52 views

Skip to first unread message

Apr 16, 2017, 8:21:13 PM4/16/17

to CorpLing with R

Hello,

I have been using the script in R for a collexeme analysis of nouns and various particles (e.g. *that, of, to*). A reviewer of a paper I'm working on has asked me to include exact p-values if making a statement about a word's association strength with a pattern. Previously I had simply stated which of the three "significance bands" the association strength falls into (i.e., coll.strength>3 => p<0.001; coll.strength>2 => p<0.01; coll.strength>1.30103 => p<0.05), but this reviewer has suggested instead to report actual p-values. While my main point in the project is to demonstrate the number of items falling within one of the three levels of significance, I do want to satisfy this reviewer.

My question is: how might I find a precise p-value, if possible? As an example: if it is revealed that "possibility" and "of" have an attraction in a small corpus with FYE log-transformed score of 115, because this is greater than 3, then p<.001. Maybe I could "reverse" the Fisher-Yates log-tranformation somehow, or have, in addition to the script also report actual p-values?

Hope this explanation makes sense, and thanks for the very useful collexeme script!

Brian

Apr 17, 2017, 2:49:28 AM4/17/17

to CorpLing with R

If you have a positive collexeme strength value of, say, 144.936653,

for a word that is attracted to something else, just exponentiate the

negative collexeme value:

> 10^-144.936653

[1] 1.157036e-145 # p-value

If you have a negative collexeme strength value of, say, -8.553066,

for a word that is repelled by something else, just exponentiate the

collexeme value:

> 10^-8.553066

[1] 2.798556e-09 # p-value

Best,

STG

--

Stefan Th. Gries

----------------------------------

Univ. of California, Santa Barbara

http://tinyurl.com/stgries

----------------------------------

for a word that is attracted to something else, just exponentiate the

negative collexeme value:

> 10^-144.936653

[1] 1.157036e-145 # p-value

If you have a negative collexeme strength value of, say, -8.553066,

for a word that is repelled by something else, just exponentiate the

collexeme value:

> 10^-8.553066

[1] 2.798556e-09 # p-value

Best,

STG

--

Stefan Th. Gries

----------------------------------

Univ. of California, Santa Barbara

http://tinyurl.com/stgries

----------------------------------

Reply all

Reply to author

Forward

0 new messages

Search

Clear search

Close search

Google apps

Main menu