Fwd: [CSMysore] Gifts in Agm
256 views
Skip to first unread message
CS A Rengarajan
Aug 4, 2011, 1:25:17 PM8/4/11
to CSMysore, cschennai, charteredsecretaries, Company_Secretary, corporate-legal-club, corporate-legal-updates, csfra...@yahoogroups.co.in, css, lawprofessional, CACSCWA, cssouth, company-secretary-vacancies, CS Students Club
Der All
We have already written about gift at AGM six months before. The copy of the same is appended below. The entire issue of giving gifts to shareholders not to ask questions. Some shareholders are taking advantage and just taking away 100 sweet boxes or 100 gifts while attending the Annual General meeting. Their concentration is mainly focused on gifts not to attend Annual general meeting. Recently one AGM held in Chennai, the shareholders has got 50 folios, he took away 50 sweet box and 50 cup of coffee. He brought vessel from his house to take away coffee.
Is it not discrimination among shareholders attending the meeting and not attending the meetings?
Now MCA has asked views . They have already implemented voting through video conferencing. More shareholders will participate from all over india. It is just like webcast that everybody will participate. There is no question of distribution of gifts arises because they have got adequate no of shareholders participate through video conferencing.
Conclusion: The Solution for this malady lies with MCA/SEBI The regulatory authorities should not be watching this fun for ever. Better late than never, MCA/SEBI should issue a circular IMMEDIATELY prohibiting issue of Gifts of any kind Articles , Samples of the products of the Company or ASSOCIATE Company Sweet packets or Snacks . The Circular should state that only a cup of tea / coffee / or soft drinks is only should be given and nothing more. In particular shareholders while attending AGM will be given tea or coffee or soft drinks not to carry the same to their houses also.
Best Regards
AGM of Listed entity – mockery by CS A Rengarajan
Introduction: As per Companies Act, 1956, it is necessary to obtain shareholders consent for their books of accounts i.e. financial transactions of all companies. This involves discussion among shareholders before voting. The Adoption of Accounts prohibited under postal ballot method. Conducting Annual General Meeting is routine work every year. In closely held companies, they conduct the AGM among the shareholders and all resolutions will be passed. Listed companies are governed stock exchange listing agreement compliance and general public are invested in the shares of the company. The Listed companies are to disclose corporate governance requirement under clause 49 of Listing Agreement. They are conducting Annual General meeting by sending notice to their shareholders and to conduct the proceedings.
One person one Folio: In Physical mode, One person has got multiple folios through creation of ab, ac, ad, ae, etc and the concept of one share one folio. Each folio got one share will be alloted and person holding the same in the joint name as per above method.. They can create large number of shareholders/members through physical mode. Even in demat mode, single folio single share can be obtained. Many listed companies, the single shareholding around minimum of 3000 shareholders. For example in Wipro current year annual report specifically reports that 4130 shareholders are having single share.
Printing of Balance sheets A person can hold only one share and it will give big problem to the company to send a copy of balance sheet as well as postal charges. The corporate has to make uphill task to over come this kind of shareholding patterns. For printing balance sheets it costs around Rs.150/- whereas the holding of one share is Rs.2/- ( the market value is higher in some cases)
AGM Preparation: The Secretary of the company make necessary arrangement to smooth conduct of the meeting including sending notices to the shareholders, to take necessary arrangement for venue .
During the Meeting: First start of the meeting, the chairman to be invited to preside over the meeting. Once Chairman comes to dais, he will see proper quorum was present. After that Secretary will read Auditors Report and Before taking up accounts adoption, the questions to be raised by the members. Then the resolutions will be taken up for voting and shareholders vote for and against of the resolution. There is no doubt all resolution will be passed and it is considered as ritual rather than realistic one. The Minority shareholders are those fragmented shares will not be in a position to prevail the company to stop passing the resolutions.. But in recent days, minority prevails over the majority shares and their activism has already started i.e. institutional shareholders who are holding shares in concert.
Distribution of sweet boxesAfter the AGM, the distribution of sweet boxes begun.
There is no provision in the Companies Act, 1956 to prohibit the companies to give gifts/sweet boxes to their shareholders. This has done to please them and vote in favour of the company. However SEBI has directed the listed entities not to entertain gifts to their shareholders. In one company recently held AGM, there are only 200 shareholders are present whereas 9000 sweet boxes are distributed. The person holding one share also entitled for sweet boxes. The cost of one sweet box comes around Rs.70/- but he is holding share cost is Rs.2/-
Discount coupons: Discount Coupon to buy their products e.g RELIANCE sent along with Dividend Warrant or Copy of Annual Accounts.Few companies are sending discount coupons. No Gift please even distributing company products should be prohibited because only share holders attend the meeting can avail it whereas the discount coupon would reach all share holders wherever they reside. In this case no discrimination among shareholders
Conclusion: The Solution for this malady lies with SEBI The regulatory authority should not be watching this fun for ever. Better late than never, SEBI should issue a circular IMMEDIATELY prohibiting issue of Gifts of any kind Articles , Samples of the products of the Company or ASSOCIATE Company Sweet packets or Snacks . The Circular should state that only a cup of tea / coffee / or soft drinks is only should be given and nothing more.
Introduction: As per Companies Act, 1956, it is necessary to obtain shareholders consent for their books of accounts i.e. financial transactions of all companies. This involves discussion among shareholders before voting. The Adoption of Accounts prohibited under postal ballot method. Conducting Annual General Meeting is routine work every year. In closely held companies, they conduct the AGM among the shareholders and all resolutions will be passed. Listed companies are governed stock exchange listing agreement compliance and general public are invested in the shares of the company. The Listed companies are to disclose corporate governance requirement under clause 49 of Listing Agreement. They are conducting Annual General meeting by sending notice to their shareholders and to conduct the proceedings.
One person one Folio: In Physical mode, One person has got multiple folios through creation of ab, ac, ad, ae, etc and the concept of one share one folio. Each folio got one share will be alloted and person holding the same in the joint name as per above method.. They can create large number of shareholders/members through physical mode. Even in demat mode, single folio single share can be obtained. Many listed companies, the single shareholding around minimum of 3000 shareholders. For example in Wipro current year annual report specifically reports that 4130 shareholders are having single share.
Printing of Balance sheets A person can hold only one share and it will give big problem to the company to send a copy of balance sheet as well as postal charges. The corporate has to make uphill task to over come this kind of shareholding patterns. For printing balance sheets it costs around Rs.150/- whereas the holding of one share is Rs.2/- ( the market value is higher in some cases)
AGM Preparation: The Secretary of the company make necessary arrangement to smooth conduct of the meeting including sending notices to the shareholders, to take necessary arrangement for venue .
During the Meeting: First start of the meeting, the chairman to be invited to preside over the meeting. Once Chairman comes to dais, he will see proper quorum was present. After that Secretary will read Auditors Report and Before taking up accounts adoption, the questions to be raised by the members. Then the resolutions will be taken up for voting and shareholders vote for and against of the resolution. There is no doubt all resolution will be passed and it is considered as ritual rather than realistic one. The Minority shareholders are those fragmented shares will not be in a position to prevail the company to stop passing the resolutions.. But in recent days, minority prevails over the majority shares and their activism has already started i.e. institutional shareholders who are holding shares in concert.
Distribution of sweet boxesAfter the AGM, the distribution of sweet boxes begun.
There is no provision in the Companies Act, 1956 to prohibit the companies to give gifts/sweet boxes to their shareholders. This has done to please them and vote in favour of the company. However SEBI has directed the listed entities not to entertain gifts to their shareholders. In one company recently held AGM, there are only 200 shareholders are present whereas 9000 sweet boxes are distributed. The person holding one share also entitled for sweet boxes. The cost of one sweet box comes around Rs.70/- but he is holding share cost is Rs.2/-
Discount coupons: Discount Coupon to buy their products e.g RELIANCE sent along with Dividend Warrant or Copy of Annual Accounts.Few companies are sending discount coupons. No Gift please even distributing company products should be prohibited because only share holders attend the meeting can avail it whereas the discount coupon would reach all share holders wherever they reside. In this case no discrimination among shareholders
Conclusion: The Solution for this malady lies with SEBI The regulatory authority should not be watching this fun for ever. Better late than never, SEBI should issue a circular IMMEDIATELY prohibiting issue of Gifts of any kind Articles , Samples of the products of the Company or ASSOCIATE Company Sweet packets or Snacks . The Circular should state that only a cup of tea / coffee / or soft drinks is only should be given and nothing more.
