Improved around Davis Square?

121 views
Skip to first unread message

Genny Marlin

unread,
Sep 8, 2026, 5:50:37 PMSep 8
to DSNC Discussion

Curious to hear what everyone thinks — what’s one thing you’d like to see improved around Davis Square?

Could be anything from traffic and parking to pedestrian areas

Colin McMillen

unread,
Sep 8, 2026, 5:53:58 PMSep 8
to dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
More bike parking.

Enforcement of double-parking, especially on Elm Street. 

Pigeon poop and other detritus cleaned from inside Davis Station more regularly.



On Wed, Sep 2, 2026, at 8:53 AM, Genny Marlin wrote:

Curious to hear what everyone thinks — what’s one thing you’d like to see improved around Davis Square?

Could be anything from traffic and parking to pedestrian areas


--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "DSNC Discussion" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dsnc-discussi...@googlegroups.com.

Ron Newman

unread,
Sep 8, 2026, 5:58:45 PMSep 8
to Genny Marlin, DSNC Discussion

On Sep 2, 2026, at 8:53 AM, Genny Marlin <genny...@gmail.com> wrote:

Curious to hear what everyone thinks — what’s one thing you’d like to see improved around Davis Square?

Filling vacant storefronts.   To me, nothing else is even a close second to this.

Adam Grossman

unread,
Sep 8, 2026, 6:01:25 PMSep 8
to Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin
I agree with Ron.
 
Adam Grossman
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "DSNC Discussion" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dsnc-discussi...@googlegroups.com.

Penelope Doherty

unread,
Sep 8, 2026, 6:06:13 PMSep 8
to Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin
Completely agree w Ron and Adam - a vibrant neighborhood requires a vibrant anchor layer. So important to keep business needs in mind as changes are considered 

Penelope


From: 'Adam Grossman' via DSNC Discussion <dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com>
Sent: Tuesday, 08 September 2026 18:01:21
To: Ron Newman <rne...@alum.mit.edu>; Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion <dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com>; Genny Marlin <genny...@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: [DSNC-Discussion] Improved around Davis Square?
 

Alan Ball

unread,
Sep 8, 2026, 6:32:36 PMSep 8
to Penelope Doherty, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin
No more scooter chop shop in the middle of statue park.

AL

Jeff Byrnes

unread,
Sep 8, 2026, 9:51:21 PMSep 8
to Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty
Unfortunately, the City isn’t in charge of whether retail spaces are leased or not. It can incentivize with various financial tools, like tax abatement or financial assistance with renovations, but otherwise that’s entirely up to the owner & a potential tenant.

Perhaps helpful to reframe: what’s one thing the City owns & controls that you’d like to see improved?

I’m with Colin that more bike parking & better enforcement of double-parking would be helpful!

hu...@comcast.net

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 2:51:39 PMSep 9
to Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty

My 2c on a single improvement to Davis Square:

 

Eliminate vehicular through traffic.

 

The vast majority of traffic through the square appears to be cut-through traffic. The square is a destination for a very small proportion of the traffic.

 

Modest proposal:

 

  • Ring Davis Square with a series of bollards blocking vehicular traffic into the square.
    • Select bollards would be retractable, to let through buses, delivery and sanitation vehicles, and the like, not to mention emergency vehicles.
      • For example, retractable bollards at College, Holland, Elm and Highland; but not Day and Dover
    • Access restricted to the center of the square only
      • On-street parking still available for people with business in the square.
    • Peripheral streets re-defined as necessary to be one way in directions designed to frustrate attempts to find alternate cut-through routes.
    • Let the larger arteries such as Broadway and Mass. Ave. carry the traffic they were designed for.

 

-Hume

 

 

Hume Vance

211 Morrison Ave.

Alan Ball

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 4:45:42 PMSep 9
to hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty
“The vast majority of traffic through the square appears to be cut-through traffic. The square is a destination for a very small proportion of the traffic.”

Is there any empirical evidence this is true?



Alan Ball
A.B.I.D.

Alan Ball Industrial Design Inc.
50 Francesca Ave
Somerville, Ma 02144


Amy Greene

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 5:26:51 PMSep 9
to Ron Newman, Genny Marlin, Discussion DSNC
Agree with Ron! Filling vacancies. 
Sent from my iPhone

On Sep 8, 2026, at 5:58 PM, 'Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion <dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com> wrote:




On Sep 2, 2026, at 8:53 AM, Genny Marlin <genny...@gmail.com> wrote:

Curious to hear what everyone thinks — what’s one thing you’d like to see improved around Davis Square?

Filling vacant storefronts.   To me, nothing else is even a close second to this.

hu...@comcast.net

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 6:13:44 PMSep 9
to Alan Ball, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty

Hi Alan,

 

Just stand in the middle of the square for a few minutes, and observe traffic whizzing off in all directions.

 

Or, observe the overall volume of traffic through the square, and then observe the number of cars entering or leaving the various nearby parking lots or parking spaces along College, Holland, Elm and Highland. The numbers appear to be totally incommensurate.

 

I don’t know of a study that examines destinations of traffic through Davis Square. However, a study for the recent Herbert St. development includes traffic and parking measurements for one quadrant of the square (the study examines the quadrant along Elm St. from Day St. to Chester St., but excludes Highland, College and Holland Sts., for example):

 

https://s3.amazonaws.com/somervillema-live/s3fs-public/2023-01/TIS.pdf

 

And

 

 

Putting this into a spreadsheet, we see:

 

Location

Total Supply

Average Utilization %

Average Spaces Occupied

Private 55 Day Lot

81

33%

27

Public 44 Day Lot

61

57%

35

Day Street

21

49%

10

Elm Street

15

76%

11

Herbert Street

5

68%

3

Chester Street

8

59%

5

Total

191

91

 

 

I have no idea what the average duration of a parking session is in the respective lots and streets. (Can anyone help here?) Assuming it’s somewhere between  20 minutes and 1 hour, and assuming a 12 hour period from 8 am to 8 pm, this could amount to anywhere from 1100 to 3300 vehicles per day. For traffic volume, perhaps only Elm and Dover should be counted, since the others likely double-count a good deal of that traffic. In that case, we have roughly 12.5K vehicles per day.

1100/12.5K ~=9%

3300/12.5K ~=27%

 

Do you agree the range of cut-through traffic appears to be somewhere between  73% and 91%? If so, I believe it’s safe to say that since the bulk of traffic isn’t parking in the square, it is headed elsewhere.

 

-Hume

image001.png
image002.png

Alan Ball

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 9:23:41 PMSep 9
to hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty
I do not find your analysis convincing at all. You seem to have started with the conclusion, and are simply fitting the data to support it.

I find the idea of routing all of the through traffic entering the square from highland, holland , day and (circuitously) elm, some how around the square, to be preposterous…just as preposterous as a 25 story building in the square. I am sure the merchants in the square would have a lot to say about this as well.

I also find this entire discussion problematic. I thought the role of DSNC was to solicit opinions from the community and represent them to the local government. Spit balling a wish list from dilletant urban planners does not align with the mission of DSNC as I understand it.

This discussion should be how can DSNC reach out to the community (not membership) to solicit opinions and concerns about the future of DS, then figure a way to rank these based on community consensus. Then the most supported issues can be identified for action or recommendation.

That said, it would be great if the city excercised the vacancy ordinance to make it painful for landlords to let commercial space sit vacant.

AL

Ashish Shrestha

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 10:04:00 PMSep 9
to Alan Ball, hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty
Hi Alan,

Do you have any evidence to rebut Hume's careful and well-cited mathematical analysis?  Or was there a flaw in their analysis that you'd like to share with us?  Otherwise I'm not sure what your disagreement is beyond that you don't like the conclusion.

Ashish

Penelope Doherty

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 10:10:48 PMSep 9
to Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin
To Jeff's points: 

As a former city dept head in charge of downtown revitalization (and yes, focusing on healthy business anchors to provide healthy public spaces), I can attest that a city's decisions and actions can absolutely impact/influence/affect whether the retail/storefront environment can thrive. If as a group DSNC plans to provide input to the city, it must be aware and mindful of this. Infrastructure will not survive if the focus is only on bicycles and pedestrians.

And I agree with a later comment that to route traffic around the square is unrealistic given our realities and the space. It would punish businesses, surrounding homes, bus routes/users, you name it. It is easy to romanticize a non-vehicular space but it is very difficult (and hugely expensive!) to attain, maintain, and sustain. 

In my experience a healthy balance of uses and a business-friendly (not the same as dominant) environment is what will attract and keep sustainable anchors 

Best
Penelope


From: Jeff Byrnes <je...@somervilleyimby.org>
Sent: Tuesday, 08 September 2026 21:51:10
To: Adam Grossman <aljgr...@comcast.net>; Ron Newman <rne...@alum.mit.edu>; Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion <dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com>; Genny Marlin <genny...@gmail.com>; Penelope Doherty <dohe...@hotmail.com>

Jonathan Cohen

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 10:16:42 PMSep 9
to Alan Ball, hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty
Hume - Thank you for taking the time to present an interesting idea and backing it up with thoughtful data when pressed. There are many other considerations, but this seems like a useful starting point if one were to study/discuss this idea further.

Alan - 
  • I find it disheartening that you pressed Hume to do additional work when it appears you were never going to be receptive to it. If you disagree with the argument, it would be constructive to push back based on its methodology, additional data, or some other explicit tradeoff.  
  • While I’m hesitant to engage in meta-discussions about the DSNC—as I believe that takes up a disproportionate amount of focus relative to its impact—I disagree that this discussion conflicts with your interpretation of the DSNC’s role. Brainstorming ideas and representing community consensus are complements, not substitutes. Priorities and proposals have to come from somewhere: DSNC forums let residents surface ideas and refine them through discussion. Those ideas can then be stress-tested through broader outreach to determine whether they actually have community support.

Best,
Jon

On Wed, Sep 9, 2026 at 9:23 PM Alan Ball <alb...@abidstudio.com> wrote:

Jonathan Cohen

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 10:22:02 PMSep 9
to Alan Ball, hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty
(Re-copying my reply here because the font showed up as white text above)


Hume - Thank you for taking the time to present an interesting idea and backing it up with thoughtful data when pressed. There are many other considerations, but this seems like a useful starting point if one were to study/discuss this idea further.

Alan -
  • I find it disheartening that you pressed Hume to do additional work when it appears you were never going to be receptive to it. If you disagree with the argument, it would be constructive to push back based on its methodology, additional data, or some other explicit tradeoff. 
  • While I’m hesitant to engage in meta-discussions about the DSNC—as I believe that takes up a disproportionate amount of focus relative to its impact—I disagree that this discussion conflicts with your interpretation of the DSNC’s role. Brainstorming ideas and representing community consensus are complements, not substitutes. Priorities and proposals have to come from somewhere: DSNC forums let residents surface ideas and refine them through discussion. Those ideas can then be stress-tested through broader outreach to determine whether they actually have community support. 
Best,
Jon

hu...@comcast.net

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 10:50:09 PMSep 9
to Jonathan Cohen, Alan Ball, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty

Jonathan and Ashish,

 

Thank you for your appreciative comments.

 

Penelope—Are you certain that re-routing traffic around the square would have the impacts you list? For one thing, I mentioned that buses could pass through the square over retractable bollards. With this feature, all bus routes would remain unaffected. And, it’s not clear to me that businesses would be adversely impacted. Parking would remain unaffected, and with significantly curtailed traffic, the square would seem to become a more attractive place to visit.

 

-Hume

image001.png
image002.png

Penelope Doherty

unread,
Sep 9, 2026, 11:13:08 PMSep 9
to hu...@comcast.net, Jonathan Cohen, Alan Ball, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin
In my humble opinion no one can be certain that any of these suggestions will be successful until they are attempted - some risking more harm than others. However history can serve us well in these situations, and experiences in other spaces, as well as consulting the businesses whose margins are already incredibly small. I just haven't seen in Davis Square the kind of singular attraction that typically makes a pedestrian center a destination that can sustain businesses through the transition. It's risky to assume something will come along.

Several people have suggested more conservative/reversible trial approaches that can inform forward movement without extreme and expensive change. There doesn't seem to be much appetite for that unfortunately.

Take care
Penelope


From: hu...@comcast.net <hu...@comcast.net>
Sent: Wednesday, 09 September 2026 22:48:01
To: 'Jonathan Cohen' <jonp...@gmail.com>; 'Alan Ball' <alb...@abidstudio.com>

Cc: 'Jeff Byrnes' <je...@somervilleyimby.org>; 'Adam Grossman' <aljgr...@comcast.net>; 'Ron Newman' <rne...@alum.mit.edu>; 'Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion' <dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com>; 'Genny Marlin' <genny...@gmail.com>; 'Penelope Doherty' <dohe...@hotmail.com>
Subject: RE: [DSNC-Discussion] Improved around Davis Square?
 

Christopher Beland

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 12:06:42 AMSep 10
to Penelope Doherty, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com

Penelope Doherty wrote:

And I agree with a later comment that to route traffic around the square is unrealistic given our realities and the space. It would punish businesses, surrounding homes, bus routes/users, you name it. It is easy to romanticize a non-vehicular space but it is very difficult (and hugely expensive!) to attain, maintain, and sustain.  ... I just haven't seen in Davis Square the kind of singular attraction that typically makes a pedestrian center a destination that can sustain businesses through the transition. It's risky to assume something will come along.

I'm scratching my head at the idea that pedestrianizing streets is punishment or would be bad for business. The restaurants I've talked to on Elm Street say that outdoor dining is a huge windfall for them, often making the difference between profit and breaking even. Plenty of stores seem to be able to thrive in high-foot-traffic areas with zero on-street parking (locally, I'm thinking of the Harvard-Brattle area).

I just got back from Copenhagen, and most of the main shopping streets there have banned cars for most of the day, allowing deliveries before 11am. Businesses are thriving, and there's a huge amount of foot traffic - far more than the street could handle if those people were in cars. The main no-car squares where people hang out are pretty similar to Davis, with paving stones instead of brick and concrete, and maybe a fountain instead of Keytar Bear. The mix of ground-level businesses is familiar - a lot of restaurants with outdoor dining, and a random selection of retail ranging from clothes to housewares to hardware to groceries. On the upper floors there's a mix of offices and housing, varying from block to block.

I think Davis already has what we need to attract people into a pedestrian zone, and the transit infrastructure (and 3/4ths of the bike infrastructure) to get them there. What would boost foot traffic even further would be more density on the surrounding blocks. Not necessarily Manhattan levels of density - Copenhagen is pretty much a six-story inner city. (That human-scale height has also made it very expensive, so to relieve the pressure it's becoming popular to commute across the ocean from Sweden. 12-story residential buildings have gone up near the new metro stations on the suburban island of Amager, so perhaps the low building height is mostly a legacy of the pre-elevator era?)

I found some interesting stats in their 2026 Mobility Report about how mode share breaks down for different activities. Denmark has a considerably lower traffic death rate, and I'm sure part of that is separating cars and pedestrians on different streets. They also separate bikes into protected lanes on major streets, and have fewer people driving overall (about 25% in Copenhagen).

Chris

Colin McMillen

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 12:16:20 AMSep 10
to Christopher Beland, Penelope Doherty, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Denmark's lack of car dependence is strongly encouraged via taxation. The average cheap new car is taxed at 85% of the purchase price, and any amount over $37,000 (approximately) is taxed at 150%, *plus* a 25% VAT, *plus* an emissions surcharge based on its fuel efficiency. 

Part of the reason so many people bike in Denmark is because the infrastructure is good and the weather is reasonable even in winter, but also the Danish government has intentionally made it very expensive to own a car. 
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "DSNC Discussion" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dsnc-discussi...@googlegroups.com.

Penelope Doherty

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 8:56:44 AMSep 10
to Colin McMillen, Christopher Beland, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Thanks Colin. I agree that seeing something in one place doesn't guarantee it will translate well to another environment. 

Chris, favoring outdoor dining is not the same thing as pedestrianizing a street. I'm just saying there is a much larger picture to consider, which seems to frequently be focused instead on one aspect. 

Thanks all
Penelope 


From: Colin McMillen <co...@mcmillen.dev>
Sent: Thursday, 10 September 2026 00:15:56
To: Christopher Beland <bel...@alum.mit.edu>; Penelope Doherty <dohe...@hotmail.com>
Cc: dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com <dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com>

Subject: Re: [DSNC-Discussion] Improved around Davis Square?

David Booth

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 9:21:38 AMSep 10
to dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Making Davis a pedestrian center would be awesome. The center of the
square could then be used for farmers' markets, arts festivals and other
community events. I think that's definitely the right long-term direction.

BUT concerns about what that change would disrupt are valid too, and
will need to be carefully addressed. And such a change should only be
done incrementally, so that we can adjust course if needed.

Ironically a change like that would make Davis Square an even *more*
desirable place to live, which would push up housing prices even higher,
unless a lot more housing stock is added to counteract the increased demand.

On 9/10/26 00:06, 'Christopher Beland' via DSNC Discussion wrote:
> . . . Copenhagen is pretty much a six-story
> inner city. (That human-scale height has also made it very expensive, so
> to relieve the pressure it's becoming popular to commute across the
> ocean from Sweden.

Ouch! That's a horrible unintended consequence.

> 12-story residential buildings have gone up near the
> new metro stations on the suburban island of Amager, so perhaps
> the low building height is mostly a legacy of the pre-elevator era?)

I think 12 stories in Davis Square could even be reasonable *if* the
architecture aligned with the historical character of the neighborhood.

Thanks,
David Booth

Alan Ball

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 9:33:07 AMSep 10
to Ashish Shrestha, hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty
No. I am not advocating for such a dramatic change to the local infrastructure, so it is not my burden to provide evidence.
I do not accept the base assumption that all pass-through traffic is undesirable.
I do not accept the analysis of parking space utilization has a direct correlation to traffic moving around and through the square
I do not believe there is a realistic way to reroute traffic around the square without establishing some kind of ring road, which is not possible due to the city's density.
I do not believe anyone has seriously thought through the unintended consequences of such a dramatic scheme, such as offloading traffic to small residential streets, and the detrimental effect on businesses in the square.
I believe it is outside the role of a Neighborhood Council to brainstorm about pet projects. The group should strive to understand the needs and desires of the DS community as a whole, not just folks subscribed to the news group. 
Comparisons to European cities are irrelevant. We live in Somerville, in a car centric country. That is the reality.
Focusing on unrealistic "romantic" notions of making Davis Square a non-vehicular space distracts from smaller, important incremental changes that could be recommended which would greatly improve the square and have universal community support.

AL

Alan Ball

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 10:40:16 AMSep 10
to Glen Nuckolls, Ashish Shrestha, hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty
Good point. I think traffic calming in the square is very important, particularly on highland approaching grove.

al

On Thu, Sep 10, 2026 at 10:33 AM Glen Nuckolls <nucko...@gmail.com> wrote:
I do suspect there is a lot of traffic through Davis that does not stop in Davis, but this is from my observation and not quantified. However, I think it’s helpful to focus on problems I can clearly see. One is that cars coming into Davis from Highland are often going too fast. I have seen many incidents of fast/aggressive driving at Holland and Grove st (crosswalk near Five Horses Tavern) that cause problems for people crossing there. This has happened to me several times and I’ve probably seen at least 15 - 20 instances of dangerous or at least very uncomfortable incidents just from walking through there. The two one-way lanes there cause some of the problem (cars are quick to pass a car slowing or stopped for someone crossing. I have actually seen someone hit there (the little “people crossing” sign that was in the middle of the crosswalk was literally on top of her). I’ve seen an assault by a driver mad at being told to slow down after nearly hitting someone in the crosswalk. I was flipped off by a guy with his teenage son in the car after I motioned that he should slow down since there were people in the crosswalk. Even when cars stop, they are often going fast enough to make it uncomfortable for people crossing. Often, one car will stop, but another is coming in the other lane fast enough that it’s not clear they will stop. This spot is clearly a problem just from what I’ve personally witnessed. 

Slowing the cars down at this spot seems hard to argue against if you are interested in improving Davis Square for the people who spend time there. No one drives through Davis quickly unless they get lucky. Speeding down Highland mostly just gets you more quickly to the same spot in line to wait for the light that you would have had if you went 15mph. If cut-through traffic is causing this, those drivers can just go at a more steady pace and make the square safer and more inviting. The city knows how to slow cars down and it doesn’t require a multi-year study. It’s interesting that I rarely see anything like this one street over on Elm at Chester, and it has even more people crossing there. The drivers through there are (mostly) quite capable of going slow.  

If slowing cars down at Highland and Grove causes spillover traffic through more quiet residential streets, that should be addressed, but not by letting drivers speed through a very busy crosswalk. 


<image001.png>

And

 

<image002.png>

Patricia Abreu

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 10:45:30 AMSep 10
to Alan Ball, Ashish Shrestha, hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty

Putting aside the effect on local businesses, I gather I am not alone in saying that I do not wish to have to run a side-street obstacle course around the square just to get home, or to go anywhere else.  

I also gather Mass Ave cannot handle more traffic, as it is already so often backed up from Porter to Alewife, with the right lanes reserved for busses.  


On Sep 10, 2026, at 9:32 AM, Alan Ball <alb...@abidstudio.com> wrote:

<image001.png>

And

 

<image002.png>

Penelope Doherty

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 10:47:47 AMSep 10
to Glen Nuckolls, Alan Ball, Ashish Shrestha, hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin
Glen you bring up great points, and ones I've brought up several times to initiative leadership. If our concern is primarily traffic safety, there are quick and easy ways to address some observed pain points, with immediate results that can also inform forward movement. 

A couple of speed tables in key places and simple signage directing to nearby parking are easy to try. Such actions don't preclude people from continued visioning, but it does provide a less-risky start to the endeavor. It could also allow different goals (traffic safety vs amenities, for instance) to be addressed on their own merits instead of an all-or-nothing approach. 

Food for thought.
Penelope


From: Glen Nuckolls <nucko...@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, 10 September 2026 10:33:15
To: Alan Ball <alb...@abidstudio.com>
Cc: Ashish Shrestha <ashres...@gmail.com>; hu...@comcast.net <hu...@comcast.net>; Jeff Byrnes <je...@somervilleyimby.org>; Adam Grossman <aljgr...@comcast.net>; Ron Newman <rne...@alum.mit.edu>; Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion <dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com>; Genny Marlin <genny...@gmail.com>; Penelope Doherty <dohe...@hotmail.com>

Subject: Re: [DSNC-Discussion] Improved around Davis Square?
I do suspect there is a lot of traffic through Davis that does not stop in Davis, but this is from my observation and not quantified. However, I think it’s helpful to focus on problems I can clearly see. One is that cars coming into Davis from Highland are often going too fast. I have seen many incidents of fast/aggressive driving at Holland and Grove st (crosswalk near Five Horses Tavern) that cause problems for people crossing there. This has happened to me several times and I’ve probably seen at least 15 - 20 instances of dangerous or at least very uncomfortable incidents just from walking through there. The two one-way lanes there cause some of the problem (cars are quick to pass a car slowing or stopped for someone crossing. I have actually seen someone hit there (the little “people crossing” sign that was in the middle of the crosswalk was literally on top of her). I’ve seen an assault by a driver mad at being told to slow down after nearly hitting someone in the crosswalk. I was flipped off by a guy with his teenage son in the car after I motioned that he should slow down since there were people in the crosswalk. Even when cars stop, they are often going fast enough to make it uncomfortable for people crossing. Often, one car will stop, but another is coming in the other lane fast enough that it’s not clear they will stop. This spot is clearly a problem just from what I’ve personally witnessed. 

Slowing the cars down at this spot seems hard to argue against if you are interested in improving Davis Square for the people who spend time there. No one drives through Davis quickly unless they get lucky. Speeding down Highland mostly just gets you more quickly to the same spot in line to wait for the light that you would have had if you went 15mph. If cut-through traffic is causing this, those drivers can just go at a more steady pace and make the square safer and more inviting. The city knows how to slow cars down and it doesn’t require a multi-year study. It’s interesting that I rarely see anything like this one street over on Elm at Chester, and it has even more people crossing there. The drivers through there are (mostly) quite capable of going slow.  

If slowing cars down at Highland and Grove causes spillover traffic through more quiet residential streets, that should be addressed, but not by letting drivers speed through a very busy crosswalk. 

On Sep 10, 2026, at 9:32 AM, Alan Ball <alb...@abidstudio.com> wrote:

<image001.png>

And

 

<image002.png>

Christopher Beland

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 11:54:24 AMSep 10
to Alan Ball, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com

On Thu, 2026-09-10 at 09:32 -0400, Alan Ball wrote:

I do not believe there is a realistic way to reroute traffic around the square without establishing some kind of ring road, which is not possible due to the city's density.

Evan Cohen also has an amazingly well-developed concept he presented to the Elmway Action Group which illustrates a potential circulation pattern around a pedestrianized Davis Square. It completes the loop by adding a road between Day and Dover over part of the parking lot behind the CVS.

Even without doing this, there are other roads that traffic would shift onto if the main Davis intersection were closed - like Broadway, Mass Ave, Cameron, Willow, and Cedar.

I do not believe anyone has seriously thought through the unintended consequences of such a dramatic scheme, such as offloading traffic to small residential streets, and the detrimental effect on businesses in the square.

Sure, it's the job of professional traffic engineers to study the consequences, figure out what complementary changes are needed, and identify any bottlenecks that might be dealbreakers. I would not assume that the impact on business would be negative; I expect there would be winners and losers.

I believe it is outside the role of a Neighborhood Council to brainstorm about pet projects. The group should strive to understand the needs and desires of the DS community as a whole, not just folks subscribed to the news group.

Pedestrianizing Elm Street is actually already in the drafts of the Davis Square Neighborhood Plan; it may actually represent something the community as a whole does strive for. From what I understand, the Mobility Division wants to study the incremental improvements that would enable that, like the traffic impacts of making Highland two-way, but they are short on resources.  

Comparisons to European cities are irrelevant. We live in Somerville, in a car centric country. That is the reality.

Even the most car-centric cities have pedestrian areas that interrupt the street grid. People drive there and then get out and walk around. I'm thinking of a great outdoor mall in Los Angeles, the pedestrianized street LINQ in Las Vegas, and grade-separated City Creek in downtown Salt Lake, and Lincoln Road in Miami.

I think comparison to European cities are apt because not all US cities are car-centric. Somerville is a streetcar suburb, just like Dorchester and old tram-centric neighborhoods in Vienna, Berlin, Prague, Amsterdam, Copenhagen, Stockholm, Chicago, San Francisco, and Philadelphia.

Davis Square grew up as a steam railroad stop and a streetcar terminus. Cars are a new thing that have only happened in the most recent couple of centuries. We still have most of the same buildings from that streetcar era.

If you look at Wikipedia's mode share table, you'll see New York is between London and Paris for transit, and its transport patterns resemble those two cities more than any US city. It would be very wrong to think that just because they are in the same country, NYC works more like Phoenix or Dallas (which have just barely started to get local rail transit) than London or Paris.

Focusing on unrealistic "romantic" notions of making Davis Square a non-vehicular space distracts from smaller, important incremental changes that could be recommended which would greatly improve the square and have universal community support.

Don't we need both long-term and short-term planning to prevent different types of mistakes?

I'm curious what would you like to see in the short term.

Chris

Christopher Beland

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 12:57:14 PMSep 10
to Penelope Doherty, Glen Nuckolls, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com

On Thu, 2026-09-10 at 14:47 +0000, Penelope Doherty wrote:

Glen you bring up great points, and ones I've brought up several times to initiative leadership. If our concern is primarily traffic safety, there are quick and easy ways to address some observed pain points, with immediate results that can also inform forward movement. 

A couple of speed tables in key places and simple signage directing to nearby parking are easy to try. Such actions don't preclude people from continued visioning, but it does provide a less-risky start to the endeavor. It could also allow different goals (traffic safety vs amenities, for instance) to be addressed on their own merits instead of an all-or-nothing approach.

Not sure who "initiative leadership" is, but DSNC did include parking signage and raised tables along Elm at Day, Chester, and Grove, in our short-term improvements letter. I'm expecting a response from the Mobility Division by winter.

Glen Nuckolls wrote:

Often, one car will stop, but another is coming in the other lane fast enough that it’s not clear they will stop...The city knows how to slow cars down and it doesn’t require a multi-year study.

