I keep just wondering who has got time to read 1,600,000 climate articles collected by Carbon Brief. Brilliant job!
This raises interesting questions: How much duplication? How much brilliant ideas buried within and without having been taken adequate notice. I am sure there are many invaluable gems within the pile to be rediscovered.
I recall here how the Nature article on moulins got forgotten which explained in 1952 the process in its entirety, then "re-discovered" in 2000's by someone else "discovering" it again with another article more or less the same explanation - and no reference
to 1952 Nature article on moulins. If that happens with stuff published in Nature, how much more that happens in lesser publications?
Another interesting point to rise is Encyclopaedia Britannica article on Greenland glaciers which stated that it was once thought that Ellesmere Island, which at the beginning of 1900's was virtually encircled by ice shelves, was having its ice shelves formed
soon after the Eemian Period, 128,000 years ago. Alas! It came to happen that once of its northern ice shelves suddenly collapsed and when the wood buried beneath it was radiocarbon-dated, its age was just meagre 3,000 years old or something like that. Similarly,
Comphytheres were thought to have become extinct 42 million years ago, until someone came across a hunted one with a Clovis flint embedded in its bones and it was since then ice age.
The above examples underline limitations of naturalistic interpretation and importance to be given all anomalies found. That kind of heap 1,6 million articles is bound to contain nasty surprises but some kind of search engines should be developed to extricate
forgotten or under-esteemed observations and data. The information system theorists call it the minimization of the size of the X-factor box by minimising the number of "unknown unknowns" and "little known unknowns" .
Carbon Brief's article bank's value is functionally greater than the sum of its individual parts, but it should be made accessible by AI applications to make it really useful tool to identify misconceptions and overlooked aspects and forgotten research on climate
system.
Veli Albert Kallio, Vice President
Sea Research Society
Environmental Affairs Department