RESULT: comp.publish.cdrom.{hardware,multimedia,software} pass
Chaim Manaster
newsgroups called comp.publish.cdrom.{software, hardware,
multimedia} which have been voted on and passed. The voting ended on
May 21, 1993.
[[ news.announce.newgroups moderator's note: the result was delayed
for so long because Mr. Manaster was away from the net throughout
the month of June; I was originally notified of passing results by
this tabulation in late May, but the final RESULT article was not
prepared until recently. -- tale ]]
VOTE RESULT
294 persons voted in all:
Since the difference of the numbers of positive and negative votes
is more than 100, and more than 2/3 of the voters were positive,
for each of the 3 newsgroups voted upon, comp.publish.cdrom.{software,
hardware, multimedia} PASS the Usenet criteria for the
creation of a newsgroup. If substantial objections concerning
individual votes or the fairness of the voting process as a whole are
not made within 5 days of the posting of this result (by posting to
news.groups), then a control message for the creation of the newsgroup
will be issued by David Lawrence (ta...@uunet.uu.net), the moderator
of news.announce.newgroups.
The votes tabulate as follows:
group Yes vote No vote Abstain
----- -------- ------- -------
software 240 38 1
hardware 234 38 3
multimedia 227 45 3
In the vote listing below the votes are shown in the sequence
listed above for the groups. The symbols have the following
meaning:
A abstain
blank no vote cast for that group
? ambiguous vote discarded
T untimely vote discarded
N a no vote
Y a yes vote
May 22, 1993 (date of original RESULT posting in old format).
July 6, 1993 (date of this posting in requested format).
Henry Manaster <mana...@yu1.yu.edu>
The following is the list of voters:
YYY 6500null%ucs...@hub.ucsb.edu (-Null-)
YY <jlane%sedofis%sed.b...@CUNYVM.CUNY.EDU>
NNN Ahmed Al-Ashabb <ah...@mansun.lut.ac.uk>
YYY Alan Honeyman <al...@hparc1.aus.hp.com>
YYY Alexandros Labrinidis <labr...@ics.forth.gr>
YYY Amir Plivatsky <am...@actcom.com>
YYY Andre' V. Thomas" <an...@boombox.micro.umn.edu>
YYY Ari Lemmke <a...@cs.hut.fi>
YYY BRY...@AppleLink.Apple.COM (BryTen, Bryant Patten,PAS)
YYY Bernard Cuche <cu...@vaw.ethz.ch>
YYY Bernard Lang <Bernar...@inria.fr>
YYY Brent L. Bates ViGYAN AAD/TAB" <blb...@aero36.larc.nasa.gov>
YYY Bryan Boreham <br...@alex.com>
YYY Chris Eich <chr...@srlr13.sr.hp.com>
YYY Christian Smith <csm...@blackplague.gmu.edu>
YYY Christopher Kilbourn <squ...@u.washington.edu>
YYY DO...@sscl.uwo.ca (Doug Link)
YYY Dave Beckett <dj...@ukc.ac.uk>
YYY Dave L Isenberg <src...@world.std.com>
YYY Dave_...@vos.stratus.com
YYY David K Wall <dkw...@afic01.af.mil>
YYY David Martland <David.M...@brunel.ac.uk>
YYY David Muir Sharnoff <mu...@idiom.berkeley.ca.us>
YYY David Turcaso <dtur...@world.std.com>
YYY David Ziedman" <David_Ziedman@mac_link.aimla.com>
YYY David.T...@East.Sun.COM (David Tahajian - Sun BOS Software)
YAA Dawn_He...@oclc.org
Y Denise_...@umail.umd.edu (dd46)
YYY Dennis Carothers <den...@world.std.com>
YYY Diomidis Spinellis <d...@doc.ic.ac.uk>
YYY Dirk Herr-Hoyman <hoy...@joe.uwex.edu>
YYN Doug Raichle" <doug_r...@maca.sarnoff.com>
YYY Dr Jim Cummins <cum...@csuvax1.csu.murdoch.edu.au>
YNY Dr. Francis J. Van Wetering" <FJVA...@cbafaculty.unomaha.edu>
YYY ED...@ARIEL.LERC.NASA.GOV (Jeff Brown)
YYY Ed Hall <edh...@ives.rand.org>
YYA Edward C Connors <ecco...@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu>
NYY Emmanuel Vlastakis <vlas...@CC.ims.disa.mil>
NNN Ernest A. Cline <cl...@usceast.cs.scarolina.edu>
YYY F_JACKSONJL@CCSVAX
YYY Francois Rouaix <Francoi...@inria.fr>
YYY George Lindholm <lind...@ucs.ubc.ca>
YYY Gerald A. Smith <gsm...@gunter-emh.af.mil>
YYY Giuliani Roberto <g...@necsy.it>
YNN Glyn Simpson <simp...@sun1.bham.ac.uk>
NNN Hardcore Alaskan <FS...@acad3.alaska.edu>
YYY Harley Quilliam <cus...@surrey.ac.uk>
YYY Harold Ancell" <pl0...@psilink.com>
YYY Heinz Morandell <mora...@orchidee.informatik.uni-stuttgart.de>
YYY J. KEITH OSTERTAG" <OSTERTAGK%SNYCORV...@CUNYVM.CUNY.EDU>
TTT JACK...@vms.cis.pitt.edu
Y JOSEPHINE SHAW, ATTICA CYBERNETICS, OXFORD, UK."
YYY JWI...@Jetson.UH.EDU
YYY Jann VanOver <van...@atc.boeing.com>
YYY Jason Titus <ti...@ecosys.drdr.virginia.edu>
??? Jerry Feldman, ZKO3-3/Y25, DTN:381-2970" <g...@zk3.dec.com>
??? Jesse Anderson <JAND...@vax.clarku.edu>
YYY Jim Gregory <jgre...@STL-04SIMA.ARMY.MIL>
NNN Jonathan Lin <jw...@soda.berkeley.edu>
YYY Jonathon <jshe...@laurel.ocs.mq.edu.au>
YYY Jostein Svendsen <JOST...@dhhalden.no>
YYY Katherine W. Cochrane" <71216...@CompuServe.COM>
YYY Kevin Jih <ke...@Shiva.COM>
YYY Krzy...@netxsys.guild.org (Krzysztof Adamski)
YYY LAN Lubber <AN...@acad2.alaska.edu>
YYY Larry Irons <SKG...@UMSLVMA.UMSL.EDU>
YYY Linda R. Bentley" <lin...@csn.org>
YYY Lisanke, M.G. (Mike)" <mic...@vnet.IBM.COM>
YYY M.T.Ha...@loughborough.ac.uk
YYY M.Z...@compsci.liverpool.ac.uk
YYY MAAP...@SIVM.SI.EDU" <MAAP...@SIVM.SI.EDU>
YYY MAT...@vm.cc.metu.edu.tr
YYY Manolis Tsiknakis <tsik...@ics.forth.gr>
YYY Manuel Eduardo Correia <m...@ciup1.ncc.up.pt>
YYY Manuel Friedrich <manu...@cs.tu-berlin.de>
NNN Marc Moorcroft <sma...@zooid.guild.org>
NNN Marcus Hampel <q77...@pbhrzx.uni-paderborn.de>
YYY Mark Wohar <wo...@cwis.unomaha.edu>
YYY Mew6522 <mew652...@pcmail.dcccd.edu>
YYY Michael Havemester <t...@Hamburg.Germany.EU.net>
Y Michael Hutchins <p...@draper.com>
YYY Michael.La...@nd.edu
??? Mike Gilbert <mgil...@cln.etc.bc.ca>
YYY Mike Roberts <mik...@CERF.NET>
NNN Murray Nesbitt <uunet!pseudo!m...@alsys1.aecom.yu.edu>
YYY NAME BOYD COLLINS <manc...@shrsys.hslc.org>
YYY Nathan W. Fullerton" <nf...@andrew.cmu.edu>
YYY Nathaniel W Guyton <n...@owlnet.rice.edu>
YYY Niels E. Raun" <RKU...@vm.uni-c.dk>
YYY Norval...@idt.unit.no
YYY O_RET...@ACAD.FANDM.EDU (Oscar Retterer)
YYY PAT COTY <NER...@ubvms.cc.buffalo.edu>
YYY Pamela Mason <pma...@nalusda.gov>
YYY Paul L Belloni <pl...@midway.uchicago.edu>
YYY Paul Prescod <papr...@undergrad.math.uwaterloo.ca>
YYY Paul Robinson <tda...@access.digex.net>
YYY Penio Penev <penev%rockefe...@BRL.MIL>
Y Perry_L...@vos.stratus.com
Y Philippe AIGRAIN <aig...@cerise.irit.fr>
YYY Phyllis Erck-Poole" <PHYLLIS.E...@OFFICE.WANG.COM>
YYY Pietro....@crs4.it
??? Power, Julie" <po...@stamail1.vut.edu.au>
YYY Prof. L. P. Levine" <lev...@blatz.cs.uwm.edu>
YYY Ric Canale <ric_c...@muwayf.unimelb.edu.au>
YYY Richar...@vos.stratus.com
??? Rick Hartmann <rhar...@dsl2.uoregon.edu>
YYY Rick Innis <ri...@sq.com>
Y Rick O'Connor <oco...@uamont.edu>
NNN Rob Knauerhase <kna...@cs.uiuc.edu>
NNN Robert Benningfield" <aurs01!aurw7a!benn...@concert.net>
NNN Robert Lenoil <len...@catalogic.com>
YYY Robertj Jaquiss (503) 627-4444 DS 50-454 <rob...@tekgen.bv.tek.com>
YYY Ron Zweig <r...@ccsg.tau.ac.il>
YYY Ross -Ph. 6086" <RSHE...@mtroyal.ab.ca>
YYY Ryan Waite <ry...@microsoft.com>
YYY SP M/S Services <scho...@emoryu1.cc.emory.edu>
YYY STUA...@AppleLink.Apple.COM (Aust - Nat Ed Sys Eng)
YYY Sam Elbizri <sa...@extro.ucc.su.OZ.AU>
YYY Samuel J. Goshorn" <gosh...@staff.tc.umn.edu>
NNN Shane Hartman <sh...@spr.com>
YYY Shinji Teragaito <shi...@hpjsdo.kobe.hp.com>
YYY Stephen L Stclair <stc...@world.std.com>
YYY Teppo Savinen <sav...@hkkk.fi>
YYY Terry kelleher <ter...@encore.com>
YYY Thomas D Gasser-1" <tho...@staff.tc.umn.edu> (Thomas D.Gasser)
YYY Thomas Nhan <t...@cassandra.chem.washington.edu>
YYY Thorst...@mk.maus.de (Thorsten Kitz)
NNN Timothy VanFosson <ti...@ccad.uiowa.edu>
YYY Tom German" <TGE...@vax.cns.muskingum.edu>
NNN Tom Lathrop 588-0677 <t...@sector.Kodak.COM>
??? Tom Lundstrom, Library, Hong Kong Univ. Sci. & Tech."
YYY Torsten Droste[totronik]" <10006...@CompuServe.COM>
YYN Traczyk, Jeffrey Lt Col" <JTRA...@ARIESPO.SPACELAN.SPACECOM.AF.MIL>
YYY Vidar Sonerud <vson...@alkymi.unit.no>
YYY Vivien Lim <CCELIMLL%NUSVM....@CUNYVM.CUNY.EDU>
YYY WAL...@utkvx.utk.edu
YYY WA...@GANDLF.UINDY.EDU (Joyce Wang)
YYY Wagner Michael <wagn...@informatik.tu-muenchen.de>
YYY Walter Knowles <wa...@halcyon.halcyon.com>
YY William S. Hein and Co. Inc." <wshe...@class.org>
YYY William Y. Lai" <l...@seas.gwu.edu>
YYY Youki Kadobayashi <yo...@rd.ecip.osaka-u.ac.jp>
YYY Youngwhan Lee <yw...@sparc0a.cs.uiuc.edu>
YYY ady...@jpr.com (Al Dykes)
YYY a...@econ.msk.su (Pushkin A.E.)
YYY aki...@v401.nuc.ucla.edu (Annali Kiers)
YYY ak...@sra.co.jp (Akira Hatakeyama)
YYY al...@cleveland.Freenet.Edu (Gerard Pinzone)
YYY amen...@llwsbe.linknet.com (Arthur J. Mendonca)
YYY and...@lep.lep-philips.fr (V. Andres)
YYY a...@ipac.caltech.edu
YYY aubrie claude andre <Claude...@inria.fr>
NNN bar...@dino.cs.umass.edu (Daniel Barrett)
YYY be...@uk.ate.slb.com (Malcolm Bebb)
YYY ber...@cpio1.fr.mugnet.org (Bernard Fouche)
YYY bes...@maximum.com (Brad Besmer)
YYY bill...@lynx.dac.northeastern.edu (William Smith)
NNN bog...@blaze.cs.jhu.edu (Bill Bogstad)
YYY bonelli%vax.d...@ifctr.mi.cnr.it (G.Bonelli IFCTR/CNR 39 2 2363542)
YYY bra...@pysgjb.physics.ncsu.edu (Charles Brabec)
NNN br...@huey.Jpl.Nasa.Gov (Brad Hines)
YYY br...@fangorn.hacktic.nl
YYY br...@eitech.com (Brian Smithson)
YYY bu...@siswat.hou.tx.us (Lester Buck)
YYY cald...@ohsu.EDU (Larry Caldwell)
YYY car...@allen.com (Carolyn Allen)
YYY cfu...@pnc-pimc.com (Catherine Fulmer)
YYY chang hsu liu <cl...@silver.ucs.indiana.edu>
YYY charlie birnbaum <cim...@world.std.com>
YYY cks...@beaver.win.net (Carlton K. Scott)
NNN cl...@cavebbs.welly.gen.nz (Charlie Lear)
YYY cl...@allen.com (Cliff Allen)
NNN cran...@korrd.usc.edu (Mike Crandall)
NNN cw...@amex-trs.com (Christopher Ward)
YYY da...@permanet.org (dack)
YYY dcl...@pax.tpa.com.au (David Clunie)
NNN de...@ccr-p.ida.org (David desJardins)
YYY d...@ecn.purdue.edu (Larry Weeks)
YYY dhu...@NADC.NADC.NAVY.MIL (D Huang)
NNN djo...@black.clarku.edu (Dave Joyce)
YYY dm...@ulb.ac.be (Maes D.)
YYY dmcl...@tnt.acsys.com (David Paul McLaughlin)
YYY dmdscs!viamar!kme...@rutgers.edu (Kirk Membry)
YYY dps...@husc.harvard.edu
YYY dr...@kaleida.com (Ken Morse)
YYY dsc...@b888s1.ssc.af.mil
YYY dst...@novalis.stgt.sub.org (Dieter Stoll)
YYY edw...@pro-ren.cts.com (Edward Floden)
NNN egg...@twinsun.com (Paul Eggert)
TTT emanuel rubin <eru...@bgumail.bgu.ac.il>
YYY e...@xgml.com
YYY exu...@exu.ericsson.se (Dennis Plafcan)
NNN fol...@blackstone.eece.unm.edu
NNN fran...@GAS.uug.Arizona.EDU (Gregory C Franklin )
YYY fr...@netcom.com (Fred Tempereau)
YYY g_r...@csuvax1.murdoch.edu.au
YYY ge...@bluemoon.GUN.de (Georg Sassen)
NNN g...@wolves.Durham.NC.US (Gregory G. Woodbury)
YY gr...@amazon.sandiego.NCR.COM
NNN gs...@joker.cs.hut.fi
YYY ha...@centerline.com
YYY herb...@lassie.ucx.lkg.dec.com (B.J.)
YYY hli...@fwi.uva.nl (Lieuw)
NNN hmp...@mosaic.uncc.edu (Herbert M Petro)
YYY ho...@tnt.acsys.com (Jung Pyo Hong)
YYY hub...@inference.com (Bruce D. Hubbard)
NNN hutc...@acf4.NYU.EDU (hutchins)
YYN iv...@cattell.psych.upenn.edu (Jeffrey Ivler)
YYY jb...@mswe1.dnet.ms.philips.nl (J.E.Bos, PMSN, tel. +31-40-763457)
YYY jb...@radical.com (Jim Brownfield)
NNN jb...@ohm.Berkeley.EDU (Joe Buck)
YYY je...@cbmvax.cbm.commodore.com (Randell Jesup)
YYY jh...@auburnschl.edu (Jim Hart)
YYY j...@grimaldi.rutgers.edu (Jim Martin)
YYY j...@vpm.icl.co.uk (Jim Cheetham)
??? jimson...@hub.eng.wayne.edu (Jimson Vedua)
YYY jlb...@lobby.ti.com (J. Bates)
YYY jms@tardis (Joe Smith)
YYY jnich...@bowker.com (Jim Nicholson)
YYY joh...@autodesk.com (John Freeman)
??? jost...@dhhalden.no (JOSTEIN SVENDSEN)
YYY jpgo...@ucdavis.edu
NNN j...@anaconda.Bloomington.IN.US (J.P. Hillenburg)
YYY jur...@gandalf.umcs.maine.edu (Jeff Urlwin)
YYY jwi...@whsun1.wh.whoi.edu (James Widman)
YYY kel...@tnt.acsys.com (Richard G. Kellner)
YYY k...@utig.ig.utexas.edu (Ken Griffiths) (Ken Griffiths)
YY lar...@corvus.udac.uu.se
YYY le...@microsoft.com
NNN l...@cae.wisc.edu
NNN l...@Athena.MIT.EDU
YYN lwai...@nygate.undp.org (Lorraine Waitman)
Y Y maapb006.sivm.si.edu" <emory!SIVM.SI.EDU!MAAPB006>
YYY ma...@newton.apple.com (Matthew MacLaurin)
YYY manasse!michaelv%mnvege...@Germany.EU.net (Michael Vishchers)
YYY mana...@yu1.yu.edu (Chaim Manaster)
YYY ma...@amc.com (Mark Johns)
??? mat...@peruvian.cs.utah.edu (Mark Atwood)
YYY mccl...@dlgeo.cr.usgs.gov
YYY mcm...@qucis.queensu.ca (Michael McMahon)
??? milan@mjm (Milan Merhar)
YYY mjr...@acs.ucalgary.ca
YYY mull...@cc.gettysburg.edu
YYY mundymm <mun...@lib.amc.edu>
YYY mwoo...@nyx.cs.du.edu (Mark Woodward)
YYY nda...@r-node.hub.org (Nigel Allen)
YYY ni...@netcom.com (Nick Taylor)
YYN nis...@draken.src.ricoh.co.jp
YYY n...@intermicro.msk.su (Nick Volkov)
YYY od...@ub.uit.no (Odd Ingvar Almaas)
AAY ovill...@daimi.aau.dk (Ole V. Villumsen)
YYY par...@issi.com
YYY ph...@newmedia.equinox.gen.nz (Phillip Coxon)
YYY pli...@ll.mit.edu
YYY psh...@Athena.MIT.EDU
YYY ra...@cs.usm.MY (Muhammad Rafie Hj Arshad)
YYY ra...@rafa.in-berlin.de (Ralf Neumann)
NNN ra...@UNIXHUB.SLAC.STANFORD.EDU
YYY ra...@radical2.radical.com (Ralph Jung)
NNN rba...@babylon.rmt.sub.org (Ralph Babel)
YYY rcsi...@vnet3.vub.ac.be (Roland Siebelink)
YYY r...@cfcl.com (Rich Morin)
YYY re...@silver.lcs.mit.edu (Diane Reamy)
NNN ri...@crick.ssctr.bcm.tmc.edu (Richard H. Miller)
YYY ri...@digibd.com (Rick Richardson)
YYY r...@helen.surfcty.com (Robert L. McMillin)
YYY rosa...@info.anu.edu.au
YYY ro...@kaos.b11.ingr.com (Ross Erickson)
YYY sa...@tellabs.com
YYY s...@swarm.wustl.edu (Samudra Sengupta)
YYY schoen...@eiunix.tuwien.ac.at (Martin Schoenhacker
NYN sc...@audiofax.com (Scott Lee)
YYY sh...@octel.com (Deus Xor Machina)
YYY sm...@sunyit.edu (Mary Strife)
YYY spag...@FRI-nxt-Pagiola.Stanford.EDU (Stefano Pagiola)
YYY sro...@tad.eds.com (Steve Rogers)
YYN s...@travis.csd.harris.com ( Stephen Pietrowicz)
YYY st...@dt.wdc.com (Jeff Stai (Stai) x7644)
YYY starnet!solution!fe...@uucp-gw-2.pa.dec.com
YYY s...@valinor.mythical.com (Stu Labovitz)
YAA stuart kohler" <wk0...@worldlink.com>
YYY t...@aaahq05.aaa.com (Tilak Kasturi)
YYY thi...@galton.uchicago.edu (Ronald A. Thisted)
YYY t...@wigeo.wu-wien.ac.at (Thomas Netousek)
YYY t...@cx5.com
YYY to...@microware.co.uk (Tony Mountifield)
YYY tro...@ips.id.ethz.ch
YYN uunet!decwrl!decvax!av8r!jc...@alsys1.aecom.yu.edu (John C. Cole)
NNN uunet!ta...@alsys1.aecom.yu.edu (David C Lawrence)
YYY war...@tnt.acsys.com (Tristan Wardell)
YYY wo...@alumni.cco.caltech.edu (William Edward Woody)
YYY wp...@prism.gatech.edu (Ed Price)
YYY y...@iris11.lbo.be (Yves Bernard)
YYY ylch...@etro2.vub.ac.be (Yves Christophe)
--
Henry Manaster * EMail: mana...@yu1.yu.edu
Brooklyn, NY *
Disclaimer: The above is not necessarily MY opinion nor that
of anyone else :-) ????!