Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

ATI or 3DFX or Mistique

1 view
Skip to first unread message

Arthur Merar

unread,
Apr 21, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/21/97
to

Hello,

I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different
stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
is. Which one should I get?

Thanks for your comments,

Arthur
amerar@#unsu.com
http://www.unsu.com

Ron Ablang

unread,
Apr 22, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/22/97
to Arthur Merar

Arthur Merar wrote:
>
> Hello,
>
> I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different
> stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
> ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
> is. Which one should I get?

I myself am planning to get the ATI All-In-Wonder video card. The price
is very high, yes, but I want to be able to make use of those nice
features when given a tv/cable input signal.

http://www.atitech.com/

--

Main Home Page - http://www.netforward.com/poboxes/?ablang
Computer Games Sale - http://gaia.csus.edu/~ablangr/sale.html
Secondary Site - http://members.tripod.com/~ablang
The Callisto Page - http://gaia.csus.edu/~ablangr/cal
My Dream Computer - http://gaia.csus.edu/~cs008150

"Those most likely to kill or be killed include engineering students,
disgruntled postal office workers, and Packard Bell owners."

-- Ron Ablang, April 1997

Amit Raam

unread,
Apr 24, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/24/97
to

Arthur Merar <ame...@unsu.com> wrote:

>Hello,
>
>I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different
>stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
>ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
>is. Which one should I get?
>

>Thanks for your comments,
>
>Arthur
>amerar@#unsu.com
>http://www.unsu.com

Hi,
It's quite simple:
want 3D ? stay away from ATI.
Want TV output or tuner or good MPEG ? get ATI.

Amit Raam

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sorry, I don't post my Email anymore.
All that real.address.nospam stuff does't work!
Sorry for the inconvenience, I've been spammed to death!

Gregory Kam

unread,
Apr 24, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/24/97
to

Amit Raam <q...@no.junk.mail.please> wrote:

>Arthur Merar <ame...@unsu.com> wrote:
>
>>I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different
>>stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
>>ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
>>is. Which one should I get?
>
>It's quite simple:
>want 3D ? stay away from ATI.
>Want TV output or tuner or good MPEG ? get ATI.

What if you want them all? :-)

I'm thinking of getting an ATI All-in-Wonder and then later upgrading
the 3D with a 3Dfx card. That should work, shouldn't it?

Greg

Michael Kelsey

unread,
Apr 24, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/24/97
to

In article <335C3F...@unsu.com>,
Arthur Merar <ame...@unsu.com> writes:
> Hello,

>
> I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different
> stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
> ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
> is. Which one should I get?
>
> Thanks for your comments,
>
> Arthur
> amerar@#unsu.com
> http://www.unsu.com

Your choice of video card should be based upon your needs. I will describe
the basic needs each of the above satisfies.

[1] Matrox Mystique

Excellent DOS VGA/SVGA performance. Great for proprietary CAD software
and DOS games.
Excellent 2D acceleration in Windows '95. Not blazing, but fast 32-bit
color.
Mediocre MPEG playback. And S3-Virge performs equally if not better.
Limited but SPEEDY 3D acceleration functions. Lacks support for
Fog, Transparency, Texture Filtering and MIP Mapping in most Direct-3D
[Windows '95] games.
Flashable BIOS. Great for future improvements in speed.
Expandable to 8MB of memory.
DMA enhancements for better throughput.
Robust and speedy "Matrox quality" video drivers.
Quick but very limited 3D acceleration.

This video adapter is a marvelous compromise offering remarkable 2D
acceleration and DOS VGA/SVGA performance, high refresh rates [nonOEM],
and some albeit limited but fast 3D rendering features. Tomb Raider is
an excellent example of how the Matrox Mystique will be supported in the
future.
By default, this video adapter meets basic user criteria. Matrox is
developing video capture/playback solutions that will increase the function-
ality of the Mystique. Also note the 2MB edition may be upgraded to 8MB
of memory unlike most 2MB video adapters which are only upgradable to 4MB.
In terms of 3D acceleration, the Mystique offers good performance,
on par with the ATI 3D Pro Turbo [with equivalently set features] however,
if plan on any serious 3D, you may as well purchase a VooDoo 3DFX at the
same time. The Mystique lacks some important features that are becoming
"options" in upcoming Windows '95 Direct-3D products. Activision's
Mechwarrior II Mercaneries clearly shows what Matrox chose not to include
in their 3D rendering engine.

[2] VooDoo 3DFX

A dedicated 3D adapter that enables or disables your existing 2D adapter
based on the application.
Requires an existing 2D adapter to be present in your system.
Requires an open PCI slot [this can be a problem if you have SCSI,
ethernet, ATI+TV, bus mouse, and audio]
Provides OUSTANDING 3D performance even on lower end Pentium systems.
Ships with a variety of 3D software optimized for the 3DFX.
Limited to 4MB of EDO memory, [split 2MB texture and 2MB rendering]

The addition is a must have for any dedicated gamer. You will neither
sacrafice your 2D performance in DOS or Windows and you will gain the
3D functionality that all the 3DFX owners brag about. I tested out Tomb
Raider, Descent II, and Mechwarrior II and each of these was equally
as impressive. Just one phrase describes this adapter "you'll never want
to go back!"
Note that 3DFX interactive has a proprietary OpenGL library dedicated
to accelerate GL Quake. GL Quake, although not as overwhelming as Tomb
Raider and Mechwarrior II made me think twice about waiting for ATI's
distribution of their GL libraries.

[3] ATI 3D Pro Turbo PC2TV [similar to All-In-Wonder]

4MB of SGRAM exp. to 8MB with 2MB and 4MB upgrade modules.
2MB [up to 4MB?] on the All-In-Wonder using SDRAM.
Ships with or with the following games. "With" if not the 3D Pro Turbo.
WipeOut Mechwarrior II Assault Rigs
Sub-par DOS VGA performance.
Excellent DOS VGA X-MODE performance.
Average SVGA DOS performance, on par with S3-Vision and Virge chipsets
with UniVBE loaded.
VESA 2.0 built-in. Loading UniVBE does not improve performance, unlike
the mentioned S3 boards.
Jaw dropping MPEG performance/filtering.
Adequate 2D Windows '95 performance. Flies in both 16-bit and 8-bit
modes, all resolutions.
Tolerable 24-bit mode acceleration. Horrible 32-bit speed.
Facilitated TV output all resolutions up to 800x600x32-bit.
Optional TV tuner addition. Built-in TV tuner on All-In-Wonder.
stereo TNC coax connection on the All-In-Wonder.
Slow but full featured 3D abilities.

I have never tested the features or performance of the All-In-Wonder,
however it is based on the Rage II chipset therefore I can draw some
[accurate] conclusions about the performance.
The ATI Rage II boards offer good acceleration in Windows '95 all
all resolutions with color depths of 16-bit or less. This basically makes
the video adapter useless for any serious Windows poweruser. The ATI, like
the Mystique, offers 3D in a window allowing for CAD related Direct-3D
applications to take advantage of hardware acceleration.
Unlike the Mystique, the ATI is rather slow when renderig 3D functions.
The quality is good, but nowhere near the quality of the 3DFX based add-on
adapters. Counter to the Mystique, the ATI, like the 3DFX offers recog-
nizable fog, transparency, filtering and MIP mapping through Windows '95.
A good example is Direct-3D Mechwarrior II Mercaneries. No doubt this
application would be horrible without 3D acceleration, but even the 3D
features of the Mystique couldn't help increase the image qaulity or
performance. The 3DFX was not tested with the program, however, the ATI
has been and the image quality is world's above that offered by the
Mystique with little or no sacrafice in speed.
The MPEG performance on the ATI is outstanding at all resolutions
and color depths. I nice improvement over the Matrox Mystique. Note
that the subject of MPEG performance is not applicable to the 3DFX.
ATI has provided a TV tuner, optional with their other boards,
specifically on the All-In-Wonder. Streaming capture is possible,
although there is a steep processor requirement should you want any
reasonable frame rate or size. The TV input is easy to use and of
good clarity and quality at all color depths and resolutions.

/\/\ichael |<elsey
mke...@eecs.wsu.edu


Jian-xiong Wang

unread,
Apr 25, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/25/97
to

Ron Ablang (cs00...@gaia.ecs.csus.edu) wrote:

: Arthur Merar wrote:
: >
: > Hello,


: >
: > I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different
: > stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
: > ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
: > is. Which one should I get?

: I myself am planning to get the ATI All-In-Wonder video card. The price


: is very high, yes, but I want to be able to make use of those nice
: features when given a tv/cable input signal.

: http://www.atitech.com/


I have seen it for $295 and $329CND for 2MB and 4MB.
It's about $200US and cheaper than a card + TV tunner.


Edward Hong

unread,
Apr 26, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/26/97
to

Gregory Kam (gk...@Newbridge.COM) writes:
> Amit Raam <q...@no.junk.mail.please> wrote:
>>Arthur Merar <ame...@unsu.com> wrote:
>>

>>>I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different
>>>stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
>>>ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
>>>is. Which one should I get?
>>

>>It's quite simple:
>>want 3D ? stay away from ATI.
>>Want TV output or tuner or good MPEG ? get ATI.
>
> What if you want them all? :-)
>
> I'm thinking of getting an ATI All-in-Wonder and then later upgrading
> the 3D with a 3Dfx card. That should work, shouldn't it?
>
> Greg

If you want a TV tuner and an ATI card, I would get the 3D xpression +
PC2TV and the TV tuner instead of the All-in-wonder. The reason is if you
want to upgrade to a faster 2d/3d ATI card you can always use your tv tuner
for that card. For the all-in-wonder, you have to chuck the whole card to
upgrade. Also, the all-in-wonder costs more than buying the two cards
separately and the Xpression uses SDRAM while the all-in-wonder uses EDO.
The cool thing about the PC2TV cards is you can use a PCX2 based card and
it will output to your TV.

ed


s...@shasta.mtn

unread,
Apr 26, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/26/97
to

In article <5jqve3$1...@ccshst05.cs.uoguelph.ca>, jxw...@uoguelph.ca
says...

>
> Ron Ablang (cs00...@gaia.ecs.csus.edu) wrote:
>
> : Arthur Merar wrote:
> : >
> : > Hello,
> : >
> : > I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different

> : > stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
> : > ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
> : > is. Which one should I get?
>
> : I myself am planning to get the ATI All-In-Wonder video card. The price
> : is very high, yes, but I want to be able to make use of those nice
> : features when given a tv/cable input signal.
>
> : http://www.atitech.com/
>
>
> I have seen it for $295 and $329CND for 2MB and 4MB.
> It's about $200US and cheaper than a card + TV tunner.
>
>
>
They are in Canada -

http://www.atitech.ca


Allan Cole

unread,
Apr 27, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/27/97
to


> This video adapter is a marvelous compromise offering remarkable 2D
>acceleration and DOS VGA/SVGA performance, high refresh rates [nonOEM],

The OEM and retail versions of the Mystique use the same internal
RAMDAC running at 170mhz and support the same resolutions and refresh
rates (they are identical, AFAIK).


>and some albeit limited but fast 3D rendering features. Tomb Raider is
>an excellent example of how the Matrox Mystique will be supported in the
>future.

I really doubt there will be many, if any, more future direct ports
for the Mystique.


> By default, this video adapter meets basic user criteria. Matrox is
>developing video capture/playback solutions that will increase the function-
>ality of the Mystique. Also note the 2MB edition may be upgraded to 8MB
>of memory unlike most 2MB video adapters which are only upgradable to 4MB.

Like the ATI 3D Pro Turbo though, the extra 4megs of memory does
nothing for supporting 1600x1200x24bit\32bit like the extra 4megs on a
Millennium will. AFAIK, the extra memory on the Mystique or 3D Pro
will only benefit their not-so-great 3D performance in allowing 3D
acceleration at higher resolutions or possibly allowing great virtual
desktop resolutions. I'd say most everyone using a Mystique or Rage
II board would find the extra 4megs practically useless. Also, AFAIK
the Rainbow Runner additions for the Mystique that you are referring
to aren't usable when a memory upgrade is used unlike the Rage II
boards.


> In terms of 3D acceleration, the Mystique offers good performance,
>on par with the ATI 3D Pro Turbo [with equivalently set features] however,

Calling either the 3D Pro's or Mystique's 3D performance "good" is
being quite generous, IMHO. I'd say the ATI's 3D performance is slow,
the Mystique's 3D performance is mediocre with some features lacking,
the Verite's 3D performance is very good, and the Voodoo's 3D
performance is great.


>if plan on any serious 3D, you may as well purchase a VooDoo 3DFX at the
>same time. The Mystique lacks some important features that are becoming
>"options" in upcoming Windows '95 Direct-3D products. Activision's
>Mechwarrior II Mercaneries clearly shows what Matrox chose not to include
>in their 3D rendering engine.
>
>[2] VooDoo 3DFX
>
> A dedicated 3D adapter that enables or disables your existing 2D adapter
> based on the application.
> Requires an existing 2D adapter to be present in your system.
> Requires an open PCI slot [this can be a problem if you have SCSI,
> ethernet, ATI+TV, bus mouse, and audio]
> Provides OUSTANDING 3D performance even on lower end Pentium systems.
> Ships with a variety of 3D software optimized for the 3DFX.
> Limited to 4MB of EDO memory, [split 2MB texture and 2MB rendering]
>
> The addition is a must have for any dedicated gamer. You will neither
>sacrafice your 2D performance in DOS or Windows and you will gain the
>3D functionality that all the 3DFX owners brag about. I tested out Tomb
>Raider, Descent II, and Mechwarrior II and each of these was equally
>as impressive. Just one phrase describes this adapter "you'll never want
>to go back!"
> Note that 3DFX interactive has a proprietary OpenGL library dedicated
>to accelerate GL Quake. GL Quake, although not as overwhelming as Tomb
>Raider and Mechwarrior II made me think twice about waiting for ATI's
>distribution of their GL libraries.

I feel sure that GLQuake will be unplayable on the 3D Pro even with
OpenGL support. Personally, I think that GLQuake and derivatives
thereof are more overwhelming than Tomb Raider and Mechwarrior II, but
that is clearly a matter of personal opinion.


>[3] ATI 3D Pro Turbo PC2TV [similar to All-In-Wonder]
>
> 4MB of SGRAM exp. to 8MB with 2MB and 4MB upgrade modules.
> 2MB [up to 4MB?] on the All-In-Wonder using SDRAM.
> Ships with or with the following games. "With" if not the 3D Pro Turbo.
> WipeOut Mechwarrior II Assault Rigs
> Sub-par DOS VGA performance.
> Excellent DOS VGA X-MODE performance.

I find the ModeX performance of the 3D Pro to be pretty good but not
excellent. Other cards such as the ET6000, Virge, and Mystique have
better ModeX performance, IMO.


> Average SVGA DOS performance, on par with S3-Vision and Virge chipsets
> with UniVBE loaded.

The retail Stealth3D 2000 Virge (using Univbe) is significantly faster
than the 3D Pro in SVGA DOS performance.


> VESA 2.0 built-in. Loading UniVBE does not improve performance, unlike
> the mentioned S3 boards.

Well, that would be because S3 boards don't support VESA 2.0 in
hardware so they naturally don't perform as well or at all without a
VESA 2.0 TSR.


> Jaw dropping MPEG performance/filtering.
> Adequate 2D Windows '95 performance. Flies in both 16-bit and 8-bit
> modes, all resolutions.
> Tolerable 24-bit mode acceleration. Horrible 32-bit speed.
> Facilitated TV output all resolutions up to 800x600x32-bit.
> Optional TV tuner addition. Built-in TV tuner on All-In-Wonder.
> stereo TNC coax connection on the All-In-Wonder.

Also, the All-In-Wonder leaves the AMC channel open for future
upgrades whereas adding an ATI-Tuner board to the 3D Pro\Xpression+
does not. Maybe future AMC upgrade options will address this with a
passthrough?


> Slow but full featured 3D abilities.
>
> I have never tested the features or performance of the All-In-Wonder,
>however it is based on the Rage II chipset therefore I can draw some
>[accurate] conclusions about the performance.
> The ATI Rage II boards offer good acceleration in Windows '95 all
>all resolutions with color depths of 16-bit or less. This basically makes
>the video adapter useless for any serious Windows poweruser.

I suppose you mean any window's power user that needs excellent
24\32bit color performance... I'd say a large percentage (if not most)
"window's power users" don't need 24\32bit color or need it so rarely
that the Rage II's mediocre performance in those modes isn't much of a
hinderance.


>The ATI, like
>the Mystique, offers 3D in a window allowing for CAD related Direct-3D
>applications to take advantage of hardware acceleration.
> Unlike the Mystique, the ATI is rather slow when renderig 3D functions.
>The quality is good, but nowhere near the quality of the 3DFX based add-on
>adapters. Counter to the Mystique, the ATI, like the 3DFX offers recog-
>nizable fog, transparency, filtering and MIP mapping through Windows '95.
>A good example is Direct-3D Mechwarrior II Mercaneries. No doubt this
>application would be horrible without 3D acceleration, but even the 3D
>features of the Mystique couldn't help increase the image qaulity or
>performance.

Unless I'm missing something or you're testing a beta release,
Mechwarrior Mercenaries -doesn't- support hardware 3D acceleration.
The Mystique should_look the same as other boards playing the game.


>The 3DFX was not tested with the program, however, the ATI
>has been and the image quality is world's above that offered by the
>Mystique with little or no sacrafice in speed.
> The MPEG performance on the ATI is outstanding at all resolutions
>and color depths. I nice improvement over the Matrox Mystique. Note
>that the subject of MPEG performance is not applicable to the 3DFX.

Video playback in games with the Voodoo isn't that great though, IMO.
The cut scenes from Descent II and Tomb Raider don't look nearly as
good as when played back with my 2D board. Correcting the gamma on
the Voodoo to reduce the gross pixelation that occurs during video
playback with the default gamma settings helps some with the
pixelization, but I've found that setting the gamma low enough to
eliminate the pixelization results in everything being too dark.
Regardless, the clarity of the video just isn't as good with the
Voodoo even if the gamma pixelization problem isn't figured in, IMO...
at least in Descent II and Tomb Raider. Maybe the problem is specific
to the video in those games... I'm not sure yet.


> ATI has provided a TV tuner, optional with their other boards,
>specifically on the All-In-Wonder. Streaming capture is possible,
>although there is a steep processor requirement should you want any
>reasonable frame rate or size.

Like you say, processor speed is important, but possibly more
important is that most current EIDE and many SCSI hard disks aren't
capable of the bandwidth needed for reliably capturing the
uncompressed video of the Rage II boards at high frame rates and
larger sizes.


>The TV input is easy to use and of
>good clarity and quality at all color depths and resolutions.

Allan Cole

no...@nuc.net

Allan Cole

unread,
Apr 27, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/27/97
to


>>>I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different
>>>stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
>>>ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
>>>is. Which one should I get?
>>

>>It's quite simple:
>>want 3D ? stay away from ATI.
>>Want TV output or tuner or good MPEG ? get ATI.
>
>What if you want them all? :-)
>
>I'm thinking of getting an ATI All-in-Wonder and then later upgrading
>the 3D with a 3Dfx card. That should work, shouldn't it?

That's basically what I have (3D Pro\Tuner\Voodoo). I think it is a
fantastic combination that is the best choice available if you want
what that combination has to offer. If the Mystique's Rainbow Runner
options turn out to be as reliable, full-featured, and easy to use as
the ATI combo, the Mystique\Rainbow Runner\Voodoo may be the best
(although considerably more expensive) choice, IMO.

Allan Cole

no...@nuc.net

Allan Cole

unread,
Apr 27, 1997, 3:00:00 AM4/27/97
to


>>>>I am trying to decide which video card to get. I have heard different
>>>>stories from different people. One of my friends tells me how good the
>>>>ATI All-In-Wonder is, and other friend tells my how good the Mistique
>>>>is. Which one should I get?
>>>
>>>It's quite simple:
>>>want 3D ? stay away from ATI.
>>>Want TV output or tuner or good MPEG ? get ATI.
>>
>> What if you want them all? :-)
>>
>> I'm thinking of getting an ATI All-in-Wonder and then later upgrading
>> the 3D with a 3Dfx card. That should work, shouldn't it?
>>

>> Greg
>
>If you want a TV tuner and an ATI card, I would get the 3D xpression +
>PC2TV and the TV tuner instead of the All-in-wonder. The reason is if you
>want to upgrade to a faster 2d/3d ATI card you can always use your tv tuner
>for that card. For the all-in-wonder, you have to chuck the whole card to
>upgrade. Also, the all-in-wonder costs more than buying the two cards
>separately and the Xpression uses SDRAM while the all-in-wonder uses EDO.
>The cool thing about the PC2TV cards is you can use a PCX2 based card and
>it will output to your TV.

I think the All-In-Wonder is a better choice than the 3D
Xpression+\Tuner combo. The All-In-Wonder only takes up one slot, it
has a stereo TV tuner instead of the mono one that comes on the
ATI-Tuner add-in board, and it leaves the AMC channel open for future
upgrades. I'm left wondering how the Xpression+\Tuner combo will be
able to upgrade to ATI's future DVD add-in PCI board that will use the
AMC channel that the ATI-Tuner in that setup would be using. Maybe
there will be a passthrough? Also, the faster ATI board may not be
the best choice when it is released so I wouldn't be basing any of my
current purchasing decisions on vaporware. I'm not going to buy a
Rage III board costing $200-300US just so I can use my current $100US
ATI-Tuner board that I've been using for months if the Rage III isn't
one of the best choices in its price range. Regardless, by the time
the Rage III is released, ATI may have a better tuner option, and even
if they don't, the tuner option will be fairly cheap (currently they
are selling for around $100US... it should sell for less a few months
down the road) and the All-In-Wonder should be relatively easy to
re-sell, especially with its built-in tuner, or would be a great
choice to use in a second system. Just my two cents.

Allan Cole

no...@nuc.net

0 new messages