Yes, the Grove-Highland intersection is SO alarming and unsafe, and Mobility does want to improve it. The "first car sees you, second car doesn't" problem is called "double threat" and it sounds like the consensus way to fix that is to make Highland two-way, which would also allow better traffic detours when Elm is closed for events or if we want to pedestrianize it. That doesn't take a multi-year study, but it does take a professional traffic study to measure the impact on nearby intersections. There are also problems with trees and bike lanes and redoing the lights at Davis to solve. All of this would have happened already, except that the expected money from the Scape and Asana projects never materialized, so now Mobility is waiting for resources to free up.

I think a raised table would make a lot of sense here as well, whether the street is one-way or two-way. I believe that requires approval of a certain fraction of property owners on the street, but that should be easy to get. If the city is going to have to partly rebuild to make the street two-way, I assume it's more cost-efficient to do the raised table at the same time, much as we could use it now. In the meantime the city has upgraded a bunch of other intersections recently, Elm Street from Cutter to Somerville Ave is like 20x better to bike on compared to last month now that the protected bike lanes are in, Cambridge has started fixing the Beech Street intersection, and we're getting a complete rebuild of West Broadway.

Chris

Jim Gallagher

unread,
Sep 10, 2026, 5:32:44 PMSep 10
to Genny Marlin, DSNC Discussion
I agree with the people who want empty storefronts filled, and maybe new ones added. But there won't be more storefronts filled without more people in the square so I want more homes in the square.
I'm a transportation planner so of course I have a transportation wish - to pedestrianize Elm St. I think Somerville could make it permanently one late by next year and then a year or two for a plan tocconodate all the people who are using that lane.

And if I learned one thing in 40+ years as a planner it that a long range vision is great but without short range steps to make it happen you just get expensive door stops.
Jim Gallagher

On Tue, Sep 8, 2026, 5:50 PM Genny Marlin <genny...@gmail.com> wrote:

Curious to hear what everyone thinks — what’s one thing you’d like to see improved around Davis Square?

Could be anything from traffic and parking to pedestrian areas

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "DSNC Discussion" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dsnc-discussi...@googlegroups.com.

WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE

unread,
Sep 11, 2026, 9:24:52 AMSep 11
to Patricia Abreu, Patricia Abreu' via DSNC Discussion, Alan Ball, Ashish Shrestha, Jeff Byrnes, Adam Grossman, Ron Newman, Genny Marlin, Penelope Doherty
Hi Patricia,
 
It's good to see your name. I hope your house continues to be filled with music.
 
Well, it's not as though driving in and around Davis Square is an unalloyed joy as things stand, right? Our street meets College Ave. a tenth of a mile outside the square. Frequently, I have to wait a light cycle or so to find a break in traffic to turn onto College, and then typically another two light cycles to get into the square. As it happens, yesterday a food delivery guy had parked his little motorcycle in the bus lane, which forced a couple of buses into the travel lane, resulting in an additional light cycle.
 
Were you affected by Cambridge's elimination of a left turn from Mass Ave. inbound onto Cameron a couple of years ago? When returning from Rt. 2 or Arlington, I used to work my way home via Cameron and Paulina to Broadway and then College. Now, I'm diverted onto Rt. 16 and Broadway (or, given the recent construction near Teele Sq., to Powder House Blvd.) That's the kind of adjustment that closing Davis Square to through traffic might force.
 
Here's a question. When I passed through Davis Square fifty years ago, only three or four cars entered the expanse of the square at one time, and tracked around each other with no apparent difficulty. There wasn't a single traffic signal! (I didn't witness rush hour; perhaps that was different.) What changed?
 
No doubt there are more cars per household in the streets surrounding the square, possibly each generating more trips per day. But, it beggars belief that that alone could account for the massive increase in traffic.
 
Possibly a larger radius of streets contribute to traffic in the street today than was the case fifty years ago. Still, that doesn't seem to explain the current situation.
 
The current freeway section of Rt. 2 through Arlington and Belmont, and I-93 were completed about fifty years ago. We'd have to enlist a traffic engineer to know for sure, but my hunch is that these major highways, together perhaps with the Pike and other projects, have funneled traffic from the outer suburbs onto roadways in Boston and the inner suburbs that just can't absorb the volume. The result is traffic finding its way through all manner of streets, like water forcing its way through cracks in a pipe.
 
As Chris Beland put it with such characteristic clarity and depth of knowledge, Davis Square was designed as the commercial center in a streetcar suburb. Why should we tolerate it serving as a substitute thoroughfare for traffic that has trouble squeezing its way along Rt. 16, the McGrath Highway, etc., etc.?
 
To Jim Gallagher's (sp?) point about taking an incremental approach--I don't doubt this is sound advice. But, I do think it's important to insist, in the not too distant future, on eliminating through traffic from Davis Square.
 
[There can be be pitfalls in an incremental approach. Reminds me of a joke about the Belgians, who were debating whether to change from driving on the left to driving on the right, as in all neighboring countries. One parliamentarian, "Let's not do this all at once. First, only trucks!"]
 
-Hume

Adam Grossman

unread,
Sep 11, 2026, 4:59:54 PMSep 11
to Penelope Doherty, Glen Nuckolls, Alan Ball, Ashish Shrestha, hu...@comcast.net, Jeff Byrnes, Ron Newman, Ron Newman' via DSNC Discussion, Genny Marlin
Perhaps Davis Square has a significant amount of pass-through traffic because it is an integral part of an extended urban network. It is not like Assembly Row, the Seaport, Disneyworld, Winchester, a backwater, college town, tourist trap, gated community or any of a large number of places I don’t want to live. It is a dynamic urban space which is by its nature noisy and chaotic. It is home to a wide variety of residents, varying in age, income and ability. It will always be a little messy, which is why I continue to live here. It is a great place to live, work and play. It does not need to become a playground.
 
Adam Grossman
 

David Booth

unread,
Sep 12, 2026, 7:08:41 AMSep 12
to dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
On 9/10/26 10:45, 'Patricia Abreu' via DSNC Discussion wrote:
> . . . I do not wish to have to run a side-street obstacle course
> around the square just to get home

I frequently do exactly that already, to avoid the traffic congestion
backed up through Davis Square. And I live on Elm Street.

David Booth

Beth Kevles

unread,
Sep 12, 2026, 12:29:14 PMSep 12
to David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Hi --

I'm curious how one defines "cut through" traffic? I almost never drive into Davis Square myself, outside of the occasional Atrius appointment or when I'm picking up large quantities of produce from the farmer's market. On those occasions, I just find the nearest on-street parking where my Somerville permit is valid.

I do, however, sometimes drive through on my way home. I live within a 1/2 mile of the square. Depending on where I'm coming from, driving through is often my best option.

So ... what defines "cut through" in people's opinions? And, if traffic is very slow (as it usually is near the square), is it actually a problem? If it is, what is the nature of the problem?

My own wish list for Davis, by the way, includes far more handicap parking, more 15-minute spots for people picking up either take-out or people, and more buildings with retail on the ground floor plus residential units on upper floors, with most buildings being 4-6 stories high and fairly dense in terms of units/building. (Ie, mostly units with individual rooms that are small to tiny so they can't be confused with "luxury".) I'd also love cleaner, more attractive public spaces, which to me means regular (multiple times per day) inspection and cleaning of such spaces. 

--Beth

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "DSNC Discussion" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dsnc-discussi...@googlegroups.com.

Lovan Chetty

unread,
Sep 13, 2026, 12:17:59 PMSep 13
to Beth Kevles, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Based on the economics of Copper Mill, I am not sure how one has a financially viable project that is restricted to 4-6 stories. If the goal is more units available, then we should have the minimum height be determined by economics. If we have taller buildings a block or 2 from a T-Stop, I personally do not see an issue.

Cheers
Lovan

On Sep 12, 2026, at 12:29 PM, Beth Kevles <bethk...@gmail.com> wrote:



Alan Ball

unread,
Sep 13, 2026, 12:29:08 PMSep 13
to Lovan Chetty, Beth Kevles, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Copper mill asserted a false economy based on inflated commercial rental rates. The landlord needs to accept that the rates per square foot in Davis Square are not commensurate with much higher rates in other more developed areas, like Boston or some areas in Cambridge. There is no reason a development within the current zoning restrictions could not be completed based on an actual market rental rates.



--

Elizabeth Merrick

unread,
Sep 13, 2026, 2:25:51 PMSep 13
to Alan Ball, Lovan Chetty, Beth Kevles, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
I personally don’t accept at face value any unsupported assertions of a developer, and also don’t see why we should be boxed into agreeing to any out of scale project based on such assertions about what’s economically viable. Of course it’s possible Copper Mill or other developer finds something truly not viable because of their own faulty business decisions, but again , none of that should  hold the neighborhood hostage. Surely  there are some ethical, responsible developers who will recognize what’s reasonable and work with us for win-win outcome. But I’m placing my hope in Davis Square planning process to help lay groundwork for broadly acceptable development guidelines.

Elizabeth Merrick 


From: dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com <dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com> on behalf of Alan Ball <alb...@abidstudio.com>
Sent: Sunday, September 13, 2026 12:29 PM
To: Lovan Chetty <lov...@outlook.com>
Cc: Beth Kevles <bethk...@gmail.com>; dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com <dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com>

Subject: Re: [DSNC-Discussion] Improved around Davis Square?

Ashish Shrestha

unread,
Sep 13, 2026, 2:48:49 PMSep 13
to Elizabeth Merrick, Alan Ball, Lovan Chetty, Beth Kevles, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
I did some back-of-the-envelope math in another email thread discussing Copper Mill's numbers, so I'm just going to paste a summary here to understand what we're dealing with:

At the $40 million price point the Danas asked for, a 6% loan at a 30 year timeline would be ~200k/mo (I don't work in real estate and don't know what actual developer loans look like, so someone else can correct me).  That is just the land price, not including labor, materials, upkeep, etc.

At 200k/mo with ~3.5k/unit pricing, that's ~60 market-rate units (plus 12 affordable units) just to break even on the land.  At the ~20 units per floor that CM was expecting, that would be 3.5 floors just to cover the land costs.

The only way to develop the Elm-Grove lot is to either build very tall, or convince the Danas to drop their price.  This is all my math, you don't need to trust the developer for any of it.

Christopher Beland

unread,
Sep 13, 2026, 4:33:29 PMSep 13
to Alan Ball, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com

On Sun, 2026-09-13 at 12:28 -0400, Alan Ball wrote:

There is no reason a development within the current zoning restrictions could not be completed based on an actual market rental rates.

The Elm-Grove site is currently zoned commercial-only, and the office rental market has crashed. Based on how developers are behaving in response to actual commercial market rental rates, no redevelopment here is currently feasible.

Examples:

  • A 9-story R&D and office building at 50 Webster Ave in Union Square is fully permitted but construction is on hold "waiting for commercial leasing conditions to improve". Now there's a vacant lot for the indefinite future, as the previous building has already been demolished. USQ master overlay zoning here requires 60% of floor area to be commercial use for that height. The crash in the R&D market is also why the fully permitted Scape lab building in Davis failed to materialize.
  • The owner of One Union Square said in a community meeting the other day that an all-commercial 6-story building there would not be financially feasible. They have been proposing a zoning change to MR6 to allow upper-story residential with ground floor retail. Half the storefronts on this site (which is nearly all of the south side of the main Union Square intersection) are now vacant, for the same reason half the Elm-Grove storefronts are vacant - retail tenants have been scared away by the impending redevelopment, but loud local voices have resulted in zoning that prevents any redevelopment from actually happening.
  • Boston is actively giving developers money to convert existing commercial construction to residential, to simultaneously reduce the high commercial vacancy rate and high residential rents.

It looks like Union is becoming the next Davis by making the same mistake - keeping the pre-COVID core commercial-only zoning that no longer matches the local economy. Because we have a lot of under-developed land around our rapid transit stations, we don't have to go as far as Boston. The obvious solution is to change both squares from CC to MR zoning, which keeps ground floor retail on main streets, but allows commercial or residential on the upper floors based on what the market needs at the time of construction.

It does seem a lot more likely that a 6-story mixed-use development at Elm and Grove is financially feasible. Maybe. That would be mostly wood construction; on top of whatever is going to happen with tariffs on imported Canadian lumber, it's also much more expensive to build in Somerville than neighboring municipalities and other metro areas, so it's that much harder to attract developers who actually want to invest here. Our requirement that 20% of units be income-restricted is effectively a heavy, permanent tax, which is perversely charged to developers who are doing the right thing and building more housing.

If we shifted the cost burden to also include property owners who are not building more housing (i.e. the entire city), it would be much smaller, and it would make a lot more projects not only feasible but financially attractive. We could do that by paying for the income-restricted housing units with tax breaks, or using general property tax revenue on buying units to make them social housing (for which we already have several local organizations).

Chris

WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE

unread,
Sep 13, 2026, 4:45:37 PMSep 13
to Ashish Shrestha, Elizabeth Merrick, Alan Ball, Lovan Chetty, Beth Kevles, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Hi Ashish,
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but as best I can tell, the assessed value of the lots making up the Copper Mill parcel comes to roughly $10M. That may be a more realistic number to work with than the $40M asking price, which we can't accept unless someone pays it.
 
However, isn't there another huge issue--the cost per unit for construction? Per a quick Google query, that comes to $350 - $550K per 2-bedroom unit in Somerville for a multi-story structure, exclusive of architecture, engineering, permitting and financing costs. Those "soft costs" apparently add 20% to 40% to the total.
 
Taking the mid-point for both costs, that is, $450K for a 2-bedroom unit, and 30% for soft costs, we arrive at $450 x 1.3 = $585K, or call it $600K per unit. 
 
BTW, I'm pretty sure these estimates don't account for effects of the latest round of tariffs, nor recent energy cost increases.
 
Leaving that aside...
 
Construction loan rates appear to range from 6% at the very low end for extremely well-qualified entities (do you suppose that might be for example an established insurance company building its own headquarters?) to 10%, (and much higher for entities that don't qualify for bank loans). Let's take a middle figure again, this time of 8%.
 
Am I right that works out to $48K per year per unit, or $4K per month, for loan service alone? That doesn't account for a single penny for the land, for taxes, for utilities, for building management and maintenance, or allowances for vacancies, let alone profit for the developer. Those costs, again exclusive of land costs or of profit, might run about $1.5K per month. So, we're talking about $5.5K rent per month just to break even.
 
It's true that land cost at $10M for a high-rise with 500 units would be $20K, almost a rounding error relative to $600K per unit. By comparison, land cost for a five story low-rise on the same footprint with 100 units would run to $100K, a very significant added burden. (Note that land purchased at $40M would add nearly the same burden to 500 units ($80K) as land at $10M would add to 100 units.)
 
