84:1 + 69:16 + 55:37 + 21:104

23 views
Skip to first unread message

Daniel Sabirin

unread,
Jul 17, 2015, 11:37:59 AM7/17/15
to Forum Study

Karena 84:1, 69:16, 55:37 dan 21:104 semuanya benar, pertanyaannya 'mungkinkah universe yang flat akhirnya akan menggulung (deformasi) karena kerapatan material universe terus menurun akibat ekspansi?'.

Dengan umpan 'universe maintains flatness in expansion' beberapa ikan terpancing dari kolam google; 

> Umum; flatness problem & fine-tuning to very 'special' values.

The flatness problem (also known as the oldness problem) is a cosmological fine-tuning problem within the Big Bang model of the universe. Such problems arise from the observation that some of the initial conditions of the universe appear to be fine-tuned to very 'special' values, and that a small deviation from these values would have had massive effects on the nature of the universe at the current time.

In the case of the flatness problem, the parameter which appears fine-tuned is the density of matter and energy in the universe. This value affects the curvature of space-time, with a very specific critical value being required for a flat universe. The current density of the universe is observed to be very close to this critical value. Since the total density departs rapidly from the critical value over cosmic time, the early universe must have had a density even closer to the critical density, departing from it by one part in 1062 or less. This leads cosmologists to question how the initial density came to be so closely fine-tuned to this 'special' value.
The problem was first mentioned by Robert Dicke in 1969. The most commonly accepted solution among cosmologists is cosmic inflation, the idea that the universe went through a brief period of extremely rapid expansion in the first fraction of a second after the Big Bang; along with the monopole problem and the horizon problem, the flatness problem is one of the three primary motivations for inflationary theory.

Some cosmologists agreed with Dicke that the flatness problem was a serious one, in need of a fundamental reason for the closeness of the density to criticality. But there was also a school of thought which denied that there was a problem to solve, arguing instead that since the universe must have some density it may as well have one close to \rho_{crit} as far from it, and that speculating on a reason for any particular value was "beyond the domain of science".
(Wikipedia).

Fine-tuned to very 'special' values, "beyond the domain of science" -deja vu, udah sering ketemu kalimat seperti.

> Matter density was assumed to be key to geometry.

Matter density was assumed to be key to geometry – and estimates of the matter density of our universe came to around 0.2 atoms per cubic metre, while the relevant part of the Friedmann equations calculated that the critical density required to keep our universe flat would be 5 atoms per cubic metre. Since we could only find 4% of the required critical density, this suggested that we probably lived in an open universe – but then we started coming up with ways to measure the universe’s geometry directly.
 
This is done with cosmic microwave background data (from WMAP and earlier experiments) – where the CMB mapped on the sky represents one side of a triangle with you at its opposite apex looking out along its two other sides. The angles of the triangle can then be measured, which will add up to 180 degrees in a flat (Euclidean) universe, more than 180 in a closed universe and less than 180 in an open universe.
These findings, indicating that the universe was remarkably flat, came at the turn of the century around the same time that the 1998 accelerated expansion finding was announced.

So really, it is the universe’s flatness and the estimate that there is only 4% (0.2 atoms per metre) of the matter density required to keep it flat that drives us to call on dark stuff to explain the universe. Indeed we can’t easily call on just matter, light or dark, to account for how our universe sustains its critical density in the face of expansion, let alone accelerated expansion – since whatever it is appears out of nowhere. So, we appeal to dark energy to make up the deficit – without having a clue what it is.
(Universe Today).

Energy density and the Friedmann equation.
According to Einstein's field equations of general relativity, the structure of spacetime is affected by the presence of matter and energy. On small scales space appears flat – as does the surface of the Earth if one looks at a small area. On large scales however, space is bent by the gravitational effect of matter. Since relativity indicates that matter and energy are equivalent, this effect is also produced by the presence of energy (such as light and other electromagnetic radiation) in addition to matter. The amount of bending (or curvature) of the universe depends on the density of matter/energy present.
This relationship can be expressed by the first Friedmann equation.
(Wikipedia).

> The universe will evolve away from flatness. Open-closed  transition = open - flat - closed. Flat -> closed = menggulung ?.

Q : Does it also imply that if the universe is flat the density parameter is and always has been exactly one? Or is a open-flat transition not considered a topology change?
A : I see -- now I think I understand what you're getting at.

First off, keep in mind that spatial curvature is not the same thing as spacetime curvature. When we say that the universe is flat, we mean that its spatial curvature is zero, but its spacetime curvature is not.
Exact flatness requires that a physical parameter take on an exact value. In general, we don't expect that the evolution of any physical system will result, with any finite probability, in any parameter's attaining an exact value and retaining that exact value for any finite time interval. So I think it makes more sense physically to talk about an open-closed transition. That would definitely be a topology change.

