Steve,
Well, when I co-managed the D-STAR repeaters overhere, my impression is
that 99 % of the traffic on the repeater where just voice-calls on one
of the conference systems.
One option would be to the "interconnection" of all these digital
systems at that point. AllStar is a good starting point for that.
How I see it would be something like this:
- let's take a conference called "VIC" ("Very Interesting Conference").
- create multiple "rooms" for this conference:
VIC-PCM for voip users (and some echolink repeaters)
VIC-GSM for echolink repeaters
VIC-AMBE for D-STAR repeaters
VIC-AMBE+ for DMR, P25, ... repeaters
VIC-C2 for FreeDV and c2gmsk users
Create a bridge from VIC-PCM to all the other rooms to provide the
interconnection between everybody. Using a single hub-and-spoke approach
also reduces the chance of loops.
- From the conference-servers, you then connect to the repeaters, either
using the "DV" protocol if it exists (echolink, D-STAR, voip SIP, ...)
or with a raw "codec" stream (PCM, GSM, AMBE, ...). In the latter case,
it's up to the repeater to create the DV stream to be put on DV.
As said, AllStar does already provide part of this service (but -as far
as I know it- it is based on one single "room" and does transcoding).
The idea of multiple rooms is to avoid transcoding as much as possible.
As it looks now, we are going into a future of multiple DV systems all
living next to eachother. Instead of complain about that, we are
probably better of with just acknowledge this fact and look for means to
interconnect these systems, but avoid transcoding as much as possible.
73
kristoff - ON1ARF