The part number near the IDE connector is 0A30317.01 on both PCBs, so that would suggest that the PCBs are identical.
Both have the same MCU (0A30164, UAB-M3057-HT, V3.3).
The motor controllers must be pin compatible, but one bears a Hitachi P/N, 0A30502, while the other has 14R9276. I suspect they are identical, but I'm not sure.
The 14R9276 part appears to have a burn mark on the 5V side, so perhaps the PCB was hit with an overvoltage on the 5V input. I would test R5 near the power connector. It should measure 0.47 ohms. If it is open circuit, then the preamp is probably shorted, in which case you will be looking for a headstack donor, with possibly different criteria.