RTI on Parking/ Tow away by Delhi Traffic Police to Dwarka Specific & Majority of the INFO DENIED by DCP WR Mr. S K Sinha
REJIMON C K
The self explnatory Reply by DCP Traffic WR.
My comments and Note for Appeal also enclosed.
It is evident that DTP does not have any real policy but create more funds for Crane Operators and Encourage more Illegal Parking so that more earning and NOT TO SOLUTION. All the efforts tried by various forums, rwa/mta to have proper parking in all markets and set good example in Dwarka a planned city is getting failed and DTP certainly have more role but not interested to play that role, REASON BEST KNOWN TO THEM.
INFO DENIAL by DCP Traffic point gross neglect towards RTI Act 2005.
Members please press Reply All so that your comments/inputs reaches to authorites to make corrective measure and mutually find a solution to this for Dwarka if not now then when?
- Please provide the certified copies of the contract by DTP with Crane Operator for Dwarka Area.
- As per contract what is the responsibility of the contractor for damaging the vehicle towed away cause loss to public.
- Please provide the procedure to claim the damage and loss on account of mishandling of vehicle by Crane No. DL-1L-K6833.
- As per contract what is the qualification of the person deployed in addition to Driver for the cranes.
Point No. 1 to 4: -It does not relate to this office.
(1 to 4 info NOT provided and Declined to transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO).
Appeal: The APIO is defaulted
- Please provide the details on Crane Vehicle No. DL-1L-K 6833 (operated on 30/9/2012) DTP Staff, Driver and Operator/Technical assistant etc Name, Age, ID Proof as per DTP records,
Constable Rakesh No. 1180/T was deployed on crane No. DL 1 LK 6833 on dated
30.09.2012 and the detail of crane driver & operator etc. may be had from concern.
Appeal: Info only partially provided. No information on Driver, Crane Operator detials were denied by DCP-T-WR.
- Please provide the appeal authority for the Towed Vehicles away from Dwarka Sub-City and related to grievances.
Answer: -It does not relate to this office.
Info Declined and failed transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO)
Appeal: The APIO is defaulted
- What is the % of the towing away charges paid to Contractor and what is the % DTP receives.
Answer: -It does not relate to this office.
Info Declined and failed transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO)
Appeal: The APIO is defaulted
- What is the definition of IMPROPER PARKING as per DTP understanding and Provide us the location in Dwarka Sector 6, 10, 4,5,11,12 market for PROPER PARKING.
Please refer to section 122 M.V. Act 1988. Location of parking may be had from land owing agencies.
Appeal: The reply from APIO is evident that DCP T-WR have NO RECORDS on where are the locations of proper parking in Dwarka. IF DTP have no records of Propeer parking places in Dwarka will public have? Use this as cover the Cranes operators and DTP staff are(as seen from these reply) free to harass the public at large and remove vehicle even if they are not ABANDONED or OBSTRUCTING other vehicles movements.
u/s 122 read Any person in-charge of a vehicle or a trailer abandoning or permitting to abandon, etc., in a public place (improper and obstructive parking)
Isn't it responsible act of DTP to put sign boards to state where is Proper Parking Lot while stating this are is not Parking/Halting area.
- Have DTP marked the locations of parking areas through visible sign boards in above markets, if so please provide the list of locations.
Answer: -It does not relate to this office.
Info Declined and failed transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO)
Appeal: The APIO is defaulted
- Please provide the list of location and No of Vehicles along with type towed away from Dwarka (Sector wise) for year 2012.
It is not possible to provide the requisite information as the record is voluminous and not maintained in computerized manner. Applicant may examine record during office hours.
Appeal: In a meeting Jt. CP Traffic had informed all the data on Penalty and others are computerised and MIS reports generated. DTP even disclosed once the vehicle is towed away the owner get information on the status by SMS, which is evident that the tow away vehicle info is COMPUTERISED(Does this means DTP mislead or DCP-T-WR mislead under RTI ?) .While the DCP T-WR denied stating it is VOLUMNOUS, which means the DTP and CRANE OPERATORS earns over CRORES from Dwarka on Towaway. What is the data 10,000 Vehicle per month or 1 Lakh Vehicle per month.
- Please provide the reason recorded in the files and exemption given to schools and institutional areas allowed to park vehicles on road obstructing movement or footpaths in Dwarka.
No exemptions are given to schools and institutional areas to park their vehicles unauthorized! improperly.
Appeal: The is CERTAINLY a MISLEADING info provoded by DTP-T-WR DCP and APIO. As almost all the schools and institutional areas of Dwarka have parked on roads and NOT SEEN a SINGLE Action by DTP.
The Challan RECORDS proove whether the info provided is MISLEADING or not.
- Please provide the reason recorded in the files and exemption for allowing hazard parking in Sector 7 Ramphal chowk area and allowed to park vehicles on road obstructing movement or footpaths.
No exemptions are given to Sector-07, Dwarka, Ramphal Chowk to park their vehicles unauthorized/improperly.
Appeal:
The is CERTAINLY a MISLEADING info provoded by DTP-T-WR DCP and APIO.
As the entire stretch of Ramphal Chowk is CHOCKED and not seen any DTP staff or Crane removing the vehicles from this part. The Challan RECORDS proove whether the info provided is MISLEADING or not.
- Please provide the reason recorded in the file noting for Not removing the vehicles from Markets in Sector 23, 23, 19, 7 LSC where private builders NOT opened the designated basement parking.
No one is allowed to park his/her vehicle in improper/unauthorized manner anywhere in Dwarka and violators are prosecuted accordingly.
The Challan RECORDS proove whether the info provided is MISLEADING or not. These markets the designated parking in the basement are not open known to Jt. CP to Constables. Reason also known to all including public as many even dont have FIRE NOC. Let Shri. SK Sinha proove this correct by providing the DATA for challaned vehicles from these LSC area.
- Please provide the complete file notings on complaints related to NON operational Parking lots in LSC/CSC build by builders Manish Mall in Sector 22, Vardhaman in Sector 23, 19 and Sector 7
Answer: -It does not relate to this office.
Info Declined and failed transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO)
Appeal: The APIO is defaulted
- Please provide file noting concerning the Traffic Police decision to select Dwarka Sect 6/10, 5/11 market road parking with Rs. 600 as penalty as published in News Paper.
Info Declined/Denied by DCP WR(APIO)
Appeal: The APIO is defaulted
- Please provide reason to exclude other sectors and markets, if so under which provision of CMV, Delhi Police Act this public notice issued.
Info Declined/Denied by DCP WR(APIO)
Appeal: The APIO is defaulted
- Have DTP taken up with DDA and MCD for lack of designated parking in various Sectors of Dwarka and Ramphal Chowk.
Info Declined/Denied by DCP WR(APIO)
Appeal: The APIO is defaulted
Sushil Kumar
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "DWARKA FORUM (Regd)" group.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.
swa...@gmail.com
Tks
Shobhit Chauhan
purshotam behl
Subject: [Dwarka Forum] RTI on Parking/ Tow away by Delhi Traffic Police to Dwarka Specific & Majority of the INFO DENIED by DCP WR Mr. S K Sinha
Mahendra Kumar Gupta
Mahendra Kumar Gupta
--
Arun Banerjee
REJIMON C K
However, If we Dwarkites wants a better Traffic Managemetn and DTP not just make money but act PROMPTLY and Help in finding Solution on these matters, all of us need to put extra efforts.
I read a lot of grops from Dwarka work on these, instead of that A UNITED step need to be taken, it is the right time at least we can make Dwarka a better place if not entire Delhi.
DF have been initiating from its inception of 2005 on this matter at that time there was NO Fly Over or Under Pass for Dwarka, we used to struck on Palam Rail Crossing and Shahbad Muhmadpur etc.
Ofcourse then there was no SIGN of Ramphal Chowk, nor had any problem in Sect 6/10 parking.
I am sure peple like Sudha, Sareen, Shobhit, Sanjeev , Robin and many others could draft a Transport and Traffic Policy for Dwarka(just a suggestion).
Provided our fellow Dwarkites themselves by majority respect the rules and most importantly support such documents and submit to authorities through mechanism like UTTIPEC working Group.
It take time and need lot of patient wait...
call is on our fellow residents and take part and help the lead team such as above if agreed.
Drive Safe, Let make others also to Drive with sense(if they are not).
Cheers!
An advice I got from a friend today is that " You will definitely succeed in your life if you follow all the advices that you give to OTHERS". I hope I could do at least improve %
Arun Banerjee
Raju Verma
Sushil Kumar
Shobhit Chauhan
Arun Banerjee
REJIMON C K
More to get as the file notings after depositing the due amounts will be getting.
--
sushil...@gmail.com
REJIMON C K
See just like DINESH YADAV runs the Bus, the Crane have 3 people with same address, I have not found any matured one in any craned. I doubt these are FACTUAL Residence address.
