On 2012-10-06 16:15:50 +0000, Alan Browne said:
> On 2012.10.06 00:21 , Salmon Egg wrote:
>
>> Another thing Steve left at Apple is an almost great (so-called)
>> aluminum keyboard. I just tried an old Apple keyboard. I made fewer
>
> When I bought this iMac the biggest letdown was the shitless keyboard.
>
> Can't even give it away. It's now the TV room keyboard for the Boxee -
> something it can't be too useless at (entering searches or website
> data).
If you mean the current slim low-profile aluminum keyboards, I have to
strongly disagree.
I hated them when Apple first came out with them. I loved my Matias
and had hated several previous Apple keyboards and just assumed that
the aluminum one was going to be even worse, with those chiclet-looking
keys.
I was completely wrong.
I was in an Apple store and actually tried to use one seriously - not
for two seconds, but to type, really type something.
I proceeded to buy two of them, one to plug into my laptop and one to
plug into my ancient iMac. I put the Matias away and haven't used it
since.
We did get the bluetooth version for another newer machine, and I think
that was a mistake, not because of the keys or keyboard, but because I
really prefer an extended keyboard and the USB cord doesn't bother me
in the slightest, to the bluetooth is just silly. (I suppose it might
be nice if one were using it from the sofa talking to a machine across
the room plugged into a large screen or projector, but on the desk, the
bluetooth thing just seems goofy to me).
>
>> Why should arty-farty win out over utility?
>
> Because it's Apple - made to look great and work great. Except when
> something does not work great.
Are you saying that the aluminum keyboards look great, but don't work
great? It may be a matter of personal preference, but my personal
experience and that of almost everyone else I've talked to about this
agree that the aluminum keyboards are actually pretty great.
In particular, I find the low profile to be absolutely invaluable. And
the key press feedback is good enough. It's no Matias, but at this
point, I actually prefer the quiet to the strong clickity-click.
Anyway, at best, you can say "works great" with regard to these is a
matter of taste, and most people seem to like them a lot. I was
really, absolutely surprised that I liked it at all.
This is not like the hideous and horrible hockey-puck mouse which was
pretty universally hated. (Though, in my opinion, Apple hasn't made a
decent mouse, well, almost ever. Again, though, that's mostly a
personal taste issue.)