Sorry, time got away from me. Here are some before & after shots of the bells. I am not real sure if the before pictures show just how dirty the bells were, but the bass bells were covered in hand prints - you could see the entire hand in some instances, both outside and inside the bell casting. The smaller bells were more of a matte finish over the entire bell. I am assuming it was multiple hand prints just overlapping on those bells, but it certainly could have been something else. It definitely was not a matter of them being very tarnished.
Elke asked how we ended up getting the bells clean. Based on what my friend Jim had done with the 3 bells he borrowed, we used the following protocol on the entire set. The bells were completely disassembled. We polished the tang, followed by the inside of each bell. Once reassembled, we did the outside casting. As stated earlier, I was willing to go this route since this was going to be my set of bells.
1) BellZest was applied to each surface, wiped down & then had to apply a second coat.
2) Then we used the rouge surface of the Shino polishing cloth and then wiped it down.
3) It usually took two applications of polishing cream to finish removing the prints. While I had used Blue Magic on a couple of the bells I tried to clean up last summer, Jim had better luck using some old Malmark polish that he had. So I am not sure if we had gone with the Blue Magic if it would have done the job that the Malmark brand did. Unfortunately, Malmark does not sell the old stuff any longer.
Rebecca