Festivids Nominations Questions Post #3

[fest...@gmail.com]

Source: festivids

Thanks everyone for getting your nominations in! We have a 20% increase in total nominations over last year, so expect more questions posts like this (and don't worry if your nominations show up as unreviewed).

We have questions about:

Eternal Law: Are you looking for the British TV series or Chinese TV series?

Justified: There are many thing called Justified. Which one are you looking for?

Sleep No More - Punchdrunk: Are you looking for a specific run or performance, or for an Umbrella fandom of all performances?

Humans (TV): There are 4 TV series called "Humans." Which one are you looking for?

Soldier (1998): There are 2 1998 movies called Soldier. Which one are you looking for?

My Little Pony Generation 1 (Cartoon 1984): We've previously called this My Little Pony (Cartoon 1984-1987). Nominator, is that what you're looking for? Or did you mean just the first 22 minute 1984 cartoon?

Matthew Cremona - Home Renovation & Addition (YouTube Playlist) and Matthew Cremona (YouTube Channel): This was nominated two different and overlapping ways. If the playlist stands on its own as a fandom and is sufficiently distinct from other playlists, we might then call the youtube channel an Umbrella. If it doesn't stand on its own we would call the youtube channel the fandom, and a request for a specific playlist would go in option details. Which of these options makes sense to you, nominators?

We also have some Umbrella questions:

Hamlet - Adaptations [UMBRELLA]: We haven't searched yet, but given Disney fandom this is almost definitely disqualified by The Lion King. Nominator, if you want to reframe this it would probably work as Performances?

Penn and Teller Magic Performances [UMBRELLA]: Are you looking for their independent magic performances under their own names, that generally start with "Penn and Teller" in the title? Or for all performances of magic they've done, including as actors in e.g. Young Sheldon and Borderlands 3? If the first, can we come up with a phrase that encapsulates that? If the second, Borderlands 3 might disqualify it.

Half-Life mods [UMBRELLA]: Could you explain what you're looking for? People making the mods? The mods being used in-game? Something else?

And these questions are still outstanding from previous posts:

R is for Rocket - Ray Bradbury: Are you looking for the short story by itself? Or for the collection of short stories that has the same name?

Akame ga Kill! (Anime & Manga): Do you want the anime or manga? Or is there a compelling reason to say both are typically vidded together?

Fate/Grand Order: Which part of this franchise are you looking for? Or should this be an Umbrella fandom?

Rosencrantz & Guildenstern are Dead - Stoppard: Are you looking for a specific performance, or all performances?

悪魔のリドル | Akuma no Riddle | Riddle Story of Devil: The anime is on the pre-disqualification list. Is the nominator looking for the manga?