Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Best Quality CD-R Media

1 view
Skip to first unread message

Steven A. Lapp

unread,
Feb 15, 2001, 9:34:22 AM2/15/01
to
I'm new to CD-R burning and am interested in opinions on who makes the
best quality CD-R discs. I plan to do both data and audio burns.
Thanks in advance for any advice.

--
Steve Lapp

$p@m H8er

unread,
Feb 15, 2001, 9:28:45 PM2/15/01
to
http://www.cdrplanet.com - Mitsui Silver. Been using them successfully
for over 4 years now....both for Data and for Audio (and many local bands
have me burn their CDs).

"Steven A. Lapp" wrote:

> I'm new to CD-R burning and am interested in opinions on who makes the
> best quality CD-R discs. I plan to do both data and audio burns.

--
Brian S. Graham Entertainment
Spam-Haters reply to: dj at knoxvillewedding dot com
Visit my DJ/Audio site at http://www.knoxvillewedding.com
The only kind of SPAM I want comes from Hormel, thank you!


Daryl & Lisa D.

unread,
Feb 20, 2001, 3:28:24 AM2/20/01
to
FYI, after having problems burning with my new HP9350i, and after several
calls to tech support, they say that HP drives are only compatible with the
brands: Sony, Imation and Verbatim. They told me I couldn't use TDK, Maxell
or Memorex. I also cannot use 80 minute cds. They say I can only use media
that is "SCMS" (serial copy management system) How I'm supposed to figure
that out I'll never know. It would be nice if all of this was mentioned in
a user's guide!!

"Steven A. Lapp" <sl...@designsciencesinc.com> wrote in message
news:slapp-B2B21D....@news6.bellatlantic.net...

Mtnguy (CO)

unread,
Feb 20, 2001, 10:18:55 AM2/20/01
to
Obviously this must be particular to the HP9350i because I have a HP8100i
and it will burn ANY brand that I've ever gotten including the really cheap
'non-brands' at $10 per 100. My TDK Velocd 121032 will also burn all the
same, so far, that my HP does.

Jim

"Daryl & Lisa D." <MakeM...@mediaone.net> wrote in message
news:IUpk6.46819$_D.70...@typhoon.we.rr.com...

James Perrett

unread,
Feb 21, 2001, 12:55:17 PM2/21/01
to
"Daryl & Lisa D." wrote:
>
> FYI, after having problems burning with my new HP9350i, and after several
> calls to tech support, they say that HP drives are only compatible with the
> brands: Sony, Imation and Verbatim. They told me I couldn't use TDK, Maxell
> or Memorex. I also cannot use 80 minute cds. They say I can only use media
> that is "SCMS" (serial copy management system) How I'm supposed to figure
> that out I'll never know. It would be nice if all of this was mentioned in
> a user's guide!!

If they recommend Imation then they are really recommending CMC who also
make BASF branded discs. Verbatim are made by Mitsubishi and Sony are
normally made by Taiyo Yuden. This gives you a wider choice.

SCMS doesn't apply to CD burning unless you are using a consumer hifi
burner.

James.


--
**********************************************************************
* James Perrett Ocean Engineering Division *
* Southampton Oceanography Centre, *
* Empress Dock, Southampton SO14 3ZH, U.K. *
* Phone +44 (0)23 8059 6141, Fax +44 (0)23 8059 6149 *
* e-mail jrp @ soc . soton . ac . uk http://www.soc.soton.ac.uk/ *
**********************************************************************

David Chien

unread,
Feb 22, 2001, 1:14:40 PM2/22/01
to
> > FYI, after having problems burning with my new HP9350i, and after several
> > calls to tech support, they say that HP drives are only compatible with the
> > brands: Sony, Imation and Verbatim. They told me I couldn't use TDK, Maxell
> > or Memorex. I also cannot use 80 minute cds. They say I can only use media

Gee...At this rate, I'd toss the HP into the trash and get a Plextor/Yamaha/Ricoh
instead. What a crummy CD-RW drive HP is! My Plextor and Ricoh gobble up all
types of discs w/o any problems at all, and there is no reason at all today that
you should suffer with such mad limitations!!

Seriously, toss the drive and get one of the three above.

--

If you must stick with the HP, try a Taiyo Yuden disc. Usually rebranded as a
Sony, Maxell, etc. You may be able to use CDRIdentifier with your HP if it
supports reading such information from CD-Rs. TY's tend to be one disc the HP had
better be able to write to as it is one of the 'standards' out there - they made
the very first CD-R discs for consumers years back, and if the HP doesn't work
with a TY disc, it's crap.

d =)

Imations used to be TY's but now they've gone cheap, and are made by cheapie CD-R
makers. Avoid if possible! Same goes with TDK, which have also gone cheap! A
few stacks are still TY's, but the rest are all now cheapies!

Freebie of the day for you (er, maybe you get a CD-RW that'll work with 80min
CD-Rs first?):
www.fatwallet.com/forums/ -> hot deals -> 100 FREE CD-R 80MIN from Microcenter
deal !!!!! with any item purchase (eg. stack of paper). No brand, pure silver top
with blue bottom, CMC Magnetics cheapie, but great for those tossable burns like
Napster Music, giveways, in-car-stereo meltables, etc.

mrdancer

unread,
Feb 22, 2001, 7:16:06 PM2/22/01
to
I've burned about eight or ten different types of CDR's with my HP 9100i
with absolutely no problems. I usually buy the cheapest CDR's I can find,
like $20/100.

--
Remove .your.underwear to reply
--
David Chien <chi...@uci.edu> wrote in message
news:3A955710...@uci.edu...

Signet

unread,
Feb 23, 2001, 12:18:06 PM2/23/01
to
> > > FYI, after having problems burning with my new HP9350i,
and after several
> > > calls to tech support, they say that HP drives are only
compatible with the
> > > brands: Sony, Imation and Verbatim. They told me I
couldn't use TDK, Maxell
> > > or Memorex. I also cannot use 80 minute cds. They say I
can only use media
>

I've never had a problem with /any/ brand of CDR on my HP9350.
I've used generic, TDK, Memorex, Kingston, Verbatim, Maxell,
etc. I've burned about 1400 so far, with only about two
coasters.

--
Sig...@att.net
--------------------------------
"For every action, there is an equal and opposite criticism."


Signet

unread,
Feb 23, 2001, 12:18:52 PM2/23/01
to
"mrdancer" <mrda...@home.your.underwear.com> wrote in message
news:aZhl6.106674$bb.12...@news1.rdc1.tx.home.com...

> I've burned about eight or ten different types of CDR's with
my HP 9100i
> with absolutely no problems. I usually buy the cheapest CDR's
I can find,
> like $20/100.
>

Me too on my 9350. My source of $20/100 CD's has dried up. Can
you suggest one/some? Thanks!

David Chien

unread,
Feb 23, 2001, 5:07:06 PM2/23/01
to
> Me too on my 9350. My source of $20/100 CD's has dried up. Can
> you suggest one/some? Thanks!

Free: www.fatwallet.com -> forums -> hot deals -> microcenter 800# for
free 100pk of 80 min CD-Rs for free with any item purchase like a stack
of paper.

mrdancer

unread,
Feb 23, 2001, 8:54:59 PM2/23/01
to
I don't have a constant source. I just scan the Sunday paper ads and wait
for Circuit City, CompUSA, Office Depot, etc. to have a sale or special deal
on CD's. So far, I've been able to stock up on enough cheap CD's to keep
myself in supply. I imagine there're some good deals online if you shop
around.

--
Remove .your.underwear to reply
--
Signet <Sig...@att.net> wrote in message
news:0Ywl6.1848$rL4.1...@bgtnsc04-news.ops.worldnet.att.net...
0 new messages