I recovered the cultures. All worked.
To recap, I had cultures with 40%, 20% and 10% glycerol. All were created on 6-25-14 and placed at -20 in a frequently used box.
When I took the cultures out, 40% was completely aqueous. 20% was partially frozen, and 10% was barely frozen (similar to a very fine snow cone). I vortexed them all for a few seconds, which mixed them up a bit. Still, after that there was cells stuck to the bottom. The 40% I was able to mix up more, and after pipetting a few times in and out I got 20µl near the bottom (higher concentration of cells) into a culture tube. I did that with the others, although less efficiently of course because they were frozen.
10% looked to have the highest cell growth rate after, but that could just be an error on my hand on perhaps taking cells too close to the bottom. 20% and 40% were closely matched in their visible RFP expression. All had nice cell growth.
My recommendation then would be 40% for now: the cells have stayed good and it being aqueous allows for you to get cells out quicker and easier. Yes, this is not a very well controlled experiment, but for simply storing cells it might be enough
I'll email you on the DIYbio culture collection! Perhaps we could get something worked out.
-Koeng