Well, Windschuttle is a rather controversial character as it is, having stirred the pot of Australian historians by acting as something of the equivalent of a Holocaust denier (might be a bold comparison, however genocide of Aboriginal Australians has been compared as such). I have little opinion one way or another for the audacity of his conclusions, yet his research methods have been less than rigorous, which is why I suspect the author chose this magazine in particular. It does have a good reputation in some circles, so it's not really some backwater rag here...however as you said, it isn't a journal, as such.
Mike McRae
Science by Email, CSIRO Education
PO Box 225, Dickson ACT 2602
Phone: 02 6276 6291 Mobile: 0423 596 774
Email:
mike....@csiro.au | Web:
www.csiro.au/education