this exercise does get discussed .. but till now, there isn't much
hindi script material in electronic format .. so results are usually
based on a few books, or some sections of some books .. with
widely varying results
so it cannot be authoritatively determined
further, the existing 'logic' of grouping of consonants .. the
separate grouping and placement of vowels .. the symbols
used as modifiers of consonants .. all these are more or
less 'fixed' in the hindi alphabet .. the sequence of letters
is not 'fixed' on any logic or any basis in the european
character set
so, it is much easier for keeping the character set laid out
in any s/w or h/w 'as is' .. instead of putting most used
letters near each other and others 'further away'
it will be easier for hindi language users to 'understand' and
then 'remember' .. and then practice and become high speed
typists on the existing logic based key-layout
a bit of elaboration here .. when a consonant combines with a vowel
its 'look' is altered by 'adding' the modifier-symbol ..
e.g. pa joins with aa .. so we for 'papa' we write :
p+a+p+a = papa (english)
pa+aa+pa+aa (hindi .. consonant 'pa' + vowel 'aa')
प+ आ+ प+ आ (hindi .. consonant प + vowel आ )
प+ ा + प + ा (hindi .. consonant प + modifier symbol ा )
पापा (as it is actually written .. it takes up only TWO spaces
unlike the english letter papa which takes FOUR spaces)
EVERY CONSONANT is so 'modified' to give out the
sound dictated by the vowel-symbol
in operating systems/ browsers, the 'rendering' is done
by the system/browser/application .. so the
consonant combines with a modifier-symbol of the
vowel and the changed shape is displayed on the
computer's screen by the sytem/application/browser
there IS a need though .. the vowel is different from the
modifier-symbol for that vowel .. as such the two have
two separate distinct unicode points
for GKOS this means that the vowels will need
different keys assigned to them and their modifier-
symbols will need yet other different keys
(gosh .. this does sound quite complicated .. but
actually it is not complicated at all .. once the
character set logic is understood .. and the
glyph forming logic is understood)
seppo