In general, the Friedmann equations predict that the universe will evolve away from flatness.
The fact that the universe evolves away from flatness in realistic cosmological models is consistent with the more general theorem saying that we can't have topology change in GR* (without exotic matter or CTCs). To get topology change, you would have to evolve *toward* flatness and then cross the line.
(Physics Forum).
* = general relativity.

> Q verse 'embedded' in initial conditions of the universe, 14 billion years ago ?.

The ‘problem’ is that for the Universe to be so close to critical density after ~ 14 billion years of expansion and evolution, it must have been even closer at earlier times. For instance, it requires the density at the Planck time (within 10-43 seconds of the Big Bang) to be within 1 part in 1057 of the critical density. i.e. Ω0 initially must have been almost exactly:

1.00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

There is no known reason for the density of the Universe to be so close to the critical density, and this appears to be an unacceptably strange coincidence in the view of most astronomers. Hence the flatness ‘problem’.

Dengan konteks 'there is no known reason for the density of the Universe to be so close to the critical density, and this appears to be an unacceptably strange coincidence in the view of most astronomers' makna deretan angka di bawah jadi gamblang ;

1.000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

-------------------------------->1 = (The Knower of all secrets and declarations,) be He

-> 60 nol di belakang dot = exalted, far above having a partner (23:92).


http://astronomy.swin.edu.au/cosmos/F/Flatness+Problem






1) deceleration acceleration.jpg
2) 3 scenarios.jpg
3) components of universe.jpg
4) cosmic tug of war.jpg
5) BB BR.jpg

Supriyono Soehirman

unread,
Jul 17, 2015, 8:33:07 PM7/17/15
to Milis foQus
May Allah Blesses you. This is a very intelligence prophetic analysis and discussion. The ultimate result of the 10 (60) is just like a binary code. Is that telling us to be back to the Allah, The Almighty ? A teaching of an Iqra' towards the "Tafakur" of the Universe may also tell us that Allah, the Greatest Creator, has blessed us with our greatness and therefore we must surrender with gratitude towards Allah and a part of our gratitude action is learning, teaching, and elaborating as well as making this small world peace. Happy Idhul Fitri. Mohon Maaf Lahir dan Batin.

Supriyono
Vice Chancellor of Academic and Information Affairs, Balitar Islamic University
Entrepreneurial Program Development team, Balitar Islamic University
Founder and Trainer, G*GOLD Indonesia Training Centre: Leadership, Management, and Character Education
Address: Perum GKR BLOK S-1A Blitar, East Java, Indonesia
Phone: 08125279441/0342816141


--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Forum Quranic Study" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to forum-quranic-s...@googlegroups.com.
To post to this group, send email to forum-qur...@googlegroups.com.
Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/forum-quranic-study.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Rusdian Lubis

unread,
Jul 18, 2015, 12:56:54 AM7/18/15
to forum-qur...@googlegroups.com
Taqqobbalahu minna waminkum, kami sekeluarga mengucapkan Ied Mubarrak 1436H mohon maaf lahir bathin kepada Bapak/Ibu sekeluarga. Rusdian 

Sent from my iPhone

Sugeng Widodo

unread,
Jul 22, 2015, 12:52:13 PM7/22/15
to forum-qur...@googlegroups.com
We should call this the century discovery. This was forwarded to me by a colleague (an American, not a Muslim, surely a very good man) this morning, Terimakasih.



Bbrp highlights :

Fragments of a Koran manuscript found in a British university library are from one of the world's oldest surviving copies of the Islamic text, and may even have been written by someone who knew Prophet Mohammad, researchers said on Wednesday.

Radiocarbon dating indicated that the parchment folios held by the University of Birmingham in central England were at least 1,370 years old, which would make them one of the earliest written forms of the Islamic holy book in existence.

"The parts of the Koran that are contained in those fragments are very similar indeed to the Koran as we have it today," Thomas said. "So this tends to support the view that the Koran that we now have is more or less very close indeed to the Koran as it was brought together in the early years of Islam."

 

Researchers said the manuscript consisted of two parchment leaves and contained parts of Suras (chapters) 18 to 20, and was written with ink in an early form of Arabic script known as Hijazi.

The university said for years it had been misbound with leaves of a similar Koran manuscript which dated from the late seventh century.

Semoga bermanfaat, dan anggaplah sebagai tambahan knowledge bila telah ada yang diskusikan ini sebelumnya. Marilah terus menyumbangkan Quran DENGAN TERJEMAHAN bahasa Indonesia ke Mushola, surau di desa desa yang semoga akan mengurangi kesalahpahaman dalam interpretasi ajaran Islam.

Best Rgrds,

SW


Ele/Adley

unread,
Jul 22, 2015, 1:15:39 PM7/22/15
to Milis foQus

Supriyono Soehirman

unread,
Jul 22, 2015, 7:20:19 PM7/22/15
to Milis foQus
Thank Mas Sugeng for the "newly information". This really strengthens my exploration on the Qur'an for my educational purposes. I have created a training the so-called G*GOLD Way in which I combined the theories, practices, and motivational factors of various fields such as the one I will work for 400 students of Faculty of Syari'ah Economics in Madura. I am using the method of foQus to internalize the ayahs of Qur'an in all my trainings including Parenting, Education, Creative Economy (just finished with 1000 participants in Blitar), Leadership, and Entrepreneurship. So I appreciate of being acknowledged with foQus----Thanks Pak Gatut and team, I am also blessed of having multisector duties in Freeport including being one of the initiators and developers of QMS with Gerry Silver, Alison H, Redwin Sitindjak, Srianto Sukowati and many more people have been inspired me (including those who "misunderstood me"). Allah, the Almighty, has shown His greatness as His revalation of  the Al Hujarat:13. Happy Idhul Fitri.

Supriyono
Vice Chancellor of Academic and Information Affairs, Balitar Islamic University
Entrepreneurial Program Development team, Balitar Islamic University
Founder and Trainer, G*GOLD Indonesia Training Centre: Leadership, Management, and Character Education
Address: Perum GKR BLOK S-1A Blitar, East Java, Indonesia
Phone: 08125279441/0342816141


Daniel Sabirin

unread,
Jul 22, 2015, 10:54:37 PM7/22/15
to Forum Study
Pak Supriyono dan pak Sugeng sepertinya tidak/belum ikut di forum WA foQus-GAS yang lebih 'fast-moving'.
Pak Rusdian setahu saya tergabung.

Jika tertarik berpartisipsi bisa di-invite oleh pak Gatut.

salam,
/ds

Supriyono Soehirman

unread,
Jul 22, 2015, 11:11:18 PM7/22/15
to Milis foQus
Baik terima kasih. Diperdilakan dengan senang hati Pak Daniel.


Salam

Supriyono
Vice Chancellor of Academic and Information Affairs, Balitar Islamic University
Entrepreneurial Program Development team, Balitar Islamic University
Founder and Trainer, G*GOLD Indonesia Training Centre: Leadership, Management, and Character Education
Address: Perum GKR BLOK S-1A Blitar, East Java, Indonesia
Phone: 08125279441/0342816141


Supriyono Soehirman

unread,
Aug 4, 2015, 6:06:21 AM8/4/15
to Milis foQus
Today in the era of participative democracy we experience economic and political instability what I called. How does Islam view Democracy? What is your opinion on this speech?


Thank you

Supriyono
Vice Chancellor of Academic and Information Affairs, Balitar Islamic University
Entrepreneurial Program Development team, Balitar Islamic University
Founder and Trainer, G*GOLD Indonesia Training Centre: Leadership, Management, and Character Education
Address: Perum GKR BLOK S-1A Blitar, East Java, Indonesia
Phone: 08125279441/0342816141


On Fri, Jul 17, 2015 at 10:37 PM, Daniel Sabirin <dan...@gmail.com> wrote:

Danuri Junior

unread,
Aug 16, 2015, 6:34:29 AM8/16/15
to Forum Quranic Study
Salamun 'alaikum

Menurut Quran 42/38, sistem pemerintahan yang sesuai Islam adalah demokrasi yang berdasarkan musyawarah (sesuai sila 4 Pancasila) bukan demokrasi berdasarkan jumlah suara terbanyak. Musyawarah dilakukan oleh para pemimpin atau ulama yang memahami prinsip-prinsip dasar hukum Allah dalam Quran dan memutuskan secara adil 5/ 42-44:6/144.
Antar pihak (partai) bersaing secara adil dan memikirkan kepentingan bersama. Tidak saling menjegal dan berkoalisi hanya untuk kepentingan individu atau kelompok 58/ 8-9.
Pemimpin yang sudah dipilih secara musyawarah harus dipatuhi sepanjang tetap berpegang pada Kitabullah yang disampaikan melalui rasul Muhammad alaihi salam, 4/59.

Supriyono Soehirman

unread,
Aug 18, 2015, 5:00:18 AM8/18/15
to Milis foQus
Waalaikumussalam,
Saya memiliki pandangan yang sama bro,

Wassalam

Supriyono
Vice Chancellor of Academic and Information Affairs, Balitar Islamic University
Entrepreneurial Program Development team, Balitar Islamic University
Founder and Trainer, G*GOLD Indonesia Training Centre: Leadership, Management, and Character Education
Address: Perum GKR BLOK S-1A Blitar, East Java, Indonesia
Phone: 08125279441/0342816141


Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages