Kumon Answer Book G Math
Stayce Cawthorn
While he is learning lots of things (currently learning how to add i.e., 1+4=?, 2+4=? etc) I am concerned about the utility of this approach to teach math. For example, he already knows that 4+2=6 but when he sees 2+4=? he needs to again start counting to figure out the answer. I know that he is still too young to perhaps appreciate that 2+4 and 4+2 give the same answer.
But, the above example suggests that Kumon's method of teaching math may not necessarily enhance his understanding of math. He may come to view math as a bunch of rules to follow- an outcome which would be a complete disaster. So, given the above background my questions are:
I have had no personal dealings with Kumon. I have some friends who had their children in it for a while, and I know several people who did it as children, and I know one person who taught at a Kumon center for a while. They varied in their opinions of it.
My understanding of the Kumon method is that it focuses overwhelmingly on computation, and that the method's strongest proponents are unapologetic about this. I do not mean to suggest that they should be apologetic--- I just mean, they are entirely aware of this focus and they do not see it as a liability. Frankly it would surprise me to hear someone suggesting the Kumon system as a way of promoting any kind of generalized "understanding" of math. Whenever I have heard people talk about the Kumon method, it is promoted as, in decreasing order of frequency,
I have never heard of anyone using Kumon to directly promote "conceptual understanding" of mathematics, and if that is what you want to invest in, my personal opinion is that Kumon is not the way to go. (I don't really know what would work at that age, beyond giving your son access to puzzles, books, and people who are enthusiastic about mathematics.)
I would not evaluate any method of instruction of 5 year old children by the speed with which it acquaints students with the fact that order does not matter in addition. Many concepts like this--- concepts that generalize or abstract large numbers of individual facts, each of which can be verified through a computation--- take a long time for people to internalize. (For one thing, the language one really needs to express general relations like this is the language of algebra, and it is not taught until much later.) I do not mean to say that students at age 5 cannot grasp that order doesn't matter, only that it takes a long time for this to really "sink in". People forget about things like that, and needlessly duplicate calculations, even at the university level.
I no longer teach math, but when I did, I found that the longer I taught it, the less sympathetic I was to the idea that it is harmful for students to see math as a bunch of rules to follow. It is harmful for them to see math that way if (i) they are never given a coherent set of rules, or (ii) they aren't competently taught about how to use the rules, or (iii) they never personally practice what it means to follow symbolic rules, or (iv) they never develop any idea of where the rules came from. Your own example (that $x + y = y + x$ for any two integers $x$ and $y$) is itself a rule, and as you argued in your own question, it is immensely helpful to be able to recognize instances of this rule. From this point of view, your objection to Kumon (in that instance) is only that they haven't gotten to that rule yet.
Having said that, I don't know don't know how well the Kumon method really rates by the standards (i), (ii), (iii), (iv) just listed. My guess is that Kumon makes very little attempt at addressing the last point, and this is a legitimate source of concern, if you expect Kumon to fill that role. The person I knew who taught at a Kumon center said they were extremely restricted in what they were supposed to teach--- she didn't go so far as to say there was a script, like telemarketers have, but almost sounded like that. I think this would preclude any meaningful discussion of the "real meaning" of a lot of calculation. At the same time, I do not think your son will be getting that in his regular math classroom either. It is extremely difficult to teach basic mathematics "conceptually" and most elementary teachers are not competently trained to do it.
A few years ago when I was in high school I worked part - time for the Kumon Learning Center as a teaching assistant. Generally my experiences with Kumon is that the learning is generally rote and done through the weekly worksheets assigned. Admittedly, some of the worksheets are quite cleverly designed, the material is not of a theoretical nature. Although personally I feel that this would not affect children too much at the younger grades, where I don't really see a better alternative to learning simple arithmetic other than simple repetition, the theoretical understanding when it comes to upper mathematics like algebra or calculus can be a little lacking (although in Kumon's defense, some of the kids get really good, simply from the sheer amount of practice they've had).
I feel that if you have the time and energy to simply sit down with your son and teach him yourself, then Kumon is not needed. In reality, most of the money you pay are for the worksheets you get. If you do not have the time and energy and you want your son to have a solid grounding in arithmetic then Kumon wouldn't hurt, although I would recommend an alternative when he gets into algebra based maths.
Interactive SAts practice papers, nonhomogeneous equations second order, cost accounting basics free, matlab simultaneous equations, Printable Ged Practice Tests with Answers "printable tests" GED OR Printable Ged Practice Tests with Answers "printable tests" free, standard trigonomic formulas,algebra expressions calculator.
Jacobs elementary algebra sample, how to find the third root on ti-84 plus calculator, scientific calculator emulator free ti-83, fourth gradeMean, median and mode, star test sample 6th grade math, slope worksheets,yr 9 Maths sats papers 6-8 print.
How to find radius and degree in aljebra, simply radicals calculator, factoring equation calculator, trig refresher for compass test, how to convert time to decimal java, how to find ratio in formulas,TI factoring.
Probability and algebra practice questions for the sixth grade, explanation of conic basic, step by step permutations and combinations, free cost accounting ebooks, ti-89 polynomial factoring, TI 38 Plus,multiplying integers worksheet.
ALGEBRA HELP SHEET, matlab second order ode, free online TI-84 plus calculator, multiply and divide rational expressions and functions, first grade fractions, who invented permutations in math,"Algebra 1. Volume" john hall.
Polynomial root calculator, graphing quadratic functions games, laplace for ti89, easy answers algebra 2, "Printable Maths SATS", free enter problem to graph parabola and get answer,how to solve equations involving rational expressions.
Solve difference quotient, algebra factors, diamond problem solver, calculate on line 5 unknowns, find the greatest common factor of a equetion,how to find the least common denominator with exponents.
How to graph polynomials on ti-83, integration formula sheet, cell potential and chemical equation, division of polynomials with multiple variables calculator, Math worksheet printouts, maths area-ks2,Dolciani math.
How to calculate log using calculator, Saxton Math Course 2 Lesson 92 answers, glencoe mathematics algebra 1, quardratic equation tutorial, differential equations matlab non linear solve,simplify quadratic + solver.
Conceptual physics third edition answers, algebra powers, general english grammer online book download, algebra tutor software, college algebra videos for children free software, factoring a third order polynomial,powerpoint presentation on composite materials.
3rd grade math taks practice work sheet, 6th grad math star test, factoring with cubed, ti-89 cheat sheet, www.mcq on topic relations and functions in maths, algebra 2 explorations and applications answers,www.Larsons Intermediate Math.com.
Conjegate variable caculator, square root problems and answers, basic statistics and maths test mcq, 5th grade iowa practice math, free math worksheets grade 6 pdf prentice hall, ti-89 graph negative,graphing a line using slope intercept form/ math cheats.
Algebra activities roots and radicals, orgage calculater, "nonlinear equations in civil engineering", algebra equations test, second order ODE on matlab, online texas graphing calculators,how to solve simultaneous equations in excel.
Ti 82 stats rom download, multiply radical expressions, factoring trinomials cubes, add, subtract, multiply, and divide negative numbers games, math conversin,PPT finding area with quadratic functions.
Mutiplying and dividing integers, formulas and substitution in sixth grade math, math test/printable, free Aptitude question papers, free printable worksheets for 9th grade, texas ti-83 plus key explanation,english advanced grammer e books free.
Pre-algebra star testing tips, step by step instructions on how work work exponents to rational exponents, free online solver for rationalizing denominators, free online math classes, how to write an equation for a function, calculating log on TI calculator,online yr 8 maths tests.
Convert mixed fraction to decimal, C# math solution of differential equation, Free Calculaters, intermediate algebra study questions, binomial solver online, free books on o-levels biology for download,third order qudratic formula.
Solve by substitution calculator, decimals numbers to expanded form, Download Algebrator, putting formulas into ti89, step by step on how to do college algebra, ti 84 emulator download,mathimatical transformation.
Printable homework sheets, boolean algebra pop quiz, evaluate the grade of your slope, differential+minimum of parabola, tutoring on square root problems, printouts of school worksheets,pre algebra with pizzazz answer.
Factoring complex trinomials were c is negative, aptitude question with answer, free radical problem solver, domains of hyperbola, largest common denominator, partial fraction binomial expansion,grade 10 Algebra equations.
4a15465005