Also note number of vehicles towed away from Dwarka in 2012. 6842 vehicles ie Rs. 20,52,600 worth (if Rs. 300 per vehicle).
Subject : Application under RTI Act on Cranes and Tow Away system of DTP in Dwarka.
- Please provide the certified copies of the contract by DTP with Crane Operator for Dwarka Area.
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 1 Private small crane No. DL-1 LK-6833 which is deployed in Dwarka Traffic Circle has been hired from M/s Rajesh Kumar. You may collect the photocopy of the contract by depositing Rs. 22/- @ Rs. 2/- per page from this office on any working day during working hours.
Organising Postal Order for Rs. 22/ by speed post
Reply by DTP-TWR: No. 1 to 4: - It does not relate to this office.
- As per contract what is the responsibility of the contractor for damaging the vehicle towed away cause loss to public.
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 2 As per Clause No. 13.1 of the contract “In the event of any damage caused to the motor vehicles towed away by the private crane, it shall be the responsibility of the contractor to compensate the repair caused due to such damage”.
Reply by DTP-TWR: No. 1 to 4: - It does not relate to this office.
- Please provide the procedure to claim the damage and loss on account of mishandling of vehicle by Crane No. DL-1L-K6833.
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 3 As per Clause No. 13.2 of the contract “In the event of any damage caused to the motor vehicles towed away by the private crane, the contractor must reach the site of occurrence/circle office immediately to settle the issue in the presence of TI concerned”.
Reply by DTP-TWR: No. 1 to 4: - It does not relate to this office.
- As per contract what is the qualification of the person deployed in addition to Driver for the cranes.
Point No. 1 to 4: -It does not relate to this office.
(1 to 4 info NOT provided and Declined to transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO)
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 4 As per Clause No. 9.3 of the contract “the staff (drivers & helpers) deployed on the crane shall be adult and physically fit”. As per clause No. 9.6 “the drivers deployed on cranes shall have a cerlificate from IDTR regarding proficiency in safe driving etc.”
Reply by DTP-TWR: No. 1 to 4: - It does not relate to this office.
- Please provide the details on Crane Vehicle No. DL-1L-K 6833 (operated on 30/9/2012) DTP Staff, Driver and Operator/Technical assistant etc Name, Age, ID Proof as per DTP records,
Constable Rakesh No. 1180/T was deployed on crane No. DL 1 LK 6833 on dated
30.09.2012 and the detail of crane driver & operator etc. may be had from concern.
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 5 Your application has already been transferred to PlO/T-WR u/s 6(3) of RTI Act- 2005.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 5: - The crane contractor was contacted personally and he revealed that on
dated 30.09.2012 driver was Mr. Hamander Mandal s/o Sh. Joginder Mandal
having DL No. 1851120005150DDC issued from Jharkhand and helper were
Vikas and Manish on crane No. DL iLK 6833.
Reply by DTP-TWR dated 12/12/12: Constable Rakesh No. 1180/T was deployed on crane No. DL 1 LK 6833 on dated
30.09.2012 and the detail of crane staff is as under:-
Driver
Mr. Hamander Mandal (Age-26 years) Sb Sh. Joginder, R/o C-107, Khazan Basti,
Mayapuri, New Delhi having DL No. 1851120005150DDC issued from Jharkhand.
Helpers:-
1. Mr. Pintoo Mandal (Age-28 years) Sb Sh. Sambhau Mandal, R/o C-107,
Khazan Basti, Mayapuri, New Delhi-110028 (Not having ID proof)
2. Mr. Vikas Mandal (Age-28 years) Sb Sh. Sargun Mandal R/o C-107, Khazan
Basti, Mayapuri, New Dehli (Not having ID proof).
- Please provide the appeal authority for the Towed Vehicles away from Dwarka Sub-City and related to grievances.
Answer: -It does not relate to this office.
Info Declined and failed transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO)
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 6 As per Clause No. 13.2 of the contract, it is the duty of concerned TI to settle the issue. However, written complaint/grievances can be given to concerned DCsP/T-Ranges and DCP/T-HQ.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 6 & 7: - It does not relate to this office.
- What is the % of the towing away charges paid to Contractor and what is the % DTP receives.
Answer: -It does not relate to this office.
Info Declined and failed transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO)
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 7 DTP has hired private small cranes @ Rs. 1298/- per day per crane (up to 12 hours) without any extra charges with fuel, one driver and 03 helpers on each crane. The revenue so collected by making fine etc, is deposited in Govt. treasury.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 6 & 7: - It does not relate to this office.
- What is the definition of IMPROPER PARKING as per DTP understanding and Provide us the location in Dwarka Sector 6, 10, 4,5,11,12 market for PROPER PARKING.
Please refer to section 122 M.V. Act 1988. Location of parking may be had from land owing agencies.
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 8 Parking of the vehicles is specified under Rule 15 of Rules of the Road Regulations, 1989 (copy enclosed).
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 8:- Please refer to section 122 M.V. Act 1988. Location of parking may be had from land owing authorities.
Reply by DTP-TWR 12/12/12: Point No. 8:- The parking space is provided and is being maintained by DDA at Sector 6/10 market, Dwarka, New Delhi, and more information may be collect from DDA.
DDA Reply to No.8- The parking area in sector-6,10,4,5, & 12 markets are
duly marked at site and developed aordingIyt0 plarnY vehicle parked beyond parking space may be treated as improper parking However detail enquiry may please be made with D.T.P.
- Have DTP marked the locations of parking areas through visible sign boards in above markets, if so please provide the list of locations.
Answer: -It does not relate to this office.
Info Declined and failed transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO)
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 9&10 Your application has already been transferred to PIO/T-WR u/s 6(3) of RTI Act- 2005.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 9:- It does not relate to this office.
DDA Reply to No.9- The concerned Officer i.e SE-CC 2 and 13 have been requested to fix the sign boards of parking area at site under their jurisdiction if not fixed.
- Please provide the list of location and No of Vehicles along with type towed away from Dwarka (Sector wise) for year 2012.
It is not possible to provide the requisite information as the record is voluminous and not maintained in computerized manner. Applicant may examine record during office hours.
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 9&10 Your application has already been transferred to PIO/T-WR u/s 6(3) of RTI Act- 2005.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 10:- Location of towed away vehicles is not maintained separately.
Reply by DTP-TWR: 12/12/12Point No. 10:- The number of vehicles towed away in 2012 till date is 6842 and data to towed away vehicles and location is not maintained prosecution wise and is not computerized and have to check each and every challan manually. The appellant is at liberty to examine the record of challan on any working day.
- Please provide the reason recorded in the files and exemption given to schools and institutional areas allowed to park vehicles on road obstructing movement or footpaths in Dwarka.
No exemptions are given to schools and institutional areas to park their vehicles unauthorized! improperly.
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 11 As per the available record of this office, no exemption is given. However, your application has already been transferred to PlO/T-WR u/s 6(3) of RTI Act-2005.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 11 to 13:- No such file/record is available for exemption for parking.
Reply by DTP-TWR 12/12/12: Point No. 11:- No exemptions are given to schools and institutional areas to park their vehicles unauthorized/improperly. School buses are allowed only to pick and drop school children during school hours and apart from this if any school/institutional bus is found parked unauthorized/improperly, prosecuted accordingly.
- Please provide the reason recorded in the files and exemption for allowing hazard parking in Sector 7 Ramphal chowk area and allowed to park vehicles on road obstructing movement or footpaths.
No exemptions are given to Sector-07, Dwarka, Ramphal Chowk to park their vehicles unauthorized/improperly.
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point1 2&13 Your application has already been transferred to PlO/T-WR u/s 6(3) of RTI Act- 2005.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 11 to 13:- No such file/record is available for exemption for parking.
Reply by DTP-TWR 12/12/12: Point No. 12:- Staff has already been deployed at Ramphal Chowk, Sec-7, Dwarka to ensure smooth and safe flow of traffic. Cranes are also functional is centralized manner in Dwarka Circle which also covers Ramphal Chowk area. The record is not maintained prosecution-wise and is not computerized and to check each and every challan manully.
- Please provide the reason recorded in the file noting for Not removing the vehicles from Markets in Sector 23, 23, 19, 7 LSC where private builders NOT opened the designated basement parking.
No one is allowed to park his/her vehicle in improper/unauthorized manner anywhere in Dwarka and violators are prosecuted accordingly.
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point1 2&13 Your application has already been transferred to PlO/T-WR u/s 6(3) of RTI Act- 2005.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 11 to 13:- No such file/record is available for exemption for parking.
Reply by DTP-TWR 12/12/2012: Point No. 13:- Staff has been deployed at Sector-23, 19, 07 Dwarka to ensure smooth and safe flow of traffic; Cranes are also functional in centralized manner in Dwarka Circle which also covers these sectors. The record is not maintained prosecution-wise and is not computerized and to check each and every challan manully.
- Please provide the complete file notings on complaints related to NON operational Parking lots in LSC/CSC build by builders Manish Mall in Sector 22, Vardhaman in Sector 23, 19 and Sector 7
Answer: -It does not relate to this office.
Info Declined and failed transfer u/s 6(3) by DCP WR(APIO)
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 14&1 7 Copy of the emails dated 06.06.2010 and 23.07.2010 from Shri Mahesh Tak and this office letters dated 12.11.2010 and 13.05.2011 sent to DDA and MCD office alongwith copy of relevant note sheet contains 12 pages, you may collect the same by depositing Rs. 24/- @ Rs. 2/- per page from this office on any working day during working hours.
Organising Postal Order for Rs. 22/ by speed post
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 14:- Information may be had from land owing authority.
- Please provide file noting concerning the Traffic Police decision to select Dwarka Sect 6/10, 5/11 market road parking with Rs. 600 as penalty as published in News Paper.
Info Declined/Denied by DCP WR(APIO)
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 15&16 The photocopy of the file noting concerning the traffic police decision to increase the penalty from Rs. 100/- to Rs. 600/- for obstructive and improper parking contains 9 pages, you may collect the same by depositing Rs. 24/- @ Rs. 18/- per page from this office on any working day during working hours.
Organising Postal Order for Rs. 24/ by speed post
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 15 to 17:- It does not relate to this office.
- Please provide reason to exclude other sectors and markets, if so under which provision of CMV, Delhi Police Act this public notice issued.
Info Declined/Denied by DCP WR(APIO)
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 1 5&1 6 The photocopy of the file noting concerning the traffic police decision to increase the penalty from Rs. 100/- to Rs. 600/- for obstructive and improper parking contains 9 pages, you may collect the same by depositing Rs. 24/- @ Rs. 18/- per page from this office on any working day during working hours.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 15 to 17:- It does not relate to this office.
- Have DTP taken up with DDA and MCD for lack of designated parking in various Sectors of Dwarka and Ramphal Chowk.
Info Declined/Denied by DCP WR(APIO)
Reply by DTP-T-HQ: Point 14&1 7 Copy of the emails dated 06.06.2010 and 23.07.2010 from Shri Mahesh Tak and this office letters dated 12.11.2010 and 13.05.2011 sent to DDA and MCD office alongwith copy of relevant note sheet contains 12 pages, you may collect the same by depositing Rs. 24/- @ Rs. 2/- per page from this office on any working day during working hours.
Reply by DTP-TWR: Point No. 15 to 17:- It does not relate to this office.
Organising Postal Order for Rs. 22/ by speed post
Satya Prakash Rastogi
-vehicles are towed away during daytime only and never after evenings when haphazard / improper parking creates maximum problems for flow of traffic or movement of pedestrians
Shobhit Chauhan
Rejimon ji
Can you provide me a copy of this RTI application and its reply for further follow up.
Regards.
Shobhit Chauhan
9717063875
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dwarka-residen...@googlegroups.com.
Mahendra Kumar Gupta
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dwarka-residen...@googlegroups.com.
Shobhit Chauhan
REJIMON C K
If ur following up.. Please ask for Revenue - If the vehicle is towed away its Benefit to Crane Contractor.
If the penalty is fixed and collected at spot it will go directly to treasury also the defaulter will be less harassed. Hope the E-Challan they expect to start from Mar will deal with this.
The cranes have to be used where there is fully obstruction.
Another issue basic facility of Parking have to be provided whether its the duty of Land Owning Agency or some one else. DTP can not wash its hands. Because they adopt BIASED mechanism.
Sorry, I cud nt follow up to get photocopies further as so many assignment.
p. menon
Beware: Traffic Police Cranes hv started lifting vehicles from sevice lanes also. It hs happened with me today. When I went to pickup the vehicle at Sect-9, there were other persons also there with similar complaints!?
 P.Menon |
|
|
|
Shobhit Chauhan
Menon ji!
Let it be put on record that service lane is for internal vehicular movement and not for parking of vehicles. I do acknowledge the fact that there need to be more and adequate parking facilities in Dwarka and we need to work on that. Ek Sangharsh is working on getting underground parking of shopping malls opened.
Regards
Mahendra Kumar Gupta
K C Kumar
Sent from my iPhone
Anil Rajput
Arun Banerjee
DDA seems to be a frustrating org. working to exhaust the applicant.