End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.

3 views
Skip to first unread message

Hoopy Frood

unread,
May 15, 2008, 10:08:25 PM5/15/08
to DopervilleMafia
This post is going to be a bit stream of consciousness since I don't
really have time to do a full analysis or write a nice cohesive post,
but hopefully I get some ideas out and spur some discussion.

First of all, I think it will help us if we all give our relative
experience. I know peekercpa has only played in simpletown, and he was
a mason, IIRC. I've only played in Batman as town role-blocker. On a
side note, I manged to actually save the game for town on night two,
mainly because I blocked Rysto's investigation of Joker, which would
have turned him to Playing For Keeps. Of course, if Rysto hadn't had
led a bandwagon of townies to lynch Atarus, I probably wouldn't have
blocked everyone that following night. I know bufftabby has the most
experience of us all, but I don't know many times she's played scum.
And I don't know about cckerberos' background at all.

Now the reason I mention the Batman thing was not to brag, but to
raise a point about the various bandwagons. Thing Fish was a nice
bandwagon that was spurred almost entirely by town. (Much like
Atarus's was.) In fact, peekercpa was the only scum on that one and he
showed up much later. And on anyrose, that bandwagon appeared largely
after scum was on it. In fact, everyone switching to her later in the
game looks a bit suspicious. These two points are important.

Had Thing Fish died, we could have pressed town big time on it and
really only risked one member. Unfortunately, we can't press town on
the anyrose thing, since we have two scum there which means we run the
risk of unintentionally throwing one of us under the bus. The nice
thing was town was sewing discord among themselves, we pretty much
were able to coast. I'm going to miss anyrose, mainly because she
provided such a lovely distraction. She wins the "Scum's Most Valuable
Townie" award so far.

Now the nice thing is Thing Fish's last minute change looks a bit
scummy. However, self-preservation is largely a null tell, so I don't
know where we can go with it. If we're lucky, town will pick up right
where they left off and Thing Fish will be under the microscope again.

Now, as far as who to whack, well the #1 person not to whack is
fluiddruid. She fingered peeker, and was the only one to do so. We
whack her, it pretty much will draw attention to peeker. I don't want
to whack anyone on the anyrose bandwagon, because there are two scum
on it, and most who changed still weren't certain about Thing Fish. I
think we can play this to our advantage. I wanted to whack Blaster
Master because he is probably the single biggest danger to us in
general, but when it looked like Thing Fish was going to die, I didn't
want to whack anyone on that bandwagon, because town might look for
scum there. However, with Thing Fish alive, I think whacking Blaster
Master will not only get rid of a formidable enemy, but will also
indicate to town that maybe the votes on Thing Fish hit a little close
to scum home. So he's my choice, unless anyone has a better idea.

Now future strategy. Running the numbers on Batman put scum at a huge
advantage according to storyteller. Scum lost mainly because they
never discussed strategy in that game. Let's not make that mistake.

I think we need to discuss each night who would be a likely candidate
to throw under the bus if needed. I am a vanilla goon, so I have no
problems being sacrificed if it's necessary to get someone some
desperately needed townie cred. Do we have any power roles among us?
(With only four, I'm guessing we'd probably only have a godfather.)

Also, we need to figure out what we do for claims should we be outed.

These are my preliminary thoughts. I'll post any more I come up with.

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 15, 2008, 10:29:37 PM5/15/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
I thought we did pretty well also. I have never played scum before, so you and I are probably pretty equal on that part, Hoopy. I like the bit me and peeker have going on together where we're disagreeing here and there. It'll serve nicely if either one of us gets the old heave-ho. I love letting Town do the work for us, and I'm surprised the Thing Fish vote swung over to anyrose. She was an excellent distraction, and I was hoping she would stay that way. Oh well. I think cckerberos and I got in early enough not to be too suspicious. Hell, I even cast the dreaded third vote. I laughed as I did it, too! As for who to lynch now: I would love to lynch BlaM. My only concern is that the Doc would be protecting him. I think he could even possibly BE the Doc. He gave advice to the Doc, which could be an easy cover on that. Of course in a game full of newbs, the Doc might not realize how wise it would be to protect BlaM. I think even if we fail at killing him, it'll give us some insight into who the doc is. If they do protect BlaM, we can narrow down our suspects to those who've at least followed along for a few games. I think it's worth a shot to give the BlaM lynch a try toNight, but if we fail, to go ahead and branch out.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: Hoopy Frood <hoopyf...@gmail.com>

