Shaikh Hyder
unread,Aug 9, 2007, 12:07:55 PM8/9/07Sign in to reply to author
Sign in to forward
You do not have permission to delete messages in this group
Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message
to hasanshab...@googlegroups.com, `·.¸¸.·*Mohammad*··.¸¸.·` ', aalime...@hotmail.com, a...@mohammed.com, ali_...@hotmail.com, Ali Abbas, alibhoj...@hotmail.com, AliWalayHaqparast ever, aminabe...@she.com, Anwar, asad...@virglio.it, asgarali bhayani, Asma, Azhar, farman Moosavi, fati...@gmail.com, Fayza Safdar, gazi....@gmail.com, Ghulam Hussain, Haider Merchant, Hani Raza, Hasan, hasans...@googlegroups.com, Hashim, iqbal...@aol.com, kas...@quamtumamc.com, ka...@jvi-global.com, kashi...@gmail.com, kazim reza, Komel B, Kumail, M.Mustafa Poonawala, mahmoo...@yahoo.co.in, maryam merchant, Masuma, mohamme...@hotmail.com, mufeed...@gmail.com, oceanex...@yahoo.com, parve...@yahoo.com, pradhan, shahid, qaisarra...@yahoo.co.in, RAFIK BADAMI, rebell...@yahoo.com, Rizvi, Rizvi FasihulHasan, Sajjad Hussain Kargil(Ladakh), Salman, Salman Bhojani, Sebtain, shahbaz sherazi, sham...@yahoo.com, Sohel Ajani, Tahasajjad, Wilayah Network, Wilayah Network, yusuf_...@yahoo.com, zakirasa...@indiatimes.com, zaki shadab, creati...@gmail.com
- from The Independent & The Independent on Sunday
- 10 August 2007 09
Jinnah's daughter takes up fight for house where Pakistan was created
By Andrew Buncombe in Delhi
Published: 09 August 2007
Dina Wadia was a teenage girl when her father, Muhammad Jinnah, built the sprawling mansion overlooking the ocean at Mumbai's Malabar Hill.
By the time he left India a decade later to live in Pakistan, the newly-minted country he had helped create, Mrs Wadia was
all but estranged from her father.
Yet at no time did she give up on the house. Now aged 87, Mrs Wadia this week launched a fresh legal attempt to force the Indian government to return the European-style property, long neglected but heavy with the ghosts of history.
The timing of her lawsuit could hardly be more symbolic: Mrs Wadia launched the legal action after being told that the Indian government planned to convert the property into an arts centre and that its formal opening was to take place on 15 August - the 60th anniversary of the partition of the British Indian Empire and the creation of independent India and Pakistan. Coincidentally, 15 August is also Mrs Wadia's birthday.
Though the property - set on around 2.5 acres and located
in Mumbai's most expensive neighbourhood - has been valued at millions of dollars, Mrs Wadia's family insist she is not driven by financial considerations.
Speaking from Mumbai last night, her son Nusli Wadia, a leading Indian industrialist, said: "It's an emotional attachment. It's [her saying] 'This was my father's house and why should the government of India be able to keep it?'."
Mr Jinnah, a leader of the Indian independence movement who served as Pakistan's first governor-general, built Jinnah House in 1936, having hired the British architect Claude Batley to carry out the design and employing Italian stonemasons to lay the marble floors. He is said to have overseen the laying of each
slab and the installation of the property's walnut panelling.
In September 1944, the house was the venue for crucial talks between Jinnah and Mahatma Gandhi concerning the partition of India and the creation of two countries, one dominated by Hindus, the other by Muslims. When partition took place, with Pakistan granted independence on 14 August 1947 and India gaining its freedom the following day, Jinnah left Mumbai and asked that his property be rented to a foreign consulate.
After partition, India's first prime
minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, dispatched an envoy to Pakistan to ask Jinnah what he wanted done with the house. He is said to have replied: "You do not know how I love Bombay. I built that house brick by brick. Tell Jawaharlal not to break my heart." Mr Wadia, his grandson, said: "Jinnah intended to come back - as crazy as it sounds."
But when Mr Jinnah died in 1948, his will left the property to his sister, Fatima, the result of his anger at his daughter for marrying a non-Muslim. Yet Fatima had also been forced to move to Pakistan and having been declared an evacuee, her property - like that of other families - was taken over by the government.
The last tenant of the property was the deputy British high commissioner, who left in 1982, by which time the house was said to have been overrun with weeds and snakes.
Mrs Wadia, born in London in 1919 and who currently lives in New York, has petitioned successive Indian governments to have the house returned. She has also written to Pakistan's President General Pervez Musharraf and asked that Pakistan drop its own claim to the property, which it wants as a high commission. Her son said she might even return to live in India if she secured the house.
In a letter last year to the Indian Prime Minister, Manmohan Singh, Mrs Wadia wrote: "It is now over 50 years since my father's death and I have been deprived of my house... This is the house where I grew up and lived until I married. The property is lying idle for 23 years... I request you return it to me."
At Mumbai's High Court this week, the federal government's lawyer said there were no plans for an inaugural party for an arts centre. The Times of India said the court gave the government a month to respond to Mrs Wadia's lawsuit.
The founding father
Muhammad Jinnah was one of the key leaders of the struggle to achieve independence for
India. Originally he thought sufficient safeguards could be built into the new Indian nation to safeguard Muslims, but as leader of the All India Muslim League, he and others began pushing for an independent nation.
In 1946 he led calls for the creation of Pakistan. Protests that were planned to be peaceful turned violent and were a key factor in the decision to proceed with partition. He wanted the new state's constitution to be secular, though guided by Islam. In one speech he said: "I am sure that it will be of a democratic type, embodying the essential principle of Islam." He had suffered from tuberculosis for many years and died in 1948 as a result of that disease and lung cancer.
Nervous about who has your email address?
Yahoo! Mail can help you win the war against spam.