Ryan, are you using an XGA card or XGA-NI [XGA-2]?
"standard 16-bit color palette load method"
For which "standard"? VGA? XGA?
"If I try to use the one listed 65536 color mode the screen redraws to
long and distorted, the colors are very dark so no luck there."
I assume the 640x480x 64k palette bypass mode [aka direct color mode]?