Date: Thu, 15 May 2008 19:08:25
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.

cckerberos

unread,
May 16, 2008, 12:36:44 AM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
I also think today went pretty smoothly. None of us have raised too
many eyebrows, and a townie got lynched. fluiddruid seems to be going
after peekercpa, but I really don't understand why.

My personal strategy for the Day went off the rails towards the end; I
was the second vote on anyrose, but I didn't expect her to end up on
the block in the end. I voted her because she was acting strangely and
I thought it would earn me some town cred when it was revealed that
Thing Fish was innocent and set her up as a possible second lynch. The
bandwagon against Thing Fish was a bit strange in that it seemed to me
that he was doing a good job defending himself and it was never based
upon all that much. I think the only reason that it failed in the end
was that Blaster Master disappeared and wasn't able to keep the
pressure on. Well, that and because anyrose had a total meltdown after
I voted for her. Anyway, two of us were involved with her lynching but
I don't think that there's going to be any significant blowback from
that; she was just acting too suspiciously.

In terms of online Mafia experience, I have absolutely none. I read
simpletown and bits and pieces of some mafiascum games as well as most
of the strategy articles on the mafiascum wiki, but this is my first
online game. Which leads me to one strategy question: why don't masons
immediately roleclaim? I don't see major benefits from whacking
confirmed masons, and by claiming they protect themselves from
lynching and add considerably to the information held by town.

Thoughts regarding whacking Blaster Master: I can see the benefits to
whacking him, but am concerned because he's so high profile. I think
he'd be an obvious choice for the Doc to protect. Also, it seems
possible that he might continue the attack on Thing Fish during the
next day. He can build a lot of momentum for a bandwagon, so I don't
mind seeming him around so long as he's not pointing at any of us. The
question is, is he stubborn enough to continue his attack on Thing
Fish?

Oh, I'm also vanilla scum, btw.

Hoopy Frood

unread,
May 16, 2008, 1:12:24 AM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
Actually, Masons are prime targets to get whacked early if they claim
early. The reason being, you get rid of town that are easily confirmed
and never get lynched. Town benefits from lynches in that it narrows
the pool of possible scum. Town also benefits from nightkills on
unconfirmed town for the same reason. That is why it's always wise to
nightkill confirmed town. Town will never lynch them. And by
nightkilling town that are exposed, you reveal nothing to town. This
is why masons are reluctant to claim early.

However, once the pool gets narrowed and things are revealed, Masons
claim to narrow the pool further, with the idea that scum helped with
their nightkills.

And even though the doctor might block Blaster, usually doctors self-
block on night 1, unless they can't. There typically is no reason to
protect someone other then yourself on Night 1 unless you think a
power role is exposed and scum have realized it as well.

The nice thing about anyrose getting lynched is that Naf won't show
up. Apparently we have nothing but newbie scum. Going up against the
combined likes of BlaM and Naf and throwing Dotchan/DeathByIrony,
Koldanar, and fluidruid into the mix makes for a very deadly town.
Heck, it's bad enough as it is without the guy.

I'm just glad storyteller isn't playing town in this one.

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 16, 2008, 1:36:14 AM5/16/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
I don't really think BlaM will continue against Thing Fish. I think if he'd had more time w/o RL interference he would have eventually removed his vote anyway. I'm definitely concerned about him being protected, but I wanna say this could be a newb enough game to pull off a Night One BlaM lynch. But there's also value in leaving him alive. There is the "why is Blam still alive" wifom that starts to develop by about Day Three or so. He can be distracting, which can really be a good thing. Plus, if he happens to be the Doc, he'll likely protect himself continuously, unless the detective manages to drop some good breadcrumbs like NAF did in Recruitment.

My other Nightkill candidate would be Koldanar. He's got some experience, but there's not really much risk involved.

