MCA site not working properly
sanjay k agarwal
I fully agree with Pittiji,
Regards,
CA. Sanjay Agarwal
FCA, FCS, CPA(USA)
Santosh Jain & Co
Chartered Accountants
Admn Office:
2 Draper Lane
Govt Place (E)
Kolkata-700 069
Ph: 22431088, 32913756
Cell: 9331023275
'Be Happy Make Happy'
P Please do not print this email unless it is extremely required.
From:
PITTI & CO [mailto:arjun...@gmail.com]
Sent: Thursday, October 29, 2009
9:51 PM
To: RAMPURIA DIPAK
Subject: Fw:
|
Please Forward your comments.
comments received so far ===============================
I am fully agree with the mail. Today in eight hours total forms upooaded-4. REGARDS,
DINESH AGARWAL, AICWA, ACS 7, MANGOE LANE, ROOM NO. 105 1ST FLOOR, KOLKATA -
700001,
DEAR PITTIJI,
----- Original Message ----- From: PITTI & CO To: Bimal Chand Bhandari ; bklohar...@yahoo.com ; b...@cal3.vsnl.net.in ; blr...@rediffmail.com ; BOHRA PRASAD JAGDISH ; bothr...@gmail.com ; BRIJ MOHAN NANGALIA Sent: 29-10-2009 7:58 PM Subject: Fw: RE:
----- Original Message ----- From: dharmendra maloo Sent: 29-10-2009 7:29 PM Subject: RE:
DEAR PITTIJI,
----- Original Message ----- From: PITTI & CO Cc: DEBASIS BANDO MCA Sent: 29-10-2009 5:41 PM
From Arjun Pitti M.Com., LL.B., F.C.A., A.I.C.W.A. PITTI & CO. CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS CE 147 SALT LAKE CITY SECTOR - 1 KOLKATA - 700064 From 23rd October, 2009 the web side OF MCA is not working properly. Its very slow. After trying for almost one hour a professional can upload hardly 1 or 2 return. Moreover getting role check is almost all impossible. Its true that the people are trying in last moment but what the department was doing. If the web side will remain slow as at present position how the company can upload its return in time. Its is also the duty of the department to make proper arrangement for geeting getting all the returns uploaded if people are interested to upload by providing necessary facilities.
Moreover the biggest problem is with the Council members of both the Institute i.e. The Institute of Chartered Accounatnts of India as well as the Institute of Company Secretaries of India. The Council members are only interested to get vote rather than raising such types of the issues with the Institute.
I have tried to talk on these two numbers of Front office several times i.e. 033-64506000 & 09748978789 but no body picked up the line.
Arjun Pitti
|
NS RAJAN
C.A. N SUNDARA RAJAN
C.A. N.Sundara Rajan
CA Deepak Agarwal
Esteemed Colleagues,
Well, Fully agree with the concern, Even taken up the problem with help desk mca, they just send a formal reply letter “assuring you best services”. When and how not clear. This is a serious issue and creating lot of hardship to users without there fault. Cant the members make a representation with Ministry of Companies Affairs, as this issue has not come for the first time.
Regard
CA. Deepak Agarwal
4th fl, E block, Room No: 3
Mercantile Bldg
9/12 Lal Bazar St, Kol-1
Cell: 9331887601
From:
eserve...@googlegroups.com [mailto:eserve...@googlegroups.com] On
Behalf Of sanjay k agarwal
Sent: Friday, October 30, 2009 11:46 AM
To: 'PITTI & CO'; eserve...@googlegroups.com
Subject: e-Serve MCA site not working properly
I fully agree with Pittiji,
s
kc k
From: sanjay k agarwal <sanj...@gmail.com>
To: PITTI & CO <arjun...@gmail.com>; eserve...@googlegroups.com
Sent: Fri, 30 October, 2009 11:46:01 AM
Subject: e-Serve MCA site not working properly
Now, send attachments up to 25MB with Yahoo! India Mail. Learn how.
Rakesh Baid
Regards,
CA. Rakesh Baid
Rakesh Baid & Co.
Chartered Accountants
2 Mandir Street
Kolkata 700073
Phone : 22357918
Cell: 9903700000
From: sanj...@gmail.com
To: arjun...@gmail.com; eserve...@googlegroups.com
Subject: e-Serve MCA site not working properly
P.D.RUNGTA
MCA site not working properly
dear all
om shanti
let five persons go to Regional director and give complaint in writing ..there will be action...but we do not have time......however i am forwarding this email to RD west Bengal...pl remain in touch...all of you can individually send email to RD if u do not have time.......
bk ca tulsi ram tibrewala 09830080444
We are agree on this issue. But there is another dimension to this, the site
perfectly with MCA service centre and uploan is fast , quick and for sure.
Dear All
We also fully agree with the same problem as we are facing lot of problem for Annual filing of Forms, the Institute must take strong action against Such problem.
Regards
ANAND GUPTA
GUJRANI & CO.
We tried in early morning to upload around 6.30 a.m. and we were successful
without redoing.
One form was left out on the last day and that also we got uploaded by sending
thro assistant to MCA cell at 6.45 p.m.
FYI pl.
Regards,
S. NAKKIRAN| Asst. General Manager | Corporate
SPML Infrastructure Limited (A Fully-owned Subsidiary of Subhash Projects and
Marketing Ltd.
Mfar Silverline Tech Park | 2nd Floor, Plot No.180, EPIP 2nd Phase | Whitefield
| Bangalore - 560066
Mobile: +91-99809 33076
Tel: +91-80-40520200 | Extn: 398 | Dir: 40520398 | Fax: +91-80-40956701
Web: www.spml.co.in<http://www.spml.co.in>
Its horrible experience in e-filing this time. When Chalan was about to
appear on screen upon payment thr card it throws message " page can not be
displayed" to know the status track payment another 1 hour...if gets
connected! In income tax ack is stored in web space of the assessee PAN.
whereas it doesnt stores anywhere in MCA website to verify the chalan
status...!
To
All the members
Due to this delay I cannot submit the form on 28th (as the AGM date was
28.09.09,
when on 29th I submitted the form 500 + 500 extra charge levied for 20B
& 23AC, How can I reimburse it from my client, They will say it is my fault
for payment of additional fees.
CA PRITHWIRAJ PAL
098301 93594
dear all !
when so much is said about the mca for sluggish service and
in consequence tcs who governs the mca when common people is fined
for act of negligence why should not rti act be applied and for loss of man
power and angxiety we have to bear due to the fault of tcs etc waiver of
addl fees is prerequisite at this juncture of time . a valid subject of
concern bravo mera bharat mahan
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111
C.A.PREM KHANDELWAL 9339752585 22126308/
90070 22221
What are you complaining about? People like you should be forced to pay fine
as you will wake up only after the eleventh hour. What were you and your
clients doing for last 30 days since 30th September? Waiting for the last day
to arrive to file returns. The MCA should make the fine 10 times than what it
is now to bring people like you in line
__________________________________________________________________________
now, after due date site will be working properly and our clients are
compelled to file return by paying penalty. Why MCA department will be
inerested in looking after the problems of common people. After all they are
now able to collect more revenue from corporates by way of fine/penalty. To be
very frank, after trying for 2-3 days when i could not file any return, i
informed all my clients to be ready for paying penalty and all the returns will
be filed after due date is over. Though all returns are ready before due date.
I hope now MCA people do not change the version of their forms before filing of
those return which are prepared but could not be uploaded.
Regards,
CA. Rakesh Baid
Rakesh Baid & Co.