Bottom line, our region appears to be a very challenging environment for developers, Short of various kinds of subsidies, land acquired through a Community Land Trust, or similar means, I can understand why projects in Davis Square don't seem to pencil out.
 
That's why a planning process will be extremely valuable, in evaluating Davis Square in its current state, setting a template for future modifications and development, and finding ways to leverage available programs to bring those ideas to fruition.
 
BTW, there's a nice summary of the work of the Davis Square Task Force fifty years ago at:
See p 39 ff. It's impressive work that put its stamp on the square for fifty years. Do you think we should now be planning for the next fifty years?
 
-Hume
 

Ashish Shrestha

unread,
Sep 13, 2026, 4:56:16 PMSep 13
to WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, Elizabeth Merrick, Alan Ball, Lovan Chetty, Beth Kevles, DSNC Discussion
Hi Hume,

Im not sure what the assessed price of the lot is, but Copper Mill has provided legal paperwork to MassHousing indicating the Dana family was asking for $40mil for the lot.  Even if it is legally with only 10, if the owners will not sell it for less than 40 then our options are make it profitable to buy it at 40 or do not expect any redevelopment on the lot. That's my only point. 

And thank you for doing more math to show the costs.  Im not particularly familiar with construction costs or loans so your numbers provide some more thorough context.

Jeff Byrnes

unread,
Sep 13, 2026, 8:25:46 PMSep 13
to Ashish Shrestha, WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, Elizabeth Merrick, Alan Ball, Lovan Chetty, Beth Kevles, DSNC Discussion
Hume, Ashish, thanks for your numbers.

Worth adding: The Globe ran a piece in 2023 showing hard costs for an apartment in metro Boston at $600k. I've heard it's since climbed to $700–800k, with subsidized homes (aka Affordable Housing, capitals intended) running $900k–1M.

On assessed vs. market price for the land, which has come up here a few times: the assessed price doesn’t mean much if the owner has decided their land is worth more. In this case, Copper Mill agreed to that price, and presented that in their 40B filings.

So if the Dana family holds firm on that asking price, we’ll have to accept it, even if we use eminent domain to force a sale. A Taking that doesn't meet their price means a lawsuit, & our track record there is lousy. See 90 Washington St, where the City is taking a bath: maybe $20M back on a site that cost $39M in the end. Not great, and it would mean zero redevelopment until the courts are done.

The Danas can point to Copper Mill contractually agreeing to pay $40M, so I'd guess they have a strong case that's what a Taking should cost. Not a lawyer, but it makes sense 🤷🏻‍♂️

Regardless, I don’t want to spend any of the City’s money on redevelopment when a private builder will do it for us. We’re in a tough enough spot financially as a City already.

To Chris Beland's point: if these parcels had been zoned MR6 back in 2019 during the zoning overhaul, when conditions were very different, we might already have a newer building here of modest height. Instead, larger forces mean a building that modest is unlikely to work out financially.

In short (pun intended), the lowest height that works here now might be 12 storeys. Food for thought: Porter Square on the Cambridge side is now zoned for 12–18 storeys, depending on proximity to the T station.

-- 
Jeff Byrnes
he/him

David Booth

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 8:23:56 AMSep 14
to dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Good comments, but some clarifications about fair market value . . .

On 9/13/26 20:25, Jeff Byrnes wrote:
> . . .
> On assessed vs. market price for the land, which has come up here a few
> times: the assessed price doesn’t mean much

Correct. Assessed values *very* often lag far behind true market value.
They are pretty much irrelevant in determining fair market value.

> if the owner has decided their land is worth more.

> Not correct. The owner's opinion of value is irrelevant.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/fair_market_value

> A Taking that
> doesn't meet [the Dana family's] price means a lawsuit,

They might sue, but that does not mean they will win.

> & our track record there is
> lousy. See 90 Washington St, where the City is taking a bath: maybe $20M
> back on a site that cost $39M in the end. Not great, and it would mean
> zero redevelopment until the courts are done.

Agreed, but the lesson there is that the City should have done a better
job of determining fair market value in the first place -- not that the
City should pay whatever an owner demands.

>
> The Danas can point to Copper Mill contractually agreeing to pay $40M,
> so I'd guess they have a strong case that's what a Taking should cost.
> Not a lawyer, but it makes sense 🤷🏻‍♂️

No it doesn't, because Copper Mill did not come anywhere near conforming
with current zoning. Their willingness to pay $40M was *predicated* on
being able to build 26 stories, which was a total fantasy. Heck, I
would be willing to pay $100M, provided that I am able to become the
king of France. That does not suddenly make the property worth $100M.

Thanks,
David Booth

WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 10:11:30 AMSep 14
to David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
David,

In furtherance of your points, and FWIW:

According to Google AI:

"In late 2024, 1840 Mass Ave (a 0.3-acre/13,258 sq. ft. parking lot) and the adjacent 1826 Mass Ave lot were sold together by Lesley University to the nonprofit developer Just A Start for $10,500,000 across a combined 25,277 square feet of land."

and

"The now-failed Copper Mill mixed-use tower development project spanned a combined lot size of approximately 0.78 acres (roughly 34,000 square feet)."

My comments:

The sale price of the Porter Square lots comes to $415 / sq. ft.

Applying that value to the Copper Mill parcels yields a total of:
($415 / sq. ft.) x 34,000 sq. ft. = $14.1M

Is there a reason the Porter Square lots wouldn't represent a roughly fair comparable? In that case the $40M figure is a pipe dream.

-Hume
> --
> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "DSNC Discussion" group.
> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dsnc-discussi...@googlegroups.com.
> To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/dsnc-discussion/de79cc18-9900-4064-bd08-0ae4b1ac5405%40dbooth.org.

Colin McMillen

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 10:24:20 AMSep 14
to WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
I don't trust anything Google AI says -- please link to a real source that backs up its claims.

That said: Lesley University is undergoing a huge financial crisis and is undergoing massive cost-cutting measures (and leadership changes) to try to avoid shutting down. In real estate terms, this makes them a "motivated seller" that was probably happy to find any buyer -- especially a nonprofit -- and give them favorable terms so that they could get cash on hand quickly. 

I agree that the Dana / Copper Mill estimates are all on the high side *because* the proposal was for such a large tower, but it wouldn't surprise me if zoning for a half-size tower of 12-13 stories would still put the value of that land at something like 20-25M. 

Jeff Byrnes

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 10:51:21 AMSep 14
to Colin McMillen, WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Colin, I happen to know the info Hume pulled from Google is accurate, I followed along JAS’s purchase of those two surface parking lots from Lesley.

If anyone is interested, you can learn more about the project on its website, and read the press release from when they purchased the lots (which confirms the sale price of $10.5M).

Regarding “the owner's opinion of value is irrelevant”, this is a “multiple things are true” situation.

The owner can choose to never sell if the market never reaches a price point they’ll accept, provided they’re willing to continuously take a loss on the property in terms of carrying costs (taxes, upkeep, etc) if it stops producing enough revenue.

299 Broadway is an example of this, the owner held it for over a decade, despite the defunct Star Market & disused parking lot.

So to clarify, I wasn’t arguing what the actual market-clearing price is, which to David’s & Hume’s points is likely lower than $40M, but that the Dana Family may choose to be irrational about the economics at play because one time a buyer dangled $40M in front of them.

Hume, one thing to note is that the price of land in 2024 is less than it is today, that $10.5M number is 2024 dollars, and Just-A-Start will be building a 100% subsidized project at 1840 & 1826 Mass Ave, as is their business. So not quite apples-to-apples in terms of valuation. Then there’s Colin’s point that Lesley is in financial crisis.

My worry is that the current owners can choose to hold out for a very long time, potentially indefinitely, if they really like that $40M price tag, regardless of the actual market.

As for a “total fantasy”, there’s nothing fantastical about changing our zoning to allow for taller buildings. Assembly, Union Square, and Boynton Yards are already entitled to taller buildings, as is Porter Square with its new 12 to 18 storey zoning.

Then there’s Central Square with its Market Central high-rise at 19 storeys. Useful to note that the zoning for Market Central is an overlay atop an overlay atop the base zoning, and was written specifically to entitle that project, which was called Mass + Main at the time, to be built. You can review the zoning language in Cambridge’s Zoning Ordinance in section 20.307 Mass and Main Residential Mixed Income Subdistrict (scroll to 20.307).

How tall we allow Davis Square to be is entirely an arbitrary policy decision.
-- 
-Jeff Byrnes

Frank Mals

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 11:01:48 AMSep 14
to Colin McMillen, WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Colin, respectfully I don't think it's fair to scold someone for citing google (clearly disclosed and as it turns out accurate) and immediately following it up with an opinion that doesn't cite anything at all. 

Regards,
Frank

Ashish Shrestha

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 11:08:11 AMSep 14
to Frank Mals, Colin McMillen, WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
An uncited claim is honest in its lack of citation, while an AI-sourced claim is dishonest in that it claims to be cited but in reality could be entirely made up.  We've had multiple conversations now where an AI-sourced claim has been used to underpin an argument and been wildly off reality, but psychologically the fake citation discourages fact-checking because it has been "cited" via an AI.

Personally I think we should ban all AI statistics from our discussions.  If you want to use an AI to do your research, the only proper way is to ask it for its citation and follow up on the primary source.  And never use it for an opinion.

We are, of course, quickly veering off topic.

Colin McMillen

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 11:36:53 AMSep 14
to Ashish Shrestha, Frank Mals, WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
As a former AI researcher, my biggest concern with citing AI is that it is specifically bad at finding the "right" number in a source document if there are multiple numbers in close proximity and insufficient surrounding context to disambiguate them. We've had numerous examples on this very mailing list of people citing AI numbers that later turned out to be incorrect.

Most reputable AIs, including Google's, provide links to the source documents and it only take a couple minutes to click through and make sure that the AI claim is actually correct in context. In this case, the $10.5M number is sourced from official Cambridge city hall documents here:

Tomas Bok

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 12:51:32 PMSep 14
to Colin McMillen, WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Colin,

Your "half-size tower of 12-13 stories" is anchoring to the wrong number. 26 stories was just a developer's fantasy. The current zoning is 4 stories, and the city's 2019 draft plan proposed increasing that to 4-6 stories (with significant thought and supporting science behind that choice, not just plucking from thin air). If we adopted 4-6-story zoning, Davis Square has the potential to add 500+ units of housing without building any towers.

Folks on this forum also frequently compare Davis Square to Union Square, where the 25-story Prospect tower was completed a few years ago. But Somerville's development master plan (Somervision 2040) clearly differentiates Davis (priority = "Enhance") from Union Square and Assembly Row (priority = "Transform"). If the city allows 12-story towers in Davis Square when they release the new neighborhood plan next year, it would represent a major reversal.

On Mon, Sep 14, 2026 at 10:24 AM Colin McMillen <co...@mcmillen.dev> wrote:

Christopher Beland

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 1:12:51 PMSep 14
to Tomas Bok, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com

On Mon, 2026-09-14 at 12:51 -0400, Tomas Bok wrote:

Somerville's development master plan (Somervision 2040) clearly differentiates Davis (priority = "Enhance") from Union Square and Assembly Row (priority = "Transform"). If the city allows 12-story towers in Davis Square when they release the new neighborhood plan next year, it would represent a major reversal.

I would argue putting a residential tower, ground-level retail, and a T stop on Prospect Street was a big transformation compared to the radiator scrap yard that was there. Putting a residential tower next to an existing T stop and above existing ground floor retail on Elm Street seems like more of an enhancement than a transformation.

Somervision 2040 was completed pre-COVID; since then, the housing crisis has gotten a lot worse, and the commercial real estate market has crashed, so I think it is time to re-examine several of its core assumptions.

Davis Square has the potential to add 500+ units of housing without building any towers.

Just for context, the 2016 Winter Hill Neighborhood Plan noted Somerville would need 8,145 to 14,625 housing units by 2030 just to keep up with demand. We've only built 3,506 since then, leaving a city-wide gap of 11119 at the high end (which seems fair given what's happened since 2016). To bridge that gap in the next four years, we'd need 22 projects like Copper Mill (500 units), 62 projects like the proposed One Union Square (180 units, 6 stories, eating up an entire city block), or to convert all ~4,000 detached single family homes and ~1500 duplexes into triple-deckers. Not all of that needs to happen in Davis, but it would mitigate traffic congestion if high-density buildings were near Red, Green, and Orange Line stops.

-B.

David Booth

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 2:31:31 PMSep 14
to dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
On 9/14/26 12:51, Tomas Bok wrote:
> . . . The current zoning is
> 4 stories, and the city's 2019 draft plan proposed increasing that to
> 4-6 stories

A zoning increase from 4 to 6 stories would have minimal effect, because
very few buildings would *actually* be increased to 6 stories. It is
not usually economically worthwhile to tear down a functioning 4-story
building just to increase the height by two stories (unless the building
already needed to be replaced). One-story buildings would be stronger
candidates for replacement, but even those would not be replaced all at
once.

In other words, since the Davis Square area has *very* few empty lots,
for any zoning height increase to have a significant effect on housing
supply, the height increase needs to be large enough to make
tear-down-and-rebuild economically viable. I do not believe a zoning
change to 6 stories would be enough to do that.

Thanks,
David Booth

Jeff Kaufman

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 3:47:30 PMSep 14
to Tomas Bok, Colin McMillen, WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
Hi Tomas,

When you say things like adding 500+ units of housing without building any towers, that would mean demolishing almost every building in Davis Sq to replace them with ones 4-6 stories tall.  That would be far more disruptive, and (rightly!) extremely unpopular.

Jeff

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "DSNC Discussion" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to dsnc-discussi...@googlegroups.com.

Tomas Bok

unread,
Sep 14, 2026, 6:42:31 PMSep 14
to Jeff Kaufman, Colin McMillen, WILLIAM-VANCE WILLIAM-VANCE, David Booth, dsnc-di...@googlegroups.com
I agree that demolishing every building in Davis Square would be unpopular, but that's a twisted caricature of what was a very simple point. Davis Square has significant untapped capacity for adding housing. It doesn't have to be a tower. For example, the 2019 DS neighborhood plan shows sketches of a new development at 233-239 Elm Street (Copper Mill lot) with a 5-story tower (with top floor step-back) that has capacity for 120,000 sq ft of residential. That plan identifies a few other high-priority lots that could be developed as well. There is also the vacant lot on Highland. And it can happen over time.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages