RESULT: comp.unix.cde passes 499:17
Warren Lavallee
unmoderated group comp.unix.cde passes 499:17
There were 499 YES votes and 17 NO votes, for a total of 516 valid votes.
There was 1 abstain and 4 invalid ballots.
For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO)
votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes.
There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted. If no
serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the moderator of
news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly thereafter.
Newsgroups line:
comp.unix.cde The Common Desktop Environment.
This was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions about
this proposal should be directed to the proponent.
Proponent: Daniel Dardailler <dan...@x.org>
Proponent: Bob Scheifler <r...@x.org>
Proponent: Ken Flowers <flo...@osf.org>
Votetaker: Warren Lavallee <war...@Syra.NET>
RATIONALE: comp.unix.cde
The CDE topic is currently being discussed among several Unix
operating system specific groups, such as comp.unix.solaris,
comp.unix.aix, comp.sys.hp.hpux, comp.unix.osf.osf1, ergo readers
exist and would use a newsgroup about CDE if there was one.
It is important to note that most CDE threads in the above OS specific
group are often only relevant to the CDE technology itself, and not to
a particular Unix variant. The fact that CDE users have to follow
multiple platform specific groups to get information and answers about
CDE merely defeats the purpose of CDE itself: which is unification.
As noted in the header, there exists a CDE specific group in the Alt
hierarchy already , but its parenting under "windows" makes it such
that a lot of MS/Windows messages are sent to this group by mistake
(and CDE is an X- and Unix-based technology). Several times in the
past year, people have requested the creation of a "real" CDE group.
In the same alt.windows.cde forum were also discussed the rationales
for having a comp.unix.cde group, vs. a comp.windows.x.cde group. The
idea is that although CDE is mostly perceived as an extension of the X
and the Motif technology (visually it is), it encompasses more than
that in reality: ToolTalk, Calendar Management, and a Mail are
examples of services provided by CDE, and the CDE applications
directly extends the "standard" set of Unix utilitaries (CDE is an
X/Open standard).
CHARTER: comp.unix.cde
The charter for the CDE group is to discuss technical matters relevant
to the CDE, Common Desktop Environment.
CDE is a technology that unifies access, both programmatic and user,
to Unix desktop services such as windowing, graphics, and user
interface presentation, file and session management, and
inter-application messaging (a good introduction can be found at
http://www.austin.ibm.com/software/CDE/TOC/Intro/cdeintro.html).
An important aspect, since CDE is a "compound" technology, is that it
is not meant to replace the existing groups that already cover
individual parts of CDE: comp.windows.x.motif for instance, or
alt.soft-sys.tooltalk.
In other words, if the symptoms of the problem that a user is
reporting, or more generally if the matters presented is applicable to
one of the individual technology that forms CDE out of the CDE
context, it is better to only post to the specific group.
I can give more details about the CDE parts and their corresponding
existing Usenet group if requested.
END CHARTER.
DISTRIBUTION:
This RESULT is being posted to the following newsgroups:
comp.unix.solaris
comp.unix.aix
comp.sys.hp.hpux
comp.unix.osf.osf1
comp.windows.x.motif
comp.windows.x
comp.sys.sun.admin
alt.windows.cde
comp.unix.cde Final Vote Ack
Voted Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2067...@MSU.EDU John.Stone
7535...@compuserve.com Andrew J. Cubbon
a...@piano.fpk.hp.com
aba...@w3.org Anselm Baird-Smith
ab...@macorp.com Abhay Gadre
ab...@inet.uni-c.dk Jens Abildgaard
ac...@swm.metrotor.on.ca Andrew Chan
ado...@amc.de Alexander Adolf
adr...@plato.uni-paderborn.de Achim Dreyer
adr...@hpcvuia.cv.hp.com Adrian Lavrov
a...@r3125sv2.atl.hp.com Andrew J Phillips
al...@unx.dec.com Alaa Zeineldine
Alain....@irisa.fr Alain Cedelle
al...@godzilla.EECS.Berkeley.EDU Alan Coopersmith
alb...@natlab.research.philips.com J.P. Albers van der Linden
al...@srce.hr Aleksandar Milivojevic
al...@VNET.IBM.COM
a...@rsinc.com Ali Bahrami
am...@cse.unsw.edu.au Peter Urbanec
and...@bilbo.cra.enel.it Andrea Omodeo
Andrea...@dlr.de
an...@lindeman.indstate.edu Andy Lindeman
an...@parallax.co.uk Andy Piper
an...@x.org Anne Salemme
ant...@austin.ibm.com
arne...@sunw113.oslo.Geco-Prakla.slb.com Truls Arnegaard
as...@btsslc.com ASEEM BAKSHI
asl...@jocko.bri.hp.com Al Slater
au...@cs.albany.edu Jim Ault
aus...@cc.gatech.edu J Austin David
av...@natlab.research.philips.com
a...@stade.co.uk Adrian Wontroba
azh...@grtadv.shl.com Allan Zheng
b.b...@trl.telstra.com.au Brian Booth
B.M...@kfa-juelich.de B.Mohr
B15...@vaxb.phx1.aro.allied.com CAREW, WILLIAM A
bar...@circe.wz-berlin.de Barbara Schelkle
bar...@gatwick.geco-prakla.slb.com Simon Barnes
bar...@grymoire.crd.ge.com Bruce Barnett
Barry.C...@durham.ac.uk Barry Cornelius
bar...@x.org Art Barstow
bc...@sybase.com Bill Cox
bell...@gauss.math.fsu.edu Steve Bellenot
ben...@orzan.fi.udc.es Benito Mourelo
Bent...@logica.com Neil D. Bentley
be...@rsvl.unisys.com Bert Hyman
be...@cptca.neep.wisc.edu Mike Bettenhausen
bfri...@cyberramp.net Bob Friesenhahn
bi...@ascada.demon.co.uk
birc...@email.njin.net Shag
bn...@sinend.larc.nasa.gov Bob Nine
b...@BSM.jaxnet.com R. J. Register
bog...@bpb.it Massimo.Lanfranconi
bon...@bart.esiee.fr Frank Bonnet
bren...@fz-rossendorf.de Dr.Vinzenz Brendler
bre...@tiac.net Brian Bresnahan
br...@wombat.backbone.uoknor.edu Brett Morrow
bri...@zk3.dec.com Brian Simons, UEG/I18N
br...@tellabs.com
bruce.f...@triteal.com Bruce Friedman
br...@oz.health.state.mn.us Bruce Parkin
bru...@Softworks.com Bruce Perkins
br...@yakko.cs.wmich.edu Bryan Newcastle
bue...@net.henkel.de Stefan Buenemann
burl...@x.org
bza...@sgh.waw.pl Bartosz Zawisza
c...@unx.dec.com
Carine...@aiguemarine.unice.fr Carine Fe'de`le
Carl.J....@bridge.bst.bls.com Carl J. Cummins
car...@VNET.IBM.COM
car...@triteal.com Carlos Lin
cat...@compstat.wharton.upenn.edu Tony Catone
cava...@bnr.ca christiana (c.) cavazzoni
ccz...@unix.ccc.nottingham.ac.uk Marlon Cole
cdb...@bansai.ucs.uoknor.edu Clinton Bunch
cewi...@cca.rockwell.com Chad E. Wilcox
cho...@sgh.waw.pl Piotr Kucharski
chr...@montal.co.uk Chris Colesby
chr...@wni.com Christopher L. Mello
christop...@MENTORG.COM Christophe Gorsky
c...@delcam.com Chavdar Ivanov
cl...@columbia.edu Christopher Lodge Stamper
Colas....@sophia.inria.fr Colas Nahaboo
co...@triteal.com Costa Caldis
cour...@hpcvxcl.cv.hp.com Courtney Loomis
cpie...@ford.com Clinton Pierce
craig....@triteal.com Craig Straube
cr...@ics.com Chris Craig
cr...@bnr.ca christopher (c.j.) rath
cri...@jetson.msfc.nasa.gov J. Allen Crider
csk...@delenn.jccbi.gov Charles S. Kerr
CSte...@phxase.allied.com Craig Stevens
csuros...@CS.YALE.EDU
D.J.Walk...@micromuse.co.uk
D.Mit...@dcs.shef.ac.uk Dave Mitchell
d...@cfi.org David Mallis
d...@ray.nlm.nih.gov Dennis Benson
d...@celsius.oz.au Dave Huf
Dan.D...@Eng.Sun.COM Dan Donovan - SunSoft SE
dan...@vis.inf.ethz.ch Daniel Gerald Kluge
dan...@x.org Daniel Dardailler
da...@open.cc.etf.hr Danijel Doric
da...@virgil.vnet.net Jim Vanator
dar...@canada.lsil.com Darryl Gamble
da...@Auspex.com David Singletary
david....@pt.tu-clausthal.de David Werner
dav...@ix.netcom.com Dave Wagner
da...@lannion.cnet.fr Jacques DAVY - FT.CNET/LAA/TSS/SMM
dbal...@ix.netcom.com Don Ballard
dbr...@x.org David Brooks
dca...@arlut.utexas.edu Dave Carver
dd...@sware.com Dennis Doubleday
ddh...@zk3.dec.com Dave Hill
ddi...@transition.com Dan A. Dickey
ddom...@open.cc.etf.hr Dean Domikulic
Deb...@aol.com
de...@RUS.Uni-Stuttgart.DE Helmut Springer
den...@hpcvusd.cv.hp.com Dennis Harms
dev...@alsys.com Olivier Devuns @pulsar
dfl...@io.com Douglas R. Floyd
d...@swt.edu Daniel F. Salinas
dgl...@cliffy.lfwc.lockheed.com John Douglass
dhei...@austin.ibm.com
dho...@erols.com Dave Howell
Dick_O...@vd.volvo.se Dick Olofsson
dip...@axpo1.sdrc.com
di...@kant.ping.de Dirk Rogalla
di...@umich.edu david langhorst
djo...@jcc-one.dljones.com Dr. Daniel L. Jones
d...@austin.ibm.com Dan Dao
d...@mart.nl Mark Donderwinkel
don...@x.org Mike Donati
d...@rtsffm.com Donato Petrino
dr...@sgi.com Douglas Rand
dreg...@austin.ibm.com Dennis J. Regnery
d...@x.org David Kaelbling
dsc...@cs.Buffalo.EDU Daniel S Chen
dug...@umich.edu Douglas Song
du...@pgh.nauticom.net Jim Duke
e0fk...@credit.erin.utoronto.ca John Truong
eck...@eos1.larc.nasa.gov Richard Eckman
Edwin...@univie.ac.at Edwin Cikan
e...@unx.dec.com Elaine Haher
ehs...@aom.ericsson.se Anders Ahlstrom EHS/LG 81425 6640
ehs...@ehs.ericsson.se Jan Sandquist
ejoh...@decwin.ENET.dec.com
el...@osf.org Ellis S. Cohen
engl...@agcs.com
era...@ebc.ericsson.se Kettula Jani
era...@panix.com Ed Ravin
erl...@funcom.no Erlend Simonsen
er...@sai.msu.su Vladimir Ermakov
etx...@aom.ericsson.se Olof Samuelsson FK/M 83155 6546
far...@sde.hp.com Scott Farrow
fl...@ossi.com Christopher Flake
fo...@duke.usask.ca Earl Fogel
fo...@foxxsden.bb.bawue.de Heinz Hippenstiel
fra...@dg-rtp.dg.com Marc Fraioli
fr...@color.cs.ucla.edu Frank Fabbrocino
fr...@zuunix.zuo.dec.com Francois Vorburger
Fre...@aol.com
fre...@cig.mot.com Dennis H Freidel
ful...@agen.tamu.edu Steve Fuller
G.Po...@cpro.dlo.nl Gerrit Polder
gbe...@tucana.ualr.edu Greg
gc...@tulsa.lgc.com Glenn Carr
gd...@dcs.ed.ac.uk George Ross
ge...@sun3.iaf.nl Geert Bosch
geis...@europe.ilog.fr Gisele Eisenmann
ge...@aurora.nscee.edu EuGene epetai-Tramaglino
geo...@adiva.com George Pearson
geo...@triteal.com George Zabetakis
Gerald...@att.com Geraldo Veiga
gfo...@netcom.com
g...@unx.dec.com
gibian@typhoon Marc Gibian
gil...@x.org Stephen Gildea
giu...@zk3.dec.com Susan M. Giusto
g...@austin.ibm.com George Kraft IV
glau...@VNET.IBM.COM
Glenn.W...@Eng.Sun.COM Glenn Weinberg
go...@uni-paderborn.de Frank Baumgart
go...@math.liu.se Goran Helmersson
go...@loke.btj.se Goran Svensson
gran...@kgn.ibm.com Grant McLaughlin
gr...@ohs.uwo.ca Greg Chapman
gr...@qantas.com.au Gary Riseborough
groe...@cse.psu.edu John D Groenveld
gr...@uni-muenster.de
gsw...@netcom.com Gary Swift
gut...@cda.ipmce.su Vadim F. Gouterman
g...@n3gb.umd.edu George Baltz
h875...@isis.wu-wien.ac.at Johannes Strasser
ha...@mmsrv.zko.dec.com John Hainsworth, Multimedia/Light And Sound Softwar
Hal.Je...@Eng.Sun.COM Hal Jespersen
hans...@stv.sdata.no Hans Rune Bue
hark...@airmail.net Howard Lee Harkness
har...@email.unc.edu Trey Harris
ha...@atmos.washington.edu Harry Edmon
ha...@zk3.dec.com Richard Hart USG
Heikki....@Helsinki.FI Heikki Kantola
hen...@cowboy.ds.boeing.com Howard Nebeck
HEPS...@SMTPGATE.lfwc.lockheed.com Heaps, Mark A
hof...@wpax01.Physik.Uni-Wuerzburg.DE Frank Hofmann
howard....@citicorp.com Howard Harkness
how...@ee.utah.edu Walt Howard
hsa...@marnie.teuto.de Henning Sauer
Hugh.M...@Eng.Sun.COM Hugh McIntyre
h_tr...@roam.agfa.be Herwig Troost
ibja...@panix.com Ian Jacobs
i...@mercury.co.il Ido Sarig
ig...@bnkdp.khabarovsk.su Igor Kouznetsov
i...@dd.chalmers.se Anders Hammarquist
it...@austin.ibm.com I-Hsing Tsao
Ivan....@anu.edu.au Ivan Angus
ivan.g...@ul.ie Ivan Griffin
iv...@wadsworth.org Ivan Auger
J.L.v....@bwk.tue.nl Jacques v Ishoven
ja...@cs.chalmers.se Jakob Schlyter
ja...@hollender.com James Hollender
ja...@sunra1.cern.ch Werner Jank
ja...@torpa.se Jan Andersson
ja...@finland.hp.com Jari Pirhonen
Jason....@ml.csiro.au
ja...@boud.demon.co.uk Jason Boud
j...@itre.itre.ncsu.edu Jay Novello
j...@hal.com Joe Beall
jccook@tddcae99 J. Chris Cook
jda...@wi.leidenuniv.nl J.H.M.Dassen
Jean-Mic...@sophia.inria.fr Jean-Michel Leon
j...@uoknor.edu James E. Deaton
jeff...@iinet.net.au Jeff Gray
jen...@netcom.com Jennine Townsend
jer...@canb.auug.org.au Jeremy Bishop
j...@pepelepew.raster.Kodak.COM Joe Formica
j...@x.org Jim Fournier
j...@w3.org Jim Gettys
jge...@mtl.mit.edu Jeffrey Gealow
jhid...@ll.iac.es Juan Jose Rodriguez Hidalgo
Jim.Bur...@mail.hcsc.com Jim Burmeister
jim...@jimcoa.auto-trol.com Jim Coate
ji...@zk3.dec.com Jim Glading USG
ji...@platinum.fc.hp.com Jim Norman
jla...@ichaos.nullnet.fi Juha Laiho
jlgr...@mmm.com Jim Graham
j...@ordinox.qc.ca
jljl...@austin.ibm.com Hirotaka Matsumoto
j...@uvo.dec.com
jmhe...@cscs.ch Jean-Marc Herzog
jmkn...@mercury.interpath.com Jim Knoble
jo...@inf.ethz.ch Krister Joas
jo...@et2.etools.com John W. Christy
jo...@iastate.edu
jo...@osiris.pomona.edu John Sinnott
jo...@worlds.net John Navitsky
jo...@mitre.org Jonathan Doughty
jo...@triteal.com Jon Werner
jo...@rulcmc.leidenuniv.nl joost witteveen
jor...@cadsys1.cadsystem.se Jorgen Jonsson
j...@hammer.msfc.nasa.gov J. Porter Clark
j...@dmu.ac.uk Jonathan R Hughes
jsal...@orzan.fi.udc.es Jesus M. Salceda
js...@cais.cais.com Joseph S. D. Yao
jug...@world.std.com Barry J Rosenberg
ju...@zk3.dec.com Richard June USG
jun...@hpcvusj.cv.hp.com Jim Miller
jup...@tarsier.cv.nrao.edu Jeff Uphoff
jw...@frick.fpk.hp.com Joanne Woo
ka...@x.org Kaleb S. KEITHLEY
Ken.H...@gsfc.nasa.gov Ken Hersey
ke...@godzilla.EECS.Berkeley.EDU Kenji Hubbard
ke...@panix.com Kenneth Crudup
ke...@hpcvusj.cv.hp.com Ken Steege
ke...@htilbom.ernet.in Kevin Menezes
ke...@neptune.pwc.bc.doe.ca Kevin Carson
ke...@triteal.com Kevin R Underriner
kev...@parallax.co.uk Kevin Roberts
kh...@hpl3sn03.cern.ch Rizwan Ali Khan
k...@shell.portal.com Kim DeVaughn
ko...@bcs20.bcs.cs.philips.com Koef
Koon...@bton.ac.uk Koon Tang
k...@morgan.com Khang Vu
kw...@bocagate.bocaraton.ibm.com kwanchai pawutiyapong
Laurent...@der.edfgdf.fr Laurent Vallee - IMA/ICI/ASR - CDD - 47656833
ldief...@why.net
leh...@x.org Arnaud Le Hors
lev...@cc.jyu.fi Matti Lev{nen
lin...@lonesome.com Mark Linimon
Lionel.Fo...@aar.alcatel-alsthom.fr Lionel Fournigault
l...@atl.hp.com Larry Gardner
l...@barra.csb.ki.se Leif Bergman
loef...@hpcvuia.cv.hp.com Lisa Loeffler
l...@sweng.stortek.com Lon Jones
lor...@amusing.roc.servtech.com Jeff Van Epps
l...@nautique.epm.ornl.gov Lawrence Macintyre
LU...@sgh.waw.pl Lukasz Sadalski
lyl...@cse.ucsc.edu Lylace Blake
ly...@Scorpio.Com Lyor Goldstein
ly...@mail.tiac.net Charles LaBrec
ma...@mfr.dec.com Claudius Mack
m...@charon.tauber.netz.sub.de Marc Dosch
mag...@bilbo.suite.com JC Magras
mah...@secwa.dialix.oz.au Mark Hayes
Mark.K....@att.com
ma...@darkhorse.cv.com Mark R. Bowyer
ma...@antares.demon.co.uk Mark Watson
ma...@mddmew.fc.hp.com Mark Waite
mar...@netcom.com Jared Martinsen
mar...@triteal.com martin flood
MAR...@crnvma.cern.ch
masi...@zk3.dec.com Brian W. Masinick, DTN: 381-0013
math...@phys.ocean.dal.ca Steven Matheson
Mats.L...@uab.ericsson.se Mats Larsson
matt...@tei.or.th Matthew Markopoulos
m...@beatles.cselt.stet.it Maurizio Codogno
m...@mercury.co.il Maxim Kholmyansky
m...@texsys.com max@ranger
mbal...@xmission.com Mike Allred
mbr...@siac.com Michael Breuer
mbro...@zko.dec.com Michael Brodeur
mcam...@netcom.com Michael Campbell
m...@dmu.ac.uk Matthew C. Forman
mess...@gooey.ENET.dec.com Bob Messenger ZKO3-2/W17 381-1317 21-Mar-1996
mgr...@x.org Mitch Greess
mich...@panix.com Petros Michalis
michaud...@ic.gc.ca Michaud, Bernard: IMB
Michel...@raba.com Michele Moore
Michiel....@nlutripc.origin.nl Michiel Steltman
mi...@alpha.dcs.fmph.uniba.sk Andrej Misik
ml...@andrew.cmu.edu Michael Loomis
ml...@wco.com Michael Lyle
MMA...@sgh.waw.pl MARCIN MALEC
mmic...@igate1.hac.com Mark O. Michael
mmo...@triteal.com Michael Moore
m...@unx.dec.com Mitch Kulberg
moo...@dogbert.cc.ndsu.NoDak.edu Tim Mooney
morr...@sol1.lrsm.upenn.edu Norm Morrison
mr...@gisws10.rtpnc.epa.gov Michael Rose
mth...@cc.ece.ntua.gr Marcos Ph. Theophylactou
mt...@pheasant.uwaterloo.ca Martin Timmerman
m...@drmail.dr.att.com
m...@gate.net Mark W. Alexander
mwa...@zk3.dec.com Mark Warren USG
mys...@ldhpux.immt.pwr.wroc.pl Wojciech Myszka
nel...@ix.netcom.com Ken Nelson
n...@abattoir.cc.ndsu.nodak.edu Nem W Schlecht
nhi...@theophilus.isr.umich.edu NW Hinkle-DeGroot
ni...@inferno.fc.hp.com Nick Ingegneri
Nolan...@Eng.Sun.COM Nolan C. Toone
olav.l...@geologi.uio.no Olav Lerbrekk
pal...@hotpup.zko.dec.com Paloma Ahgren-Amat
pas...@x.org Pascale Dardailler
pa...@interlog.com Paxil Psycho
pd...@zk3.dec.com Peter Derr
pec...@itg.ti.com Allen Peckham
pe...@niksula.hut.fi Pekka Marjola
PER...@VCUUCC.UCC.VCU.EDU Kenneth Perdue
p...@triteal.com Jim Pietrocini
pe...@miba.auc.dk Peter Jacob Slot
p...@unx.dec.com Paul Henderson
ph...@panix.com Phil Gustafson
Phili...@phxase.allied.com Phil Tait
Philipp...@sophia.inria.fr Philippe Kaplan
ph...@dmv.co.uk Phil Whiles
pi...@math.uh.edu pier
p...@mda.ca Phil Gray
po...@dec-pmr.enac.dgac.fr
por...@hpcvlx.cv.hp.com John Milton
PRI...@gluon.npl.washington.edu
psc...@uswest.com Pat P. Schill
p...@unx.dec.com
p...@pcdoh.pgh.wec.com Patrick T. Broderick
p...@arlut.utexas.edu Pug
putre...@jpmorgan.com Stephen M. Putre
qhs...@aom.ericsson.se Jan Lundkvist
ra...@ycvax.york.cuny.edu
rame...@hpsgncp.sgp.hp.com M. S. Ramesh
r...@adc.com Rob Nielsen
ra...@metacard.com Scott Raney
raphael...@hamburg.netsurf.de Raphael Posmyk
Raphael...@eed.ericsson.se Raphael Quinet
RAR...@cars3.uchicago.edu Harvey Rarback 312-702-9931
rca...@ASG.unb.ca Roderick Cater
rc...@dres.dnd.ca Ray Chan
rcl...@klm.nl Rodney Clark
r...@x.org Robert Seacord
rcun...@austin.ibm.com Roger Cundiff
renalds@abn_dev.abn.com Andrew Renalds
rest...@fateware.com Ramiro Estrugo
rh...@interaccess.com Bob Hays, Computer Geek
Richard.M...@Eng.Sun.COM Rich McAllister
rich...@VNET.IBM.COM Richard Polisuk
Richard_J_O'Rourke_at...@CCGATE.HAC.COM
ri...@karhide.gethen.com Rick Moore
r...@zilker.com Ray Santiago
rka...@open.cc.etf.hr Robert Kahler
r...@atl.hp.com Ricky Ralston
rob.e...@hydro.on.ca Rob Allan
r...@elprac.hvu.nl Rob F. Siesling
Robert....@abc.se Robert Burgess
Roland.D...@aix.ensam.fr Roland DARDAILLER
Roland....@dlr.de roland a. ziegler
ro...@hpcvxrv.cv.hp.com Ronald Voll
rpa...@hpcvuie.cv.hp.com Rajeev Pandey
rpa...@sadira.gb.nrao.edu Bob Payne
rpo...@austin.ibm.com
rswi...@x.org Rob Swiston
rya...@ix14.ix.netcom.com
S.No...@frna.bull.fr
sa...@blackpig.demon.co.uk David Salt
sam...@x.org
sa...@x.org Sami Mohammed
sandy....@sdrc.com Sandy Mustard
san...@triteal.com Don Sanshu
sa...@sgh.waw.pl Marcin Cieslak
sa...@darling.monosys.com David Allan Finch
sbi...@datlog.co.uk Stephen Bishop
sch...@cae.wisc.edu Jeff Schave
schou...@CCGATE.HAC.COM
sch...@x.org Mark Schuldenfrei
sch...@ips.cs.tu-bs.de Joerg Schumacher
sc...@plato.ds.boeing.com Scott Moody
sco...@belle.bork.com Randy Scott
sey...@u.washington.edu Richard Seymour
si...@derby.cdt-bnp.iway.fr P. Simon - 33 1 40149326
sito...@zia.hao.ucar.edu Leonard Sitongia
s...@alex.sebastopol.ua Sergey Kuramshin
s...@triteal.com Steve Adler
sm...@smurf.noris.de Matthias Urlichs
sod...@cs.chalmers.se Lars S|dergren
soo...@freenet.mb.ca Jim Jaworski
s...@sysalt.com Steve Snodgrass
st1...@entoil.co.uk Ket Henriksen 144
st...@ensco.com Stan Driggs
st...@netcom.com Stan Brown
ste...@eko.adm.chalmers.se Stefan Andersson
ste...@fb3-s7.math.tu-berlin.de Axel Stegner
steve....@okway.okstate.edu Steve Coltrin
Steve....@math.tamu.edu Steve Johnson
st...@hpcvusc.cv.hp.com Steve Hiebert
ste...@wni.com Steve Green
ste...@rsinc.com SK
st...@zk3.dec.com Cliff Straw USG
stre...@zk3.dec.com
str...@hpstryn.fc.hp.com Mike Stroyan
su...@habicht.BauV.UniBw-Muenchen.de Thomas Sutor
Sut...@LSPO01.CH.unisys.com Sutter, Raymond LS-CH
sw...@boco.co.gov Shane Castle
swi...@triteal.com Steve Wilson
s...@atl.hp.com Sandy Morton
T.J.Evan...@cs.bham.ac.uk Tim Evans
ta...@cs.unc.edu Todd D. Taft
tanc...@iscs.nus.sg Raymond Tan C L
tan...@freeze.oslo.dnmi.no Adrian Phillips
ta...@tor.numetrix.com Tao Lu
ta...@alsys.com Tarik Rahal @pulsar
td...@lookout.ecte.uswc.uswest.com
t...@x.org Thomas E. Cavin
t...@isgtec.com Ted Richards
tgil...@news.abq.bdm.com Todd Gilbert
tgr...@ix.netcom.com Tom Griffin
thi...@verilog.fr Marc Thirion
t...@panix.com Tim Mullen
ti...@x.org T. Hsu
tk...@cogsci.ed.ac.uk Kevin Davidson
t...@hrz.uni-kassel.de Thomas Landgraf
t...@ormaudib.cnet.att.com Teresa L. Smith X6914
tlw...@austin.ibm.com Tracy Porter
tmor...@infomania.com Tom Mornini
to...@sled.gsfc.nasa.gov Todd Bernard
t...@finwds01.tu-graz.ac.at Thomas Leitner
to...@hpcvuse.cv.hp.com Thomas J. Gilg
to...@ims.com Antonio Freixas
trul...@mscd.edu Jon Trulson
tsa...@hpcms.co.il Tsachi Merin
tur...@xdiv.LANL.GOV John Turner
unb...@srv.PacBell.COM Neil Butani
vah...@ce.philips.nl Vahsen Rob
vand...@ccmail.lhs.be Filip Vandamme
v...@triteal.com Victor Martinez
vin...@kjemi.unit.no Hans Vindvad
vo...@klee.informatik.uni-stuttgart.de Michael Vogt
W.Ko...@rc.RUG.NL Willem Koster
wak...@pinn.net tom wakelyn
wal...@hpfcsls.fc.hp.com Jeff Walls
war...@sco.COM Warren Levy
we...@rto.dec.com Digital UNIX: the only UNIX made by engineers
whi...@hpcvlx.cv.hp.com Joe Whitty
wil...@stimpy.fp.co.nz Tim Williscroft
wit...@aurean.ca Witold Owoc
w...@unx.dec.com Walt Kopy
wom...@aquilagroup.com Christopher M. Conway
wood...@zk3.dec.com Tom Woodburn, DTN 381-0429
yan...@mpd.tandem.com Qi_Yanling
yog...@sunserv.kfki.hu Joh' "None Danone...
zai...@lab.ipmce.su Pete A. Zaitcev
zde...@patpsun1.epfl.ch Zdenek Sekera
ze...@tyrell.net Ned Fleming
z...@triteal.com Tom Zipoli
Voted No
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
bo...@datasync.com Martin H. Booda
cat...@netcom.com Mark Kupferman
csa...@urc.tue.nl Michiel Wijers
d...@sws5.ctd.ornl.gov
dou...@netdoor.com Douglas Stewart
ijac...@chiark.chu.cam.ac.uk Ian Jackson
j...@anubis.han.de Jens-Uwe Mager
pa...@catfish.lcs.mit.edu Patrick J. LoPresti
ri...@bcm.tmc.edu Richard H. Miller
shun...@chat.carleton.ca Scott Huntley
sma...@turing.toronto.edu Smarasderagd
stai...@bga.com Dwight Brown
tb...@sybase.com Tony Basoglu
thor.k...@pcb.mpoli.fi Thor Kottelin
tla...@email.univpubs.american.edu Todd C. Lawson
Vincent...@hsc.fr.net Vincent Archer
wide...@cc.helsinki.fi Risto Widenius
Abstained
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
m...@RedBrick.COM Maxime Taksar KC6ZPS
Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
cfri...@radiks.net Chuck Frichot
! Conflicting votes
de...@triteal.com Dean Dapkewicz
! No vote statement in message
sa...@beryl.biotech.cdc.gov Sarah McKneally
! No vote statement in message
sys...@viper.LPL.Arizona.EDU
! Invalid address