Knoppix Startup Ogg Sound Downloads
Josephine Heathershaw
I got a cool sound from linux defender or knoppix (or something else, I dont remember which one) that says "initiating start up sequence" And I want to use it as early as I can in the boot process. Having it say that when I login wouldnt make much sense, so having it play when GRUB starts would be best. Can it be done?
Ubuntu is another live linux distribution, with a similar aim to Knoppix in that everything runs from the CD and nothing needs tobe installed on the hard drive. It's also based on debian, but comes as default with theGnome desktop environment (rather than KDE as Knoppix does) so this is a chance to see some different applications, different stylesand a different feel. Interestingly Ubuntu is also available as a full installable system, so if you decide you like it after seeingthe live version, you should have a smooth path towards a full install.
The version under investigation here is 5.10 (October 2005), codenamed "Breezy Badger". Don't ask me why, it just is - the previous version(5.04) was called "Hoary Hedgehog" and I've still no idea what "hoary" means. Debian has their Toy Story characters, Ubuntu hasalliterative animals.
Note: Since this review was written, a newer version of Ubuntu has been released. Codenamed "Dapper Drake" with the version number6.06 (meaning June 2006), I haven't tried it yet so I can't make any comparisons, although Xubuntu 6.06 has beenreviewed here. If you're interested in the Gnome version, see theRelease notes for 6.06.
As for Knoppix, getting a live CD of Ubuntu is as easy as downloading, checking, burning, booting. The download I did from the Ubuntuhome page (ubuntulinux.org) by following the signs to download the live i386 iso via BitTorrent.(Note the text for ubuntu-5.10-live-i386.iso.torrent says 'standard download' but it's really BitTorrent). This lets theBitTorrent client go to work downloading the big (627MB) iso file. I also downloaded the file MD5SUMS so I could check theiso before burning.
The BitTorrent download took several hours, but it could be easily paused and resumed as convenient. Once it was finished I checkedthe Md5 checksum with the java Md5 utility (see the downloads section) and made sure it was ok,then burnt to CD-R with K3B. As always with iso images, make sure you select to burn as an image, not just burn the file. With K3Bit's in the Tools menu under CD -> Burn CD image.
Brown is the new black. The standard theme with Ubuntu follows a very stylish brown and orange colour scheme which makes a refreshingchange. The icons are crisp, the text clear and sharp, and the feel is good.
So what do we have after a successful boot? Interesting to see the differences between Gnome here and the KDE of Knoppix and Mandriva.Instead of a combination taskbar at the bottom of the screen, Ubuntu here comes by default with a split design, with the open applicationslisted in the slim task bar at the bottom of the screen, and the menu, quick-start icons and clock across the top. Obviously this is allconfigurable, but note the simplicity of the main program menu compared to the KDE ones - it's only 2 levels deep and has much feweritems in it. This makes it much clearer and less confusing.
And what about the applications? This screengrab shows a small selection of the included programs, including the Firefox browser(bottom left, reading the included Ubuntu docs), a console (bottom right, listing a directory), an image viewer (middle right), thefile manager (called Nautilus, top right) and one of the included games called Gnome stones (top left). The main menu is open to showsome of the other internet applications available (and remember, these are all included on the single live CD). The screenshot was madewith gnome-snapshot.
There are plenty of other programs too, for example Gimp 2.2, and the whole OpenOffice 2.0 suite (Calc, Writer, and the rest).Plus sound and movie players, photo management tools and a host of accessories.
First of all, it looks good, and is a good advert for Gnome style. The icons, the colours, the text, the menus, it's all slick and neat.Interestingly Ubuntu gives by default a 1280x1024 screen on this laptop, whereas Knoppix goes down to a 1024x768 unless explicitly givena boot-time screen=1280x1024 parameter.Ubuntu's look becomes especially apparent after running the 855resolution patch (as required for Knoppix and Mandriva) to gain the native1400x1050 resolution of the laptop screen. This makes everything a lot clearer and sharper.
Another good thing, Ubuntu was able to recognise immediately my USB drive as soon as I plugged it in, and made it available not onlyin the file manager (aka Nautilus) but also from the "Places" menu on the menu bar. It also recognised my camera when it was plugged intothe USB port, and popped up the option to launch the photo manager - in this case called gThumb.
There are of course many applications included on the CD, all of which work and are easy to find from the simplified menus. It evencomes with java, using a free version of the Gnu gcj toolset. Just acouple of oddities, the "Start" key on the keyboard doesn't appear to work, and the trackpad, although it allows tapping (which I hate),doesn't allow vertical scrolling (which I find useful). Handily the "Prnt Scrn" key launches the screen capture utility, gnome-snapshot,which has a large range of options for capturing screen output.
One real problem with this Ubuntu distribution is its speed. It's obvious that any live CD will be much slower than a fully-installedoperating system, because each program has to be loaded in from the CD (including spin-up time), and then decompressed before it can beexecuted. But even comparing this Ubuntu with Knoppix 3.7, which also has to do this, this Breezy Badger is huffing and puffing its wayaround, rather than flying like the wind. It's slooooooooow, perhaps taking 50% longer than Knoppix to start programs and takinga whopping 4 minutes 50 seconds just to boot. Trying to be fair, maybe the Gnome makes a difference, rather than KDE, or maybe the updatedversions of the programs are larger and more intensive than they were for Knoppix 3.7, but whatever it is, it's really noticeable.
Just to give you some impressions, here are a few timings made on this laptop, comparing Knoppix 3.7 with Ubuntu 5.10starting from a cold boot and with mains power. Boot times didn't depend on whether the network cable was plugged in or not.
Knoppix is slow, but you expect that from a live CD and forgive this weakness. But Ubuntu is slower than slow, and especially on alower-RAM machine positively embarrassing. And it doesn't shut down, which is not a little disturbing. Hard resets make me wince.
Another gripe is that (unlike with Knoppix), the hard drives on this laptop aren't automatically recognised at startup. So instead ofjust clicking on the friendly desktop icon to mount and explore the hard drive partitions, you're left to try to manually mount themfrom the console. This is made even more challenging by the fact that only a root user can mount drives, and in Ubuntu there is no root user!So instead you need to use the sudo command to execute root-only operations. I found this confusing because in both Knoppixand Mandriva you enter root mode with the su command (with password if necessary) and then just enter whatever commands you want until you type exit to leave superuser mode. With sudo you need to prefix each command with sudo,which can get tiresome. So for example if you know that you want to mount drive hda3 you would have to open a console (foundin the programs menu under Accessories - Terminal) and enter:
but it took a bit of searching before I figured this out. Not very user-friendly considering that anyone trying out this live CD willalmost certainly want to access their files with it, and this console sudo hurdle is awkward.
Next gripe was network connectivity, in that it didn't work out of the box. For some reason my ethernet connection wasn't automaticallyconfigured (as it was by Knoppix) and I had to figure out how to switch it on before Firefox could access anything. To do this I needed togo into the System - Administration - Network Settings menu item, and examine the properties of my ethernet connection. From there I couldclick the 'enable' checkbox, select DHCP from the dropdown, OK that and then 'activate' this connection, at which point the network wasavailable. Again, this isn't terribly tricky to figure out, but it's so basic that it shouldn't require any figuring out beforeit just works.
Other, less important gripes include the lack of mp3-playing ability (or at least none that I could get to work), distorted wav-playingability, and a non-functioning battery meter (the task bar icon always says battery, even when the laptop is running on mains power, andalways says 0% irrespective of the actual charge).
I made some attempts to address the speed problem, and investigate whether it was fixable. The first suggestion was that the processormight be churning, with processor power being sucked up by some rogue process. This was not the case, as the sysem monitor shows a verylow processor load, and the command top from the terminal also shows nothing special going on except idling. Of course, whenloading an application then the processor hits 100% and the CD drive also spins up.
Next question - maybe the processor is clocked down to a low frequency? By looking at the file /etc/cpuinfo it shows aspeed of 600 MHz (instead of 1600 MHz), but after the experiments with CPU frequency I don'ttrust that file at all. And Ubuntu has shown similar (poor) performance on two separate desktops as well, which don't have variable-frequencyCPUs.
Now, maybe the CD drive is running sub-optimally? I did find the command hdparm which showed me that the CD was runningwith DMA (Direct Memory Access) disabled. I was able to set this to enabled with the command sudo hdparm -d1 /dev/hdc, butthis had negligible, if any, effect on the load times for Calc or Gimp. Unfortunately this setting is reset at boot, so I was unable totest the effect on boot times.
7fc3f7cf58