Family Gem App

8 views
Skip to first unread message

Tim

unread,
Jan 25, 2021, 12:52:30 PMJan 25
to famil...@googlegroups.com
Hello,

this app is quite useful, thank you.

However I found a risky privacy issue. If I click on a tree to share it, it is immediately uploaded to the website. I could not find an option before, that I agree to share this personal data with you website. I assumed that the share button is only an export function, where an file is created internally on my phone (image, export file, text,...). It would be much better, if you make a menu point "upload your file" and before that please consider using a pop up window that all the information is shared online. The user has to confirm it every time.

How is it with deleting a shared tree on your website?

The current solution is not GDPR friendly.

I guess because your app is FOSS and on fDroid primarily privacy oriented people are using your app. This makes it quite hard for them to use it.

Kind regards

--
-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
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=HS4g
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

Michele Salvador

unread,
Jan 29, 2021, 3:55:39 PMJan 29
to Family Gem
Hi Tim,
thank you for reporting this.
I'm working to fix the privacy issue of Family Gem.

Just done:
Coming soon:
In the next release of Family Gem:
  • When the user accesses the Share page of the app, a popup explains that the tree will be uploaded to a server to be available for download etc.
    and they has to click "I agree".
There is an open issue about that on GitHub.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages