On Fri, 25 Jan 2019 18:15:09 -0500, Rin Stowleigh
<
rstow...@xnospamx.com> wrote:
>On Fri, 25 Jan 2019 09:08:36 -0500, Spalls Hurgenson
><
spallsh...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>>On Thu, 24 Jan 2019 19:01:54 -0500, Rin Stowleigh
>><
rstow...@xnospamx.com> wrote:
>>>Agreed Cartel was horrible... but I'm pretty sure Gunslinger came
>>>before it.
>>Nope, Gunslinger is the fourth and latest of the series.
>I looked it up and you're right. I think the confusion in my mind
>came from the fact that Cartel never really felt like part of the
>series to me. Not just in the sense that it was probably one of the
>most disappointing releases I can remember in my gaming history, but
>the fact that it couldn't even be considered a Western. Maybe like
>GTA San Andreas takes place "in the west".. lol.
>WTF were they thinking, branding it Call of Juarez?
It's been a while, but the connection was that the protagonist was a
descendant of the heroes of the earlier games and - although set in
the modern age - thematically it /was/ still a "western" in the sense
that it was set in the West (albeit one that has long been overrun by
suburbs and pavement) and featured a lone gunman taking on hordes of
black-hats. But you weren't the only one disappointed by the direction
the franchise took, hence the soft reboot to Gunslinger.
Honestly, had the gameplay (and story/characters) been better, I
wouldn't have minded the shift - you /can/ do a modern-day Western -
but Cartel just wasn't a fun experience. Its setting felt generic, its
characters were unlikable and its gunplay was unsatisfying. I didn't
really enjoy any of the Juarez games, but Cartel is definitely the one
I liked least.
So rather than devote more time to /that/ awful game, let's focus on
some forgotten Westerns I enjoyed more. These aren't the best Western
games, just a handful of titles that deserve to be remembered.
- "The Gunman Chronicles"
It's a Western... but in SPACE! A mod-turned-professional, Gunman
utilized the old Half Life 1 engine to tell a story about a betrayed
space ranger hunting down his traitorous commander. In terms of
gameplay, it wasn't anything special but it had a decent variety of
locations and styles and was just camp enough to keep things
interesting.
- "Damnation"
Another odd mix of sci-fi and Western, set in a steampunk alternate
future. Its gameplay and production values are rather poor, but I
remember being impressed by its potential; it was a mix of Tomb Raider
exploration and traditional third-person shooter. It didn't pull
either facet off very well, but I appreciated that it was at least
trying something different.
- "Dead Man's Hand"
Honestly, not that great a game but given the dearth of Western
shooters, I played anything. My memories are vague on this game - I've
only played it the once and never returned for a second playthrough -
but I recall it felt slow and clunky and had an awful soundtrack.
- "Hard West"
Not a first-person shooter, this is more a cross of X-Com with a
Western. It also adds some weird mystical elements. The combat was
fairly satisfying but the bits outside that - its progression system
and the side-missions - weren't as much fun.
- "The Gunstringer"
An oft-forgotten game, largely because it was so dependent on the XBox
Kinect peripheral. Gameplay wasn't that great, but it was just weird
enough - the protagonist was a puppet-on-strings - to be memorable.