Kris,
I love the vigor of soil block transplants. I've not had the drying out problem others have described but maybe that's because I use either 1) a flat that does not have drainage holes or 2) a flat that does have drainable holes, resting in an older flat that does not have drainage holes. And I start with a pretty wet mix when I'm making blocks. My flats get a bleach water washing before use so I've never had damping off problems. The flats can be watered from the side so you don't have to water from above, just let the blocks absorb the water that's poured in. For flats that get hardened off outside, that's when the draining flat nested in the non-draining flat comes in handy because I can lift it out after a rain, dump the excess water and put it back in.
I use the Coleman recipe, with some adaptation. I use the two buckets of compost and instead of a bucket of garden soil, I use either another bucket of compost or a half bucket of vermicompost. Gotta be careful with the vermicompost--it's a rich mix and it gets the plants up and going fast so I use that mix for later transplant seeding, like in late March. An earlier, I find that transplants can get too leggy, but the heavy feeders like tomatoes and cabbage really love a shot of vermicompost .
I've got the room to plant directly into my 2"X2" blocks, so I don't mess around with the little guys. I have a friend who grows annual flowers for sale and she swears by the little blocks for germinating. I think it depends on your operation. I'm small time (12 winter shares) and I've got greenhouse space in spring, so I just go for the bigger blocks. Will be starting leeks next week.
I have also experimented with a couple of other things. At the Milwaukee urban farm, Growing Power, they use a soil mix that is equal parts coir (ground up coconut husks) and vermicompost for just about everything they do. This has worked really good when I'm growing pea shoots in flats but not so great with the blocks. It doesn't seem to bind as well as the Coleman mix using peat, so the blocks can't take much handling until the transplants have established adequate root systems to hold their blocks in place. I haven't noticed a difference in the mature plants but that could be because I also incorporate vermicompost into my beds outdoors so they all get the benefits of that soil amendment in the end.
I also found that the dust generated from mixing soil is easier to deal with when I'm using vermiculite rather than perlite. I'd be interested to hear the opinions of others because I really have a strong preference for vermiculite. It doesn't create a white dust on my eye glasses, for example. And am I the only one bugged by that green stuff that grows on the perlite?
Carol Ford
Garden Goddess Produce
Milan, MN