Chartered Accountants
2 Mandir Street
Kolkata 700073
Phone : 22357918
Cell: 9903700000
______________________________________________________________________
server was very slow on 28 th and 29 th october . so it was a problem for most
of us
regards
Madhusudan sharma
37a Bentinck street
kolkata 700069
To add to the same - I have been facing problem in log in at mca site -
Inspite of mails to helpdesk as also the telephonic calls the problem is not
resolved till date crippling myself to depend at mercy of the mca agent or
some one else. Oflate it has been communicated that to work with mca filing
win explorer has to be only of ver 6.00 no higher version will work - THIS I
DO NOT AGREE AS TILL RECENT PAST I WAS ABLE TO LOG IN AND DO FILINGS
This is really a issue of concern and the joint effort shall be made by the
associations or institutes to MCA Ministry
Regards,
CA S K Choudhary
In my view only institute and members both also take this issue to Ministry. It is the negligency of Mca people and they sholud bear the penalty why genneral public.
I think institute should take the action as well as members shold sue the MCA people so that this is not going to happen in future.
As this regular practice of MCA. If they are not able to maintain site shold close it and start manual.
Pawan Agarwal
FCA
TN TOWER
A T ROAD GUWAHATI ASSAM
Recently we paid Rx. 50/- to view documents for a Company in MCA web site.
However, because the web site was not working properly, we were unable to
view any documents and R. 50/- was lost. We were forced to pay again the
next day to view the document.
On contacting the helpline, they said that nothing can be done and we need
to pay again. Earlier I remember, the payment had validity for 7 days, but
now it is same day. Therefore if there is any server or network problem,
nothing can be done. This I gross cheating.
Regards,
Shiv Choudhry
With Regards:-
CA.RUNGTA PRAMOD DAYAL
M.COM., LL.B.,AICWA.,FCA.,DISA (ICAI)
P D RUNGTA & CO.,
Chartered Accountants
21,HEMANT BASU SARANI, 3RD FL.,R.NO. 317 ,KOLKATA 700 001 ,PH:033 3028 2500 (4 LINES) CELL: 9831007253 ,web:www.pdrungta.co.in
Disclaimer: The information contained in this communication is intended solely for the individual or entity to which it is addressed. It may contain confidential and/or legally privileged information. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking any action in reliance on the contents of this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by responding to this email and then delete it from your system. We attempt to scan e-mails and attachments for viruses, however, it does not guarantee that either are virus free and that we accept no liability for any damage sustained as a result of VIRUSES.
NOTE: Please do not print this email unless absolutely necessary. Please encourage environmental awareness.
MOHAN GOENKA
Myself has raised the said Issue in 6th Regional conference of Practising Compay secretaries of India on 01.11.2009 in kolkata and the Council has assured that some positive steps will be taken althogh as per their version of MCA as per their meeting held with MCA before 30.10 they has told that the system is uanble to take the load of 100000 form per day on 29.10 and 30.10.
so the system need to updated and for that the talk between MCA & TCS will take place very soon.
Regds
Mohan Ram Goenka
Practising Company Secretary
46 B B Ganguly Street
4 Floor Room No.6
Kolkata 7000012
goenk...@hotmail.com
9831074332
Date: Tue, 3 Nov 2009 07:53:53 +0530
Subject: e-Serve MCA site not working properly
From: pdru...@gmail.com
To: eserve...@googlegroups.com
ros...@dava.co.in
Its not MCA fault at any level. Its our fault to wait for last minute to file the papers either in Income tax or in ROC. Why don't we blame our client for that instead of ROC/Income tax. We cannot raise a figure on Income tax or on ROC as a professional. Instead of that we should encourage the e-system done by the Government.
Remember the period when we had wasted the manpower/money to file the returns in ROC or in income tax by standing in que since morning to evening.
So, I would request all my professional colleague that please don't raise the finger on the integrity of the Government's steps towards e-system.
Regards,
CA. Roshan Agrawal
Partner
D A V A & Associates
Chartered Accountants
www.dava.co.in
Sent from my BlackBerry® smartphone from Reliance Mobile
santosh...@rediffmail.com
I fully agree with concerns stated reg MCA site.institute CA CS should immediately make proper representation with copies to media.Since TCS image will be at stake they will take immediate steps.
Thanks
Santosh jain
Sent from BlackBerry® on Airtel