Calling of board meeting and attachment of form CHG-9

57 views
Skip to first unread message

Prakash Joshi

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 7:42:46 AMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com
Friends, 
Please share your thoughts urgently on the following points:

1. A is an independent director of a listed company. He informed CS of the company to convene a Board Meeting. But the company & CS  didn't respond to his request.

Can the Independent Director himself call the meeting by sending a notice to all the directors? and chair the said meeting.

2. Which form is filed(CHG-1 or CHG-9) to create a charge for FCCB(Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds) and what are the mandatory attachments to the form(CHG-1 /CHR-9).

Thanks
PC Joshi

SURENDER HARSH

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 9:12:20 AMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com

Yes, an Independent Director can convene a Board Meeting in certain situations if the company does not respond to their legitimate request. Here's how it works:

Legal Provisions

  1. Section 173(3) of the Companies Act, 2013:
    The Act empowers any director to convene a meeting of the Board, provided due notice is given to all directors.

  2. Role of Independent Director (ID):
    Under Schedule IV of the Companies Act, 2013 (Code for Independent Directors), an Independent Director has specific obligations, including ensuring that the Board adheres to proper governance practices.
    Clause VII(2) states that if the company fails to convene a meeting on the Independent Director's request, the Independent Director can convene the meeting independently.


Save a tree... Please don't print this e-mail unless it is absolutely necessary!

Thanks & Regards 

CS SURENDER KUMAR HARSH 
FCS, MBA (FINANCE), DLM, DIM, M.COM. ,TRADEMARK ATTORNEY,
S.K.HARSH & ASSOCIATES (UNIQUE ID - (S2014RJ2642000)
COMPANY SECRETARY IN PRACTICE  (F10229)
(PEER REVIEWED FIRM( PRC NO. 2691/2022)
Past Chairman Bikaner Chapter NIRC of ICSI
IST FLOOR VED MARKET RANI BAZAAR, 
BIKANER RAJASTHAN-334001
98291-61417, 85030-11417 

Company/LLP Registrations | NGO Registrations (Trust, Society, Section 8 Company) | Producer Company | NIDHI Company | NBFCs |, NCLT AND NCLAT Matters,  ROC, RD Compliances | XBRL Filings | Secretarial Compliance & Services | FEMA Compliances | Closure of Companies/LLP's | Appointment & Resignation of Directors  & Auditors | Alterations of MOA & AOA/LLP Agreement | DSC & DIN | GST Registration & Returns | Tax Registrations & Returns | Import Export Code | FSSAI (Food License) | Trade Mark ( National & International ) | Copyright | ISO Certifications | Income Tax | TAXATION | | , Court Matters (District and Hight Court Level Matters ) Etc.



--
--
************************************************
Mail your comments, feedback and suggestions on CSMysore to Moderator: datta...@gmail.com and Manager: vivekhe...@gmail.com
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "CSMysore" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to csmysore+u...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/csmysore/CALzFbfgaJgUxiFFQAzdguj3o_E9yAYCQJ7uzxWkkRY4CHn-yvA%40mail.gmail.com.

SURENDER HARSH

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 9:13:10 AMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com

for creating a charge for Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds (FCCB), Form CHG-1 is used under the Companies Act, 2013.

Explanation:

  • Form CHG-1:
    This is filed for creating or modifying a charge (other than those specifically covered by CHG-9). FCCBs fall under the category of general charges, hence Form CHG-1 is applicable.
  • Form CHG-9:
    It is filed specifically for creating or modifying charges relating to Debentures, which does not include FCCBs.
Save a tree... Please don't print this e-mail unless it is absolutely necessary!

Thanks & Regards 

CS SURENDER KUMAR HARSH 
FCS, MBA (FINANCE), DLM, DIM, M.COM. ,TRADEMARK ATTORNEY,
S.K.HARSH & ASSOCIATES (UNIQUE ID - (S2014RJ2642000)
COMPANY SECRETARY IN PRACTICE  (F10229)
(PEER REVIEWED FIRM( PRC NO. 2691/2022)
Past Chairman Bikaner Chapter NIRC of ICSI
IST FLOOR VED MARKET RANI BAZAAR, 
BIKANER RAJASTHAN-334001
98291-61417, 85030-11417 

Company/LLP Registrations | NGO Registrations (Trust, Society, Section 8 Company) | Producer Company | NIDHI Company | NBFCs |, NCLT AND NCLAT Matters,  ROC, RD Compliances | XBRL Filings | Secretarial Compliance & Services | FEMA Compliances | Closure of Companies/LLP's | Appointment & Resignation of Directors  & Auditors | Alterations of MOA & AOA/LLP Agreement | DSC & DIN | GST Registration & Returns | Tax Registrations & Returns | Import Export Code | FSSAI (Food License) | Trade Mark ( National & International ) | Copyright | ISO Certifications | Income Tax | TAXATION | | , Court Matters (District and Hight Court Level Matters ) Etc.

Prakash Joshi

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 9:15:04 AMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com
Thank you so much.
I shall be grateful to have your views on the other query as well which is as under:

2. Which form is filed(CHG-1 or CHG-9) to create a charge for FCCB(Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds) and what are the mandatory attachments to the form(CHG-1 /CHR-9).

SURENDER HARSH

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 9:16:12 AMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com
  • Instrument of Creation of Charge:
    This could include the bond issuance agreement, trust deed, or any other legal document outlining the terms and conditions of the charge.

  • Particulars of the Charge:
    Details like the amount secured, the property or assets charged, and terms of repayment.

  • Board Resolution:
    Certified copy of the resolution passed by the Board approving the creation of the charge.

  • Letter of Sanction or Loan Agreement:
    If applicable, include the sanction letter or agreement relating to the foreign currency loan or FCCB issue.

  • Optional Attachments (if applicable):

    • Details of any earlier charge modification or rectification (if the charge was modified or corrected).
    • Declaration regarding no previous charges on the same assets.

Save a tree... Please don't print this e-mail unless it is absolutely necessary!

Thanks & Regards 

CS SURENDER KUMAR HARSH 
FCS, MBA (FINANCE), DLM, DIM, M.COM. ,TRADEMARK ATTORNEY,
S.K.HARSH & ASSOCIATES (UNIQUE ID - (S2014RJ2642000)
COMPANY SECRETARY IN PRACTICE  (F10229)
(PEER REVIEWED FIRM( PRC NO. 2691/2022)
Past Chairman Bikaner Chapter NIRC of ICSI
IST FLOOR VED MARKET RANI BAZAAR, 
BIKANER RAJASTHAN-334001
98291-61417, 85030-11417 

Company/LLP Registrations | NGO Registrations (Trust, Society, Section 8 Company) | Producer Company | NIDHI Company | NBFCs |, NCLT AND NCLAT Matters,  ROC, RD Compliances | XBRL Filings | Secretarial Compliance & Services | FEMA Compliances | Closure of Companies/LLP's | Appointment & Resignation of Directors  & Auditors | Alterations of MOA & AOA/LLP Agreement | DSC & DIN | GST Registration & Returns | Tax Registrations & Returns | Import Export Code | FSSAI (Food License) | Trade Mark ( National & International ) | Copyright | ISO Certifications | Income Tax | TAXATION | | , Court Matters (District and Hight Court Level Matters ) Etc.


Prakash Joshi

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 9:21:32 AMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com
But if you see form CHG-9 it has one category Bond also.

SURENDER HARSH

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 9:29:15 AMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com


es, Form CHG-9 is specifically used for the filing of creation or modification of charges in the case of debentures, including the rectification of charges under section 71(3) of the Companies Act, 2013. The term bond in Form CHG-9 refers to instruments or securities akin to debentures, where a company raises funds against its creditworthiness or assets.

Here’s how it fits:

  • Bonds: A bond is a debt instrument issued by the company, typically structured like a debenture, to borrow money from investors. It creates a charge or security against certain company assets.

In the context of Form CHG-9, it can be used for both bonds and debentures when:

  1. A charge is created to secure the issuance of such bonds.
  2. A modification or rectification of the charge is necessary.

Form CHG-9 under the Companies Act, 2013 is used for the filing of the creation or modification of a charge for:

  1. Debentures (including rectification of charges related to debentures under Section 71(3) of the Act).
  2. Bonds (which are often treated similarly to debentures for secured borrowing).

Key Aspects of Form CHG-9:

  1. Applicability: It applies when a charge is created, modified, or rectified related to debentures or bonds issued by the company.

Save a tree... Please don't print this e-mail unless it is absolutely necessary!

Thanks & Regards 

CS SURENDER KUMAR HARSH 
FCS, MBA (FINANCE), DLM, DIM, M.COM. ,TRADEMARK ATTORNEY,
S.K.HARSH & ASSOCIATES (UNIQUE ID - (S2014RJ2642000)
COMPANY SECRETARY IN PRACTICE  (F10229)
(PEER REVIEWED FIRM( PRC NO. 2691/2022)
Past Chairman Bikaner Chapter NIRC of ICSI
IST FLOOR VED MARKET RANI BAZAAR, 
BIKANER RAJASTHAN-334001
98291-61417, 85030-11417 

Company/LLP Registrations | NGO Registrations (Trust, Society, Section 8 Company) | Producer Company | NIDHI Company | NBFCs |, NCLT AND NCLAT Matters,  ROC, RD Compliances | XBRL Filings | Secretarial Compliance & Services | FEMA Compliances | Closure of Companies/LLP's | Appointment & Resignation of Directors  & Auditors | Alterations of MOA & AOA/LLP Agreement | DSC & DIN | GST Registration & Returns | Tax Registrations & Returns | Import Export Code | FSSAI (Food License) | Trade Mark ( National & International ) | Copyright | ISO Certifications | Income Tax | TAXATION | | , Court Matters (District and Hight Court Level Matters ) Etc.


Prakash Joshi

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 9:32:52 AMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com
Suppose the company doesn't create the charge within stipulated time can the bondholder file the charge. the answer u/s 78 is yes. But he has the bond issuing docs like (Offering circular as filed with ROC) but  doesn't have the certified BR. What to do and which form he needs to file CHG-1 or CHR-9.


Prakash Joshi

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 9:38:02 AMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com
Sir,
The instruments in this case are FCCB(Foreign Currency Convertible Bobds) which form to be filed. CHG-1 or CHG-9.
Thanks.


SURENDER HARSH

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 4:55:40 PMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com

For Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds (FCCBs), the appropriate form to be filed with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) depends on the nature of the charge being created. Here's the clarification:

  1. Form CHG-1:

    • This is used for the creation or modification of charges other than debentures.
    • If FCCBs are not classified as debentures under your financing structure but involve a charge on the company's assets, then CHG-1 would be appropriate.
  2. Form CHG-9:

    • This is used specifically for the creation or modification of a charge in relation to debentures.
    • Since FCCBs are convertible bonds (a type of debenture), CHG-9 would typically apply if the FCCBs are issued and involve a charge.

Practical Guidance:

  • FCCBs are usually treated as debentures in most cases under Indian law. Therefore, CHG-9 is the likely form unless specific conditions indicate otherwise.
  • Verify your situation against the specific agreement terms or consult the transaction structure for clarity.

Save a tree... Please don't print this e-mail unless it is absolutely necessary!

Thanks & Regards 

CS SURENDER KUMAR HARSH 
FCS, MBA (FINANCE), DLM, DIM, M.COM. ,TRADEMARK ATTORNEY,
S.K.HARSH & ASSOCIATES (UNIQUE ID - (S2014RJ2642000)
COMPANY SECRETARY IN PRACTICE  (F10229)
(PEER REVIEWED FIRM( PRC NO. 2691/2022)
Past Chairman Bikaner Chapter NIRC of ICSI
IST FLOOR VED MARKET RANI BAZAAR, 
BIKANER RAJASTHAN-334001
98291-61417, 85030-11417 

Company/LLP Registrations | NGO Registrations (Trust, Society, Section 8 Company) | Producer Company | NIDHI Company | NBFCs |, NCLT AND NCLAT Matters,  ROC, RD Compliances | XBRL Filings | Secretarial Compliance & Services | FEMA Compliances | Closure of Companies/LLP's | Appointment & Resignation of Directors  & Auditors | Alterations of MOA & AOA/LLP Agreement | DSC & DIN | GST Registration & Returns | Tax Registrations & Returns | Import Export Code | FSSAI (Food License) | Trade Mark ( National & International ) | Copyright | ISO Certifications | Income Tax | TAXATION | | , Court Matters (District and Hight Court Level Matters ) Etc.


Prakash Joshi

unread,
Dec 3, 2024, 10:59:54 PMDec 3
to csmy...@googlegroups.com
Thanks for your reply.I have gone through independent Directors code as referred by you but didn't find any clause which states that if the board doesn't calla meeting then Independent director can call it. Can you pls relook and advise the same 


Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages