Dear HGVS team,
I work as a variant curator in a diagnostic lab and we have run into a question regarding variant nomenclature in clinical reports.
Following HGVS recommendations this is the nomenclature we have been using:
EGFR (NM_005228.5):c.2156G>C p.(Gly719Ala)
We participate in several EMQN schemes and we have recently got this observation: "
HGVS Nomenclature does not use ( ) brackets for the transcript reference sequence except when a genomic reference sequence is included first" and the suggested nomenclature recommendation was as it follows:
EGFR NM_005228.5:c.2156G>C p.(Gly719Ala)
Going through the recommendations on the website we do see that brackets are used for transcript identifier if NG_ is included:
Genome reference with coordinates from aligned transcript_
Syntax sequence_identifier "(" transcript_identifier "):c." transcript_position reference_sequence ">" alternate_sequence
Examples: NG_012232.1(NM_004006.2):c.93+1G>T However, gene symbol/name is not included and yet helpful for clinicians when it comes to clinical reports.
If included, where should the gene symbol go? before or after transcript identifier? should brackets ( ) be used for either gene symbol or transcript identifier? What should the correct nomenclature be?:
EGFR (NM_005228.5):c.2156G>C p.(Gly719Ala)
EGFR NM_005228.5:c.2156G>C p.(Gly719Ala)
NM_005228.5 (EGFR):c.2156G>C p.(Gly719Ala)
Does it make any difference?
Thanks in advance for your help
Kind regards