Anthology Titles as Examples of Genre - Vote!

[Jim Van Dore]

1. This should be added to the document:  "While it is the intention that stories associated with a particular feature be assigned a genre consistent with the other stories of the feature, genre can also be assigned to stories that are not a part of a feature at all, as with the majority of the stories in such anthologies as House of Mystery, Tales from the Crypt, or Young Romance. "

A. Yes ______

B. No ______

2. Some of the genres in the proposed document should have anthology titles added as examples

A. Yes _______

B. No _______

I believe these are our last issues.

Jim

[Jim Van Dore]

1. A (yes)

2. B (no)

Jim

[James Ludwig]

On Mon, Mar 26, 2012 at 8:56 PM, Jim Van Dore <jrva...@gmail.com> wrote:

> 1. This should be added to the document:  "While it is the intention that
> stories associated with a particular feature be assigned a genre consistent
> with the other stories of the feature, genre can also be assigned to stories
> that are not a part of a feature at all, as with the majority of the stories
> in such anthologies as House of Mystery, Tales from the Crypt, or Young
> Romance. "
>

> A. Yes ___X___

>
> B. No ______
>
>
>
> 2. Some of the genres in the proposed document should have anthology titles
> added as examples
>

> A. Yes __X_____

[Bob Hughes]

At 08:56 PM 3/26/2012, you wrote:

1. This should be added to the document:  "While it is the intention that stories associated with a particular feature be assigned a genre consistent with the other stories of the feature, genre can also be assigned to stories that are not a part of a feature at all, as with the majority of the stories in such anthologies as House of Mystery, Tales from the Crypt, or Young Romance. "

A. Yes __x____

B. No ______



2. Some of the genres in the proposed document should have anthology titles added as examples

A. Yes ___x____

B. No _______



I believe these are our last issues.

Jim

Bob Hughes

"Information is not knowledge; knowledge is not wisdom; wisdom is not truth; truth is not beauty; beauty is not love; love is not music.  Music is best."

                                                     Frank Zappa- Joe's Garage Act III

[Brian Saner Lamken]

Yes to both.

Although 1 to me is crucial whereas 2 is merely a good idea to reinforce 1.

BSL

Jim Van Dore wrote:

Brian Saner Lamken
blamken.blogspot.com

"You are indeed possessed, for those are not the words of a friendly Bavarian farmer!"
— Doctor Strange, "The Possessed!"; Strange Tales #118 (Marvel, 1964)

[Tony Rose]

---

From: "Jim Van Dore" <jrva...@gmail.com>
To: "gcd-genre" <gcd-...@googlegroups.com>
Sent: Monday, March 26, 2012 7:56:18 PM
Subject: [gcd-genre] Anthology Titles as Examples of Genre - Vote!

1. This should be added to the document:  "While it is the intention that stories associated with a particular feature be assigned a genre consistent with the other stories of the feature, genre can also be assigned to stories that are not a part of a feature at all, as with the majority of the stories in such anthologies as House of Mystery, Tales from the Crypt, or Young Romance. "

A. Yes _x____

B. No ______

2. Some of the genres in the proposed document should have anthology titles added as examples

A. Yes _______

B. No ___x___

[Lionel English]

I'm abstaining because I don't feel particularly strongly about the questions.

--
Lionel English

San Diego, CA
lio...@beanmar.net

[Jim Van Dore]

So far the second issue is 2-3. Any last votes?

Jim