Dotchan definitely stays alive. Rumor has it she's gonna get lynched eventually anyway. :)
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: cckerberos <ccker...@hotmail.com>

Date: Thu, 15 May 2008 21:36:44
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 16, 2008, 1:40:28 AM5/16/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
I have not played w storyteller, but I hear he is superhardcore. RoOsh had me running in circles in Simpletown; I'd hate to run up against him as Town my first time as scum. NAF's pretty good too; as soon as I saw he might be anyrose's sub, I was hoping pretty fervently that the lynch on her would succeed.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: Hoopy Frood <hoopyf...@gmail.com>

Date: Thu, 15 May 2008 22:12:24
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



golf

unread,
May 16, 2008, 8:19:10 AM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
howdy guys

as noted I have only played one game as a Mason.

couple of thoughts before i run out and available more this weekend.
real life does really exist after all

i can post a lot on weekends not so much during the week but can ramp
it up now that i am through with month end and some other ankle biters
that i had at work

i am vanilla but my pm says "...nothing can prevent you from killing
the rest of them." does this mean no doc which would mean two detecs
or whole shit pot of masons

i think that i am going to be the weak link of this group so will
defer to the groups judgement. however i do think a fluid lynch is
only going to point to me especially with blam in the mix. if he was
the first too bring this up we might be able to pull off a being lead
by the nose type of situation, however.

and i think yesterday went stellar. i am the only one being looked at
by anyone and fluiddruid can be tenacious so if we need to toss
someone under the bus i would be the right one.



On May 16, 12:40 am, bethanypa...@gmail.com wrote:
> I have not played w storyteller, but hear he is superhardcore. RoOsh had me running in circles in Simpletown; I'd hate to run up against him as Town my first time as scum. NAF's pretty good too; as soon as I saw he might be anyrose's sub, I was hoping pretty fervently that the lynch on her would succeed.
> I'm just glad storyteller isn't playing town in this one.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

golf

unread,
May 16, 2008, 8:32:02 AM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
and one last thought before i go and am unavailable for about 12
hours. is there any way we can get after the folks that started to
jump ship off of thing fish. that really was a remarkable last minute
turnaround. i think we should be safe since our votes were there
really early. also, anything that is totally random is going to eff
with the more experienced players - in my mind fluid, blam and
colddinner. gotta be careful with this one, however, since one of
them is might bring up the newbie scum observation
> > - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -

cog...@yahoo.com

unread,
May 16, 2008, 8:42:50 AM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
[mod]
Allow me to clarify, golf (bufftabby).
What you quoted was from your win condition.
It means that you can win with townies still alive (you kill them in
the "endgame") but only if "nothing can prevent you from killing
the rest of them"
It is not an indication of the game setup or possible roles.
[/mod]

golf

unread,
May 16, 2008, 8:51:22 AM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
fuck now i am not only the worst player in the game but apparently i
have lost my testicles and penis as well

peek

Hoopy Frood

unread,
May 16, 2008, 9:21:57 AM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
Well, if you weren't using them for anything important.... :)

cog...@yahoo.com

unread,
May 16, 2008, 9:25:30 AM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
sorry.... golf = peekercpa

Hoopy Frood

unread,
May 16, 2008, 9:46:37 AM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
So it appears our nightkill comes down to Blaster or Koldanar.

I'm fine with either one. I will say this about the "Why is Blaster
still alive?" thing. While it does tend to provide a distraction, I
don't think it's ever lead to his lynch. Plus, Blaster being Blaster,
he is a prime target for detectives. If I were town detective, I'd
probably investigate him on night 1. I would much rather have him dead
than rely on a slim chance town will lynch him because he's too
powerful to keep alive. It's a WIFOM situation with him being alive,
and it seems to me that when you have a WIFOM reason to do something
in addition to other reasons, throw out the WIFOM and just look at the
other reasons. So since we have a formidable foe, I say we take him
out, rather than rely on town to do so. They have a bigger fish to fry
(pun intended) at this point.

So I vote Blaster for night kill, but I am fine with Koldanar if you
guys prefer him since he'd be my second choice.

Also, since none of us are the godfather and have no other powers, I
think we're playing in a fairly basic game. There are probably 2
masons, one doctor, and one detective. There might be some other roles
(I'll have to look at the balance formula sometime to see what town
distributions balance), but if so, town will have some crippling role
out there to balance. After all, BlaM himself said before the game
started:

"4 Scum (no Godfather), 1 Detective, 1 Doctor, 2 Masons, 6 Vanilla
Townies" is a balanced setup, especially when applying JSexton's
formula.

We know that we are all just scum goons with no powers. We also know
that there are no blockers since the night kill doesn't rotate. It's
also likely that ThingFish is vanilla. He claimed as much and his
behavior screams newbie vanilla. I didn't join his lynch because town
was doing a fine job of the bandwagon on him by themselves, and I
really wouldn't have thought him likely scum even if I didn't already
know he wasn't.

Unfortunately, I don't get a read from anyone else. I think Tomorrow
we really have to start looking for breadcrumbs (whether intentional
or not). It seems newbie masons tend to flock together, and chances
are good at least one of the masons is new. I'm pretty sure this would
count out fluiddruid as a mason. (BTW, she would be my # 3 choice to
nightkill if not for the peekercpa thing--right now we leave her alive
until she backs off). I'd be also willing to bet that the masons voted
the same yesterday. (Heck, the raw chances put us really only slightly
below 50 percent for that matter even before figuring in motivation.)

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 16, 2008, 7:21:26 PM5/16/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
Let's hit Koldanar first, then maybe BlaM tomorrow. Not sure why; I've got a feeling on Koldanar, and ii know it doesn't mean he's scum! He says he's *always* cautious w his Day one vote, but he seemed *really* cautious, like he might be an important power role and he doesn't want to risk appearing scummy or having to out himself.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: Hoopy Frood <hoopyf...@gmail.com>

Date: Fri, 16 May 2008 06:46:37
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



golf

unread,
May 16, 2008, 9:01:08 PM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
I'm with whatever you gals/guys decide. Blam, Koldanar or Fluid. And
no matter what if I get in the weeds for og's sake throw me under the
bus. I don't even particularily mind a Fluid whack job. WIFOM and
all that.

If one of us starts to get cornered - false role claim or what and if
so, Doc, Detec or Mason? Or should be just ride the lightening in
silence?

Also, I don't see fluid's catch but .... Ramp it up or tone it down.
I really was hosed in real life most of last week but should be more
available next week so I should be able to to either way.

golf

unread,
May 16, 2008, 9:18:53 PM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
And total Metagame observation.

Blam and Koldanar are for sure in Cecilvania (not sure about Fluid but
will check). I got the distinct impression that they were in this one
just waiting for that one to start up.

Now that it is rolling I believe that they are going to only be paying
marginal attention to this game. I mean Naf even made some sort of
all star reference in that games forbidden thread.

So to the extent that they will be only skimming this thread I think
that some of their more normal scrutiny will be directed elsewhere.

And although they do have experience they still put their pants on one
leg at a time. FCS I for sure know that Fluid has never made it alive
to the end and am pretty sure that for the other two the survival rate
has been rather low. With this group you have two folks that made it
to the end in Simpletown. Course one was dumb luck (moi) because I
was a Mason and one who played damn good (buffer).

golf

unread,
May 16, 2008, 9:35:55 PM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
Fluid is not playing or that I can tell is even on a sub list. Maybe
we can post a whole crud load of ops in the pit to keep her
distracted. LOL

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 16, 2008, 10:05:47 PM5/16/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
Dude that is a freaking hilarious idea. I bet FD will laugh her ass off if she checks out the scum board after the game ends
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: golf <Philip...@christushealth.org>

Date: Fri, 16 May 2008 18:35:55
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



golf

unread,
May 16, 2008, 10:10:04 PM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
Is there any leverage to be had in taking Dothchan's late unvote of
anyrose that was not going to be counted if the mod played fair to
target her tomorrow?

And I think after deciding on a lynch target we also need to come up
with a couple of candidates to be "assisting" the town on whom to
lynch tomorrow.

P.s. This is what happens when I get to do a whole massive data dump
after being out of touch for a while.

golf

unread,
May 16, 2008, 11:45:41 PM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
A thought for tomorrow. Unkempt moved his vote late to anyrose
basically making it 50/50 proposition. He'll be my lynch target
tomorrow unless someone objects.

I am still down with our favored lynch targets but would like to hear
more regarding strategy.

Claim or no and also manana's strategy. And let's see if a vet
nibbles on the batman crumb.

golf

unread,
May 16, 2008, 11:52:21 PM5/16/08
to DopervilleMafia
And let's take this till the end. Having said that I feel we need to
have a concensus in about 24 hours.

Current choices
Koldanar
Fluid
Blam

Let's get some sense of urgency people.

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 12:00:37 AM5/17/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
Can you explain the batman crumb? I didn't watch that one.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: golf <Philip...@christushealth.org>

Date: Fri, 16 May 2008 20:52:21
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



golf

unread,
May 17, 2008, 12:40:34 AM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia

golf

unread,
May 17, 2008, 1:00:11 AM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
Ok. My wife also thinks I am an idiot. On my last fluff post - I am
fishing to see if my Robin comment might be construed as a Batman
comment - leader of the good guys/scum in the most recent off board
game. I'm wondering if someone real subtle like a Blam might read
something into it. Town can't strategize during the night but their
comments can still be used - see DSI. If I can get one of the more
experienced players to think I am breadcombing during innocent
exchanges then the more power to us. Just the way my mind works.
Like last game we played I saw a Naf blam ryj conspiracy with throwing
ryj under the bus as being the holy grail of all plays. Not saying
they will bite but it's something that I would be going, huh?

Confusion is our ally, especially when it comes to the rest of the
town - heathens they be.

And there were multiple gunmen at he Kennedy assasination as well as
the moon landing being faked. LOL

cog...@yahoo.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 2:30:53 AM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
[mod]
peekercpa,
You are breaking the rules by trying to bait someone in the main
thread during the Night Phase. Please don't do this.
[/mod]

cckerberos

unread,
May 17, 2008, 2:37:45 AM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
Doc strikes me as being the best roleclaim to make, since the others
require more evidence. Would it ever be worth it to have 2 of us both
roleclaim Mason at the same time? That seems like the only way of
countering the 2 real Masons counterclaiming.

I think fluid's vote was just a gut feeling. I really didn't think
that you were doing anything scummy, so don't see a need for you to
change how you've been acting.

cckerberos

unread,
May 17, 2008, 2:40:31 AM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
Koldanar or Blam, slightly favoring Blam.

golf

unread,
May 17, 2008, 7:58:50 AM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
Ok. My bad. I won't do anything like it again.

One other thought - should we do a real quick down and dirty analysis
of how we perceive each of us to be doing in the game?

I'll start and if no one wants to join in then what the hey.

I thought as a group we did real good. Lots of posts with real meat
i. e. Not just fluff. I am probably the weal link at this point. I
think that if we keep up the same pace tomorrow the rest of you gals/
guys should be just fine. If I am in danger tomorrow I will most
likely claim doc unless, once again, you all have a different opinion.

golf

unread,
May 17, 2008, 8:50:09 AM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
I think the two for two Mason thing would be very BAD. Maybe at end
game but this early the best we could hope for would be one mislynch
at a cost of two of our brethren while also giving the stinking town a
confirmed. I think Doc is the way to go. My two cents. And I agree
it should be K B or (in my op) F. I'm leaning towards the Koldanar
whack because of my previously stated Metagame reasons and buffer's
intuition (feminine and all that, don't you know).

And I still think that Unkempt's last minute vote can/should be
exploited.

I also think that we need to have a decision by the end of today and
not wait until the last second.

Last observation, I know it's early but we have been some of the
heavier lifters so far in this game. Funny how a lynch the lurker
strategy would totally backfire with this group.

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 11:21:57 AM5/17/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
I think if one of us gets pointed out by the detective it might be worthwhile to counterclaim detective. Depending on our numbers, and the levels of trust we have at that point, it could either be the accused who counters (probably less believable) or one of the Townier-seeming scum (probably more believable, but riskier.)

I think we definitely need to make a vote decision by tonight. I've got that feeling on koldanar, but I'd really like to take out blam as well. I wanna say koldanar toNight, and BlaM tomorrow Night. Killing blam night one just seems so damn predictable, and I'm worried that it might point in the direction of more experienced players if we take him out so quickly. So yeah, VOTE KOLDANAR
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: golf <Philip...@christushealth.org>

Date: Sat, 17 May 2008 05:50:09
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



Hoopy Frood

unread,
May 17, 2008, 11:47:13 AM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
I've got an all-day wedding/reception thing today, so this will be
last night post and I probably won't be able to get to the game thread
until sometime tomorrow at the earliest.

Although I still lean towards BlaM, Bufftabby makes good points about
Koldanar, and since she feels strongly about it, I'm fine with it.

So this means that we are taking out Koldanar. Can one of you mail the
mod today and let him know? (Or alternately, the mod could confirm in
here, but the rules said that he needs it emailed or PM'ed.)

I agree that we should not claim Detective unless outed by the
detective. Doctor is a much safer claim. And Mason claim is bad. Very
bad. And I don't think a Miller claim if outed by the Detective is
going to fly.

And peekercpa, I don't think you should ramp anything down. Sudden
changes of play are usually scum tells. If she presses you again, ask
her to fully explain what seems particularly bossy, since she didn't
really explain herself very well. An "I have a feeling about this"
based vote, while often times a decent day 1 strategy, is not very
useful in later days. If she presses you, press back. Self-defense is
a null tell.

I'm out of here. I'll see you guys on the other side of the game, and
let's hope there are only 12 of us remaining when the Day starts.

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 12:05:27 PM5/17/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
I know you said you favored BlaM, cckerberos, but are you ok w a koldanar lynch? As long as you are good w that, I can go ahead and send the PM, but I wanna make sure we are all in agreement here.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: cckerberos <ccker...@hotmail.com>

Date: Fri, 16 May 2008 23:40:31
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



cckerberos

unread,
May 17, 2008, 1:33:49 PM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
Yep, I'd be okay with a Koldanar hit.

golf

unread,
May 17, 2008, 1:52:46 PM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
Let's make Koldanar tonight's Colddinner. Buff you wanna send the
p.m.? Also, I assume that we can still talk until our illustrious Mod
announces day break. Buff, once you PM Cog can you post here so that
we know that it has been taken care of.

One last thought - damn there are almost as many posts here on a per
capita basis as ther are on the game thread.

We may or may not prevail but I am glad to be part of a group that is
at least playing the durn game.

Good luck all and hopefully all of us will be around to continue these
discussions next weekend. And it goes without saying that if we have
to push someone under the bus that is only in the interest of our
team.

Mod question: Can we reread this thread during the day with no
posting or is it totally off limits during the Day?

Let's Rock and Roll.

Woot Woot - Go SCUM

golf

unread,
May 17, 2008, 2:28:16 PM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
And FCS if CoG ends the night early let's not look like a buch of
eager beavers as if we knew that the next day was getting ready to
start.

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 3:12:17 PM5/17/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
I think that once we send the pm we can't talk here anymore, so I'll hold off on that until this evening, and I'll let everybody know when I get it in.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: golf <Philip...@christushealth.org>

Date: Sat, 17 May 2008 11:28:16
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



golf

unread,
May 17, 2008, 3:49:50 PM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
Sounds like a plan. So I guess we've got a couple of hours to finish
up. Does anyone have a specific person they plan on targeting
tomorrow? Just so we can complement each other's arguments.

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 3:57:13 PM5/17/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
I kinda wanna see where the townies take things, and try to get on a vote that won't go through, since I was definitely on the last successful bandwagon, but I don't want it to look like too much of a one-off. I'd like the town to do the work on this one, and maybe target anybody the next Day who appeared on both town lynches.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: golf <Philip...@christushealth.org>

Date: Sat, 17 May 2008 12:49:50
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



golf

unread,
May 17, 2008, 3:57:34 PM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
And buffer I assume you will post here that the hit has been
launched. And I agree that any further discussion here is pretty much
off bounds unless the Mod were to state differently.

But can we come back and read?

And make sure you let CoG know someplace other than the live thread.
Don't need zuma version 2.1. LOL

Also, will our Mod be generous enough to let us know that he has, in
fact, received our instructions?

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 4:03:27 PM5/17/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
I'll request that he verify in this thread. And goodness gracious, I assure you that I won't post our hit in the game thread. I'm at work, so not intoxicated, so shouldn't be a problem! Rumor has it that much of zuma's...oddness...may be a result of PWI--posting while intoxicated. The great og knows I'm guilty of that too, but not when I'm scum!
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: golf <Philip...@christushealth.org>

Date: Sat, 17 May 2008 12:57:34
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



golf

unread,
May 17, 2008, 4:38:57 PM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
But you and cc should be fine since you were there early and the whole
thing went downhill for anyrose kind of last minute. And every one of
us still has a chance to build some cred by lynching one of us (og -
what a convoluted sentence).

I am going to go back and start looking at the jumpers and we'll see
what hops up.

Man, it's fun being scum.

Peekercpa - I am a cpa and curious george combo

Bufftabby - cat person with a large feline companion?

Hoopy frood - no idea

Cckberos (sp? Aka colddiner) - seriously WTF

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 5:32:11 PM5/17/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
The deed is done. I requested a confirmation on it as well. Be vewwy, vewwy quiet now, guys.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: golf <Philip...@christushealth.org>

Date: Sat, 17 May 2008 13:38:57
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



cog...@yahoo.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 8:40:49 PM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
Confirmed.
This forum will stay open, so you can refer to it whenever you want.
I will relax the rule about no posting after submitting your choice.
That was to encourage discussion before committing.
No posting after the deadline though.

cckerberos

unread,
May 17, 2008, 10:43:01 PM5/17/08
to DopervilleMafia
Heh. Long story, but it's CC + Kerberos (the guardian dog of Hades,
aka Cerberus).

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 17, 2008, 11:08:04 PM5/17/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
I drank Flying Dog's Kerberos Tripel last night. It's pretty freakin good. I actually *did* think of you, then, well, ya know, I forgot. But yeah, you were drinking with buffersley last night (that's my fake Butler name). I'm sure we had a good, fairly sedate, and responsible time.
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: cckerberos <ccker...@hotmail.com>

Date: Sat, 17 May 2008 19:43:01
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



golf

unread,
May 18, 2008, 1:20:52 AM5/18/08
to DopervilleMafia
Regarding Buff's last post - let's start peeing and get down with it.
I really am of a mind to take this shit public. The sound of Blam and
Fluid's head exploding with our dis regard of things structured would
almost make it worthwhile.

You guys are fucking killing me. I truly don't give a shit at this
point 'cause we have already won. Not in votes necessarily, but more
along the line of having a good time and keeping this stuff in
perspective.

Tequila shots all around.

And the first fucker who suggests frozen is getting my flippin' vote.

And afterwards there has got to be a way to keep the newbs engaged.

Hoopy Frood

unread,
May 18, 2008, 10:47:28 AM5/18/08
to DopervilleMafia
My name is a reference to Chapter 3 of the Douglas Adam's "The
Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy". I've been using it as a handle on
the internet since 1996 or thereabouts. The 76 that sometimes gets
added on the end is the year I was born. While "Hoopy Frood" is
sometimes taken by someone else, Hoopy Frood 76 never is.

bethan...@gmail.com

unread,
May 18, 2008, 11:41:16 AM5/18/08
to dopervi...@googlegroups.com
Yeah, as soon as I saw a Hoopy Frood, I knew he'd be, well, one hoopy frood. One of my cats is named Wonko the Sane (his sister was Stoppity the Insane).
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile

-----Original Message-----
From: Hoopy Frood <hoopyf...@gmail.com>

Date: Sun, 18 May 2008 07:47:28
To:DopervilleMafia <dopervi...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: Re: End of Day 1. I think we did pretty well for ourselves.



golf

unread,
May 22, 2008, 9:49:32 PM5/22/08
to DopervilleMafia
Do we post Day 2 observations here or is there a separate thread?
Please pardon my technical ignorance.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages