Feedback

5 views
Skip to first unread message

Elias ACHKAR

unread,
Jul 13, 2010, 6:36:33 AM7/13/10
to duplicate-contact-ma...@googlegroups.com
Bonjour,
Il est dommage que l'on ne puisse pas rechercher les doublons dans l'ensemble des adresses.
Il faut chercher dans chaque carnet d'adresses (adresses personnelles, adresses collectée, travail etc...).
Est-il possible de rémédier à ça ?
Merci et bonne journée.
E. Achkar

Frédéric MERLE

unread,
Jul 15, 2010, 2:43:03 PM7/15/10
to duplicate-contact-ma...@googlegroups.com
Hello,
I have tried your plug-in. It could be very usefull, but ATMHO lacks a few features  :
#1 : when you identify duplicate contacts  I would like to transfer missing data on the contact to keep before deleting the other

#2 Phone numbers are good candidate fields to identify duplicate records

#3 When you want to keep both contacts, it could be nice to have a third choice : "skip and mark" the records as "non duplicate". So next time you don't have to tell again to skip "marked" records (or you can with an option on the start panel, "compare/don't compare marked records"

Thanks for help.

Frédéric MERLE
moz-screenshot-32.png
moz-screenshot-33.png

Copelnug

unread,
Jul 24, 2010, 9:11:31 PM7/24/10
to duplicate-contact-ma...@googlegroups.com
First, thank for the feedback.

Hello,
I have tried your plug-in. It could be very usefull, but ATMHO lacks a few features  :
#1 : when you identify duplicate contacts  I would like to transfer missing data on the contact to keep before deleting the other
This and the edition of those entry (which is pretty much the same), is one of, if not, the bigger demand. I don't know enought of the Thunderbird API right now to do it but it's one of the next thing I'll do. The manual edit should come first as it is easier to code.

#2 Phone numbers are good candidate fields to identify duplicate records

It would not be so hard to implement but I'm asking myself if it's worth the inconvenient. It would slow a little the plug-in and it could lead to recurrent false duplicate for certain users (Your idea #3 address this problem). My concern however is more with the fact that it will be rare that only the phone number match and not the name or the address and thus this supplementary check would not bring anything new.


#3 When you want to keep both contacts, it could be nice to have a third choice : "skip and mark" the records as "non duplicate". So next time you don't have to tell again to skip "marked" records (or you can with an option on the start panel, "compare/don't compare marked records"
Interesting and useful idea, I had already thought about it but I didn't know of anybody who wanted it so I didn't put more thought on it. Now, I think I see a way to do it. We just need to add an invisible field to the pair of contacts. When two contact are compared, they are ignored if they both have the field (This allow to detect a 3rd contact added).
The only part I'm not sure I can do is clearing the field of imported contact. This would be very useful to allow to search duplicate easily after while retaining your preferences.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages