The Decline(?) of the Indian Left: A short exploratory note

[Sukla Sen]

*The Decline(?) of the Indian Left*

*In the context of just concluded state polls*

*A short exploratory note*

I. Institutionalised leftism is, on the face of it, on the retreat worldwide - despite some significant divergences here and there.

Regardless of the mighty advances made by feminism, ecological movements and anti-racist resistances.

II. Economic neo-liberalism has emerged as the ruling doctrine of the era.

III. The consequent sharpening of socio-economic inequities and resultant conflicts have, instead of triggering social revolutions, led to the rise of various versions if right-wing authoritarian populism - spearheaded by "strong", and charismatic, leaders.

IV. The Indian Left - much like various shades of Left elsewhere, have, by and large, failed to grapple with the fact of dominance of economic neo-liberalism and consequent soaring aspirations of ever expanding segments of the populace coupled with the reality of economic ruination of many.

V. Of course, Bengal has its own distinctive features - that deserve special attention.

But, beyond minute details, it's broadly following the same pattern.

The Left, here, miserably failed to succeed as a ruthless champion of economic neo-liberalism while mouthing contrary jargons.

VI. In Kerala, for now, Vijayan has been able to negotiate between economic neo-liberalism and welfarism.

In a way, so has Mamata in West Bengal.

In addition, both - the latter far more so, could gain the confidence of the threatened minorities. 

Specific personal qualities also did count.

VII. But the challenges of rising majoritarianism as a deceptive solution - to both (large sections of) the elite and the subalterns, to problems caused by economic neo-liberalism remain quite untamed - even on the rather short term.

We may very well keep encountering periodic convulsions.

VIII. In India we're right now faced with the looming doom of "India" itself.

Has got to be fought back on "as is where is" basis - joining hands with whoever is ready to fight.