She was born on December 8,1933 in Bronx, NY, daughter of the late Michael J. Stolfi and Lucy M. Mastriano. Mrs. Caccia attended Walton High School, graduating class of 1951. She then attended St. John’s University and Elizabeth Seton College.
On October 10, 1954 she married Benedict A. Caccia. They later moved to Mount Vernon, and then in 1962, she and her family moved to Hastings on Hudson, NY, where they spent the next 32 years. While living in Hastings, Natalie was an active volunteer with local churches, schools and hospitals and worked as a real estate agent for 16 years.