on toS1 and toS4

[Matthias Bry]

Hello everyone,

This is mainly a message for @Jakub Jelinek but also for the wider NABC community.

1) is there a difference between toS1 and toS4 (which currently only exists in gresgmodern and looks a whole lot like toS1) - more angular?

2) is this glyph semantically different from other torculus variants?

(Source https://www.e-codices.unifr.ch/en/csg/0391/87 R/ Surge Petre, maniBUS)

I think so : it is a toS with the downward feature of a toS1/toM1, that is, a torculus where the three notes are long and the last note is low.

3) If yes, then should it be coded toS4 or toS5 or toSM1 ?

This issue has arisen as I was transcribed this R/ outside of the Repertorium Project, but it also impacts repertorium => Andrew & Dominique cc'd.

In Christo,

Matthias