Well, instead, I used the router, but paid attention to the navigation I was using. In essence, I added a route with no ModuleID, a hash of the URL I was pointing to (as in my navigation I was setting href = hash) and a title. That fixed the issue entirely.
Thanks for encouraging the static link, as it actually made life easier for me. (BTW, the reason I didn't just use a static link is that my navigation is (like most I think) in a foreach databound ul. Adding the static link would have wreaked havoc on my links, I think.)