Facility Code Mismatch - 170.315(b)(1) SVAP USCDI v4 Inpatient Sample 1 - Validator expects 1160-1, PDF specifies 1027-2

[surb...@gmail.com]

Hi all,

I'm validating a C-CDA against the SVAP USCDI v4 test data for 170.315(b)(1) Transitions of Care, Inpatient setting, Sample 1 (170.315_b1_toc_inp_uscdiv4_sample1_v1.pdf).

The NIST/SITE C-CDA validator is throwing the following content validation error:

"The scenario contains Facility data with type 1160-1, however there is no matching data in the submitted CCDA"

However, the published Sample 1 PDF test data (Section D, Encounter Diagnoses) explicitly instructs the following for the Service Delivery Location on both encounter diagnosis rows (D63.1/ICD-10 and 234348004/SNOMED-CT):

Facility Type Code = 1027-2 ("Medical Critical Care")
CodeSystem = Healthcare Service Location Code System (2.16.840.1.113883.6.259)

I built my C-CDA to match the PDF instructions exactly (code 1027-2), but the validator is instead expecting code 1160-1 ("Urgent Care Center") in that same codeSystem, and is not finding it in my submission.

Could you please confirm:

1. Is this a known discrepancy between the published Sample 1 PDF and the validator's internal expected-data/scenario file for this criterion?
2. Should vendors use 1027-2 (per the PDF) or 1160-1 (per the validator), or does the validator accept either?
3. If this is a bug, is there a timeline for the validator's scenario file being updated to match the current SVAP USCDI v4 PDF?

Happy to share my submitted CCDA XML if that's helpful for troubleshooting.

Thank you!

[Prahbu Shankar]

To ensure we can review this accurately, could you please confirm or provide the following (if not already included):

•        The C-CDA validation scenario you are running (criteria and scenario file name, if applicable)

•        The specific issue you are encountering

•        The relevant C-CDA XML document or snippet (please do not include any PHI/PII)

•        The exact error or warning message(s) observed (screenshots if available)

 Thanks,

-Prabhu

[surb...@gmail.com]

Hello,

Requested details as follows:

• The C-CDA validation scenario you are running (criteria and scenario file name, if applicable)

• • USCDI v4 >> Sender >> 170.315_b1_ToC_Inp >> Sample 1 (170.315_b1_toc_inp_uscdiv4_sample1_v1.pdf

• The specific issue you are encountering

• • When validating the C-CDA XML against above mentioned Sample 1 Scenario file, NIST is throwing error "The scenario contains Facility data with type 1160-1, however there is no matching data in the submitted CCDA"

• The relevant C-CDA XML document or snippet (please do not include any PHI/PII)

• • This is the part I need help with. We are not sure where to add the 1160-1 code, since its not called out in XML

• The exact error or warning message(s) observed (screenshots if available)

• • "The scenario contains Facility data with type 1160-1, however there is no matching data in the submitted CCDA"

[surb...@gmail.com]

Hello,

Any update on this issue ? We tried both 1160-1 as well as 1027-2, however NIST is throwing error " Facility information for 1160-1 , for EncounterActivity data for code D63.1 : The scenario requires FacilityIdentifiers data, but submitted file does have FacilityIdentifiers data."
Attached is XML with 1160-1 code. Please assist -
(1) why NIST is throwing error for 1160-1 when the PDF " 170.315_b1_toc_inp_uscdiv4_sample1_v1.pdf" does not mention about 1160-1?
(2) What needs to be done to remove the error ?

Or if you have any sample XML that passes the NIST without this error, that we can reference !!

Regards

Surbhit

[surb...@gmail.com]

Hello Team,

Its been multiple days, and I haven't heard on it.. Can some one please analyze/acknowledge it? Or let me know if this needs to be routed differently.

Regards

Surbhit Jain