I agree with you that the clause is probably not legally binding.
However, I personally don't like sophism of any kind and I prefer to
comply to peoples wishes as I would like that other people act in
accordance with my wishes. They clearly ask not do redistribute their
data and we could at least ask for an exception. Would you like to send
them an email and ask whether we are allowed to dump the data with added
lat/lng information? This could be your contribution to the geonames
project ;-)
Cheers
Marc
Max Jaramillo wrote:
> Dear Marc:
>
> Just following up on a previous post regarding the Mexican postal
> codes. Is it/ then /not possible to obtain the Postal Code /
I have writing daily emails to Sepomex to have them freely release
their "postal code" information to the geonames community. I would
call but have no tel/contact where to reach someone. I haven't given-
up, but do you have any suggestions?
I am anxious to get the Mexican Postal Code dump.
Max
You could try giving them some days to answer. They might get annoyed by
receiving daily emails and you end up on their spam filter and in the trash.
Cheers
Marc
It's me again with my request for the Mexican Postal Dumps.
I've been corresponding with Mr. Benjamín Luna del Razo [Subdirector
de Desarrollo de Sistemas] of Sepomex and while he reiterates that the
service is completely free, his departament does not have the vested
"authority" to authorize our request. Excuse the redundancy.
The best I could get from him is the following... I don't know if this
will "pass muster" with geonames. The e-mails are in reverse
chronological order.
I hope that based on Mr. Luna del Razo's reiterations that the Sepomex
data is of free/open use, you decide to release the geo-referenced
postal coordinates for Mexico. It's not exactly what we wanted, but
it's close...
Let us know.
Max
=====
Sr. Jaramillo:
Entendemos claramente el sentido de su solicitud, sin embargo, como le
informé en mi correo electrónico del 18 de los corrientes, no contamos
con las facultades su autorización.
La información de códigos postales de nuestro país se encuentra
publicada en el portal institucional de Sepomex, al cual ustedes
podrían direccionar su consulta, en caso de considerarlo conveniente.
Saludos,
Benjamín Luna
=====
De: max jaramillo [mailto:maxjar...@gmail.com]
Enviado el: Miércoles, 23 de Mayo de 2007 02:21 p.m.
Para: Luna del Razo Benjamín
Asunto: Re: RV: maxjar...@gmail.com ha enviado un mensaje.
Sr. Luna del Razo,
Primero, muchas gracias por su respuesta.
Como ya sabrá, la comunidad de geonames.org es sin-ánimo de lucro y no
vende ni comercializa ningúno de los datos de geo-referenciación
encontrados en su sitio web - www.geonames.org. Toda la información es
de disponsición gratuita y libre.
Al ofrecer los datos gratuitamente a los particulares de la comunidad,
confío entonces que geonames.org está actuando de acorde a las normas
de Sepomex?
Atentamente,
Max Jaramillo
pd: Favor ver como se está usando los datos de Sepomex actualmente:
http://www.geonames.org/postal-codes/postal-codes-mexico.html
=====
On 5/18/07, Luna del Razo Benjamín <ben...@sepomex.gob.mx> wrote:
Estimado Sr. Jaramillo:
Agradecemos su comunicación y su interés en los códigos postales y su
cartografía.
Por ser un organismo público proporcionamos la información del código
postal de manera gratuita a los ciudadanos y clientes de Sepomex, para
su uso y aprovechamiento como particulares. Por ello, el código postal
no se vende.
Por otra parte, nuestras facultades como Organismo público no nos
permiten otorgar el tipo de autorización que solicita.
Sin otro particular, reciba nuestros saludos.
Lic. Benjamín Luna del Razo
Subdirector de Desarrollo de Sistemas
Servicio Postal Mexicano.
On May 16, 1:28 pm, Marc <m...@geonames.org> wrote:
> Max
>
> You could try giving them some days to answer. They might get annoyed by
> receiving daily emails and you end up on their spam filter and in the trash.
>
> Cheers
>
> Marc
>