Hi Jerry - I’m on the road; just got to Tucson this evening & just now saw your email.
It’s complicated but I’d say no. The ‘87 easement agreement as I understand it had a strict definition of through the fence to mean access. If you didn’t go through the fence, then you wouldn’t be charged this use fee.
As I read this you will be charged $800/year according to this fee structure. Plane or not.
However, what the town is being presented I think, breaks all prior rules and understandings. It mandates that anyone with or without an aircraft must pay the “fee” if they have access as defined by the HOA neighborhood map; anyone with a grey access path to their property.
To me this is simply taxation. It’s like charging a homeowner next to a golf course an annual membership fee even if they don’t golf.
I also see a very inequitable situation between homeowners and the commercial side on the airport.
I don’t see anything that addresses the East West runway. It will not open. However, the homeowners on the east west runway still have access.
Johan