Fwd: Geoengineering won’t save polar ice

1 view
Skip to first unread message

John Nissen

unread,
Sep 11, 2025, 4:45:38 PM (9 days ago) Sep 11
to Planetary Restoration, healthy-planet-action-coalition, Peter Wadhams, Shaun Fitzgerald
It is frightening when an influential person like Sam Wong, assistant news editor of the New Scientist, believes some scaremongering about geoengineering, without consulting the proponents and without considering both the likely necessity of such intervention and the potentially huge benefits.

As usual, the moral hazard argument comes up: that geoengineering research detracts from emissions reduction.

The only glimmer of hope for the geoengineering which is so urgently required is from Shaun Fitzgerald at the end of Wong's piece.

Cheers John 

---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: New Scientist Daily <newsl...@e.newscientist.com>
Date: Wed, 10 Sep 2025, 6:00 am
Subject: Geoengineering won’t save polar ice
To: <johnnis...@gmail.com>


Plus: can a strange new treatment finally relieve chronic sinus infections?
New Scientist's Daily Newsletter

Received this from a friend? Sign up here

Hi John,

We can’t rely on geoengineering to save the poles from climate change, researchers warn in today’s top story. Plus: can a strange new treatment finally relieve chronic sinus infections?

Sam Wong

Sam Wong

Assistant News Editor

Sam Wong

Sam Wong

Assistant News Editor

Hi John,

We can’t rely on geoengineering to save the poles from climate change, researchers warn in today’s top story. Plus: can a strange new treatment finally relieve chronic sinus infections?

Wednesday's lead story

Ice rescue plans ‘unfeasible’

Icebergs. Image links to story

Ulrik Pedersen/NurPhoto/Shutterstock

With carbon dioxide emissions still increasing, can geoengineering halt the melting of the Greenland and Antarctic ice caps and prevent massive sea level rises? No, according to a review of the main ideas for polar geoengineering proposed so far. Martin Siegert at the University of Exeter in the UK and his colleagues assessed five proposals, including “curtains” to protect ice sheets from warm currents and covering Arctic Ocean ice with glass beads to reflect sunlight. Promoting geoengineering ideas that cannot work distracts attention from the key issue, says Siegert. “It becomes something that is working against what we need to do, which is to decarbonise.” Read more

Shimmering fur

More than a dozen mammal species shimmer and glint purple and green, like precious opals. Their fur is iridescent, meaning its colour appears to change depending on the animal’s orientation relative to the viewer. It’s long been claimed that only one mammal – the golden mole – has this trait, but a new study has identified an additional 14, including 10 rodents and the giant otter shrew, a semiaquatic predator that is neither otter nor shrew. Read more

New Scientist Live 2025

The world's greatest festival of ideas and discoveries

18-19 October, Excel London and online access

Everything you love about science, technology and the wonders of our universe. Book now

New Scientist Live. Image links to event

More headlines

Strength training 

People who made the greatest gains in muscle power over eight weeks of resistance training also improved the balance of bacteria in their gut. Read more

Cosmic influence

Michael Marshall ponders whether an asteroid impact, a supernova or a disruption to Earth’s magnetic field could have had an impact on hominin evolution. Read more

Long read

The snot transplant

Image links to story.

Shutterstock/Tisha Razumovsky

“It has a huge, huge impact on almost every facet of life,” says Duncan Boak. “Not being able to breathe properly. Blowing your nose constantly, snot running out of your nose constantly, not being able to sleep, facial pain.” Boak, who is the chief executive of UK-based charity SmellTaste, is talking about a little-known but common and deeply unpleasant condition called chronic rhinosinusitis. Many people with CRS grapple with their symptoms in silence, dismissed by doctors, unaware that they aren’t alone or even that the condition exists. Those who do get proper treatment seldom shake the disease completely, and some don’t respond at all. But that bleak prospect might be about to change. A new hypothesis about the cause of the condition is offering up a radical new treatment: the snot transplant. Read more

Quote of the day

“If you stack the decks by assuming that AI leads to infinite badness, pretty much anything is justified in avoiding it.”

Jacob Aron finds flaws in the argument that superintelligent AI should trump all other concerns in his review of If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies by Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares.

Discovery Tours

Neanderthals, human origins and cave art, France

20 September 2025, 9 days

Embark on a captivating journey through time as you explore the key Neanderthal and Upper Palaeolithic sites of southern France. Find out more

New Scientist Discovery Tours, links to site

Thanks for reading!

Received this from a friend? Sign up here

For the latest science and technology news, in-depth articles and video, visit newscientist.com

Facebook TwitterInstagramLinkedIn TikTokBluesky

This email has been sent to johnnis...@gmail.com
 Unsubscribe from the Daily newsletter

Do not reply directly to this email. If you have an enquiry, please contact us using the relevant contact details listed here.

Copyright © New Scientist Ltd


Registered Office: Northcliffe House, 9 Derry Street, London, W8 5HY
Registered in England. No.10644366
Australian mailing address: PO Box 2315, Strawberry Hills, NSW 2012, Australia
Registered in Australia. ABN 22 621 413 170

 

Privacy Policy  |  Terms & Conditions

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages