Hi Costin, DigiPi Ops,
Vara/Xara is Fantastic!! I agree, but unfortunately it doesn't have
a future.
Proprietary closed-standard software makers all have a choice to
make,
- embrace open source
- litigate open source
- embrace open source then extend/corrupt/extinguish
One choice has a future.
I was really hoping this would be different but Jose/Vara chose a
combination of two
and three. History is not on Vara's side, or we'd all still be
suffering with Internet Explorer
on WindowsXP. X0rro and I went out of our way to implement Vara's
registered-speed
license attestation so he could still get funding to continue to
develop a great transport.
This accommodation was met with litigation and standards corruption.
Given the "NDA-style" wording on Xara's github page, it's clear (to
me) Vara chose to litigate.
The most recent version of Vara is expected to corrupt the protocol
to make
Xara (and old VARAs) incompatible (extend and extinguish), so this
isn't really
a DigiPi decision. This time-bomb is expected on January 1st, so
Xara will
stop working either way.
Open Sources licenses come with no indemnification nor warranty, so
there are no
legal protections from patent trolls, despite decades of prior art
(wifi, HDTV, OFDM etc).
Closed Source is great for "leaf" technologies, think "tax
software," but not so
good in "trunk" infrastructure where interoperability is paramount.
Going forward, I'll be putting my engineering/advocacy efforts into
MERCURY and
Modem73 - which is why I made the Mercury video (3128 kbps btw!) in
response
to the vara/xara debacle. I've also got Modem73 working on VHF,
with APRS too!
The future is bright! I'm just sorry vara/jose can't be a part of
it. It was really cool
technology.
best,
-craig
KM6LYW
digipi.org