Fwd: EGV: Reply To Mr. Rathin Sur

22 views
Skip to first unread message

Rathin Sur

unread,
Jan 17, 2013, 10:18:48 AM1/17/13
to elitavist...@googlegroups.com


---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Rathin Sur <rathi...@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, Jan 17, 2013 at 8:47 PM
Subject: Fwd: EGV: Reply To Mr. Rathin Sur
To: SUDIP NAG <su...@powergridindia.com>, Chandan Ghosh <chand...@gmail.com>, ayan...@yahoo.co.in, surya bhaduri <suryab...@rediffmail.com>, Ambujakshya ghosh <ambuj...@gmail.com>, Soham Bhattacharya <sami...@rediffmail.com>, debashish dutta <debashish...@gmail.com>, PRONNOY DATTA <gda...@acslindia.net>
Cc: sanjit...@yahoo.com, sth...@yahoo.com, Satyaki Bhattacharya <satya...@gmail.com>, "heman...@gmail.com\", \"chatterje...@gmail.com\" <chatterje...@gmail.com>, \"biplab...@gmail.com\" <biplab...@gmail.com>, \"dutta.n...@gmail.com\" <dutta.n...@gmail.com>, \"amit...@yahoo.com\"" <amit...@yahoo.com>, dipanker...@gmail.com, litavist...@googlegroups.com, kunal....@gmail.com


I had a long discussiuon with Mr X of keppel. I told him that they do not have guts to acknoledge the record of discussions with just 10 of their customers & not the Association of owners &
How can we be more reasonable on the SBA than what we have been,
&
The strict wording in clause says that compensation is payable from 31st Dec 11 & not from the dt thay get power. Bad drafting, if any, as the agreement now stands is due to Fox&M who has made some customers pay on SBA basis & some on Built up (bad drafting?)

There are now 2 possible responses that I havbe tjhought of 
1. Just reject their Question answer Respknsesx as spineless & ask their City head ADRIS to talk to us/me over phone/inperson. OR
2. point out 
The strict wording in clause says that compensation is payable from 31st Dec 11 & not from the dt thay get power. Bad drafting, if any, as the agreement now stands is due to Fox&M who has made some customers pay on SBA basis & some on Built up (bad drafting?)
Pl let me know your thoughts IMMEDIATELY (by phone if possible)  so that I can respond suitably today/tomarrrow itself considering time is not on our side (though I think we can prevent them from charging interest on the increase in SBA portion at least.
R. N. Sur


---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Sarvendra Vikram Singh <sarve...@elitahomes.com>
Date: Wed, Jan 16, 2013 at 9:54 PM
Subject: EGV: Reply To Mr. Rathin Sur
To: "rathi...@gmail.com" <rathi...@gmail.com>
Cc: "Adrian J. Smith" <adri...@elitahomes.com>, Abdussalam Molla <abduss...@elitahomes.com>, Archana Jain <arch...@elitahomes.com>


Dear Mr. Sur

 

We thank you for your visit on the 7 January 2013, wherein you and Mr. Ayan Banerjee met us to address certain issues. Please find the details given below:-

 

Query 1 Increase in SBA.

 

We have showed the calculation details for SBA signed by Architect Agrawal & Agrawal, drawings sanctioned by HIDCO in 2007 and present drawings. We have briefed you on the increase in SBA from sanctioned drawings to present drawings. The increase in SBA was primarily on account of following reasons.

1.      Sewage Treatment Plant (STP): There was no provision of sewage treatment plant in drawings sanctioned by HIDCO in 2007 as sewage was supposed to have been discharged to HIDCO sewer line. However, later on as per authority norms STP has been constructed to use recycled water for flushing and irrigation purpose. (Refer Attachment)

 

2.      Landscaped Podium

 

3.      Increase in area of Electrical substations(11KV)

 

4.      Increase in area of pump house and water treatment plant room.

 

We have clarified in details for an increase of 5.7% SBA against each unit due to the reasons mentioned above. (Refer Attachment for Common areas calculation)

 

 

Query 2: Compensation for delayed handover

 

As per Clause 17 (iii) of the S  & P Agreement, KMDPL is not liable for delay if it is for the reason of non- availability of electric supply. Hence, compensation for delay in handover will be paid to you on and from the date of power supply to the project (i.e. 17th October 2012) till your Scheduled Payment Date.

 

Query 3: Circulation of deed of Conveyance

 

We agreed to share Draft Copy of Deed of Conveyance to you and Mr. Banerjee

 

Query 4: Relaxation of Final payment dates for residents outside Calcutta

 

As per the Letter of Handover served to you and Mr. Banerjee, the scheduled payment date is within 15 days from the date of receipt of the same and within 30 days registration of the property should take place to get the possession of the unit. However, if you are unable to proceed as per the LOH due to any unavoidable circumstances, you are requested to inform us via email or letter citing the reasons for the delay. If it is found that the reasons cited by you are justified, we can consider the delay for some grace period as decided by us mutually. But, delay beyond the grace period would attract interest as mentioned in LOH.

 

Query 5: Proper records for common facilities being charged to each owner depending on his handover date

 

Reply: Individual account for maintenance funds usage will be created for each owner for usage of common facilities. Owners can approach the appointed Managing Agent, M/s Colliers International for a statement of their individual account.

 

Thanks & Regards

Team-Keppel Magus

 


CONFIDENTIALITY: This e-mail and any attachments are confidential and may also be privileged and protected by intellectual property rights. If you are not the named recipient, please notify the sender immediately and do not disclose the contents to another person, use it for any purpose, or store or copy the information in any medium.


"Save Paper - Think Before You Print!"



MOEF.PDF
COMPARISON.PDF

abhishek bandyopadhyay

unread,
Jan 18, 2013, 12:34:07 AM1/18/13
to Rathin Sur, elitavist...@googlegroups.com
Mr. Sur,

As spoken to you over phone just now I agree with the approach you are planning to take - rejecting their responses as well as pointing out that compensation should be payable starting 1st Jan 2012. Thank you for taking the initiative and pulling through with it. 


~ Abhishek


--
 
 

Rathin Sur

unread,
Jan 18, 2013, 10:29:07 AM1/18/13
to elitavist...@googlegroups.com
Dear All!

Since this is a strong letter Pl go through ( & make corrections by Strikethrough & insertions) before I  send this 2morow morning to Sarvender & co.

Sur
Response to Sarvenders Reply 2 Meeting of 7thJan13.doc

Rathin Sur

unread,
Jan 18, 2013, 10:30:59 AM1/18/13
to abhishek bandyopadhyay, Ambujakshya ghosh, Aniruddha Daw, Ayan Banerjee, biplab...@gmail.com, Subroto Chatterjee, elitavist...@googlegroups.com
Dear All!

Since this is a strong letter Pl go through ( & make corrections by Strikethrough & insertions) before I  send this 2morow morning to Sarvender & co.

Sur

Response to Sarvenders Reply 2 Meeting of 7thJan13.doc

Ayan Banerjee

unread,
Jan 18, 2013, 12:40:52 PM1/18/13
to Rathin Sur, elitavist...@googlegroups.com, abhishek bandyopadhyay, Subroto Chatterjee, Ambujakshya ghosh, Aniruddha Daw, biplab...@gmail.com
Hi Mr. Sur,

Please find attached a few proposed changes to your draft letter, with my opinions. (Letter_With_Suggestions.docx)
I have also compiled a letter after incorporation of the changes. (Proposed_New_Letter.docx)

Please have a look into this, and make changes as necessary. Lets discuss on this tomorrow at a suitable time.
 

Thanks and Regards,
Ayan Banerjee 
150, S.N. Chatterjee Road,
Kolkata - 700038.
Ph: 9836387370 



From: Rathin Sur <rathi...@gmail.com>
To: abhishek bandyopadhyay <abhis...@gmail.com>; Ambujakshya ghosh <ambuj...@gmail.com>; Aniruddha Daw <ani...@gmail.com>; Ayan Banerjee <ayan...@yahoo.co.in>; biplab...@gmail.com; Subroto Chatterjee <chatterje...@gmail.com>
Cc: elitavist...@googlegroups.com
Sent: Friday, 18 January 2013 9:00 PM
Subject: Re: EGV: Reply To Mr. Rathin Sur

--
 
 


Proposed_New_Letter.docx
Letter_With_Suggestions.docx

Rathin Sur

unread,
Jan 19, 2013, 12:16:27 AM1/19/13
to abhis...@gmail.com, sanjit...@yahoo.com, sth...@yahoo.com, elitavist...@googlegroups.com, Aniruddha Daw, Ayan Banerjee, chand...@gmail.com
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Rathin Sur <rathi...@gmail.com>
Date: Sat, 19 Jan 2013 10:37:57 +0530
Subject: Re: EGV: Reply To Mr. Rathin Sur
To: SUDIP NAG <su...@powergridindia.com>, Chandan Ghosh
<chand...@gmail.com>, ayan...@yahoo.co.in, surya bhaduri
<suryab...@rediffmail.com>, Ambujakshya ghosh
<ambuj...@gmail.com>, Soham Bhattacharya
<sami...@rediffmail.com>, debashish dutta
<debashish...@gmail.com>, PRONNOY DATTA <gda...@acslindia.net>,
sth...@yahoo.com, Satyaki Bhattacharya <satya...@gmail.com>,
"heman...@gmail.com" <heman...@gmail.com>, ",
On 1/19/13, Rathin Sur <rathi...@gmail.com> wrote:
> ---------- Forwarded message ----------
> From: Rathin Sur <rathi...@gmail.com>
> Date: Sat, 19 Jan 2013 10:32:39 +0530
> Subject: Re: EGV: Reply To Mr. Rathin Sur
> To: Sarvendra Vikram Singh <sarve...@elitahomes.com>
> Cc: "Adrian J. Smith" <adri...@elitahomes.com>, Abdussalam Molla
> <abduss...@elitahomes.com>, Archana Jain <arch...@elitahomes.com>
>
> Dear Mr Singh, Adrian & Mr Molla,
>
> Kindly find the attachment in response to your reply to our minuites
> of meeting on 7th Jan13.
>
> R. N. Sur
> 9476238114
Ayans Proposed_New_Letter.doc

Rohit Agarwala

unread,
Jan 19, 2013, 12:49:32 AM1/19/13
to Rathin Sur, abhis...@gmail.com, sanjit...@yahoo.com, sth...@yahoo.com, elitavist...@googlegroups.com, Aniruddha Daw, Ayan Banerjee, chand...@gmail.com
Fine go ahead please.

Thanks & Regards,

 

ROHIT AGARWALAAFP, LUTCF (IN)

+91 9830279990
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________



Farsight India Wealth Management

Farsight India Wealth Consultants Pvt. Ltd.

9, Crooked Lane, 1st Floor, Room # 8,

Kolkata - 700 069.  India.

tel: +91 33 22315755, 5757  (10:00 AM to 6:30 PM IST)
fax: +91 33 40702174

email: ro...@farsight.in

web: www.farsight.in

 

Disclaimer: The information contained in this communication is confidential and may be legally privileged. It is intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed and others authorised to receive it. If you are not the intended recipient you are hereby (a) notified that any disclosure, copying, distribution or taking any action with respect to the content of this information is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful, and (b) kindly requested to inform the sender immediately and destroy any copies. Farsight India Wealth Management is neither liable for the proper and complete transmission of the information contained in this communication nor for any delay in its receipt.

 

Please consider the environment and do not print this email unless absolutely necessary. Encourage environmental awareness



--



Rathin Sur

unread,
Jan 19, 2013, 9:06:39 AM1/19/13
to Rohit Agarwala, abhis...@gmail.com, sanjit...@yahoo.com, sth...@yahoo.com, elitavist...@googlegroups.com, Aniruddha Daw, Ayan Banerjee, chand...@gmail.com
Amit,

Surya bhaduri told me he has got the Draft DOC which he will send over on Monday.
I will be sending the mail (circulated today by me Ayan's letter) to Singapore on Monday & hope for the best.

Since i presently do not know of any lawyer myself I am unable to do anything on the lawyer front. I am trying to keep the pressure on Keppel & we have till now achieved only the followinG:
1. LOH first & then payment & not reverse.
2. DOC is coming
Lets keep the pressure on & I suggest that if you can draft a letter & at least tell the points to be mentioned to Singapore to whom I will send 
a. the draft minutes  (attachment circulated) &
b. Sarvenders response ( circulated) &
c. Ayan's letter (attachment circulated).
This will be more useful than discussing among ourselves.

R. N. Sur

--
 
 

Email Logo[3].png

Ayan Banerjee

unread,
Jan 20, 2013, 2:45:22 PM1/20/13
to elitavist...@googlegroups.com
FYI…

 
Ayan Banerjee 
150, S.N. Chatterjee Road,
Kolkata - 700038.
Ph: 9836387370 


Hi Mr. Sur,

As discussed on call last day, I have prepared this draft letter for sending to Keppel Singapore (along with the MOM and the mail chain till date), if MR. S. Singh does not respond to you or me by 12 noon Monday, 21st January 2013 - as was promised by him.

Please note, that in the draft that I am sending you, I have written that we are talking on behalf of 10 flat owners. Since, you are in contact with many of them, also I guess in the google group and the facebook group, we have more than 10 flat owners, please feel free to change the number, according to your discretion.

Do get back to me, if you need anything else.

Thanks and regards,
Ayan Banerjee 
150, S.N. Chatterjee Road,
Kolkata - 700038.
Ph: 9836387370 



Subject: Re: EGV: Reply To Mr. Rathin Sur

Dear Mr. Sur
Appreciate while sending these emails to all of Keppel mark all of us in loop also - if you feel you may copy us under BCC.
Gautam Datta
Sent on my BlackBerry® from Vodafone

From: Rathin Sur <rathi...@gmail.com>
Date: Sat, 19 Jan 2013 19:37:50 +0530
Subject: Re: EGV: Reply To Mr. Rathin Sur

Amit,

Surya bhaduri told me he has got the Draft DOC which he will send over on Monday.
I will be sending the mail (circulated today by me Ayan's letter) to Singapore on Monday & hope for the best.

Since i presently do not know of any lawyer myself I am unable to do anything on the lawyer front. I am trying to keep the pressure on Keppel & we have till now achieved only the followinG:
1. LOH first & then payment & not reverse.
2. DOC is coming
Lets keep the pressure on & I suggest that if you can draft a letter & at least tell the points to be mentioned to Singapore to whom I will send 
a. the draft minutes  (attachment circulated) &
b. Sarvenders response ( circulated) &
c. Ayan's letter (attachment circulated).
This will be more useful than discussing among ourselves.

R. N. Sur

Letter_For_Keppel_Singapore.docx

Ambujakshya ghosh

unread,
Jan 20, 2013, 11:37:25 PM1/20/13
to Ayan Banerjee, elitavist...@googlegroups.com
Ayan and all,

1 change I would suggest, don't mention 10 flat owners...."10" is very
small to the total number of flat owners..and they might think the
remaining owners (majority) are agreeing to keppel's demand...I would
suggest that to remove "10" and mention "flat owners"

thanks
Ambuj
> --
>
>
>


--
thanks and regards
Ambuj
+91-9831170430

Rathindra nath Sur

unread,
Apr 1, 2013, 11:01:50 AM4/1/13
to Rathindra nath Sur, sanje...@gmail.com, heman...@gmail.com, chatterje...@gmail.com, biplab...@gmail.com, dutta.n...@gmail.com, amit...@yahoo.com, dipankar...@gmail.com, sanjit...@yahoo.com, abhishek bandyopadhyay, sth...@yahoo.com, elitavist...@googlegroups.com, Aniruddha Daw, Ayan Banerjee, Chandan Ghosh, SUDIP NAG, surya bhaduri, Ambujakshya ghosh, Soham Bhattacharya, debashish dutta, PRONNOY DATTA, Satyaki Bhattacharya
To all for record of the Common Area calculation & MOEF Clearance to form part of EVG Owners association future records.

R. N. Sur

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Sarvendra Vikram Singh <sarve...@elitahomes.com>
Date: Wed, Jan 16, 2013 at 9:54 PM
Subject: EGV: Reply To Mr. Rathin Sur
To: "rathi...@gmail.com" <rathi...@gmail.com>
Cc: "Adrian J. Smith" <adri...@elitahomes.com>, Abdussalam Molla <abduss...@elitahomes.com>, Archana Jain <arch...@elitahomes.com>


MOEF.PDF
COMPARISON.PDF

Sanjeev Gupta

unread,
Jul 3, 2013, 8:20:26 AM7/3/13
to Rathindra nath Sur, heman...@gmail.com, chatterje...@gmail.com, biplab...@gmail.com, dutta.n...@gmail.com, amit...@yahoo.com, dipankar...@gmail.com, sanjit...@yahoo.com, abhishek bandyopadhyay, sth...@yahoo.com, elitavist...@googlegroups.com, Aniruddha Daw, Ayan Banerjee, Chandan Ghosh, SUDIP NAG, surya bhaduri, Ambujakshya ghosh, Soham Bhattacharya, debashish dutta, PRONNOY DATTA, Satyaki Bhattacharya
Hi friends,

There has been a lull on this for long time..

Any news.

Are any of you planning to move to the apartment soon..? Is the complex completely ready with amenities..?

Regards,

Sanjeev Gupta
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages