Are we really expected to believe that Guybrush dreamt the whole
thing, or, as I seem to think, LeChuck has Guybrush under a spell,
like Elaine says at the end.
Why didn't I get to use the love bomb on Elaine.
Why is this an annoying ending to an otherwise flawless game.
Is LucasArts setting itself up for a sequel or something.
Please email any comments to me - (Have I even got the right ending?)
: Unfortunately, the very ending is the worst part of the game, IMO.
: If they had cut it off just a little bit earlier....
: Anyway, enough rambling. I think that Guybrush's reversion to
: Kid Guybrush is just a result of him falling under the spell of
: LeChuck. He's just dreaming or hallucinating when he imagines himself
: as a kid at an amusement park.
: The thing that makes me say this is the fact that the last thing
: we see, if I recall correctly ( it has been awhile ), is the
: Governer hanging over the pit. She says something to the effect of:
: " I wonder where Guybrush is? I hope he hasn't fallen under LeChuck's
: spell. "
: If history had changed, or if the whole thing was a fantasy of
: Lil' Guybrush, this scene just doesn't make sense. I can't imagine
: any reason to include it, other than to tell the viewers that
: Guybrush is under the mental domination of LeChuck.
: Which is my story, and I'm sticking to it. I'm sure if I've
: misremembered or such, there will be many to correct me. Unfortunately,
: they seem to have left us with a cliffhanger either way, and absolutely
: no apparent intention to follow up on it, whatsoever. Pfah!
: It's enough to make a fellow want to lash out with a voodoo curse.
If what you say is true, where are their carnival references even back in
Monkey Island 1?
>If what you say is true, where are their carnival references even back in
>Monkey Island 1?
Uhhh. Because there are carnivals on the various islands in the
game? There are carnivals in Real Life ( TM ) and there were carnivals
in ye olde pirate days. And carnivals are colorful places to reference.
Do you have anything more specific in mind that supports Monkey
Island I and II being the dreams of Kid Guybrush at a carnival?
I don't see the carnival references in the first game as being supporting
evidence for anything in particular. There were also cemeteries in
both games, but I don't think that points to much.
I'm still sticking with Guybrush under LeChuck's spell. What is the
final scene with the Governor over the pit about if all that is just
a dream of Kid Guybrush? Did he clutch his head and have a flashback?
And, given LeChuck's ghostly manifestation as a kid, I think it's
clear that this isn't exactly a normal world. Why does Lil' LeChuck
go all ghostly? Is he some kind of psychic boy, tormenting Guybrush?
The theory that he's under a spell is just a whole lot simpler to
my mind. All we've got to explain is why LeChuck made Guybrush
experience that particular dreamscape. I just can't come up with a
story that has it all as a dream or has history changed that makes
as much sense and doesn't raise a lot more weird questions.
And having the Governor actually say that she hopes Guybrush doesn't
fall under LeChuck's spell is kind of a big indicator, IMO.
Of course the answer doesn't really have to make sense, but I'd
prefer it. It could be one of those situations where we
have two worlds I suppose, with Guybrush and LeChuck bouncing back
and forth between the two. Kind of hackneyed, IMO. I guess we'll
ultimately have to wait for either the authors to chime in, or for
the next game.
As I have posted before, this cliff-hanger has implications far beyond
just game play. My family and I loved Guybrush, and we even named one of
our gerbils after him. Alas, Guybrush Threepgerbil passed away (of old
age) several years ago, without ever learning of Guybrush Threepwood's
final fate. He is buried beneath the oak tree in our back yard, but his
soul will never be at peace until his namesake is delivered from
LeChuck's evil clutches.
Please, LucasArts. Whatever it was that you did to drive Ron Gilbert
away, can't you find some way to make amends? Please lure him back, and
set him to work on "Monkey Island 3: Guybrush Gets the Girl."
This post is dedicated to the memory of Guybrush (the gerbil) and his fellow
gerbils Gavroche, Whiskers, Nibble and Bobbin.