Will SEBI will take any steps in this regard?
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: sameer kumar <sameer.sr...@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, Aug 4, 2011 at 1:14 PM
Subject: [CSMysore] fifts in Agm
To: csmy...@googlegroups.com
Dear friends
Find eNewsletters of ICSI Mysore at: http://www.icsi.edu/NewsEvents/enewsletters/tabid/1757/Default.aspx AND www.esnips.com/web/icsimysore
You received this message as you are subscriber. To unsubscribe email to: csmysore-u...@googlegroups.com
From: sameer kumar <sameer.sr...@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, Aug 4, 2011 at 1:14 PM
Subject: [CSMysore] fifts in Agm
To: csmy...@googlegroups.com
Dear friends
MCA has asked for comments on distribution of gifts to shareholders in AGM. Kindly send your views to MCA in favor of draft circular . visit the following link for more information
regards
sameer--
-- Sameer Kumar Srivastava
Find eNewsletters of ICSI Mysore at: http://www.icsi.edu/NewsEvents/enewsletters/tabid/1757/Default.aspx AND www.esnips.com/web/icsimysore
You received this message as you are subscriber. To unsubscribe email to: csmysore-u...@googlegroups.com
--
ALL COMPANY SECRETARIES - PROUD TO BE A MEMBER OF 10000 MEMBERS OF CS BENEVOLENT FUND FOR NOBLE CAUSE
-
csarengarajanCompany Secretary, Chennai
email csarengarajan@gmail.com
http://www.csarengarajan.blogspot.com
mobile 093810 11200
SHARING KNOWLEDGE SKY IS THE LIMIT
This mail and its attachments (if any) are confidential information intended for persons to whom the email is planned for delivery by the sender. If you have received this mail in error please notify the sender of the error by forwarding the email and its attachments (if any) and then deleting the mail received in error and the relevant email trail in this connection without making any copies or taking any prints.
SHARING KNOWLEDGE SKY IS THE LIMIT
This mail and its attachments (if any) are confidential information intended for persons to whom the email is planned for delivery by the sender. If you have received this mail in error please notify the sender of the error by forwarding the email and its attachments (if any) and then deleting the mail received in error and the relevant email trail in this connection without making any copies or taking any prints.
CS A Rengarajan
Aug 4, 2011, 11:36:45 PM8/4/11
to lawprof...@yahoogroups.com, CSMysore, cschennai, charteredsecretaries, Company_Secretary, csfra...@yahoogroups.co.in, css
small correction
Der AllWe have already written about gift at AGM six months before. The copy of the same is appended below. The entire issue of giving gifts to shareholders not to ask questions. Some shareholders are taking advantage and just taking away 100 sweet boxes or 100 gifts while attending the Annual General meeting. Their concentration is mainly focused on gifts not to attend Annual general meeting. Recently one AGM held in Chennai, the shareholders has got 50 folios, he took away 50 sweet box and 50 cup of coffee. He brought vessel from his house and collected coffee for his own use.
Is it not discrimination among shareholders attending the meeting and not attending the meetings?Now MCA has asked views . They have already implemented voting through video conferencing. More shareholders will participate from all over india. It is just like webcast that everybody will participate. There is no question of distribution of gifts arises because they have got adequate no of shareholders participate through video conferencing.
Conclusion: The Solution for this malady lies with MCA/SEBI The regulatory authorities should not be watching this fun for ever. Better late than never, MCA/SEBI should issue a circular IMMEDIATELY prohibiting issue of Gifts of any kind Articles , Samples of the products of the Company or ASSOCIATE Company Sweet packets or Snacks . The Circular should state that only a cup of tea / coffee / or soft drinks is only should be given and nothing more. In particular shareholders while attending AGM will be given tea or coffee or soft drinks not to carry the same to their houses.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages