Hi Jocelynn & CRISPR forum friends,
I think you might be using an outdated version of the protocol. (We tried to save folks some $$$ with a non-AP and non-PNK protocol but it doesn't seem to work quite as reliably as the original protocol.)
It should result in a very high number of colonies on your positive plate with very little background. It uses AP and PNK, as in the original protocol.
I think there are a few spots on Addgene's website that still reference the pre-release protocol and we will work with them to update those to the new protocol. Please let me know if you have any questions or difficulty with this sgRNA cloning protocol.
best,
- Neville