f ships: oral sex, rimming and face sitting.
There's a lot more info on my likes and kinks in my linked letter.
DNW: condoms/pulling out, scat, snuff, vomit, vore, aliens, tentacles, demons/vampire/mermaid/genre bending aus, boy pussy/girl penis or any kind of gender swap or trans headcanons, specific clothing fetishes (like shoes), period sex, infantilization, age play, diapers, explicit sex with characters under 16 (can reference it happened), sex while the character is heavily pregnant, 1st or 2nd person).
Dear Creator Letter https://hauntedhives.tumblr.com/genletter
---
Holly Poly
Dec 13, 2025, 12:57:51 PM (9 days ago) Dec 13
to Holly Poly Pinchhits
We're still seeking a pinch hit for this - if you know anyone who might be interested please pass the details on
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages