Andy Burns <
use...@andyburns.uk> wrote
>> Even I could block that spam [...] Why can't Google? (if it's going
>> through them, that is).
>
> It's not only going through them, it's coming *from* their users.
Hi Andy,
I'm actually a bit confused by the enormity of this spam coming in...
I'm not so sure, but I readily admit I don't know as much about headers as
people like you or Stan or Frank Slootweg would (hell, I don't even know
how to look up an ivp6 IP address, which these headers seem to be using).
The reason I'm not so sure is that there are hundreds upon hundreds of
them, and even Google's terrible coders wouldn't be _that_ stupid to let
that happen (when I can't even sign into my own email using a VPN anyway).
I'm not sure though, because if it _is_ coming from Google's users, then
Google coders suck more than I thought they did, in terms of spam filters.
NOTE: I think Google's coders on tracking us are brilliant; so my opinion
of Google's coders stems from the way they block too much in my email.
However, I will affirm that it really does not matter to us, as
individuals, where the spam is coming from as we all have to block the spam
based on what is in the headers (or body) alone - which "appear" to be
coming from Google's users.
>> On this newsgroup, Frank is the acknowledged
>> leader in nntp headers so maybe he'll chime in.
>
> I have a separate address book called "google whitelist"
> I put people in it of I know they're google groups users
Yeah. I know how it works. What I'm wondering is why the news servers are
peering this crap. That is really where the fundamental filters should be.
Why does it show up in a Google Groups listing, for example?
<
http://groups.google.com/g/comp.mobile.android>
You'd think Google would filter that spam out, wouldn't you?
(I don't understand why it's in that URL ouput because it should not be!)
> I have a message filter that has two rules and two actions
>
> IF "from" ISN'T IN ADDR BOOK "google whitelist"
> AND message-id CONTAINS "@
googlegroups.com"
> THEN mark as read
> AND add tag #6
This is great! People like you can help those who are on TB!
It should be cut-and-paste for them.
I think Vanguard is on Dialog, so he can help the dialog users too.
Best is if he provides a script that others can just cut-and-paste.
Both have fantastic filtering capabilities, albeit some are cryptic syntax.
> That's thunderbird, I'm sure other clients can do similar
I'm well aware of filters and I'm as well aware that every newsreader has
its own method for implementing them - but that information above is useful
for folks like micky who probably would need help.
As for me, I can filter on anything as my filters use regex methods.
It's just a PITA to set it up.
Did you ever set up procmail filters, Andy?
My setup is like that (not the same, but similar in form & function).
It's a PITA.
It's not as easy as just deleting anything that comes from Joerg.
But you have a good starting point which is (pseudocode)
If it's not in the whitelist, and
if the message-id contains "@
googlegroups.com"
then delete it
My newsreader scripts don't have a whitelist though, so for me, if the
message-id has "@
googlegroups.com", then I will be wiping it out.
Is there anyone on the Android newsgroup who posts from Google Groups?